House of Commons Hansard #157 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was online.

Topics

line drawing of robot

This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Statements by Members

Question Period

The Conservatives focus on the costs of Liberal deficits and spending, arguing they fuel inflation and higher interest rates that burden families. They criticize the fuel standard tax, citing its impact on food and fuel costs, and challenge the government’s debt and accounting. They also press for action to protect Hamilton steelworkers, lift the tanker ban, and restore Banff’s search-and-rescue K9 program.
The Liberals tout strong growth and fiscal indicators while emphasizing affordability benefits, tax cuts and support for families. They highlight aid for steelworkers facing U.S. tariffs, promote energy and pipeline projects, and defend Bill C-39’s approach to collective bargaining. They also stress closer ties with the European Union.
The Bloc criticize the Prime Minister for excluding Quebec’s premier from the Canada–EU summit, arguing Quebec should have a voice on matters within its jurisdiction and in its international relations. They contrast this with the government’s honours for the UAE and engagement with Turkey, despite human rights concerns.
The NDP urge Liberals to repeal section 107 and protect workers’ right to strike, opposing Bill C-39’s limits on labour rights.

Bill C-41—Proposal to Apply Standing Order 69.1 Conservative MP Andrew Lawton asks the Speaker to divide Bill C-41 into separate votes on MAID eligibility for people with mental illness and advance requests for people who later lose capacity. 1400 words, 10 minutes.

Petitions

Safe Social Media Act Second reading of Bill C-34. The bill would establish online safety duties for social media and chatbot services, require safeguards for children under 16, speed removal of specified harmful content, and create a commission to oversee compliance and penalties. Liberal speakers say it supports families and addresses risks such as exploitation, bullying and harmful algorithms; Conservatives and the Green Party support examining protections but raise concerns about privacy, enforcement, exemptions and decisions deferred to future regulations. 61200 words, 7 hours in 2 segments: 1 2.

Protecting Young Persons from Exposure to Pornography Act Second reading of Bill S-209. The bill requires commercial pornography websites to use age-verification or age-estimation measures to restrict minors’ access, with safeguards for personal privacy and penalties for non-compliance. Members broadly support its goal of protecting children, while the government also points to related online-safety legislation. The House passes the bill at second reading and refers it to committee. 6600 words, 45 minutes.

Adjournment Debates

Grocery affordability Tamara Kronis says rising food prices and food bank use demand lasting relief, and presses Ryan Turnbull for measurable targets and public reporting on whether the $1-billion food-link fund lowers costs, especially on Vancouver Island. Turnbull points to federal food-security investments, local infrastructure and shorter supply chains, arguing these build resilience and address food insecurity over time.
Parks Canada cuts William Stevenson warns that Parks Canada workforce reductions and the planned end of Banff’s search-and-rescue dog program threaten public safety and essential park services. Ryan Turnbull defends the cuts as part of a broad spending review, citing fiscal savings and tax reductions. Stevenson asks the government to reinstate the rescue dog program, but Turnbull offers no commitment.
Was this summary helpful and accurate?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

October 28th, 2026 / 9:15 p.m.

Liberal

Shannon Miedema Liberal Halifax, NS

Madam Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville.

I rise today in support of Bill C-34, the safe social media act.

I will begin by sharing that I am a mother of three children, ages 10, 13 and 16. I, like all parents, am keenly aware of the risks of social media, and I understand the difficulties of regulating its use by our children and our youth. Even though I feel fairly confident that my kids are generally well protected, I cannot be sure, because parenting alone is not enough to protect our children.

Many parents do not want their children on social media at a young age, but it is incredibly difficult to keep them away when all of their friends are online. It can be a major source of family tension and stress, to say the least. This is not a failure of parenting. We want what is best for our children, and a large part of that is ensuring that they are not isolated from their peer groups. It is also important to recognize the ease at which these services are accessed. Often without their parents' knowledge, children are entering the digital world, and with only a few clicks, they can create an account and begin using platforms that may contain harmful content and expose them to dangerous actors at an early age.

A World Health Organization study found that more than one in 10 adolescents showed signs of problematic social media behaviour, struggling to control their use and experiencing negative consequences. Notably, this report also included the following call to action: “Ensure social media platforms enforce age restrictions and create a regulatory framework encouraging responsible design of digital tools for young users.” With the introduction of Bill C-34, this is exactly what we are aiming to do.

The bill covers both aspects of that call to action. It would create a nationwide restriction on social media services for Canadians under the age of 16 and implement three core duties for social media services. The duty to act responsibly would require regulated services to assess and mitigate risks linked to harmful content. The duty to protect children would require services to build age-appropriate safeguards into the design and operation of their products. The duty to make certain content inaccessible would require faster removal action on the most serious victimizing content: child sexual exploitation material and intimate content posted without consent.

Technology is ever-adapting, and our legislation must reflect that. Online harms are intensifying, and our laws have not kept pace. Protecting our kids from the harms of social media is a responsibility that I know we all share. The digital world connects us, it educates us, and it drives our economy. Unfortunately, it has also become a space where too many children are exposed to preventable harm.

