Agreed.
House of Commons Hansard #160 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was contract.
House of Commons Hansard #160 of the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament's site.) The word of the day was contract.
This summary is computer-generated. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.
Income Tax Act Second reading of Bill C-269. The bill proposes a permanent 30% non-refundable tax credit for Canadian businesses that recover industrial waste heat and convert it into electricity. Conservatives support studying it as a way to improve efficiency, reduce waste and boost competitiveness; the Bloc supports it in principle but seeks clearer targeting and safeguards. The Liberals oppose it as overly broad, costly and duplicative of existing incentives. 7700 words, 1 hour.
Opposition Motion—Federal Procurement Members debate a $12-million CRA security contract awarded to a Canadian subsidiary of a U.S. multinational instead of the Commissionaires, a Canadian non-profit employing veterans. Conservatives and Bloc members criticize the decision as inconsistent with the government’s Buy Canadian commitments and the Commissionaires’ employment mission, citing a bid difference under 1%. Liberals defend the competitive process, arguing the successful supplier has substantial Canadian operations and offered the best overall value. They also discuss veteran employment and procurement oversight. 38400 words, 5 hours in 2 segments: 1 2.
Special Economic Measures Act First reading of Bill S-214. The bill would amend the Special Economic Measures Act to allow the Governor in Council to dispose of foreign state assets seized without a judicial order. 100 words.
Opposition Motion—Federal ProcurementBusiness of SupplyGovernment Orders
Some hon. members
Agreed.
A motion to adjourn the House under Standing Order 38 deemed to have been moved.
Leah Gazan NDP Winnipeg Centre, MB
Mr. Speaker, on October 26 of this year, I asked the resources minister if he really respected indigenous rights and, if so, whether he would withdraw Bill C-39. I asked that in response to the BCAFN, UBCIC, Treaty 6, Onion Lake, NAN, COO, APNQL and the Iroquois Confederacy requesting the withdrawal of Bill C-39.
Those organizations represent hundreds of thousands of first nations people. Not only did the minister refuse to respond to me, he had the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations respond to me.
I was not quite sure that particular day why the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources refused to respond. I thought perhaps he was starting to agree with me that all the government was doing was building a pipeline to the courts. Then I found out today that more nations are coming forward in opposition to all the new projects that are being designated, nine today alone, nine from the St’át’imc Chiefs Council that consist of and represent, again, hundreds of thousands of first nations, because of the government's failure to exercise its power under the Building Canada Act consistently with the statutory imperatives arising from the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. They argued that the government rushed the consultation, provided insufficient information about the project and failed to adequately consider its potential impacts on first nations treaty rights.
Cold Lake First Nations is another first nation that has also put forward an application for judicial review. It has also stated it was not properly consulted or engaged at all by the Major Projects Office. It was asking for a designation of the Pacific link as a national interest project to be reversed and for a declaration that Canada has a duty to consult on the project.
Now, I am starting to put things together, and I am hoping to get some clarification today. Whether it is violating the constitutional rights of workers, gutting environmental protections or brushing aside the rights of indigenous people, the government believes that it is above the Constitution and above the rule of law. I am starting to believe that, for the government, perhaps the reason is that when there is a bunch of former CEOs leading the country, they think that they are above our Constitution and human rights.
Anthony Housefather LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Emergency Management and Community Resilience
Mr. Speaker, on October 26, first nations leaders met with the Prime Minister and premiers at a historic first ministers' meeting, the first of its kind in 20 years. One of the main topics of discussion was how first nations can develop, own and share in the economic benefits of major projects.
We know we cannot build a stronger Canada without indigenous peoples. That is why we have taken steps to support indigenous ownership and partnership in major projects. We have opened new consultation resource centres to help communities participate in project reviews. We have provided funding so that indigenous communities have the expertise and capacity to engage in discussions about projects that impact them.
We are supporting the growing role of indigenous ownership so that communities can have a stake in what is being built and can share in long-term economic benefits. This includes support using new revenue tools, like the potential creation of a first nations sovereign wealth fund, on which the Prime Minister committed to initiating discussions.
