House of Commons Hansard #373 of the 44th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was going.

Topics

line drawing of robot

This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Public Safety and National Security Members debate a 2022 report on gun and gang violence amid rising crime. Conservatives argue Liberal "soft-on-crime" laws like Bill C-75 increase violence, while gun control targets legal owners, proposing the study be reopened. Liberals defend their measures and accuse Conservatives of using the debate to avoid discussing foreign interference at committee. Other parties highlight lack of government action on report recommendations and links between crime and social issues. 23800 words, 3 hours in 3 segments: 1 2 3.

Decorum Members debate a point of order regarding a Conservative MP's statement accusing a member of responsibility for deaths, disputing the exact words used and the Speaker's decision to review the tape before ruling on withdrawal. 800 words, 10 minutes.

Petitions

Reference to Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs Members debate the government's refusal to provide unredacted documents regarding the Sustainable Development Technology Canada fund, which Conservatives call a "green slush fund". Conservatives allege mismanagement and corruption involving taxpayer money given to insiders, causing parliamentary delay. Liberals argue this is a Conservative filibuster and question the Leader of the Opposition's security clearance. NDP and Bloc support releasing documents but criticize the parliamentary paralysis, with some suggesting to refer the issue to committee. Debate touches on the cost of living and crime. 27800 words, 3 hours in 2 segments: 1 2.

Statements by Members

Question Period

The Conservatives criticize the government's soft-on-crime policies, particularly concerning serious offenders and violent crime. They argue the NDP-Liberal coalition is driving a cost of living crisis with inflation and the carbon tax, leading to increased food bank usage and poverty. They repeatedly call for a carbon tax election to "axe the tax" and offer permanent relief. They also raise concerns about corruption related to a former minister and government contracts, and condemn protests at MPs' homes.
The Liberals highlight a new tax break on essential goods and support for working Canadians to boost affordability, challenging Conservatives to vote for the measures. They also address crime and border security, housing initiatives, Indigenous priorities, official languages, UN peacekeeping, and condemn protests at MPs' homes.
The Bloc raises concerns about the decline of French in Quebec due to federal government actions. They criticize reduced border service hours and accuse Ottawa of aiding smugglers. They also question the Minister's attacks on CRA whistle-blowers instead of focusing on fraud.
The NDP call for permanently removing the GST on essential goods and action against corporate landlords driving up rents and companies potentially price-fixing. They also ask if the government will enforce ICC arrest warrants.
The Greens advocate for peace, disarmament, and peacekeeping, urging the government to re-establish a peace centre and increase involvement in peacekeeping and disarmament.

Business of the House Members debate parliamentary gridlock. Conservatives state government refuses House order for documents on a "green slush fund." Liberals state Conservatives obstruct committee referral, stalling government bills and a new tax break. 600 words.

Sitting Resumed The Speaker and a Bloc MP discuss the procedural conflict between priority given to ongoing privilege motions and the requirement to hold opposition days and approve estimates by December 10, urging parties to find a resolution. 1100 words.

Adjournment Debates

Carbon tax effectiveness Dan Mazier questions the necessity of the carbon tax for emissions reduction, referencing the environment commissioner's opinion. Ryan Turnbull defends the carbon tax, citing rebates for Canadians, expert opinions on its cost-effectiveness, and accuses Conservatives of lacking a climate plan and attacking independent experts.
SDTC scandal documents Greg McLean accuses the Liberals of withholding documents related to the SDTC scandal, fearing they reveal corruption. Ryan Turnbull claims the government acted transparently, providing many documents, and accuses the Conservatives of undermining the RCMP investigation by demanding documents already under review.
Fort Chipewyan dock contamination Philip Lawrence raises concerns about toxins contaminating a community dock in Fort Chipewyan, Alberta, and asks the government to address First Nations' requests. Ryan Turnbull says Minister Anand is engaged with the First Nations, that Transport Canada is taking steps, and emphasizes the complexity of the issue.
Was this summary helpful and accurate?

The EnvironmentAdjournment Proceedings

November 21st, 2024 / 7:05 p.m.

