House of Commons Hansard #167 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was jobs.

Topics

line drawing of robot

This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Statements by Members

Question Period

The Conservatives argue that high immigration is worsening pressure on health care and housing. They criticize the government’s spending and accounting, including overseas funding, and question its handling of Telesat funding and ethics, the Brampton Stellantis plant sale, and Millar Western job losses. They also demand an independent audit of the PrescribeIT spending.
The Liberals defend their immigration plan, citing health-care recruitment and efforts to manage population growth and ease infrastructure pressures. They promote Budget 2026’s affordability measures, investments in housing and jobs, and support for workers facing tariffs, including forestry aid and efforts to protect Stellantis jobs. They also highlight caregiver support and maintaining environmental protections.
The Bloc challenge the Prime Minister over potential Brookfield conflicts of interest, calling for him to sell his shares or options. They also condemn Bill C-39 for weakening environmental protections in national parks and marine protected areas.
The NDP oppose telecom consolidation, warning a Quebecor-Telus takeover could worsen high cellphone prices amid affordability concerns.

Canadian Heritage Members table heritage committee reports on journalism, media, and creative spaces, alongside Conservative and Bloc supplementary reports raising concerns about foreign intimidation, media support and accountability, and distinctions between professional journalism and other forms of commentary. 800 words.

Petitions

Financial Statement of Minister of Finance Members debate the 2026 budget, including proposed investments in housing, affordability, clean energy, infrastructure, agriculture and business growth. Liberal speakers present it as a plan for resilience and long-term prosperity, while Conservatives criticize its deficits, costs and immigration levels, and the Bloc raises concerns about health transfers, fiscal imbalance and federal priorities. 14000 words, 2 hours.

National Immigration Month Act Second reading of Bill S-215. The bill designates November as National Immigration Month to recognize immigrants’ contributions to Canada and encourage public awareness. Supporters emphasize immigration’s historical, cultural and economic value; critics argue recognition should be accompanied by responsible immigration levels, adequate housing and services, and action on exploitation, integration and affordability. 7800 words, 1 hour.

Adjournment Debates

Air Canada strike intervention Garnett Genuis says the government has no records or evidence supporting the minister’s claim that the Air Canada strike threatened organ and pharmaceutical shipments, and challenges her integrity. Leslie Church says the minister was briefed on risks to critical medical supplies and acted responsibly after negotiations stalled, while defending workers’ rights and proposed changes to section 107.
Airport privatization Heather McPherson warns that privatizing airport operations could raise fees, put jobs at risk and transfer profits to investors. Leslie Church says airport assets would remain federally owned, with rules protecting travellers and workers and investment supporting regional airports. She also opposes expanding Billy Bishop Airport at the expense of Toronto’s waterfront.
Small business tax relief Brad Vis urges the government to raise the small business deduction threshold from $500,000 to $700,000 and the GST small-supplier threshold from $30,000 to $60,000, arguing businesses face mounting costs. Marie-Gabrielle Ménard cites budget measures, including a productivity deduction and eased instalment requirements, and says the government will consider further support. Vis presses for lower overall taxes.
Was this summary helpful and accurate?

Bill S-215 National Immigration Month ActPrivate Members' Business

6:30 p.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

I would remind the member that I recognized him on debate, not to ask questions. I invite him to continue, if he wishes. There are nine minutes remaining in his allotted time.

Before I give him the floor, I recognize the government House leader on a point of order.

Proceedings on Bill C-42Private Members' Business

6:30 p.m.

Gatineau Québec

Liberal

Steven MacKinnon LiberalMinister of Transport and Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Mr. Speaker, pursuant to Standing Order 32(2), I am tabling a copy of a motion that the government gave notice of today in relation to Bill C-42.

The House resumed consideration of the motion that Bill S-215, An Act respecting National Immigration Month, be read the second time and referred to a committee.

Bill S-215 National Immigration Month ActPrivate Members' Business

6:30 p.m.

Bloc

Alexis Deschênes Bloc Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj, QC

Mr. Speaker, immigration is a hot-button issue. It is a polarizing issue. Today, we are debating a bill to designate a specific month as immigration month. The Bloc Québécois supports this bill, but I see it as an opportunity to share certain facts that will help people draw their own conclusions about immigration.

In recent years, immigration levels have been very high. However, before we look at the numbers and the new statistics, let us first examine Canada's total population, followed by Quebec's, in order to put things in context. What we are seeing is that Canada's population grew very little between 2025 and 2026. In percentage terms, it was the slowest population growth since 1915. The situation in Quebec is much the same. According to figures released in the spring of 2026, Quebec's population declined slightly in 2025, although it had grown significantly, at an exceptional rate, from 2022 to 2024 because of uncontrolled immigration policies. Looking at the overall population in both Canada and Quebec, what we see at present is a slight decline, or at least a stabilization of population growth.

Another interesting point to consider before we discuss immigration targets is what is actually happening on the ground. It has received relatively little attention, but the day after the budget, on November 6, the government tabled its annual report to Parliament on immigration levels for the previous year. That report matters because it provides a clearer picture of the reality. What does it show? In 2025, the federal government had set a target of 367,000 temporary foreign workers and just over 300,000 international students, for a total of approximately 673,000 temporary residents in Canada for 2025. However, those targets were not met, and I think that is worth emphasizing and telling people. The government had planned for 367,000 temporary foreign workers, but only 208,000 arrived. The gap is even more striking in the case of international students. The target was 305,000, yet only 115,000 students came. We can see that, in reality, over the past year, the targets have not been met. I think that is worth pointing out.