A study co-led by researchers at the University of Alberta found that spending more time on social media is making Canadian teenagers, especially girls, feel anxious, depressed and disconnected. The results showed that just one extra hour of daily device use was linked to a 15% higher chance of moderate to severe depression, along with a nearly 13% higher likelihood of similar levels of anxiety. This is not just a concern for parents at home. This has societal implications that go beyond one child and one family. That is why it is our responsibility to act to address these rising trends.

We are also seeing a rise in dangerous behaviour being presented online, and without effective safeguards in place, our children are subject to observing, internalizing and repeating these behaviours. A report released by Stats Canada in 2024 found that one in eight young people saw online content daily that could incite hate or violence. A study from the Canadian Centre for Child Protection found that 50% of youth had watched the Charlie Kirk assassination video, while 33% had seen videos of mass or school shootings. Despite these high rates of exposure, only a small minority said they had actively searched for that content. Instead, most said that the content frequently appears unexpectedly in posts by strangers or in algorithmic platform recommendations.

There is an unfortunate connection between viewing this sort of content and repeating it in real life. The same report from Statistics Canada found that more than a third of people suspected of cyber-related hate crimes were between the ages of 12 and 17. The harms being perpetrated online are not being left on the screen. They are being translated into real-life actions in our schools, in our homes and in our communities. Moving past the physical violence, these harms extend into sexualized violence and graphic content. Statistics from the Canadian Centre for Child Protection show that 10% of Canadian youth reported exposure to child sexual abuse material, while 13% had seen a video of adults being sexually abused. Anything above 0% is completely unacceptable, in my view.

The reality is that there has been endless research done that showcases a clear link between social media use in adolescents and mental health concerns, rising hate and sexual violence. This research is well documented and well studied. It has been presented with the backing of parental safety organizations, our world-class research institutions and even tech companies.

This topic was first brought to my attention when similar legislation was presented in my home province of Nova Scotia by Iain Rankin, member of the legislative assembly for Timberlea-Prospect and the interim leader of the Nova Scotia Liberal Party. In presenting his piece of legislation at the provincial level, he started a conversation that introduced me to the work of Jenna Poste, a tech executive by trade and founder of the Nova Scotia chapter of Unplugged Canada. Jenna and the team at Unplugged Canada have been advocating for this sort of action for years. Jenna spoke at a press conference where she highlighted a point that I made in my speech earlier, which is that many parents do not want their children to have a presence on social media, but when that comes at the cost of social ostracization, it sometimes becomes too difficult to make that decision and enforce it.

The most common criticism I have heard since this bill was first tabled in the spring is that the government has no place in parenting. I agree, but the government does have a responsibility to step in when it comes to matters of public safety. Canada does not have to reinvent the wheel. Similar laws have been passed in a number of jurisdictions around the world, including Australia, Norway, Spain and Greece. Even provinces such as Manitoba are also looking at taking matters into their own hands at a provincial level.

I also want to present a historic comparison with regard to opposition to matters regarding public safety. In 1984, when Nova Scotia was implementing its mandatory seat belt legislation, it came with much public outrage and scrutiny. In my research regarding Bill C-34, I found an archived CTV interview with people who were opposed, in which a Nova Scotian justified that opposition by calling the legislation “something that infringes on the petty details of the organization and conduct of people's lives.” I feel quite confident that if we ask most Canadians today, they will recognize that seat belt laws are appropriate measures to protect our citizens, and I feel quite confident that 42 years from now, this legislation would be met with the same wide-reaching opinion.

As we continue to debate on this important legislation, I urge my fellow members to consider the public safety concerns I have presented today and remember the full range of regulations that exist within this piece of legislation that would not only protect our children but also provide sufficient opportunities for social media platforms to implement necessary safeguards, because the safety of our children must be our top priority and should not and cannot be a responsibility left to parents alone.

The digital environment is not safe for children. Leading health authorities now warn we cannot say that social media is sufficiently safe for young people and that governments must act decisively to reduce these risks. We are proposing this legislation because it is our responsibility to act, to act now and to act with urgency.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:25 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Madam Speaker, my hon. friend clearly put a lot of time, research and thought into sharing her ideas.

I want to ask about one aspect of the concept of the age restriction. When this bill was initially tabled, I think the general impression of the bill had been that it would establish a required minimum age for access to social media, but upon subsequent review, it seems that the bill would not actually do that. It would require social media companies to incorporate certain design features in order to be able to offer youth accounts. Effectively, it would not really be an age ban. Rather, it would require certain design features before companies can offer youth accounts.

I wonder, in the interest of clarity for members of the House and the public, if the member can clarify whether she considers that the bill would be an age ban or not.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:25 p.m.

Liberal

Shannon Miedema Liberal Halifax, NS

Madam Speaker, I congratulate the hon. member on his upcoming additional child, number seven. It is fantastic news.