Building on these efforts, the Prime Minister also announced plans to expand the First Nations Finance Authority's lending authority, making it possible for first nations to work together as special purpose vehicles to finance investments in major projects and share in the returns. He also announced $260 million over four years for a new partnerships for indigenous workforce readiness fund. This will help connect indigenous people with jobs created by major projects. These are steps toward greater indigenous ownership, more job opportunities and a direct share in Canada's economic future.
However, creating these opportunities also means getting the federal review process for major projects right. Indigenous peoples must have a meaningful role in decisions about projects that affect their lands and communities and a fair opportunity to benefit from them. That is what the building Canada strong act aims to do. We want to make project reviews more efficient and more predictable while maintaining indigenous rights and environmental protections.
The bill proposes a more coordinated approach, including a Crown consultation hub to bring federal departments together. This would reduce duplication during project assessments and help communities focus their time and expertise on the issues that matter to them. It would also benefit indigenous proponents of economic projects. Under the legislation, when more time would be needed for consultation, timelines could be extended or paused.
I recognize that first nations leaders have raised concerns, but I want to be clear about the government's obligations. Canada's legal duty to consult remains in place. Our commitments under modern treaties and self-government agreements remain in effect, and indigenous rights remain protected.
Building major projects and advancing reconciliation must go hand in hand. Indigenous peoples must have a meaningful role in decisions that affect them and a fair opportunity to share in the benefits. When indigenous peoples are true partners, projects are stronger, communities are stronger and Canada is stronger.
Leah Gazan NDP Winnipeg Centre, MB
Mr. Speaker, my hon. colleague is absolutely right. We will not be able to build Canada strong without first nations' free, prior and informed consent, something that the overwhelming majority of first nations across the country have indicated the government is failing to do. They are asking the government to withdraw Bill C-39, which violates the Constitution. Just because the government says something, that does not make it true.
It is very clear to workers, environmental organizations and first nations across this country that the government does not respect the Constitution. It is building nothing more than a pipeline to the courts.
Anthony Housefather Liberal Mount Royal, QC
Mr. Speaker, I recognize that the hon. member has raised concerns, and I recognize that first nations leaders have raised concerns. We take those concerns seriously.
At the historic meeting between first ministers and first nations, we discussed those concerns, along with how first nations can own major projects and share in the economic benefits they create. The building Canada strong act would help projects move forward while supporting meaningful consultation and protecting indigenous rights.
Let me be clear. Canada's legal duty to consult, our constitutional commitments, our commitments under modern treaties and self-government agreements, and indigenous rights remain protected. Economic development and reconciliation must go hand in hand. When indigenous economies grow stronger, Canada grows stronger too.
Michael Cooper Conservative St. Albert—Sturgeon River, AB
Mr. Speaker, I rise to follow up on a question I posed to the Minister of Health regarding the PrescribeIT scandal. I have to say that a week and a half ago when I participated in an adjournment debate on this scandal, I was astounded that the parliamentary secretary to the Minister of Natural Resources had the audacity to say that the way the Liberals have handled PrescribeIT is what good governance looks like.
Is it really? We are talking about a failed IT solution to digitize prescription services that cost taxpayers $300 million for a service that almost no one used. Even more concerning is the fact that of that $300 million, 200 million tax dollars are missing and unaccounted for.
There are also the Liberal insider executives who got rich padding their pockets with exorbitant bonuses. Let us take the CEO, Michael Green, for example. He padded his pocket with in excess of $600,000 in bonuses in just three years, between 2023 and 2026. Then he was awarded $1 million on his way out the door after the Minister of Health claimed she had fired him. I can only say that most Canadians would love to have $1 million in compensation upon being fired.
There are at least five other executives who received between $70,000 and $90,000 in bonuses in the same three-year period. We are talking about millions of tax dollars that went out the door by way of bonuses to reward Liberal insider executives who presided over what was a complete and total debacle, if not something much worse.
Then, there is the Minister of Health. Where was the Minister of Health through it all? The minister had completely turned a blind eye. She turned a blind eye as millions of dollars continued to flow to PrescribeIT. Officials testified at the health committee that the minister asked no questions about PrescribeIT. She had no questions about where 300 million taxpayer dollars had gone. The parliamentary secretary says that is what good governance looks like. If that is what good governance looks like, I would hate to see what bad governance looks like.