What we are also seeing is a degree of course correction since 2024. Between the beginning of 2024 and the beginning of 2026, the number of new international students decreased by 71%. The number of new temporary workers fell by 57%. As for asylum claims, they were down 68% compared with the same period in 2024. These are facts that deserve to be mentioned before debating immigration.

There is also the issue of migration. With regard to the situation in Quebec, some fairly recent figures have been released. They show the impact of both international and interprovincial migration on Quebec. One interesting observation is that, in 2025, Quebec recorded a net loss in its international migration balance. In other words, 12,000 more people left Quebec for destinations abroad than the number of international immigrants who settled in Quebec that year. Another figure worth watching is the interprovincial migration balance. Are immigrants who first arrive in other Canadian provinces subsequently moving to Quebec? The answer is no. In fact, the opposite is true. More people are leaving Quebec for other Canadian provinces than are moving to Quebec from elsewhere in Canada. The net balance is a loss of 9,000 people. I mention all of this simply to put the facts on the table.

Now let us turn to what was announced in the budget on November 5. I touched on this earlier. Since I was not at the lock-up, I received a copy of the budget at four o'clock. On leafing through the document, we come to page 216, concerning the 2027-2029 immigration levels plan. At first, we see that the government's targets are 370,000 new temporary resident arrivals and 380,000 permanent resident admissions. We notice that these are the same targets that were announced last year. Then we get to the second paragraph, and things become really unclear. It reads, “Help transition the many longstanding temporary residents to permanent residency. Up to 200,000 temporary residents already in Canada would have the opportunity to become permanent residents by the end of 2027.” It states, in the conditional tense, “would have the opportunity”. We look at that and wonder what it means. It makes the people who drafted the budget look bad when readers are left with more questions than answers. It is a sign that it was poorly drafted. The question is: Was that done deliberately?

The first point to establish is whether the 200,000 residents mentioned are included in the 380,000. It is important to know that. Are these temporary residents, people who have been here for a long time and who will be offered a pathway to permanent residency? That could be a valid argument. In the end, it was by asking questions that we learned that the 200,000 would be added to the total. It was also by asking questions that we learned that there are also 80,000 temporary residents who were planned for last year and who will also be added, for a total of 662,000.

This is the second year that the government has done this. It sets thresholds, and then adds permanent residents who fall outside those thresholds. It really is a strange concept. We just want the government to give the real figures and explain things properly. That is really important, because, as I said at the beginning, immigration is a polarizing issue, one that is hotly debated. If the government wants to bring in 662,000 permanent residents by the end of 2027, it should say so clearly, take responsibility and defend its position. People will be able to judge for themselves.

What impact will the thresholds announced this year have on Quebec? It is important to note that Quebec sets its own permanent immigration thresholds. Quebec just had an election, and the Parti Québécois has proposed setting the permanent immigration threshold at 35,000. Announcements will be made in that regard. Since Quebec sets its own permanent immigration thresholds, if the Quebec government decides to move forward with the threshold of 35,000, then only 35,000 of the 662,000 new permanent residents will settle in Quebec. The rest will have to settle elsewhere in Canada.

The programs we are hearing about will be available outside Quebec. Will temporary residents of Quebec decide to settle outside Quebec to obtain permanent residency? That is something to keep an eye on. However, one thing is certain. If Quebec takes in 35,000 residents, it will be about 5% of the total. Our demographic weight within the Canadian federation would decline as a result. This illustrates the inherent difficulty of managing immigration within the Canadian federation. Either Canada agrees to lower its thresholds to align with Quebec policy—and I do not believe that will happen—or Quebec can become a fully independent country, able to manage immigration itself and make its own decisions rather than be affected by those of the federal government. Given that recent polling shows that Quebec is the most welcoming place in Canada, Quebec's independence would allow us to better manage immigration and be more successful at it.

Bill S-215 National Immigration Month ActPrivate Members' Business

6:40 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to rise and speak to what I think is a fabulous bill. It is legislation that I would think every member of the House of Commons would want to see pass. At the end of the day, it is recognizing a reality in Canada today, in the past and looking forward into the future. I will break my comments into two areas. The first will be responding to what opposition members have said. The second will be specifically with regard to Bill S-215 and what my hon. colleague has brought forward to the House of Commons for debate today.

When I think of the opportunities within the legislation, I think of us designating months for a wide spectrum of things. On the floor, whether it is for our Lebanese community, our Filipino community, our Indian community, our Greek community or any of the many different groups, we have had recognition in the form of designating months. It provides a wonderful opportunity. To me, that is what Bill S-215 is all about. It is about recognizing a reality and how immigration from day one has made Canada the country it is today, along with first nations.

I would like to think that when it comes to awareness, for example, there are educational opportunities in terms of local schools in our communities. We can recognize that we have the opportunity, in the month of November, for a teacher to be able to encourage some sort of program; it could be a teacher or even a school. It is something that I would personally promote and encourage educational facilities to look at, even in post-secondary.