My understanding is that we are looking at age 16 and over as the appropriate age for being responsible and mature enough to navigate social media. The more important thing would be requiring the platforms profiting off our youth to do the work to make sure they are protected. In whatever ways that needs to happen, we need to make sure we are providing a safe online environment for our children, whether they be 10 years, 16 years or five years old. It is is really important and worth investigation.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:25 p.m.

Green

Elizabeth May Green Saanich—Gulf Islands, BC

Madam Speaker, I thought the analogy to seat belt legislation was particularly useful. We are talking about an inherently dangerous product in what is available online and the threat it poses to our children. This is really not unlike consumer protection legislation. It is not unlike what we do with other dangerous products in terms of regulation. We really want to be able to lower the boom on a corporation, just as we did, for instance, on ones that made cars at the time but did not put in seat belts once that was regulated and required.

Would the hon. member be interested, as I am, in figuring out how we could amend this legislation to create the maximum incentive on the corporate tech billionaires and trillionaires to make them see that Canada is not a good place to do business if they are going to harm children, and that the penalties would scare the hell out of them?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:25 p.m.

Liberal

Shannon Miedema Liberal Halifax, NS

Madam Speaker, I agree wholeheartedly that a lot of what we are aiming to do is put the responsibility properly on those who are profiting from these online platforms and to put guardrails in place so we do not have the terrible incidents we have seen in the past in this country and across the world. That is exactly what we are aiming to do.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:25 p.m.

Liberal

Michael Coteau Liberal Scarborough—Woburn, ON

Madam Speaker, legislation is of course important, but there are many roles that society can play. When it comes to parents, guardians, next door neighbours, faith groups, educators and community-based organizations, many people can play a role in making sure we provide young people with the skills and tools they need.

I would like to know from the member if she has put some thought into different ways in which parents and other members of society can play a role to really help tackle this huge challenge we have in front of us.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:25 p.m.

Liberal

Shannon Miedema Liberal Halifax, NS

Madam Speaker, a big thing I think about often is getting our children outside, getting them out of doors and connected to real people in three dimensions, in real time and in nature. I have seen, even with my children, that if they have too much screen time, the behaviour starts to get a little wonky. They start to fight with me, my other kids and my husband. When we all get out of the house and go for a walk, we reset. It is really important for kids to have, as they are growing up, a sense of community, whether that is a religious community, a neighbourhood community or an activity community. We gravitate to those supports, and the more we can do to get our kids and youth off screens and actually engaged in the world around us, the better we will be.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:25 p.m.

Liberal

Jake Sawatzky Liberal New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, BC

Madam Speaker, today I rise to speak to Bill C-34, the safe social media act.

We have been hearing a lot about the duty to act responsibly, the duty to protect children, and the duty to make certain content inaccessible. When we talk about protecting our next generation, we have to talk about the digital world they are growing up in. Even as one of the youngest MPs of the House, and the youngest member of Parliament for British Columbia, I belong to a generation that experienced a full childhood before social media became part of our everyday lives. I remember a time when, after school, I would catch up with friends meeting them in person. If we wanted to talk to somebody, we picked up the land line and hoped they were home. I spent time outdoors biking with my friends to the corner store, skateboarding, playing tag and making memories away from a screen.

Today is a bit of a different world, of course. Children are growing up in an environment where social media is always within reach. Endless scrolling really is endless. Instead of simply catching up with friends, they can find themselves spending hours online, caught in addictive algorithms designed to keep them scrolling for many hours. There are concerns about what they are exposed to, how online platforms influence their behaviour, and what happens to their mental health as they grow up spending more time on their phone.

There are ways to mitigate this, of course. Consider YouTube, for example, which has been a bit of a leader in this space. It allows users and parents to turn off endless scrolling in the settings, to limit the addictive nature and the endless scrolling that many kids are growing up with these days. This is an example of the options we want our social media platforms to allow as settings.

We cannot expect our children to navigate these challenges on their own. Protecting young people means taking a serious look at how these platforms are operating and the responsibility they have to the children who use them. Social media does create opportunities for people to connect, to explore, to learn and to express themselves, but we cannot ignore the risks that come with it, especially when it comes to their mental health and personal safety.

Algorithms can amplify harmful content and expose young people to unrealistic standards, which they see day in and day out. For some people, this can contribute to anxiety, depression, low self-esteem and feelings of isolation. All these have been on the rise, as reported by psychologists, especially in younger age groups, which are using these technologies on a very frequent basis. At the same time, online platforms can also expose users to cyber-bullying, harassment, exploitation and other harmful content that can have very serious real-world consequences.

In 2025, 23% of Canadian youth aged 16 to 24 reported spending almost one-third of their day on social media. Research has associated longer screen times with poorer mental health indicators, including higher levels of anxiety, depression, and psychological distress, as well as reports of suicidal ideation. This matters because protecting young Canadians is about making sure the digital world does not come at the expense of their well-being or their relationships with others. Young people need supportive environments where they can build meaningful connections and access help when they need it.

