Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I would just like confirmation that the vote of the member for Burlington was not counted. She was not sitting in her place.
Lost his last election, in 2004, with 36% of the vote.
Division No. 211 June 9th, 1998
Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I would just like confirmation that the vote of the member for Burlington was not counted. She was not sitting in her place.
Judges Act June 4th, 1998
Mr. Speaker, Motion No. 2 was put forward by the Reform Party and adds a few lines after line 34 on page 3 of the bill:
“(6.1) A report that is tabled in each House of Parliament under subsection (6), shall, on the day it is tabled or if the House is not sitting on that day, on the day that the House next sits, be referred by that House to a committee of that House that is designated or established by that House for the purpose of considering matters relating to justice”.
The amendment goes on with two other parts related to getting some accountability into the system.
Some years ago there was an attempt to roll back judicial salaries as part of the cost cutting measures of the government. The supreme court actually ruled that any attempt to roll back judicial salaries was an interference in the independence of the judiciary.
It is amazing that rolling back salaries is an interference in the independence of the judiciary but increasing its salaries is not. Is that not amusing, that one is an interference and one is not?
The court ruled that the government had to set up a commission to set judicial salaries. It issued it as an order to the government. Theoretically the government does not actually have to obey the order. It could say we are certainly not going to take orders from the judges. But if the government did not accept the position put forward by the supreme court, it would find itself in court. What a sort of rigmarolic circle we would get into then with the government trying to legislate itself out of court and the court trying to take the government to court and all from the starting point where the judges felt the government had no right to set their salaries.
Many of the examples my colleagues have given throughout the day indicate quite clearly that the general public is quite dissatisfied with what is happening at the judicial level in this country. The poll mentioned in July 1997 showed more than 50% of the population dissatisfied with the performance of judges. The examples I gave in my speech earlier today are just from the North Vancouver area over the past few months. They are decisions people were outraged to see, short sentences, failure of people to appear in court, no arrest warrants issued, simple instructions, please turn up next time.
Judges are acting as if they are running classrooms and not courts of law. This lack of confidence in judges has caused the opposition to look at this bill and ask what on earth is going on. Judges are telling us what to do while as the supreme level of justice in Canada we should be setting the rules. That is the reason for the number of motions being put forward to alter this bill. It is unfortunate that as usual the government will not accept any of them. It will overrule all of them. No matter how good the ideas might be, no matter how logical the arguments, it will use its voting power to overturn anything we propose.
We can get up and talk to the bill or speak in favour of any of the amendments here but we know in our hearts that none of them will pass. If nothing more, at least we can get the message out to the people of Canada that we are speaking on their behalf, that we are telling the government side and this place that people are dissatisfied with what is happening in this thing called the justice system which the average person is now calling the legal system and is not even respecting it anymore for what it should be. It is time we took action in this place to correct the problems. That is the main thrust and the main reason the opposition is taking a position of opposition to this legislation.
Judges Act June 4th, 1998
Madam Speaker, I am pleased to speak on Motion No. 1 related to Bill C-37, amendments to the Judges Act. The motion put forward by the Bloc member is that Bill C-37 be amended by deleting clause 5.
Clause 5 has to do with pay increases for judges. The way the pay increase would work is it is an increase of 4.1% retroactive from April 1, 1997 to March 31, 1998, and an additional 4.1% from April 1, 1998 to March 31, 1999. At that time the salaries will be reviewed by a newly created body called the judicial compensation and benefits commission. What this amounts to is that judges will get about an 8.3% increase over two years. It is important to note that the average salary for judges at the moment is approximately $140,000 a year.
A few minutes ago in the debate the member for Windsor—St. Clair said that by talking about these judges and the outrageous decisions that they have been making we are undermining the prestige of the judges and the courts. I say to the hon. member that it is not us undermining the prestige of the judges and the courts, it is the judges who make the ridiculous decisions that appear out there. Many of my colleagues on this side of the House have given the most outrageous examples of decisions that have been made by judges over the last while. I will be giving a few from my own area as part of speaking to Motion No. 1. If these judges were more representative of their community and our community values we would not be faced with these problems.