However, this is not only for educational facilities. I suggest we could even get workplaces and work environments involved. This could include community facilities seeing the value of recognizing Bill S-215 and the benefits of having that sense of awareness. I see that as a very strong positive. It is something we can see as a very special celebration. Every year, in the month of August, if someone comes to Winnipeg, they can experience Folklorama first-hand. I would say it is one of the world's best celebrations over two weeks with numerous pavilions, all different groups and celebrations of our diversity.

Proceedings on Bill C-42Private Members' Business

6:45 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Mr. Speaker, before I go to the second part of my speech, I do want to ask members, and I believe there have been discussions among the parties, for unanimous consent for the following motion.

I move:

That the motion tabled earlier today regarding Bill C-42 be adopted.

Proceedings on Bill C-42Private Members' Business

6:45 p.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

All those opposed to the hon. minister’s moving the motion will please say nay. It is agreed.

The House has heard the terms of the motion. All those opposed to the motion will please say nay.

(Motion agreed to)

The House resumed consideration of the motion that Bill S-215, An Act respecting National Immigration Month, be read the second time and referred to a committee.

Bill S-215 National Immigration Month ActPrivate Members' Business

6:45 p.m.

Winnipeg North Manitoba

Liberal

Kevin Lamoureux LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Mr. Speaker, I want to be able to recognize the substance of Bill S-215. Recognizing national immigration month is a positive thing.

Having said that, I am discouraged by the comments I have heard from my colleagues in the Conservative Party and the Bloc Party, in particular, the Conservative Party.

Earlier today, I put a challenge out to the shadow minister for immigration for the Conservative Party. I hope she takes me up on that challenge, because I believe there has been a distortion of reality toward the negative side in a certain sector of society that uses and sees immigration as a bad thing. It has raised the level of things like racism, and so much more. There are some within the House who are promoting it, indirectly.

Let me give members a tangible example. The Conservative Party of Canada, on numerous occasions, in question period, even this afternoon, has tried to give the impression that there are 600,000-plus immigrants coming to Canada in the next year. That is just not true. It is far from reality.

The minister herself made reference to the program, and well over 50% are people living in Canada today, most of whom are already employed. They are paying taxes. They are already housed. Every week I am talking to individuals, and I have a databank of hundreds of individuals who have been working in the province of Manitoba for two or more years. That is why I like the question the Minister of Immigration threw back today in question period when she asked the member which ones she would like to leave Canada. Is it those who have been working here for two or three years, or would it be the Ukrainian settlers? Is that who the official opposition wants us to kick out of Canada?

To me, it is more about perception and how, as an official opposition, they are trying to get that anti-immigrant feeling pumped to the degree that it is marginally racism, and that hurts us all. It is very short-sighted.

Earlier today, I sent an invite out to the shadow critic for immigration to come to Winnipeg. I will do better than that. I will go to Calgary. I will debate this issue in any major city in Canada, ideally Winnipeg, followed by Calgary, then maybe Ottawa. I am not scared of the truth. I see the benefits of what is being proposed on the floor of the House of Commons. It is sound.

Do members know how many health care workers have been working in a health care field, and who the Conservatives are trying to imply to Canadians are not even here, but in some other land, and the Government of Canada is going to bring them over? In reality, they are working here today, and contributing taxes, in health care, education and different ways.

The point is, when we look at this legislation, we should appreciate the contributions of immigration from the past, today and going forward. That is what Bill S-215 would do. Having national immigration month in the month of November, the very month in which we are having second reading on this bill, makes a whole lot of sense. It is something we should look at as a treasure.

One of the greatest treasures Canada has is our diversity, from first nations to the immigration policies to the immigrants who are coming today and everything in between. That is what has made Canada the greatest country in the world to call home, and we should not be preaching to others that they should be fearful of immigration. I can tell members on the opposite side that, in working collaboratively with provinces, I know that Manitoba desperately wants to be able to retain those individuals the Conservatives want to send away. Talk to the provincial government. Talk to the business council. Talk to the mayors of Winnipeg and Brandon and many other municipalities. They see the benefits that we all will have.

I look forward to the bill ultimately passing so that we can, in fact, celebrate the month of November as a month of diversity and immigration.

Bill S-215 National Immigration Month ActPrivate Members' Business

6:50 p.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

Mr. Speaker, as an immigrant, I can tell members that Canada has always been a country of promise, a promise that if someone came here prepared to work, contribute and play by the rules, they could build a better life. I am living proof of that promise.

I stand here today because Canada gave me a chance. That is why I support national immigration month, but it is also why I believe we have a responsibility to make sure that promise is still being kept.

I left behind my parents, my relatives, my friends and everything familiar to me. I arrived in a new country with no guarantees. I was not looking for a shortcut or special treatment. I was looking for a fair opportunity, and Canada gave me one. I studied here, worked here and raised my family here. I spent nearly three decades working as a cop, and today, I have the privilege of representing the people of Windsor West in the House. When I look back on that journey, I see a country that gave me the opportunity to earn my success, and I know thousands of Canadians have similar stories.