It is time for the Liberals to stop gaslighting and begin to answer some basic questions such as where the oversight was as 300 million tax dollars went up in smoke as the health minister was asleep at the switch.
Maggie Chi LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Health
Mr. Speaker, first, I appreciate a lot of the late show speeches. Monday is a good start to the week. As we go through the session, we have a lot of great legislation going on in the House, including Bill C-39 and a lot of the safe social media bills we are trying to advance also.
As the minister announced in June, our government wants to be sure we are getting accountability and value for money for taxpayers. This why she launched the independent review of Infoway's governance and structure, and a third party audit of the organization's findings. I want to make sure my colleague is aware that the review and the audits are both under way, and we are looking forward to seeing and sharing the results once they are available.
The Auditor General herself felt this was a very strong response, and the last time I checked, my Conservative colleague still respects the work of the Auditor General. She said that any additional work on the file by her would be “duplicative and therefore of limited added value for Parliamentarians and Canadians.” Especially seeing that the member opposite's Conservative colleagues on the health committee were some of the people who asked for the Auditor General's thoughts on the matter, I hope it is a good enough response for my colleague across the way as well.
Michael Cooper Conservative St. Albert—Sturgeon River, AB
Mr. Speaker, it is a totally inadequate response. What we just heard from the parliamentary secretary was more gaslighting. Her answer was very much in line with the ridiculous answer provided by the parliamentary secretary to the Minister of Natural Resources.
Since she will not answer basic questions, such as where the oversight was, perhaps she will answer a very specific question: Why did Mr. Green receive a $1-million golden parachute on his way out the door, and why did the minister fail to disclose this?
Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON
Mr. Speaker, I want to emphasize that there is work under way, and we need to allow the independent auditors to do their work, work that I hope the member will also allow. There is work under way, an internal review of the governance and structure of Infoway. Maybe my colleague did not get the updated QP card from his leader.
Canadians deserve a modernized health care system, and we will always make sure that that is built on the best possible information. Allowing for that third-party review and audit to be completed will do that work, and it will give Canadians the confidence that our money is being spent appropriately.
Jacob Mantle Conservative York—Durham, ON
Mr. Speaker, I am rising to follow up on a question that I posed to the Minister of Natural Resources not that long ago about the Liberal government's failure to remove antidevelopment laws from our oil and gas industry that are hindering our ability to become, in the government's own words, an energy superpower.
We still have, as I pointed out to the minister, a west coast shipping ban. We still have an industrial carbon tax. CEOs have come out and said that Canada is a tough place to invest in this industry because of these issues.
Energy security is fundamentally a geographic issue. Members can think about the news and the Strait of Hormuz, which is a geographic issue.
One place that does not have a geographic issue is the Pacific west coast. Before TMX, exports of Canadian crude to Asia were basically negligible. Today, exports of Canadian crude are reaching Asian markets in significant amounts. In fact, the Asia Pacific Foundation estimates that it is over $500 million per month in exports, which is half a billion dollars of new Canadian exports, because of one pipeline. That is not the only issue.
The barrier is not just getting exports to tidewater. That is only part of the challenge. Canadian crude is a distinctive type of heavy crude. Refineries around the world cannot always switch from one blend of crude oil to another without investments in upgrading equipment, storage, transportation, processing and refining infrastructure.
Canada has another barrier that it has put in front of our oil and gas industry, one barrier that the Liberals are entirely responsible for, because Canada has chosen to restrict one of the tools that could be used to develop these new Asian markets.
When the Prime Minister was the UN envoy for climate action and the financial adviser at the United Nations Climate Change Conference, commonly referred to as COP, or COP26 to be specific, in Glasgow, countries around the world, including Canada, signed what is called the Glasgow statement.
The Glasgow statement, among many other things, forced countries to ban their export promotion agencies from supporting new investments in oil and gas development. Therefore, as an agency of the Government of Canada, Export Development Canada had to adhere to the Glasgow statement.
