Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague from Beauport—Limoilou. We both work on some of the same files.
People seem to be getting lost in the weeds and straying from the debate. I think it is important to focus our debate on the fact that the carbon tax is abusive. The member for Winnipeg North says it is 80%, and the Bloc Québécois says it is 90%. The main goal of the carbon tax is to produce results and reduce greenhouse gases. The government has been in power for eight years, but it has not produced results, unfortunately.
Whether people pay 10% and get back 15% or 20% is not the point. Those were examples I gave my colleague because he put that number out there.
I quoted the Parliamentary Budget Officer. My colleague gave us numbers from 2019, but it is 2023.