We also have to recognize the role that social media platforms play in shaping what young people see online. Algorithms influence the content they are exposed to, and recommendation systems can repeatedly push harmful material onto someone's screen. For a young person already struggling with their mental health, repeated exposure to harmful content can create additional risks. Over time, this can normalize very dangerous behaviours and make it harder for young people to seek help.

It is crucial that online platforms take greater responsibility to ensure that their algorithms prioritize safety and well-being, especially for vulnerable users. It is also very important that the social media giants that are monetizing the attention span of our next generation be held accountable for the harms they are causing, and that our legislation have teeth to enforce consequences for the social media companies that are providing these harms to our youth.

I will soon be introducing my own private member's bill, which is a national strategy for suicide prevention. Of course, one of the main things it is also looking at is what some of the risk factors are for suicide, which is unfortunately all too common in our modern day and age.

It is an unfortunate reality that there is content on social media that can sometimes propagate tendencies toward self-harm and toward suicidal ideation. It is very important that it is not just up to parents to regulate the things their kids are seeing and to be the police of the content their kids are taking in. That is why it is up to us as government to do that.

We need to ask ourselves this: Is it fair to expect parents to manage these risks on their own while the companies designing these platforms face limited accountability? Parents are already balancing the pressures of everyday life. We cannot expect them to monitor everything that their children do 24 hours a day, particularly when kids have their own screens. We cannot constantly see everything that our kids are seeing. It is, frankly, impossible. Parents have an important role to play, of course, by setting up certain settings on devices, but protecting children cannot fall on their shoulders alone.

Social media companies design these platforms. They design how content is recommended and how users interact with these services. That is why we need clear expectations for these companies. They must take meaningful steps to identify risks and reduce harm. Just as importantly, they must be transparent about what they are doing and demonstrate that their efforts are making a difference. Canadians should not have to simply take a company's word that a platform is safe.

Technology has moved faster than the rules to protect our people are keeping up. We have been slow to respond to these changing online environments, and we need to take action. As a result, harmful content can spread unchecked, and dangerous behaviours can be amplified. Vulnerable users can repeatedly be exposed to materials that put their well-being at risk.

Bill C-34 takes an important step toward closing that gap by recognizing that those who design and profit from these platforms also have a responsibility to prevent foreseeable harms, the harms that they know they are causing. We should not wait for a young person to experience harm before expecting action from the companies that operate these services.

The legislation would establish clear expectations from social media platforms. Companies would be required to assess the risks associated with harmful content on their services and take proactive steps to reduce those risks. Users would have access to a clear reporting and complaint mechanism so they know where to turn when they encounter harmful content or have concerns for their own safety. It is important that we make sure this happens with a very quick process, because throughout this, we do not want to see young people turn away from platforms that we are familiar with and go toward corners of the Internet that might be less regulated. That is why it is important that the legislation move quickly. If we stand these things up, we can prevent people from going to less safe corners of the Internet.

Another factor here is, of course, the new challenges emerging with artificial intelligence. AI has made it easier to create fake or manipulated images that damage someone's reputation. Some content can go viral within minutes. It can also make it much harder for people to distinguish between authentic content and material designed to mislead them. We have now entered an age where when we see a photo, it is virtually impossible to tell if that photo is real or if it has been generated in a matter of seconds by somebody on a keyboard anywhere on the planet.

AI chatbots raise additional concerns, particularly when they interact with young people who are experiencing emotional distress. These interactions feel very personal, and young users may not always understand the limitations of these systems. We need appropriate safeguards to reduce the risk of harmful responses and ensure that vulnerable young people are not left without proper support.

Take the example of somebody using an AI chatbot as a counsellor, for example. These chatbots are not registered counsellors and can sometimes give very misleading and harmful advice to the young people who are using them. Some government oversight is very needed here. We cannot wait until harm has already occurred before asking how these technologies should be used responsibly. Platforms must take responsibility for the risks associated with the services they provide, including the AI tools that they make available to their users.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:40 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Madam Speaker, my hon. friend spent a lot of time talking about the problem, and I completely agree with his description of the problem. There is going to be no disagreement in the House that we have a serious problem with what happens online and the effects it has on young people, that we need action and that this action has to include real accountability for platforms and actors for the things they are responsible for. The work we will do at committee on this bill specifically will be to study the government's proposed solution to see whether it is fit for purpose.

One of the questions I have, I asked earlier, and I wonder if the member has thoughts on it. The bill does not appear to be an age ban, which was initially proposed. I think it proposes to require certain adaptations or changes to design features, ultimately with the idea that the social media platforms that exist could continue to offer youth accounts. There would not be a requirement, for instance, for parental consent for those youth accounts.

Can the member tell me whether my reading of the legislation is correct, or does he see the bill as being an age ban, as some have proposed?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:40 p.m.

