Madam Speaker, over the years, in the nine years that I have been here, I have watched the member here in the House. He brings a lot of experience because he was here before my time. The Harper era was before my time, so he is asking me to respond on questions that I was not here for.
However, with that said, for almost 10 years, the NDP-Liberal government has been here. The only reason the Liberal government has been here for the last five years is that it has been propped up by the NDP. If it were not for the NDP standing up and supporting it, the House would have fallen a long time ago; we would have been in that carbon tax election. However, we are never given that opportunity, because the NDP continually wants to support the government. Its members love to say to the media that they have torn up the document, but when the votes come, they vote for the Liberals.