In connection with the comments made by the member for Windsor—St. Clair, a poll last July showed that more than 50% of those polled have little faith in judges. Surely that is a very good message to all of us that there is something wrong if more than half the population feels that judges are not doing the right thing. It is time to address a major problem.
In the North Vancouver area a number of my close friends are members of the RCMP. In North Vancouver the RCMP looks after our policing. Some members have told me about their frustration with judges and how difficult it is as a police officer to get some sort of charge against somebody and then get it to stick. There are so many technical flaws or problems in the way of laying a charge in the first place and then to be successful in court to get somebody convicted. Then to get them put in jail is a tremendously difficult thing to do.
It is very frustrating for police officers who know they are faced with this problem every day. Police officers are working hard to keep our streets safe and to get these offenders dealt with. Yet starting constables have had their wages frozen for five years and the starting salary for a third year constable is in the range of $50,500 to about $52,400. That is $90,000 less than the judges who are making judgments on the sorts of criminals these police officers are bringing forward.
As many of my colleagues have mentioned earlier, most Canadians now are starting to think about the justice system not as a justice system but as a legal system, a wonderful place for the judges to share experiences with one another and to talk about the technicalities and how they can find flaws in the things that parliament has passed as our laws. The will of parliament should be ultimate in these decisions.
In the Lynn Valley area, like many other areas of the country, we have a fair bit of youth crime. Of my constituents, like those across Canada, well over 90% would like to see significant changes to the Young Offenders Act and they would like to see some judges being a lot more particular about the sentencing of youth offenders. For example, in May there was a court date for some young offenders in my riding who allegedly had committed a devastating crime in the Lynn Valley area in March.
What they are alleged to have done is that in the middle of night they attacked a person in the street, beat him so severely that plastic surgery was required and practically trashed a person's house and their almost brand new car. They were identified and arrested. But of course nobody could give out their names. It was extremely frustrating to the father of the victim who wants to take civil action against these people but was unable to get names until recently when they appeared in court. There is a general feeling in the community that these people should be named, especially once they are convicted.
There was a court date set for May. Only a few of these defendants actually showed up in court. What did the judge do? He said “you should tell your friends they really should appear”. He set a new court date and put the case off for another few months.
This is absolutely ridiculous and outrageous. Surely the judge should have issued arrest warrants immediately for those people who did not turn up. Instead, it was almost a flippant comment for him to make.
This is the sort of comment that brings judges into disrepute. Maybe they have been numbed by hearing so many cases that they just do not take anything seriously any more. They are at this point where we have to start imposing minimum sentences for these judges to use. Otherwise they are just not going to do anything.
There was another case in the Vancouver area recently where a prisoner in the Kent institution escaped from the institution in a cardboard box. He asked for a stand for his television set. He knew there were not any stands for television sets, so he then made the suggestion that a cardboard box would be fine.
The prison authorities found him a nice big cardboard box which he put under his TV set. While the cardboard box was there over a period of a few months, he reinforced it with bits of plywood and stuff that he got from the prison workshop. He knew a friend of his was going to be released at a certain date. On the night before he climbed into this box and his prisoner friend took it to his cell. It was put in storage overnight as personal effects of the prisoner who would be leaving the next morning.
At no time did the prison authorities ever check the box to see what was in there. The following morning it was loaded into the trunk of a car and left with the prisoner who was being released.
This prisoner who was in the cardboard box was then released from the trunk and he was out at large. He was recaptured within a short time. But he had already escaped numerous times from correctional facilities.
The ridiculous part was when he came to court for this crime, what did the judge do? He sentenced him all right to a number of years in prison but he made it concurrent with the sentence he was already serving. So there is no additional time. It is free time. Escaping from prison means nothing. They get it free. Try it again, please.
We have to congratulate the prisoner for his creativity in escaping in the cardboard box but there is absolutely no accountability for that and the judge undermines the confidence of the public by making ridiculous decisions like that.