Liberal

Jake Sawatzky Liberal New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, BC

Madam Speaker, it is very important that in this process, we make sure that these platforms are fit for young people to be on them. If they are deemed fit for use, then of course that is great and youth will be allowed to continue to use them. However, if there are platforms that are deemed to not be taking these measures, then there will be a ban until they are. It is an age ban particularly for the platforms that have the most severe consequences.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:40 p.m.

Green

Elizabeth May Green Saanich—Gulf Islands, BC

Madam Speaker, there is something of a lovely age gap between the member for New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville and I, and it is with a sense of generational continuity that I address him. Our first conversation was about how his best friend was the grandson of one of my very best friends. This is one of those things where some of us have more familiarity with social media than others.

I want to ask a question following up on the question from my friend from Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan.

We do not really have an age ban in the bill. I think all of us are united in wanting to protect children from online harms, but my current fixation is what we could fix through amendments to this bill. We could create incentives for corporations to protect children in Canada, saying that otherwise, they would suffer significant and crushing financial or personal punishment. They would then be highly incentivized to make sure their platforms do not harm our children. Does the member have any thoughts on that?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:40 p.m.

Liberal

Jake Sawatzky Liberal New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, BC

Madam Speaker, I would like to first off thank my hon. colleague for the question. I would also like to say hi to Walker and Pam Jennings, with whom we share a mutual friendship.

I agree with my hon. colleague that this legislation needs to have teeth. We, of course, are talking about very large social media giants, and a slap on the wrist would not be enough for enforcement. We need to make sure we have penalties, particularly for the worst cases and worst offences. These are things too horrible to even talk about, but when we talk about about sexualized deepfakes of children, for example, they must be removed in a very swift manner, and if not, there need to be consequences for the social media giants.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:40 p.m.

Liberal

Natilien Joseph Liberal Longueuil—Saint-Hubert, QC

Madam Speaker, the government has an essential role to play in protecting children and keeping them safe while respecting parental authority. The goal is to strike a balance between protecting children and respecting parents' responsibilities.

Can my colleague explain how this bill would help speed up the removal of intimate content distributed without consent and content that sexually victimizes children, in order to better protect them?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:45 p.m.

Liberal

Jake Sawatzky Liberal New Westminster—Burnaby—Maillardville, BC

Madam Speaker, I thank my colleague for his excellent question. It is important for social networks to ensure that this type of content, which is harmful, is removed within an acceptable time period.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

9:45 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Madam Speaker, it is a real honour for me tonight to join what is a very important and substantial conversation about how we protect our kids in the age of the Internet. Obviously, as members know, this is a deeply important and personal conversation for me, as I am the father of six children I have met so far and one who will be born in April.

If the House will indulge me briefly, I just want to say that I am so proud of and grateful to my kids. I love them. I care about them. I am proud of what they do, and I feel so supported by them in the work that I do in this place. The way my kids take care of chores and responsibilities around the house, which maybe I would do if I was home more, is really heartwarming and something I am very grateful for. I am grateful that my kids can come with me to Ottawa from time to time to learn about the work I do here. Even when they are not physically with me, I always have them on my mind and in my heart as I think about the work we are doing and the country we are trying to build for them. That is especially the case, of course, as we deal with these weighty questions of child safety online.

It is interesting the way, coincidentally maybe, the parliamentary calendar has lined up tonight. We are having a debate on Bill C-34, and during private members' hour, we were debating Bill S-209, another important piece of legislation that deals with the question of the safety of children online. It is interesting to look at what these two bills would do, and at some of the similarities and differences. During my speech, I will make reference to some extent to both of those pieces of legislation.

Because I did not have a chance to speak to Bill S-209, I want to recognize and express my appreciation to the whole House for the passage of it at second reading. I think it is excellent legislation. I look forward to the study that is going to happen at committee. I salute the hard work of Senator Miville-Dechêne, as well as my friend and colleague from Battlefords—Lloydminster—Meadow Lake, who sponsored the bill in the House, and my friend and colleague from Peace River—Westlock, who has done so much work on the protection of children online for the entirety of his time as a member of Parliament.

In Bill S-209 in particular, but also included in the provisions of Bill C-34, is the issue of trying to address the scourge of early exposure to pornography on the Internet by young people. This is a massive problem, and I think we should correctly identify it as a form of Internet-based child abuse. Exposing children to sexual imagery is child abuse.

So many children are exposed very early on in life to sexual and often violent sexual images that they stumble upon when on the Internet. Some statistics suggest that the average age of first exposure to pornography is 11, so many children, boys and girls of nine, 10, 11 and 12, are seeing sexual scenes and violent sexual scenes at a time when they are obviously not making choices. They are not knowingly and wilfully doing this. They are stumbling into things they do not understand, and it is shaping their beliefs and expectations in ways that have lifelong effects that lead to increased sexual violence, all kinds of other harms and wildly dangerous expectations of what is expected in the context of intimate relationships.