Look at Windsor: Generations of families came from France, Italy, Portugal, Poland, Greece, Vietnam, India, Pakistan, the Caribbean and so many other parts of the world. They worked in our auto plants, built our homes, staffed our hospitals, worked on farms and construction sites, and opened businesses. Many workers worked long hours and overtime, so their children could have opportunities they never had. They may not have had much when they arrived, but they had something powerful, the belief that their children could have a better future here. That is how Windsor was built, and that is how Canada was built.

Those generations taught us something important: People do not have to abandon their heritage to belong here. They can celebrate Diwali, Eid, Christmas or Hanukkah. They can speak another language at home and pass their traditions on to their children. They can be proud of where they came from, and they can be equally proud of where they belong now.

However, we also must be honest about the reality facing newcomers today. What happens when someone sells everything they own, leaves their family behind, spends their savings and travels thousands of miles, believing they are coming to a country of opportunity? They arrive, and they discover they cannot afford a home, their qualifications are not recognized, the job they expected is not there, and rent, groceries and transportation consume almost everything they earn. Many have to work far below their qualifications. Others are exploited by unscrupulous recruiters, immigration consultants and employers. Imagine someone making the enormous sacrifice, only to discover that the Canada they were promised does not exist. That is not the Canada or the Canadian dream we should be selling.

How did we get here? For years, the Liberal government allowed immigration and temporary resident numbers to grow dramatically without ensuring that housing, health care, infrastructure and essential services could keep pace. The government seemed to believe that announcing immigration targets was the same as having an immigration plan. It is not. A target is a number on a government document. A plan means making sure there are homes for people to live in, doctors to look after them, schools for their children and jobs that allow them to support their families.

The government recklessly increased the numbers, and it failed to manage the consequences. Everyone is paying the price. Young Canadians cannot afford their homes, families are struggling with rent and grocery bills, newcomers are finding housing out of reach, patients are waiting for doctors, and employers need workers while qualified people cannot get their credentials recognized.

Let me be clear. The newcomer did not create the housing shortage, and the Canadian families struggling to pay rent did not design the immigration system. These people are not each other's enemies. They want the same things: a safe place to live, a decent job and the opportunity to build a future. They deserve a government that understands that.

We can welcome immigrants and still insist on responsible immigration levels. We can celebrate diversity and still demand accountability. Those positions are not contradictory. They are common sense.

There is another part of this discussion we cannot ignore. For the Canadians born and educated here, who join our police services, serve our military and build businesses in this community, this is their home. This is their country, yet I hear from these same people that they are being asked where they are really from or told to go back to a country they do not even know. The hostility they experience today just did not happen 10 or 12 years ago.

A Canadian should never have to explain why they belong in Canada. They should never have to produce a family tree to prove that this is their home. Racism and hatred have no place in this country. We must confront them wherever they appear.

Political leaders have a responsibility to bring people together. Too often, the Liberal government has responded to legitimate questions about immigration, housing and population growth by questioning the motives of those asking those questions.

When people raise concerns about affordability, they deserve answers, not accusations. When communities say that their infrastructure is under pressure, they deserve a plan, not a reprimand. We must never confuse a debate about government policy with an attack on the people who come to Canada. We must never allow the debate to become an excuse for prejudice.

I want to bring this discussion to a more personal space. I spent nearly three decades in policing. I know what it means to put on a uniform, leave one's family at home and head out the door without knowing what the day will bring. This year, Canadians have mourned seven police officers who made the ultimate sacrifice in service to their community and their country. Among them were OPP officer Tarun Bali, who came to Canada from India as a child, and Montreal police officer Mohamed Benredouane, who came to Quebec from Algeria as a teenager. We also lost officers Ramandeep Kaur Maan, from India, and Nicolae Serban, from Romania.

They had different beginnings and different journeys but one country and one commitment to service. They put on a uniform, accepted their responsibility and went to work knowing that their duties sometimes meant putting themselves in harm's way. Tragically, they did not make it home. They were not outsiders. They were not guests. They were Canadians serving Canadians. They were our colleagues, our neighbours, our sons and daughters, and our heroes.

Their families came here believing in the promise of Canada. Their loved ones helped protect that promise for the rest of us, so I ask the government and every member of the House, are we are keeping faith with them? Are we keeping faith with families who came here believing their children could build a better future? Are we keeping faith with the next generation born and raised here, who should never have to question whether they belong? Those officers served their country. Their families made sacrifices for this country. The least we owe them is a country that lives up to the promise they believed in.

I also want to say something to my colleagues on both sides of the House. No community belongs to any one political party. We should never take people for granted or assume that someone's background determines what they believe. People want their children to be safe. They want decent jobs, affordable homes and a government that respects their hard work and spends their tax dollars responsibly. Those are Canadian values. They do not belong to one culture, one faith or one political party.

If November is going to be national immigration month, let us make it mean something. Let us tackle immigration fraud and worker exploitation. Let us address unreasonable processing delays. Let us recognize foreign credentials for nurses, doctors, engineers and tradespeople who can contribute. Let us confront racism wherever it appears. A commemorative month would not find someone an affordable home. It would not put a family doctor in a community that needs one. It would not protect a vulnerable worker or erase the hurt felt by a young Canadian who has been told they do not belong here. These things require leadership, accountability and action.

