The House resumed from October 27 consideration of the motion.
House of Commons Hansard #157 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was online.
House of Commons Hansard #157 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was online.
This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.
Bill C-41—Proposal to Apply Standing Order 69.1 Conservative MP Andrew Lawton asks the Speaker to divide Bill C-41 into separate votes on MAID eligibility for people with mental illness and advance requests for people who later lose capacity. 1400 words, 10 minutes.
Safe Social Media Act Second reading of Bill C-34. The bill would establish online safety duties for social media and chatbot services, require safeguards for children under 16, speed removal of specified harmful content, and create a commission to oversee compliance and penalties. Liberal speakers say it supports families and addresses risks such as exploitation, bullying and harmful algorithms; Conservatives and the Green Party support examining protections but raise concerns about privacy, enforcement, exemptions and decisions deferred to future regulations. 61200 words, 7 hours in 2 segments: 1 2.
Protecting Young Persons from Exposure to Pornography Act Second reading of Bill S-209. The bill requires commercial pornography websites to use age-verification or age-estimation measures to restrict minors’ access, with safeguards for personal privacy and penalties for non-compliance. Members broadly support its goal of protecting children, while the government also points to related online-safety legislation. The House passes the bill at second reading and refers it to committee. 6600 words, 45 minutes.
The House resumed from October 27 consideration of the motion.
Opposition Motion—Appearance of the Prime Minister before the Standing Committee on FinanceBusiness of SupplyGovernment Orders
The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia
It being 3:14 p.m., the House will now proceed to the taking of the deferred recorded division on the motion of the member for Richmond—Arthabaska—des-Sources relating to the business of supply.
Call in the members.
Business of SupplyGovernment Orders
The House resumed from October 27 consideration of the motion.
Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of Persons with DisabilitiesConcurrence in Committee ReportsOrders of the Day
The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia
The House will now proceed to the taking of the deferred recorded division on the motion to concur in the 10th report of the Standing Committee on Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of Persons with Disabilities.
Concurrence in Committee ReportsOrders of the Day
The House resumed from October 22 consideration of the motion that Bill C-247, An Act to amend the Canada Labour Code, be read the second time and referred to a committee.
Bill C-247 Canada Labour CodePrivate Members' Business
The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia
The House will now proceed to the taking of the deferred recorded division on the motion at second reading stage of Bill C-247 under Private Members' Business.
Bill C-247 Canada Labour CodePrivate Members' Business
The House resumed from October 23 consideration of the motion that Bill C-241, An Act to establish a national strategy respecting flood and drought forecasting, be read the third time and passed.
Bill C-241 National Strategy on Flood and Drought Forecasting ActPrivate Members' Business
The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia
The House will now proceed to the taking of the deferred recorded division on the motion at third reading stage of Bill C‑241, under Private Members' Business.
Bill C-241 National Strategy on Flood and Drought Forecasting ActPrivate Members' Business
The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia
I declare the motion carried.
(Bill read the third time and passed)
The House resumed from October 26 consideration of the motion that Bill C-264, An Act to repeal certain restrictions on shipping, be read the second time and referred to a committee.
Bill C-264 An Act to Repeal Certain Restrictions on ShippingPrivate Members' Business
The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia
The House will now proceed to the taking of the deferred recorded division on the motion at second reading stage of Bill C-264 under Private Members' Business.
Bill C-264 An Act to Repeal Certain Restrictions on ShippingPrivate Members' Business
The House resumed from October 27 consideration of the motion that Bill C-222, An Act to amend the Employment Insurance Act and the Canada Labour Code (death of a child), be read the third time and passed.
Bill C-222 Relieving Grieving Parents of an Administrative Burden Act (Evan's Law)Private Members' Business
The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia
We will now proceed to the taking of the deferred recorded division on the motion at third reading of Bill C-222, under Private Members' Business.
Bill C-222 Relieving Grieving Parents of an Administrative Burden Act (Evan's Law)Private Members' Business
The Speaker Francis Scarpaleggia
I declare the motion carried.
(Bill read the third time and passed)
Bill C-41—Proposal to Apply Standing Order 69.1Points of OrderPrivate Members' Business
Conservative
Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON
Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order to request the division of Bill C-41 for voting purposes, pursuant to Standing Order 69.1. Standing Order 69.1(1) says the following:
In the case where a government bill seeks to repeal, amend or enact more than one act, and where there is not a common element connecting the various provisions or where unrelated matters are linked, the Speaker shall have the power to divide the questions, for the purposes of voting, on the motion for second reading and reference to a committee and the motion for third reading and passage of the bill. The Speaker shall have the power to combine clauses of the bill thematically and to put the aforementioned questions on each of these groups of clauses separately, provided that there will be a single debate at each stage.
Bill C-41 seeks to do two fundamental things. That is to say, the bill stands for two separate principles. The bill seeks to stop the forthcoming expansion of medical assistance in dying to people whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness. It also seeks to allow medical assistance in dying for people who have no capacity to consent but who requested MAID before they lost capacity, otherwise known as advance requests. These are two fundamentally different questions that must, I submit, be voted on separately. The bill, as worded, would also fundamentally change the nature of the MAID regime by partially removing it from the realm of criminal law insofar as advance requests are concerned. This is another matter that speaks to both the complexity of the bill and its omnibus nature, which I believe warrants your prerogative to divide the question pursuant to Standing Order 69.1.