It is incumbent upon all of us to try to address and confront this epidemic of early exposure to pornographic material by children. This is something we have been talking about in the House and has been talked about repeatedly in the Senate for many years, yet there has been a failure to complete the required legislative action.

We almost got there in the last Parliament, and now we have the continuation of these efforts. There was a similar bill to Bill S-209 in the previous Parliament that the government was not supportive of, so I am very pleased to see the adoption at second reading and look forward to the continuing work as we go forward. I know that Bill S-209 has certain new features that are different from a similar bill in a previous Parliament. It is now the absolute gold standard in terms of privacy protection. The way Bill S-209 has been written, it has been endorsed by the Privacy Commissioner. It has been worked over so extensively across multiple Parliaments to be airtight in terms of the provisions to protect privacy. Again, I want to recognize Senator Miville-Dechêne for her extensive work on that, as well as the colleagues I already highlighted in this House.

Bill S-209 and other bills aimed at protecting children online obviously have to include requirements around age verification or age estimation tools. This is inevitable. If we want to take the position that, on the Internet, some material should never be accessed by children and the same material should be available to adults, the only way to make that distinction is to have credible tools for age verification or estimation. The only alternative to that is you make it available to everybody or you make it available to nobody. Assuming that we agree that a distinction has to be made, we need age verification or estimation tools. That is the only way to do it.

The legislation that has moved forward to committee today would require age verification or estimation. It does not prescribe the specific mechanics of that method, and I think that is appropriate because technology will develop and we will find more and more credible and effective ways of doing this over time. In an area where technology is constantly developing, even over the time the bill is being discussed, we should not prescribe the specific method. The legislation would require that age verification or estimation occur in such a way that children are not being exposed to these materials. Further, it provides an opportunity for the government to prescribe age verification methods that could be used and also establishes criteria for those methods that include the use of third parties and the protection of privacy.

The use of a third party for age verification means that an individual would go to a third party to verify their age or have age estimation in some way with that third party and then receive a kind of digital key. I am not a real technology person, I will admit, so I am sharing terms that may not be the precise technical terms, but this is how the design of the legislation works. It is that people can go to a third party, get what is effectively a digital key and bring it back to whatever site they are trying to access, and the site they are accessing is not the one that did the age verification. The age verification was done externally. It is what I know Senator Miville-Dechêne has called double anonymity. People's privacy is protected because of the use of the third party verification method.

There are these various requirements in Bill S-209 that really make it the gold standard in terms of privacy protection, but we need to have age verification or estimation if we are going to say there is going to be an age cut-off required for access to these kinds of materials. This is very important. We know the problem. The early exposure to pornography is something that desperately must be addressed. We finally seem to have an emerging consensus in this House to be able to move toward the realization of that objective.

As I understand it, Bill C-34 would address the issue of exposure of minors to pornography. However, it would only address it in the context of social media. Bill C-34 would not deal with age verification or estimation for dedicated pornographic websites; that is in Bill S-209. Bill C-34 would deal with pornographic content on social media and the presentation of it on those platforms. Those provisions are certainly important, and action is required on the social media side, but it is important to be clear that Bill C-34's provisions would not address the full range of places where this material is available. This is why Bill S-209 is very much required. Bill S-209 would address everything. It would address all of the places that kind of content is available.

I spoke about being a parent, and I want to just reflect a bit on some of the discussion about the relationship between parents and the state in terms of protection of children online. I believe very much in the paramount importance of parental involvement and parental decision-making. I think the job of the state is to act as an ally to parents, to support parents in the protection of their children by helping parents and maybe by performing tasks parents are not able to perform. The state should prevent bad actors from trying to interfere in the lives of my children. It should try to prevent bad actors from targeting my children with dangerous or abusive material. It should try to protect my children from being exposed to things out and about outside of my home.

People have rightly pointed out that parents can, in the context of their own homes, establish rules around what material their kids can access online. This is true, but many of our kids have access to screens and to the Internet in other places, maybe when they are at school or with friends. We can do our best as parents to provide protections elsewhere, but we cannot be everywhere. We cannot be in those places all the time, so I think it is right and legitimate for the state to seek to protect children in ways that are allied with the efforts of parents. Parents want to protect their kids, and I think they are looking for state action in those other spaces, which is why it is right and legitimate for the state to seek to prevent minors from being exposed to, for instance, sexual material online, but also to other types of dangerous material, insofar as they are doing so in a way allied with their parents.

If we are talking about sexual material, exposing children to that material is a form of child abuse. It should never be allowed, ever, under any circumstances, and the state obviously has a compelling interest in preventing child abuse. I really see the importance of allied action between parents and the state, the paramount importance of the role of parents in the lives of their children, and state action that supports child protection in ways that are allied with the actions of parents.

There is obviously a lot in this bill. I am going to try to cover as much as I can here. On the issue of social media, I agree with what members have said. They have grave concerns about early exposure to social media and some of the design features of social media, aspects of the algorithm, etc. They have an addictive quality. They tend to create anxiety. It is important for us to discuss and look for ways to respond to that. I am quite sympathetic to arguments in favour of establishing that, under a certain age, kids should not have access to social media. I share many of the concerns members have articulated.

