Madam Speaker, after the next election, when we are on the other side, if the member is re-elected, he will have an opportunity to ask questions of a future Conservative government, but tonight is when opposition members ask questions of the government.
If I am to take the point the member made in his response, which was that we are not fighting climate change and that the carbon tax is a successful policy instrument in fighting climate change, I might be prepared to accept his full argument, but the carbon tax has not allowed for Canada to meet any of its emissions targets. We are not controlling emissions or reducing emissions through the carbon tax. All it does is make life more expensive for Canadians who cannot afford to eat, heat or buy groceries.