Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was terms.

Last in Parliament May 2004, as NDP MP for Regina—Qu'Appelle (Saskatchewan)

Lost his last election, in 2006, with 32% of the vote.

Statements in the House

The Economy December 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, today's Globe and Mail contains an article written by former Supreme Court Justice Willard Estey in which he expresses concern over the sellout of our Canadian economy to foreigners.

It leads me to give the corporate sellout award for the month of December to a company which has been responsible for the biggest sellout in our Canadian economy.

Our first nominee is MacMillan Bloedel, which sold out to U.S. forestry giant Weyerhauser for $2.4 billion U.S. The second nominee is Unihost Corporation, which operates in the hotel industry. It sold out to U.S. Westmount Partnership for $377 million. The third nominee is none other than People's Jewellers, which sold out to the U.S. Zale company for $75 million.

I will now look at the envelope. The winner for the biggest sellout of the month award for the month of December is Weyerhauser, which gobbled up MacMillan Bloedel, one of Canada's leading companies in the forestry industry.

Standing Committee On Finance December 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I am surprised my good friend across the way who is an accountant interprets the numbers in the way he does.

He knows that the projected surplus will be around $10 billion in the next fiscal year. If we take into consideration the contingency that the government is setting aside, if we take into consideration the prudence that it is setting aside and if we look at the history of the Minister of Finance, it might be even more than $10 billion. The Minister of Finance consistently underestimates the revenues of the Government of Canada, so there may be more than $10 billion.

The member across the way knows that. He is an accountant. He is a good member of the finance committee. Unfortunately he has become very, very conservative in terms of the tax cut agenda for wealthy people.

The GST cutback by one point will cost around $3 billion. That is about 30% of the surplus. That is a good amount to put in tax relief at the federal level at this time. Let us put most of the rest of the money into programs that are needed by the people of this country: health care, education, the farm crisis, the homeless situation and a children's agenda. That is what the people want.

Standing Committee On Finance December 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, this is a good question. In 1995, the current Minister of Finance cut more than $6 billion from Canada's national health program. This is in sync with the policy being put forward by the Reform Party.

The Minister of Finance, who is not a member of the Reform Party, made the worst cuts ever to health care, at the national level.

I remember very well when the national health program was introduced under Mr. Pearson. The CCF with Woodrow Lloyd and Tommy Douglas, from my province of Saskatchewan, were the first ones to come up with the idea. It was created at the national level by Mr. Pearson, a true Liberal. A true small “l” liberal, not a capital “L” Liberal like the ones we have today. At the time, the provinces and the federal government came to an agreement whereby the federal government would pay one half of the costs of the national health program, and the provinces, the other half.

Where do we stand today? The federal government only pays 12% or 13% of the costs. There is no national unity. Our country has no great vision. Where are the old Liberals? Where is the old Liberal Party of Pierre Trudeau, of Mr. Pearson, of Laurier and King? Where is that Liberal Party?

That Liberal Party has vanished completely. There is not a lot of difference now between the Liberal Party and the Mr. Manning's Reform Party. They are just about the same. We are stuck here with a government that is more conservative than Brian Mulroney's government was. Brian Mulroney never did such a thing. The government of the current Prime Minister is the only one to blame here.

Standing Committee On Finance December 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I did not even mention native people. I am not sure where that came from. I was saying that the member across the way like other Liberal members is not rising in the House of Commons and calling on the Minister of Finance to put more money into health care. The record speaks for itself.

The Liberal Party is implementing policies of the Leader of the Opposition and the Reform Party which call for massive cutbacks and a reduction of the role of government. That is exactly what it is doing. They are setting the agenda and that party across the way has implemented that agenda and knows it. That is why its members are so sensitive.

It is not just health care and the farm crisis. Let us look at what happened in terms of the cutbacks to education. The government is not investing in education like it should be. That is why we are falling behind in public support of education almost every state in United States. That is what is happening in Canada. If we had more federal moneys going to the provinces for education we would have better training for our people. We would have a more competitive and productive economy. That is not happening because of the cutbacks and the priorities of the government across the way.

The important point about the finance committee report is that it is supposed to be a framework and a vision for the next five years. What will the government do? It will continue the same right wing reactionary policies of the Reform Party in terms of handing out more and more money to wealthy people. In fact, the member for Calgary Southwest said at one time in the House that Conrad Black deserved a tax cut. The Reform Party is not implementing it but it is the Liberal Party across the way.

This is why we need a public debate in the country about our real priorities. The priorities should be to invest in people, to create more equality in people, to invest in the health care system, to come to the assistance of prairie farmers and to invest in the education system. Those should be our priorities and they are not the priorities today.