Whitby Ontario

Liberal

Ryan Turnbull LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance and to the Minister of Innovation

Mr. Speaker, I am glad I am here tonight for this late show to answer this question. The reason I say that is because I spent three years of my life, before I got into politics, going up to Fort Chipewyan and working with the first nations there on environmental monitoring. It was a great privilege to be in that community, be invited into it, to meet with the elders there, and to understand the issues of those first nation communities and their community members. I take this matter very seriously.

I want to preface what I am saying with something that I think the member opposite should also take seriously. These contaminants that are being monitored are directly from the tailing ponds of the oil sands. I know the member to be an hon. member, and I think he does care about the environment. I hope he can convince his party leader one day to take the matter of climate change and the contamination from our oil and gas industry seriously enough so that we can work together across the aisle in the House to address these issues for these first nation communities.

Those contaminants did not come from anywhere else. The first nations there have started a collaborative initiative to monitor the water, the contaminants in the water and the impacts on their ecosystem. They also employ their community members to do that work. That is really important work, and I think it has led to the realization that the moving of the dock and the dredging that would need to take place to replace it is going to be a difficult issue. It is not as simple as just funding the issue.

However, I do take the matter seriously. The reason I say that is that, when we dredge that toxic waste up from the bottom, we are essentially going to spread it throughout the watershed. The Peace-Athabasca Delta, for generations and generations, has been the water source and the home to those first nations. They identify with that place. They identify that water and that watershed as being the most important thing for their lives, their livelihoods, their identity, their culture, their traditions and their traditional knowledge. All of these things connect back to that watershed.

I think this is really important. I know that Minister Anand has been in touch directly with the nations to discuss their concerns. Transport Canada has previously disclosed the presence of contamination in Transport Canada-owned lands at Fort Chipewyan. The Fort Chipewyan public port facility has been listed on the federal contaminated sites inventory, an open public list, since 2014. For almost a century, the wharf at Fort Chipewyan has been active with multiple users and uses. Studies show that contaminants in the sediments in the Transport Canada-owned water lot and in the lands adjacent to the wharf may have come from a variety of sources.

I really think this is an important issue. I would say there are a number of different steps that the department has taken, and I would think that we could work together with the first nations. I know that Minister Anand is taking this matter seriously. Transport Canada has taken some immediate steps and retained a qualified third-party environmental consultant through Public Services and Procurement Canada, and is working with the first nations and the consultant to address this very issue.

The EnvironmentAdjournment Proceedings

7:10 p.m.

The Speaker Greg Fergus

I would just like to remind the hon. parliamentary secretary that we are not to mention the proper names of current members of the House of Commons.

Once again, I would remind staffers who are listening to please do a better job in making sure that, when they provide information, they respect the traditions and rules of Parliament.

The EnvironmentAdjournment Proceedings

7:10 p.m.

Conservative

Philip Lawrence Conservative Northumberland—Peterborough South, ON

Mr. Speaker, that does sort of beg the question of if a tree falls in the forest and there is no one there to hear it, was there really a violation of the rules? Although I do thank the Speaker for enforcing the rules.

I know the member to be an hon. member and I do, to answer his question, care about climate change and where the toxins came from. I am more than happy to work with the member and anyone else who wants to resolve that issue to make sure that we hold accountable wherever those toxins came from. However, there are several issues that I do want to drill down on because we did not get a response.

Will the government commit to remediating the site? Will it commit to bringing the dock up to code? Will it commit to doing further testing? Can the government do something to make residents aware of the potential contamination?

The EnvironmentAdjournment Proceedings

7:10 p.m.

Liberal

Ryan Turnbull Liberal Whitby, ON

Mr. Speaker, as I said in my response, and I will say it again, the Minister of Transport is taking this matter seriously. She has heard the concerns of the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation, the Mikisew Cree and the Fort Chipewyan Métis Nation.

While recent studies have found that the wharf at Fort Chipewyan is not likely to pose risk to human health, Transport Canada is committed to collaborating and working with the first nations to address community concerns about potential contaminants at the dock.

Transport Canada will continue to work closely with the communities to address their concerns about the contamination.

The EnvironmentAdjournment Proceedings

7:10 p.m.

The Speaker Greg Fergus

The motion to adjourn the House is now deemed to have been adopted. Accordingly, the House stands adjourned until tomorrow at 10 a.m. pursuant to Standing Order 24(1).

(The House adjourned at 7:14 p.m.)