If we go on their website, they have a policy from 2023, when the government signed on to the Glasgow statement, saying that they are now going to follow this and prohibit investment in those industries. That means that Export Development Canada and other Canadian export promotion agencies can no longer fund or invest in the kind of infrastructure that would facilitate the export of Canadian crude oil, in particular, to Asian markets.
My question to the parliamentary secretary is whether the government will repeal that prohibition so that Canadian export agencies can once again support strategic international infrastructure that expands markets for Canadian industry to, in its own words, make Canada an energy superpower.
Claude Guay LiberalParliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources
Mr. Speaker, in the words of our finance minister, I have good news for my colleague. There are projects moving forward in this country.
A pipeline is being built from Taylor, British Columbia, to Gordondale in Alberta. There is a major expansion of the sunrise natural gas pipeline system in British Columbia as well. I am also pleased to remind the member that the LNG Canada phase two expansion has achieved a final investment decision and is moving forward. There is significant investment, billions of dollars, going into energy infrastructure in Labrador, and there is a new transmission line being built to connect Nova Scotia and New Brunswick, which will improve the reliability of interprovincial power grids and respond to the growing demand for electricity.
What does that mean? It means workers are on the job site, equipment is on the ground, communities are seeing the benefits and Canada is building again. However, projects do not move forward just by accident. Canada is also changing how our projects move forward. Through the Major Projects Office, we are bringing together federal decision-making, reducing duplication and giving proponents a clearer path from proposal to construction.
The member asked when the next pipeline will be built, and the Prime Minister delivered the clearest possible answer—
Claude Guay Liberal LaSalle—Émard—Verdun, QC
You did last time.
Mr. Speaker, on October 1, the Prime Minister confirmed that the Pacific link pipeline is of national interest. Pacific link is critical to Canada's ambition to become a global energy superpower. Over the next year, the Major Projects Office, supported by the Canada Energy Regulator, will lead the project's federal review process and consultation. By September 2027, the goal is to finalize conditions for this project and advance Pacific link toward construction.
Canadians expect us to build, and they expect us to build responsibly. That means respecting our duty to consult indigenous people and ensuring that consultation helps shape the project, not just reacting to it. It means working with provinces, including British Columbia, because these projects cross jurisdictions and require co-operation to succeed. It means linking new infrastructure to real emissions reduction. In this case, Pacific link advanced with industry commitment to the Pathways project, a major carbon capture and storage project designed to significantly cut emissions while supporting jobs and growth.
Yes, we are moving forward. We are doing it in a way that is durable, economically, environmentally and socially, and that matters.
Jacob Mantle Conservative York—Durham, ON
Mr. Speaker, I am not asking the member about news today. I am asking him about a policy from 2023, which the government refuses to change. I am not asking about LNG or when the next pipeline will be built because it does not matter if someone gets a pipeline built if their customers cannot refine the product. That is the problem with the Glasgow statement. It prohibits Export Development Canada from investing in those types of refinery capabilities around the world, which would increase the market for Canadian oil and gas. This is, as I said in my original question, just one more Liberal policy that the Prime Minister refuses to change, because he was the one at Glasgow pushing these statements. I do not think a tiger can change its spots.
I will repeat my question to the parliamentary secretary. Will the Liberals repeal the Glasgow statement and let Export Development Canada and other export agencies promote Canadian oil and gas development infrastructure around the world?
Claude Guay Liberal LaSalle—Émard—Verdun, QC
Mr. Speaker, there is, in a way, common ground here because everyone in the House wants projects built. Everyone wants jobs created. Everyone wants Canada to succeed. There is no point living in the past.
Our job is to move from discussion to delivery, and that is exactly what Canadians are seeing through the Major Projects Office, through new infrastructure, through projects already moving forward across the country, including pipelines. We are seeing projects advance. We are seeing partnerships built early and built to last. That is how we deliver, and that is what Canadians expect.
Natural ResourcesAdjournment Proceedings
The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec
The motion to adjourn the House is now deemed to have been adopted. Accordingly, the House now stands adjourned until tomorrow at 10 a.m., pursuant to Standing Order 24(1).
(The House adjourned at 6:41 p.m.)