When I arrived in Canada in 1988, I came on my own with the hope and willingness to work. I was fortunate. This country gave me a chance. I want the next person arriving in Canada to have the same opportunity I had, and I want every Canadian, regardless of where their family began, to know that hard work, contribution and commitment still count for something in this country. That is the promise of Canada. A promise is fulfilled not simply by repeating it. It is fulfilled when a young family can afford a home, when a newcomer can put their skills to work, when a child never has to feel like a stranger in their own country and when every Canadian can look to the future with confidence.

Let us honour those who came before us, let us stand with those who are here today, and let us welcome those who want to build their future here. Let us make sure that the promise that brought generations of immigrants to Canada is not simply a memory of what the country once was but a reality for the generations still to come, because Canada is not simply a place people come to. It is a promise people come here believing in. Our responsibility is to make sure that promise remains alive for the next generation. That is the Canada worth celebrating. That is the Canada worth defending.

Bill S-215 National Immigration Month ActPrivate Members' Business

7 p.m.

Conservative

Ted Falk Conservative Provencher, MB

Mr. Speaker, it is my privilege to speak to this private member's bill today, and I want to just reiterate what my colleague, the member for Calgary Nose Hill, so eloquently said, which is that there should have been discussions from the mover of this bill, which have not happened.

Canada makes a promise to immigrants when they come here, and the promise is very simple. When someone comes to Canada, if they work hard and play by the law, they will be able to live in a safe neighbourhood and raise a family, to find a job that will afford them that privilege, and to get an education for their family. Those are the promises we make to immigrants, and we need to match our immigration levels with what our country is able to provide so everybody can afford a house to live in and so we can also provide the health care and the education that are necessary for immigrants to be successful here.

I want to talk a bit about my particular story. My grandparents were all immigrants to this country in the late 1920s. They immigrated here from southern Russia at that time. It is Ukraine today, the centre of where the conflict is happening between Russia and Ukraine.

On July 23, 1873, a promise was made to the Mennonites who came to Canada, and that promise—

Bill S-215 National Immigration Month ActPrivate Members' Business

7 p.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

Unfortunately I have to cut off the member. We will find out about the rest of his story when the House next takes this up.

The time provided for the consideration of Private Members' Business has now expired, and the order is dropped to the bottom of the order of precedence on the Order Paper.

A motion to adjourn the House under Standing Order 38 deemed to have been moved.

LabourAdjournment Proceedings

7 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Mr. Speaker, my question tonight relates to the Air Canada strike and a decision made by the Minister of Jobs and Families to use section 107, but more fundamentally, it is a question about integrity. I know it is against our rules in the House to accuse a member of lying, and I would certainly never do that. I want to share some of the context around what happened in this case and allow people to draw their own conclusions about what the Minister of Jobs and Families said.

In the context of deciding to use section 107 to end a strike at Air Canada, the minister spoke specifically about the transportation of pharmaceuticals and organ tissue as being a motivator for ending that strike. She said in a written statement, not in an off-the-cuff comment, “This nationwide labour disruption is impeding the movement of passengers and critical cargo.” Later in the statement she wrote, “Further, the shipments of critical goods such as pharmaceuticals and organ tissue, over 40% of which are moved by Air Canada, should continue to reach their destinations.”

Blacklock's, I believe, was the first one to do an ATIP and identify the fact that there were no records within the Government of Canada to verify claims about how the strike was putting at risk the transport of organs and tissue. I repeatedly asked the minister and officials at committee whether they could present the evidence they had relied on to do this. I also asked whether, if they had been told in some meeting that the transport of organs and tissue was at risk, they could share with us who told them that and when the meeting was. I then asked officials whether officials have any record of this meeting, where it took place and which officials were present. Of course, typically officials or staff of some sort would be present for briefings with the minister.

No information was provided, in terms of when and where that meeting took place, so I followed up with this again with an Order Paper question, which is Question No. 1407. I asked in various ways what records the government has with regard to the transportation of organs by air and how those shipments are tracked and managed. In response to this question, the government repeatedly affirmed that it did not collect data. It had no data on those things. I then asked in the same question about the meeting or alleged meeting that took place in which the minister received this information. Again, there were no records of that meeting whatsoever and no record of the information.

The best that the government could offer is that “the Minister receives a continuous flow of information, analysis, assessments, and advice from a broad range of sources within and outside government.” At best, taking the most charitable view, maybe the minister was, in private and off the cuff, told by somebody that this was a risk associated with the strike, and used that information as the basis for ending the strike, even though she had no evidence whatsoever to support that claim. Perhaps she made it up herself. Perhaps somebody else made it up and said it to her, but this was clearly a statement that was not true, one that the minister has repeatedly made and doubled down on.

Speaking of the integrity of the minister, is she or a representative willing to acknowledge that this was not true? At what point, given the clear evidence in this Order Paper question, are we going to have an acknowledgement of that reality?

LabourAdjournment Proceedings

7:05 p.m.

Toronto—St. Paul's Ontario

Liberal

Leslie Church LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Secretaries of State for Labour

Mr. Speaker, I do not accept the member's characterization of the minister's actions. She has explained the concerns she was weighing in her responsibility to Canadians. At committee, the minister said she received briefings about disruptions to critical medical supplies. In the House, she explained why those concerns mattered.