There is a member on the government side who has been trying to get a private member's bill into this place which would get rid of these concurrent sentences and make people serve time for these types of crimes.
This prisoner had been into bank robberies and had been jailed for those a number of times and he has all these concurrent sentences. They get time for the first crime but not for subsequent withdrawals so it does not really matter what they do.
What we are really pointing out here is that if judges will have their pay increased from the already very generous level of $140,000 per year on average, it is about time they were a little more accountable. One of the things that the official opposition has proposed is that judges should be selected through a more democratic process.
If we cannot get to the point where the constituents actually elect the judges themselves to truly reflect community values, let us at least have some sort of public process where parliamentarians or MLAs at the provincial level can at least grill and question, get to the bottom and background of people who are to be appointed as judges. I think that is a reasonable approach. It is a step we should be taking and before any of us agree to pass a bill like Bill C-37 with these very generous pay increases we should be insisting on accountability for judges.
Dna Identification Act May 11th, 1998
Mr. Speaker, I did warn you that you would probably hear from me twice today.
The government has argued it is far too costly to take DNA samples at the time of the arrest of somebody who has been previously convicted.
It amazes me. It has indicated it will not support this amendment which would enable the police to take these samples at the time of arresting someone with a previous conviction.
It says it is too costly and yet it is prepared to spend perhaps hundreds of millions of dollars on registering the guns of law-abiding people like farmers who will never do anything wrong. It will not spend money on building a DNA bank which would solve crimes and therefore save enormous amounts of money in terms of property damage and personal harm done by criminals.
Where is the sense in wasting all that money on law-abiding citizens when there is absolutely no reason to do it and not spending the money where it is required in crime control?
This government is happy to give the Minister of Canadian Heritage millions of dollars to blow away on a flag program and millions of dollars to throw away on a heritage calendar which mentions every ethnic religious holiday one can think of except for Christmas and New Year, but it will not spend the money to help build a DNA databank which would help us solve crimes.
The government will spend hundreds of millions of dollars on the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council which gives grants to professors which appear to be awfully like vacations but it will not give money to build a DNA bank that would help solve crimes for ordinary Canadians.
I was looking at some of the grants of the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council. There was one for a woman to go to a little island just west of Fiji, a tax haven island. She was going for three years to study housing on this island. It is an absolutely ridiculous waste of money for a person to be given money to do that under the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council grants.
These organizations give away money to study the make-up of blueberry jam. The member for Langley—Abbotsford has mentioned that one before. What a lot of rubbish. This is money just poured down the drain on useless, idiotic projects when we have here an opportunity to build a DNA bank that would actually make a difference. It would actually provide a deterrent, would enable the police to actually solve crimes and would relieve the suffering of many law-abiding Canadians.
The Liberals absolutely love spending money on all sorts of social engineering but they hate spending money on crime control or solving crimes. They are completely out of step with the public.
On another aspect of this bill, the government constantly talks about the court test of the legislation. It is so terrified of the court and what the court might do that it has become hog tied. It is unable to produce reasonable legislation because it is so afraid of the supreme court.
There was a clause put into the charter of rights called the notwithstanding clause and it was put there for a reason. It was put there so that notwithstanding the rulings of the courts, if the government felt that a ruling had been made out of step with the will of parliament and the will of the people the notwithstanding clause could be used to correct that problem.
Instead of being so afraid of these judges who defy the will of parliament and the will of the people and spending enormous amounts of money on preparing bills to be charter safe, why not use the notwithstanding clause a few times and show the judges what we expect of them?
We can have the public confirm the decision of the government by putting it to a binding referendum on the public will so that the government then cannot act in a tyrannical manner. If it does use the notwithstanding clause it will be endorsed by the public.
If we continue down this road of constantly talking about making bills charter safe, we surely know from our own experience in life that for every lawyer who says they drew up a document free of challenge and there is no way anyone can challenge this, there is another lawyer across the street who says it is full of loopholes and can be challenged from every direction.
We can have all the experts in committee who can make these suggestions on how we can make bills charter safe, but there is always going to be a lawyer out there who will study that bill and find some loophole or some clause where he can take it to challenge and with perseverance will mock it down. It happens all the time.