I also think it is important to identify that Bill C-34, as it relates to social media, would not impose an age ban as many people understand it would. I was just chatting informally with a colleague about what we mean by an age ban.

What Bill C-34 says is that someone cannot access social media if they are under 16, unless this social media company makes certain adjustments in terms of design features and it complies with certain directives established by regulation. The member said that I have that right. If the social media companies comply with those directives of government, then they will be able to issue youth accounts. In fact, the Liberal member who spoke before me said that they want the existing mainstream platforms to be able to act in ways that will allow them to offer youth accounts so that young people do not end up accessing other dark corners of the web that are less regulated, etc.

The point is, I think it is important for parents at home to know, this bill is not about saying people under 16 should never be on social media. It is about the government saying that it will allow young people to be on certain social media platforms that comply with certain things that the commissioner has established, but it will retain the ability to prevent young people from being on other social media platforms if certain other requirements are not met.

I do not think that constitutes an age ban, as maybe it has been sold, or as most parents understand an age ban to be. I think parents would understand the communications around an age ban to be that young people are not going to be on social media anymore, period. That is not what Liberal members are talking about. Liberal members are talking about a world in which young people would be on social media, on the same social media platforms, and those social media platforms would be required to comply with certain design features. I say that not to affirm or criticize that approach, but simply to say it is important for people to know what that approach is, so that people are not expecting this legislation to be something that it is not. We can have an argument about the idea of an age ban, but we should also kind of debate what is in this bill and whether this is the right approach as opposed to other kinds of architecture.

I think the other concern worth raising and reflecting on, and I know this is going to go to committee and it will be studied there, is how much, in terms of those design features, is being left to regulation. At what point is this going to be through regulation, through the action of a commissioner saying, okay, we kind of like what is going on on this platform and we do not like what is going on on that platform? Of course, we have different kinds of social media platforms that are doing different kinds of things. Some skew a little one way politically, some skew another way politically. There are different things going on, on different platforms.

If we were saying, always and ever, our young people should not be on social media, that would be one kind of architecture, but this sort of involves the government saying, in any case, we are going to have some platforms where people are on them and some platforms where people are not on them, or they can be on those platforms if they comply with certain things the government says. That just raises some potential questions about how regulatory intervention could shape what digital platforms are doing in a world where young people are ultimately still on the platforms. If someone's concern is the anxiety induced by a presence on these platforms, it seems like the world envisioned by the government on Bill C-34 is still one in which minors, people under 16, are accessing social media. It is just subject to some of these limitations.

I do think another thing to just point out is that there is always concern when we have government legislation, with the Liberal government in particular, about the implications for censorship. I am very concerned about genuinely harmful content online and its impact on young people. I also know that sometimes, informally in debate, government members will call things misinformation or disinformation simply because they disagree with it. They will accuse someone else's argument as being disinformation, simply because they disagree with it. I think there is sometimes a lack of trust, legitimately, in the government around actions that it takes online.

We are eager to engage in the discussion around this bill in good faith, because we think there are many important issues that are raised in it. Certainly, we need to act and look for opportunities to act together to protect our children, but there is a lack of trust in the actions by the Liberal government in the online space in general. I think there are good reasons for that if we look at some of the legislation it has brought forward in the past.

Twenty minutes flies by. I could talk for another 20, if this House would allow, but we will have questions and comments soon, so maybe I will be able to add to it at that point.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:05 p.m.

Liberal

Guillaume Deschênes-Thériault Liberal Madawaska—Restigouche, NB

Madam Speaker, after listening to my colleague, I realize that we both care about protecting our children online. I think that if we did not care about this issue, we would not be here tonight at this late hour.

Bill C‑34 proposes several improvements to better regulate social media platforms in order to protect young people from harmful online content that could have an impact on their mental health.

If my colleague supports the bill's guiding principles and the broad objectives it seeks to achieve, will he vote to send it to committee so that it can be studied in depth?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:05 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Madam Speaker, genuinely, it is always a challenge when we are asked to rule on the objectives of a bill. I agree with the stated objectives. If a stated objective is to protect children, I agree with protecting children. I have a lot of questions about the architecture of the bill and whether it achieves its objectives.

I look forward to the study that is going to happen at committee. I hope we have a detailed and robust study. I hope we are able to see amendments to address some of the issues around the architecture. I think action is required to protect kids online. The status quo is not acceptable. We need new robust responses by government to this challenge.

I hope that through the process of debate, refinement and amendment, we can get to a piece of legislation that answers all the questions that I and other members have and achieves the objective that we are all saying we want.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:05 p.m.

Liberal

Greg Fergus Liberal Hull—Aylmer, QC

Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member from Edmonton for his thoughtful reply.