Canadians depend on the movement of essential medicines and medical products, including organs for transplant, within Canada and across our borders. For someone waiting for treatment, getting those supplies on time matters. That had to be part of the decision. The member is entitled to question the decision. Canadians are also entitled to hear the context in which it was made.

The government believes in collective bargaining. We respect the right to strike. We know that a negotiated agreement gives workers and employers the strongest foundation to move forward together. That is why federal mediators work alongside the parties to help them find common ground. The vast majority of negotiations in federally regulated workplaces conclude without a work stoppage. That reflects the hard work of unions, employers and the people who help them reach agreements.

In the Air Canada dispute, negotiations had been under way for eight months. Despite extensive support, the parties remained at an impasse. The minister had a responsibility to protect Canadians' access to essential medicines and medical supplies. People depend on those deliveries for their care. Those needs could not be set aside. That meant weighing the consequences of a disruption alongside workers' rights. The minister directed the Canada Industrial Relations Board to send the dispute to arbitration under section 107 of the Canada Labour Code. As she has explained, the purpose was to help resolve the dispute and protect Canadians. Intervening in a labour dispute is a serious and exceptional step. Our preference was, and remains, an agreement reached by the parties at the table.

The concerns flight attendants raised about their own working conditions also deserve action. I have said in this House that nobody should work for free in this country. Flight attendants do important work to keep passengers safe. They deserve to be paid fairly for that work. When allegations of unpaid work were raised, the government launched an investigation into pay practices in the airline sector. We have been working with airlines and unions to examine compliance with the Canada Labour Code. Employers must meet their obligations. Workers deserve certainty.

We also want to give workers and employers a better chance of resolving difficult disputes themselves. That is why Bill C-39 proposes earlier support for bargaining and clearer requirements before section 107 can be used. A special mediator would work intensively with the parties. If they could not reach an agreement, a public report would help Canadians understand the outstanding issues and prospects for settlement. A national impact assessment would examine the consequences of a disruption beyond the bargaining table. These changes would make the process more transparent and give the parties further opportunities to reach a deal. Intervention must always remain a last resort.

Bringing people together takes work. It means listening to workers, expecting employers to do their part, and taking seriously the consequences for Canadians when talks break down. The government will continue to do that work. Workers deserve fair treatment, and Canadians deserve a government that takes their health and safety seriously.

LabourAdjournment Proceedings

7:10 p.m.

Conservative

Garnett Genuis Conservative Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan, AB

Mr. Speaker, there is a lot I could say about the unpaid work issue, but that is not the core issue here. The core issue here is the integrity of the government.

The minister made a written claim. That claim is not supported by any evidence or by any information the minister received. In response to my question tonight, the parliamentary secretary doubled down on and repeated this claim.

The claim that the strike impacted organ transport is not a matter of opinion or philosophy. It is a falsifiable, factual claim. That is, it is either objectively true or objectively not, and whether or not it is true is dependent entirely on the evidence. However, the minister made a claim, that factual claim, as we now know from the Order Paper question, the ATIP and other supporting evidence, entirely without information or evidence. How do they defend that?

LabourAdjournment Proceedings

7:10 p.m.

Liberal

Leslie Church Liberal Toronto—St. Paul's, ON

Mr. Speaker, the member opposite keeps repeating his allegation. The minister told the committee that she was briefed on risks to critical medical supplies. She has explained why she took those concerns seriously. Canadians depend on essential medicines, medical supplies and organs moving across this country and across our borders. Their needs do not stop because there is a labour dispute.

After months of negotiations, the parties at the time were at an impasse. The minister had a responsibility to work toward a resolution and consider the consequences for Canadians. That is why she referred the dispute to the Canada Industrial Relations Board. Nobody should be expected to work for free. We acted on allegations of unpaid work in the airline sector, and employers must meet their obligations.

The member is entitled to disagree, but the responsibility to protect Canadians does not disappear because a decision is difficult.

Air TransportationAdjournment Proceedings

7:10 p.m.

NDP

Heather McPherson NDP Edmonton Strathcona, AB

Mr. Speaker, I am standing today to talk about airport privatization. It was a question I brought up in the House earlier and is something that I and, I think, so many Canadians across this country are deeply concerned about.

The airports in this country belong to Canadians. They are our assets, purchased with Canadian dollars, and the benefits of those airports should be to Canadian communities and Canadians who travel and use those airports, not to private investors. However, we are seeing a desire by the Liberal government to sell those assets off and give them to private investors to make that income. There is only one way for private investors to make money off our airports. There are two things that can be done: reduce costs or increase revenue. Both of those things are to the detriment of Canadians.

The first thing we know about privatization of airports is that it will cost Canadians more. The Canadian Labour Congress report “Public Runways, Private Profits” examined privatization in Australia, New Zealand, Portugal, the U.K. and the United States. That report estimates that airports would need to generate 15% to 20% more revenue to provide competitive returns to private investors. At Perth Airport, after privatization, the cost per passenger went up 60% over a decade.