It is time we made it clear that we will no longer tolerate that as a society, that we need some crime control, and that if the judges will not help us with that project we will use the notwithstanding clause to ensure they carry out the public will and begin to reflect a little of what society wants instead of what lawyers want.
Notwithstanding the comments of the member for Scarborough—Rouge River when he spoke earlier that there is nothing to stop the taking of DNA samples under warrant, when we look at the amendment being proposed by Reform we could have this amendment and still have the taking of samples by warrant if necessary. This motion gives an opportunity to begin building a DNA bank for repeat offenders so that we can solve some of the crimes they commit. I cannot understand why anyone would oppose that.
The member mentioned again that they are worried about charter challenges. Everything in this place is done worrying about what the courts might do to it. It is just completely crippling us, preventing us from doing our job.
Let us pass this motion. Let us add it into the bill and let us worry about what the court does with it a little later.
Dna Identification Act May 11th, 1998
Yes persons, as one of the Liberals said. Isn't that just the ultimate in political correctness.
These yes persons, or the Chrétien lookalikes as I mentioned earlier, will each bleat their approval of any of the regulations without really considering seriously whether they are appropriate or legal.
At least by putting them through the process, eventually they will reach the joint Standing Committee on Scrutiny of Regulations and could even be brought to our attention earlier.
If the regulations go before the justice committee, then at least members of the opposition or a member of the public, a witness who sees those regulations coming forward and has concerns about them, can bring them to the attention of the joint Standing Committee on Scrutiny of Regulations. We can give our input.
One of the things absolutely essential with regulations is to get a regulatory impact statement. Then there is an obligation on the department producing the regulations to also produce a regulatory impact statement explaining what impact is expected for the regulation to have on the public or on those affected by the regulation and it also gives the cost and whether alternatives have been pursued.
There could be other ways of achieving the same result. Those regulatory impact statements are an important part of the process.
I endorse the motion put forward by the Bloc. I doubt very much that the government will find in its heart to support this very good suggestion at the time of the vote but we certainly will.
Dna Identification Act May 11th, 1998
Mr. Speaker, what a pleasure to see you back in the chair. I was giving speeches on Thursday and there you were. You had to listen to two. You will probably have to listen to two today. I can see you are thrilled with that prospect.
We are debating Group No. 4, Motion No. 8 on Bill C-3, the DNA bill. This motion amends clause 12 of the bill. As the bill now reads, under clause 12 the governor in council can make regulations for carrying out the purposes and provisions of the bill but there is no statutory requirement for the regulations to be laid before parliament or the appropriate committee for review. We see this as a major problem. Parliamentarians and eventually the joint Standing Committee on Scrutiny of Regulations should be able to properly review, comment on and correct problems in the regulations.
The Bloc member wished all parliamentarians would support this motion because it would give us more say in the running of things. He will be hoping for that result but I suspect the Chrétien lookalikes will end up all standing in their places and doing what they have to do. While I will argue in favour of this motion I do not think for a moment that we are going to see support for it. None of the members opposite have stood in support. There is a very large attendance of them today. They are drastically interested in the bill. I see some laughter from the gallery and I think we all know why they are laughing when I talk about the large number of Liberals here today to listen to the content of the speeches.
We have had problems with regulations. When they do not go before a committee there is a danger there will be some sort of flaw in them. I am a member of the joint Standing Committee on Scrutiny of Regulations and I have been on that committee since I was first elected in 1993. I suspect most members would wonder what it is all really about and what that committee does. It is probably one of the most useful committees on the Hill. It is totally non-partisan in nature. We look at purely the legality and the appropriateness of the regulations that come before us.
Unfortunately it usually takes a few years before the regulations work their way through the system and come to our attention. On the odd occasion when a member of the House or some outside person notices some sort of problem in a regulation, they can bring that to our attention and we can take a look at it to see whether that regulation is ultra vires or whether it is appropriate. I admit that most of the problems we deal with are minor in nature. They tend to be related to translation where there could be a different word in French than in English. They may be minor misprints of one type or another. Sometimes they are technical in nature or legal in nature and the concerned departments will readily agree to alter them.
