Mr. Speaker, it is obvious that the hon. member was not listening to what I was saying.
The NDP did write a dissenting report and I did read it. I congratulate the NDP for its dissenting report. Why, then, would the NDP members want to concur with the actual report that came out when they wrote a dissenting report against it? That is what I was saying. Maybe the hon. member should listen the next time and not jump to conclusions.
I did agree with the NDP's dissenting report. Why would the NDP members want to concur with the report when they dissented against it?
The second question was with regard to what the Liberals did? We actually got rid of a deficit. We actually brought the debt down, which is what the present government seems unable to do. We put $41.2 billion into a health accord with five clear objectives, none of which were achieved because in 2006 the present government walked away from it.
We are not digging ourselves out from a hole. We are digging ourselves out from inaction by the government.