CUPE and Unifor have warned the government that there is a risk of increased airport improvement fees, landing fees, parking fees, even charges for dropping off family members. The Minister of Transport tells Canadians there would be no unjustifiable increases to the cost of travel for Canadians. He says, no unjustifiable costs. I would really like to hear from the minister as to what a justifiable cost is.

A perfect example would be Heathrow Airport. It is an example I know the government has used to justify the privatization of four of our biggest airports: the airport in Montreal, Toronto Pearson and the airports in Calgary and Vancouver. These four airports, by the way, make $525 million a year in revenue for the federal government, money that is then used to support smaller airports around this country. The example the government gave in its budget was Heathrow Airport. Heathrow, we have heard, costs up to 10 times as much as a public airport in Alberta does.

Canadians have a right to be very concerned that air travel, which is necessary in a country as big as Canada, and the cost of which is already very prohibitive for many Canadians, is going to get worse with this privatization scheme.

Aside from making things more expensive for Canadians who want to use airports, the second way these private investors and companies can make money is by cutting jobs and cutting corners. I am worried about the safety and the sovereignty of our airports, but I am also deeply concerned about the jobs that will be lost. There are good union jobs in these airports, and the government is giving up on those workers.

Air TransportationAdjournment Proceedings

7:15 p.m.

Toronto—St. Paul's Ontario

Liberal

Leslie Church LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Secretaries of State for Labour

Mr. Speaker, let me address the member's original question. As a Toronto member of Parliament, I have heard directly from hundreds of residents in my riding of Toronto—St. Paul's about Billy Bishop. Their concerns about noise, about health and about the future of our waterfront always deserve a clear response.

Our government is not supporting the proposed expansion. Following the consultation that closed on July 24, the Minister of Transport was clear: We will not pursue plans that encroach on Little Norway Park or Hanlan's Point Beach, that increase noise, that cause significant environmental harm or that hinder Toronto's ability to build housing. I share that position. I do not support losing green space or community amenities on the waterfront or the islands. The waterfront matters to people across our city. It is where families come to spend time together and enjoy the lake. The decisions we make now will shape that shared space for years to come.

We are investing in new homes, better transit and public spaces along the waterfront. The airport's future must respect the communities around it and the city we are building together. Toronto's municipal government has a vital role in those decisions. Ontario's move to acquire city lands makes transparent engagement with residents and the city all that much more important.

Billy Bishop serves travellers, supports jobs and connects communities. Our immediate priority is completing the runway safety improvements already approved. That work does not authorize Ontario's proposed expansion. For Canada's major airports, the proposed model for investment would require operators to follow clear, strict rules on fees, service standards, worker protections and safety. Airport lands and assets would remain federally owned. The purpose is to improve the infrastructure Canadians rely on, with clear oversight to protect the public interest.

As Toronto grows, as Canada grows, we need to build housing and transit, and improve transportation infrastructure while protecting the places people cherish. I will continue to insist that Torontonians have a meaningful say in the future of our waterfront in a city that we love.

Air TransportationAdjournment Proceedings

November 18th, 2026 / 7:15 p.m.

NDP

Heather McPherson NDP Edmonton Strathcona, AB

Mr. Speaker, I certainly think the member's government is also interested in protecting the Toronto waterfront because we keep hearing from the Toronto MPs that they have some interest in this, but then the government does not listen to Canadians, as usual. Members should listen as $7.3 billion of rent has been paid to the federal government by airports under the existing model, money that Canadians have earned, which the government has with the asset it has.

The member talks about the fact that Canadians will still own the land, but when the government has given away the running of those airports for 50 years to potentially foreign investors, what difference does it make if the land is still there because the profits have been given away? The rights have been given away.

There are 435,800 jobs in this sector and all of those jobs are at risk. This is shocking. It is a joke to have them talk about this as if this will be better for Canadians.

Air TransportationAdjournment Proceedings

7:20 p.m.

Liberal

Leslie Church Liberal Toronto—St. Paul's, ON

Mr. Speaker, once again, I stand up in this House to share directly what I have heard from residents in my community about our airports. I share the determination to protect our city and our waterfront, while ensuring we have the transportation infrastructure and the public transit, in particular, in place to meet our city's needs.

Our government is not supporting the proposed expansion at the waterfront. We will not pursue plans that threaten cherished public spaces, increase noise, cause significant environmental harm or limit housing. The immediate focus is approved runway safety work.

On the broader airport proposals the member referenced, lands and assets would remain federally owned with rules to protect travellers and workers. Part of this proposal is to ensure we have the means to support regional airports, air connections between communities and the infrastructure, and transportation that connects people and airports.

Torontonians deserve reliable transportation. That is what we are going to deliver.

Small BusinessAdjournment Proceedings

7:20 p.m.

Conservative

Brad Vis Conservative Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford, BC

Mr. Speaker, I rise today to return to measures I raised in question period during Small Business Week. I specifically proposed two measures.

The first would be increasing the small business deduction threshold from $500,000 to $700,000, which would have reduced the taxes collected from Canadian businesses to help them keep more money in their pockets.

The second proposal I brought forward during Small Business Week was about increasing the GST small supplier threshold from $30,000 to $60,000 and indexing it to inflation moving forward. This would have saved many Canadian small businesses from the hassle of being a GST registrant. We are specifically talking here about the real small businesses, side hustles like maybe a car detailing business or a mom doing baked goods in the evenings to support her kids' dance and hockey activities.