We hear all this stuff about tax cuts. I remember the Liberals in opposition, Mr. Speaker, and so do you. The member from the Northwest Territories was there. I remember when Brian Mulroney brought in the GST. I remember the Liberal Party saying in the House that if Canadians elected the Liberal Party, and it is in the red book, it would abolish the GST. Does everyone remember that?

The only member who had some honour in that regard was the former Deputy Prime Minister who resigned her seat and went to her people in a byelection. The Liberals made that promise on the GST. They promised to get rid of NAFTA, the free trade agreement. They promised many other things that were in the red book, and they broke those promises.

With that, Mr. Speaker, I hope you agree with me that what we are seeing is a right wing agenda by the Minister of Finance implementing the policies of the Reform Party of Canada.

Standing Committee On Finance December 16th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I congratulate the member for Saskatoon—Rosetown—Biggar on his maiden speech in the House of Commons. He follows in the great tradition of prairie social democrats such M. J. Coldwell, the second leader of the CCF in Canada; Alf Gleave, a former national president of the Farmers Union and member of the House of Commons for six years; and the honourable Chris Axworthy, attorney general and justice minister of the province of Saskatchewan, his immediate predecessor. I welcome him to the House of Commons.

I was quite struck by the majority report of the finance committee. I see my Liberal friends are probably even astonishing you, Mr. Speaker, because they are recommending that $46 billion or about half of the $95 billion surplus should go to tax cuts.

My good red Tory friend from Nova Scotia talked about hypocrisy tax in the red book promises. Perhaps that is why you are in the chair today, Mr. Speaker, because you can remain neutral on the breaking of a great Liberal principle of balance. Half of it was to go into program spending and half into deficit reduction and tax cuts. Now, afraid of the Leader of the Opposition, the Liberal Party has become a very right wing Conservative Party and is advocating putting half the surplus into tax cuts primarily for wealthy people.

Who in the country has paid for the fight on the debt and the deficit? Is it the Conrad Blacks of the world? Is it the wealthy people of the world? Is it the wealthier banks or the big firms in Canada? No. It is the ordinary people of the country who have paid for the fight on the deficit through cutbacks in health care, through cutbacks in education, through cutbacks in our social programs, and through cutbacks imposed on farmers. That is who has paid for the fight on the deficit. That is who has paid for the debt. Now that we have a surplus it seems to me the people who paid the price should reap the reward of a fiscal surplus, the ordinary people of Canada.

The Liberal Party is afraid of the Reform Party and the Leader of the Opposition and the tax cut agenda. I see across the way the member for Renfrew—Nipissing—Pembroke who is shaking in his chair in fear of the Reform Party. It is the same with the Minister of Finance who is implementing the Reform Party policy in terms of massive cutbacks in social programs like we never saw from any Conservative Party in the history of Canada including Brian Mulroney's.

That is exactly what has happened and there is no better example of that than the 60% cutback in support to farmers by the Liberal government across the way when their competitors in Europe and the United States have not been cutting back but indeed have been increasing support and subsidies to their farmers.

As the member for Saskatoon—Rosetown—Biggar said, 56 cents of a dollar in Europe will come from the treasury in Brussels and in the United States 38 cents will come from the treasury in Washington to support farmers. What is it in our country? It is 9 cents on the dollar.

The Reform Party has called for the end of all farm subsidies. Now it is the Liberal Party that is implementing the Reform policy to get rid of subsidies and support prices for our farmers. Farmers are leaving the land. Farmers are going bankrupt. We have heard time and time again that on the prairies we need $1.3 billion of immediate aid, a trade equalization payment to farmers to allow them to survive which would not even bring us up to the American levels or the European levels. What has the Liberal Party done? This message has fallen on deaf ears.

We had in parliament in Ottawa a few weeks ago the premiers of Manitoba and Saskatchewan, supported by all three political parties in Manitoba, three political parties in Saskatchewan, the farm organizations, the chambers of commerce and the trade unions, with a joint position of solidarity in support of $1.3 billion for farmers in Saskatchewan and Manitoba. What did the Liberal government say? It said nothing in terms of extra assistance to farmers. No wonder the Liberals are hanging their heads in shame.

There was a throne speech back in October. I looked at it very carefully and there was absolutely nothing in it, not even a reference to the farm crisis. Where do these people live? They do not know the real poor people who are facing problems.

Then a month later we got this media show by the Minister of Finance. He flew to London, Ontario, to make a media statement. Again many of the Liberal members are wondering why all this money was spent for him to fly to London. A big schedule was worked out for the Minister of Finance and he made a statement on national television. In a 45 minute speech there was not one reference to the farm crisis despite the suffering, the pain, the demonstrations, the protests, the writings and the calls by the united front across Saskatchewan and Manitoba for extra assistance.

