Mr. Speaker, I respect the member. I know that she cares a lot about the environment. It must be a very difficult position for the member to be in given what her leader has done, and I empathize with her.
However, when she suggests that this is because there was an exemption on everybody throughout the country who uses oil, well, my response to the member would be this: Where was her voice when it happened? That was in the middle of the winter, and I did not hear any member from any NDP say, “Hold on, don't give them that exemption.” They waited until September, after their leader had made a position on the supply and confidence agreement and, honestly, caved to the pressure of the Conservatives.