These recommendations were both supported by the Canadian Federation of Independent Business. Both of these recommendations would have saved real money for Canadian businesses that are struggling right now.

I have travelled across the country and spoken to thousands of small business owners. Many of them right now, at a period when we are seeing more and more insolvencies, are struggling to pay their commercial rent. Their input costs have gone through the roof. Their employee taxes, CPP, EI and payroll taxes, have all gone up in the last number of years. There are additional days off: In certain provinces there has been the addition of mandatory sick days.

In many respects, small business owners say it has been a death by a thousand cuts, so in good faith, before the budget, I brought these proposals forward to the government, hoping it would support them, because it would simplify the tax code and life for small business owners in Canada. Unfortunately, it rejected these proposals.

The Canadian Federation of Independent Business called the federal budget a “mega disappointment”, so I want to ask a straightforward question. My two specific proposals were, number one, increasing the small business deduction threshold from $500,000 to $700,000 and, number two, increasing the GST small supplier threshold from $30,000 to $60,000. Why did the government reject them?

We even have Liberals on record supporting these policies at the industry committee. Why would the government reject them? It would not have cost too much money. In fact, if we took even a portion of what we just gave Brazil, which was over $500 million, we could have afforded these measures.

Small BusinessAdjournment Proceedings

7:25 p.m.

Hochelaga—Rosemont-Est Québec

Liberal

Marie-Gabrielle Ménard LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Women and Gender Equality and Secretary of State (Small Business and Tourism)

Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to see you again. I commend you for your excellent work and for your diligence in the House.

I want to thank my colleague. I have no doubt about his commitment to supporting small businesses, and I am sure everyone in the House would agree. Small businesses are a source of pride for Canadians. One million businesses employ six million Canadians, so we are well aware of the importance of the economic contribution of small businesses to Canada's economic vitality.

Since this government took office, we have been doing everything we can to rise to the top of the ranks of G7 countries, to foster opportunities and create a favourable business environment, so that small businesses can thrive. What we are rolling out right now, particularly with budget 2026, are various initiatives and measures. Small businesses are not a monolith. While some are thriving and keen to export, we have concluded 20 trade agreements over the past year that are directly benefiting many of them. Others, and we recognize this, are facing significant challenges, particularly as a result of geopolitical uncertainty.

The productivity mega deduction is an exceptional measure. There is something about it that points to a new future for small businesses. The productivity mega deduction reduces the effective marginal tax rate on new business investment from 13% to 6.4%. This changes the business environment. It is the lowest rate among the world's major economies and less than half the rate in the United States. It is an unprecedented tax advantage that has been applauded by small businesses.

I believe that the name “mega deduction” is intended as a nod to the government's ambition and vision. In the riding that I have the honour of representing, it is going to benefit the Arhoma bakery on Ontario Street, which might be able to replace its coffee machine. A coffee machine can cost $50,000 these days. This deduction provides businesses with greater flexibility when structuring their financing. I am also thinking of ARA Robotics, also located in Hochelaga, where people are developing drone technology. There are really all sorts of potential applications, and the deduction will make businesses more productive and more competitive. It will foster innovation and, above all, help create value and jobs.

The idea is to make businesses more agile, but it is also to promote employee retention and knowledge retention. As we know, the future of small businesses depends heavily on their human resources and their ability to diversify their areas of operation. The Canadian Federation of Independent Business praised the mega deduction.

Budget 2026 includes various measures, as I mentioned. These are concrete measures. I would like to highlight the higher tax instalment thresholds. This may seem like a minor detail, but it is anything but. More than 180,000 businesses across the country have just had their administrative burdens eased. More than 180,000 businesses across the country will no longer have to file this type of form. Our goal is to free up entrepreneurs' time so they can focus on growing their businesses and continuing to represent the best of what Canada has to offer: talent and innovation.

Small BusinessAdjournment Proceedings

7:25 p.m.

Conservative

Brad Vis Conservative Mission—Matsqui—Abbotsford, BC

Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague for her remarks, but she did not respond to my two very specific questions on two very specific policies.

I am not opposed to the mega deduction in the budget, but the reality is that the taxation burden held by small businesses right now is becoming increasingly hard to shoulder. Businesses have been hit with input cost increases and with payroll tax increases that have limited their ability to grow and limited their ability to invest in things like new equipment, even if they get a really good capital cost writeoff.

What we need to do in Canada, and what businesses are asking of the Government of Canada, is to lower their overall tax burden. I would like the member to comment on that. When can they expect lower taxes in Canada?

Small BusinessAdjournment Proceedings

7:30 p.m.

Liberal

Marie-Gabrielle Ménard Liberal Hochelaga—Rosemont-Est, QC

Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague for his concern. He is clearly in regular contact with small business owners, and so are we on the government side of the House. Over the past several months, our government has demonstrated that it is agile. Whenever people have brought forward concrete proposals that could help Canadian businesses, we have considered them. I believe this is what we can look forward to in the future: working constructively across party lines to identify and implement additional measures, because this is not the end of the line. We want measures that can genuinely support small businesses in Canada.