I am genuinely interested in getting to the gist of the matter. I would like to give him the opportunity to expand a bit more on the architecture that he thinks would be acceptable to gain his support for the bill. The architecture could be presented either here in the House or at committee.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:05 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Madam Speaker, I was getting to it toward the end of my comments. I think the concerns about misinformation, disinformation and hateful content are real and legitimate concerns. I also think that sometimes that language can be used to silence different opinions.

Often in debates in this House, I have heard a person make a good-faith, well-reasoned and perhaps true argument, and someone else says it is disinformation or misinformation. There may have been times when those accusations have been levied in lots of different directions.

We have to be very careful with the creation of a new agency that would establish standards for regulating harmful content and ensure that it is not being used to limit legitimate speech and debate. At the same time, there is real, genuine harmful content that we obviously want to put a stop to. That is the work that has to be done in striking the right structure to get the work done.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:05 p.m.

Green

Elizabeth May Green Saanich—Gulf Islands, BC

Madam Speaker, I am surprised that we are discussing the difference between misinformation and disinformation. I think my friend from Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan would agree that if we look at any dictionary definition, “misinformation” can be understood to be an error or mistake, and “disinformation” is defined universally as being deliberately deceptive. Spreading something with the intent to deceive is usually what we find in the dictionary there. I think it is important in this place that we not suggest they are the same term or that they can be confused.

In terms of this legislation, I know there is a lot to be determined later in regulations. For that terminology, can we assume that any commissioner will rely on commonly understood Oxford English Dictionary sorts of definitions for the difference, with “disinformation” meaning deliberately deceitful?

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:10 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Madam Speaker, of course I agree there is a difference between those two words. My point was simply that those words get thrown around casually, often interchangeably, and admittedly in a way that is disconnected from the true meanings of them. Because it is against parliamentary rules for someone to accuse someone else of lying in this place, I think often people just say that something is misinformation, which is their way of trying to get underneath the rules of not being able to say someone is lying.

The point, though, is that when we have the casual use of the terms “misinformation” and “disinformation” thrown against political critics at the same time as there is legislation aiming to, through legal intervention and online regulation, prevent misinformation and disinformation, there is a bit of a problem: How do we prevent the misuse of terms that we see in political discourse from creeping into the misuse of terms in other places?

I will pick up on what the member said as well. She highlighted the number of decisions that are left to regulation. That is a concern we have in general. The number of decisions in this framework that are ultimately left to regulation rather than established in legislation increases the risk and potential concern of abusive decisions later.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:10 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Madam Speaker, put very simply, this legislation is all about protecting our children. I think everyone in the House recognizes the value of that. Putting in regulations that would ultimately deal with social media services, AI, chatbots and so forth is a good thing. I believe the member would concur with that.

There has been some misinformation. If we take a look at pornography, it is being dealt with in a very limiting way to protect the interests of children. There are also age verification issues within that.

Would the member not recognize that the principle of the legislation is sound and that we need to get it to committee stage, where a lot of the details could be fleshed out? In particular, I am a big advocate of the commission. I think the commission is one of the ways in which we could see an enforcement of the regulations to hold these services and programmers to account. I would like his thoughts on that specifically.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:10 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Madam Speaker, I do not doubt the sincerity of every member who is talking about their aspirations to protect kids. I think that aspiration is widely shared. It is also important to underline that good intentions are not enough in legislation. What becomes law is not the good intentions of legislators. What becomes law is the text of the bill. That is the work we are doing now and that we will do at the committee. It is to discuss, as I did in my speech, the alignment between the intentions and the results as they would be created by the legislation.

There are good things in this bill. It is important to acknowledge that there may have been some dissonance in the communication that there would not be an age ban. It would not actually prevent people under 16 from accessing social media. While there are important and positive provisions around pornographic content, it would not cover pornography websites; it would only covers social media. That is why Bill S-209 is important.

The work that is going to happen at committee, the study, is very important. It is important to acknowledge what the bill would do and what it would not do. Again, it would not create an age ban. It does not address all issues of pornography. It only deals with pornography on some kinds of websites. However, there are important and positive aspirations that are expressed through it, and it is worthy of serious and thoughtful study.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:10 p.m.

Liberal

Will Greaves Liberal Victoria, BC

Madam Speaker, I have heard my hon. colleagues mention several times, with a bit of fence-sitting, the question of whether the bill constitutes an age ban for young Canadians under 16. I am curious if the member is able to clarify that. In his view, would it be preferable to have a universal ban for Canadians under 16 on social media platforms, or would it be preferable to have social media platforms fix their systems such that there would be limitations on age-inappropriate content and young Canadians could safely use those platforms, given some of the benefits that we know exist? Which of those two options would the member prefer? I cannot tell based on his remarks this evening.

Bill C-34 Safe Social Media ActGovernment Orders

10:15 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Madam Speaker, in the point I made, admittedly, I did not comment on that either way. I simply pointed out that the bill is not an age ban.

What would the ideal architecture be? I think there will be lots of time to study that question at committee. I am open to the argument—