The Minister of Finance and the parliamentary committee on finance are more Conservative than anything I saw with Brian Mulroney or Conservative governments in the past. It is not just the farm crisis. Let us look at what they have done to health care. It is enough to tear our hair out. We have had the biggest cutbacks in health care in the history of the country. The cutback in federal funding to the provinces for health care is causing problems today in hospitals and emergency rooms from one part of the country to another. The closings of hospitals and the lineups for surgery are because of the cutbacks by the Minister of Finance.

Why is there silence on the backbench? The minister from the Northwest Territories never gets up to defend health care. I have never seen her get up to say that the Minister of Finance should put more money into health care. She should be ashamed of herself. She represents ordinary people and knows that people are in lineups because of cutbacks in health care by the federal government.

We have the farm crisis and the health care problem. Where are the recommendations in this report for money for health care? We have a $100 billion surplus, and what has been recommended for health care? Nothing. Even the Canadian Medical Association is saying that we need an extra $1.5 billion per year in health care.

First Nations Veterans' Compensation Act December 10th, 1999

moved for leave to introduce Bill C-398, an act to provide compensation to First Nations veterans on a comparable basis to that given to other war veterans.

Mr. Speaker, this private member's bill attempts to right a wrong because of discrimination against first nations veterans who returned home after the first world war, the second world war and the Korean war by doing four things: first, providing compensation to them; second, setting up a scholarship fund in honour of these veterans who returned home from war; third, constructing a war memorial at or near Parliament Hill; and fourth, a public apology from the Prime Minister of the country on behalf of the people of Canada for the way they were treated, similar to the apologies made to other groups in the past.

(Motions deemed adopted, bill read the first time and printed)

Agriculture December 10th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I remind the Minister of Finance that Tommy Douglas never got out of health care. Tommy Douglas founded health care in this country. We now have the money to do some of these things.

I want to ask the minister a supplementary question about agriculture. The Europeans are now funding their farmers. The Americans are funding their farmers. Saskatchewan and Manitoba farmers and all the parties in these provinces supported by the chamber of commerce and trade movement have asked for an extra $1.3 billion. The farmers want to know why the Minister of Finance has not listened.

Will the Minister of Finance tell us whether or not there will be an additional $1.3 billion coming to the farmers of those two provinces?

Social Programs December 10th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, my question is for the Minister of Finance.

Members will recall that in 1995 under pressure from the Reform Party the Minister of Finance slashed funding for social programs to the point where these programs are now seriously underfunded. Some 20% of our children now live in poverty.

Will the minister listen to the people and restore funding for health and education, or is he still intimidated by the Leader of the Opposition on this question?

Supply December 10th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I agree with the minister. The Reform Party wanted to cut back even further.

My question is one that farmers are asking me on an almost daily basis, and I ask it very sincerely. Why is there no more assistance coming from the government?

The minister knows that the joint position in Manitoba and Saskatchewan is supported by all three provincial political parties: the Liberal Party, the New Democratic Party, which is the Saskatchewan party, and the Conservative Party. It is supported by all farm organizations, chambers of commerce and federations of labour. There is sort of a position of solidarity in both provinces that they need an extra $1.3 billion for people to survive.

I do not want to go over the arguments this morning. We all know the argument that the trade war is driving down the price of grain and people are at the point of suffering. I am sure the minister is aware of that. In light of all the protests, in light of all the representations, in light of the solidarity among members of his own party, and in light of all the media coverage, people are asking me why there has not been any action.

The Liberal Party ran an extremely high profile popular candidate in the byelection in Saskatoon—Rosetown—Biggar, Henry Dayday who was mayor of the city of Saskatoon for 11 years and a very good person. He obtained 15% of the votes, basically because the issue became the farm crisis and the economic harm that would result if there were no additional aid.

Farmers are asking why the message did not get through. We know there is a surplus of approximately $10 billion coming next year, or almost $100 billion over five years. People are aware of that. Historically the minister is very conservative in his estimates. It may even be more than that.

If this money were to come, farmers also know that a lot of it would go back to the federal government because of the extra stimulus in the economy and taxes. They are asking why this message did not get through in terms of getting the extra $1.3 billion. I hope the minister understands what I am asking.

Banks December 2nd, 1999

Notice is not exactly power, Mr. Speaker.

These same CEOs, who are eliminating some 20,000, are boosting their own incomes through exorbitant stock options. In fact, the top 24 CEOs, because of these options, will be making in excess of $250 million next year, in excess of the income of 12,000 bank tellers.

Will the minister look at the effect of these obscene stock options on the ability CEOs to balance their own personal interest with the interest of the community from which they have drawn an income in the first place?