Based on my preliminary reading of the bill, there should be two separate questions: one on the mental health expansion in clauses 9, 10 and 14, which concern a statute passed in 2021, An Act to amend the Criminal Code (medical assistance in dying), as amended in 2023 and 2024, together with subclause 4(2) of Bill C-41 on the same subject matter; and the second question on MAID for people who cannot consent, otherwise known as advance requests, in the remaining provisions of Bill C-41, which propose amendments to a different act, the Criminal Code, plus consequential cross-references in three other statutes.
I recognize that these matters concern medical assistance in dying. However, the question under Standing Order 69.1 is not simply whether the provisions fall within the same broad policy area, but rather, whether they are sufficiently distinct so as to warrant separate votes. Speaker Regan addressed this contrast in a bill containing multiple principles while addressing a singular field of policy in his March 1, 2018, ruling at page 17551 of the Debates. He stated:
In presenting arguments relating to Bill C-63, the hon. member for Calgary Shepard raised an interesting concept from the practice in the Quebec National Assembly. Quoting from page 400 of Parliamentary Procedure in Québec, he stated:
“The principle or principles contained in a bill must not be confused with the field it concerns. To frame the concept of principle in that way would prevent the division of most bills, because they apply to a specific field.”
While their procedure for dividing bills is quite different from ours, the idea of distinguishing the principles of a bill from its field has stayed with me. While each bill is different and so too each case, I believe that Standing Order 69.1 can indeed be applied to a bill where all of the initiatives relate to a specific policy area, if those initiatives are sufficiently distinct to warrant a separate decision of the House.
To that end, Mr. Speaker, I submit that you should approach Bill C-41, legislation which quite literally concerns life and death, in a fundamentally different way from how you might consider a request to, say, separate a transportation bill with respect to its rail clauses and its aviation clauses. Stopping the expansion of MAID to people with mental illness was the subject of Bill C-218, which the Liberal government voted against earlier this session, citing an intention to bring forward the legislation it tabled yesterday, Bill C-41. In the absence of legislation, this expansion will go into effect March 17, 2027. You will recall, Mr. Speaker, that this deadline has been twice delayed by the Liberals, citing the need for further study and further readiness.
In this Parliament, the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying was re-established, with the narrow mandate of exploring the forthcoming mental illness expansion. The culmination of the study was a singular recommendation, supported by Liberal and Conservative members of the committee, that the expansion not proceed. This was an incredibly important act of bipartisan co-operation on what, I reiterate, is a life-and-death matter. This work underscores the importance of allowing parliamentarians to consider the mental health expansion of MAID on its own merit rather than marrying it to the separate and also consequential question about advance requests.
During the course of the committee's hearings, we heard from many experts, including MAID practitioners, who oppose MAID for people with mental illness but support MAID itself. There are those who support MAID for people with mental illness but not MAID for people without the capacity to consent, just as the inverse is undoubtedly true. On these questions of conscience, members should be free to vote individually on each of these two distinct questions.
In approaching the exercise of your authority under Standing Order 69.1, Mr. Speaker, I would encourage you to draw inspiration from the way in which the Chair uses its discretion on the selection of report stage amendments when a matter of conscience comes before the House. While on most bills, the criteria are applied in a clinical manner, the Chair will, on matters of conscience, approach the exercise in a more generous fashion.
Two such cases concern earlier iterations of medical assistance in dying legislation. On the original MAID bill, Bill C-14, Mr. Speaker Regan said, at page 3485 of the Debates on May 17, 2016:
The Chair appreciates the arguments put forward by hon. members as to why they consider these amendments to be of such significance as to warrant further consideration at report stage. I recognize that this is an important issue on which many members have strong and varied opinions. The Chair notes that the bill before us is unique, in its far-reaching social, moral and constitutional implications. The Chair also notes that, given the variety of opinions expressed by various members in all parties in relation to the provisions of this once-in-a-generation bill, the Chair is open to the argument of exceptional significance as contemplated in our Standing Orders. For these reasons, the Chair is prepared, on this occasion, to give members the benefit of the doubt....
Similar views were expressed concerning the later Bill C-7, by the Assistant Deputy Speaker, on November 27, 2020, at page 2603 of the Debates:
As with the original medical assistance in dying legislation four years ago, I recognize that this is an important issue with profound legal, moral and constitutional dimensions and that members have strongly held and varied points of view on these matters.
For these reasons, the Chair is prepared on this occasion to give members the benefit of the doubt....
To return to the threshold for dividing votes set out in the relevant standing order, I submit here that there is a sound basis for you to find that, despite the common element between the key questions involving MAID itself, the measures are fundamentally distinct from one another, with separate political, moral and legal implications, and for that matter, distinct levels of support and opposition among Canadians and, I suspect, Parliamentarians as well.
In closing, the disparate objectives of Bill C-41 warrant your prerogative as Chair to divide the question for the purposes of voting.