From time to time we strike things that are major in nature. The committee presently has the power to make a report to the House requesting disallowance of a regulation. We are very close to that situation now in connection with regulations for the participation of the police in political activities. For some years the committee has been very concerned about the police regulations which in effect make it illegal for a policeman to even stand at a shopping centre and gather names on a petition to not have a roadway go through his area.
That is how serious those regulations are. They so restrict political participation by police officers even on their own time that probably many of the activities of policemen during elections municipally, provincially or federally are illegal and they do not even realize it. For example, to wear the button of a political party when off duty or to have a sign on their lawn is illegal.
There is a major court case going on now in Quebec where these regulations are being challenged. Even with this, the committee has already recognized that this is inappropriate. We have been pressuring the solicitor general to get the law changed.
The process is happening right now. We are having a meeting tomorrow. We believe there will be new regulations drafted that meet the requirements for appropriateness. This is a very powerful function that the committee performs.
We have looked at the regulations in a totally non-partisan way. We have dealt with them. We have spoken with the solicitor general, with the drafters and we are getting those regulations replaced.
In the absence of any committee scrutiny or process whereby that can occur, all we end up with are ongoing legal battles. Eventually they reach some conclusion but it is a lot better for the political process to fix these problems promptly.
This is one of the reasons Reform is very supportive of this motion. The motion is not ideal in that the committees that these regulations will go before will probably be pretty much yes men and women for the government.
Dna Identification Act May 11th, 1998
Madam Speaker, my colleague from Wild Rose mentioned the criminals and the easy life they have. The criminals in my area of the country get to play golf. The average taxpayer in my riding has to pay more than $50 a round but the criminals get to play golf on their own golf course. Is that not great?
If I were to think about this, I think the average Canadian would say that if we kept criminals busy 60 hours a week, 40 hours a week eight hours a day doing meaningful work and 20 hours of study a week learning to be better people, they would come out of those places a lot better than the people who come out after all the mollycoddling with colour television sets and playing on the golf course when other people have to pay. It is entirely wrong and is not the way it should be done.
As one of my colleagues said, if the government would just accept the sensible amendments to these bills, we would not have to keep revisiting these things. It is amazing how many bills come back for amendments one or two years later. The Nunavut bill is back in the House. The Minister of Canadian Heritage is running around handing out $300,000 for polls, which could have been done for $8,000 by professional companies, to try to justify and support bills that were passed when they had no idea what the definitions would be. It is a total mess.
If the government would just accept meaningful changes to its bills, little amendments like the one we are looking at here under Group No. 3, the bills would be much better. They would work better and they would not have to keep coming back here.
Under Group No. 3, the motion was put forward by a member of the NDP. We on the Reform side support the motion. It proposes a change in the penalty for releasing the DNA results for any other reason than for the purposes of the act. The government has a two year penalty in there. If somebody gets these DNA results and sends them out on a mailing list or allows them to be publicized in some way, there is only a two year penalty provided for under the act.
As my colleague from Wild Rose said, this is a typical example of the mollycoddling approach the Liberal government has toward criminals. This is a serious crime and it should have a much greater penalty. The proposal that has come from our NDP colleague is a five year penalty. We agree with it because if it was two years we could bet the person would be out in three months. That is just the way it works with this Liberal government.
Speaking today about the DNA act takes me back to when the member for Wild Rose actually got the first DNA bill through this House. Anybody who was here in the 35th Parliament, and all of those Liberals sitting on that side were here, will remember the day in question period when the member for Wild Rose stood up and challenged the then justice minister to do something about authorizing the use of DNA. On that day, whether it was by mistake or good fortune, the minister agreed to meet with the opposition. He said if the opposition would meet with him that day it could be done. The member for Wild Rose got right back up and said “We will do it this afternoon” and it was done. Within a very short time we had a bill through the House.
I was thrilled as the member for North Vancouver because the very first crime that was solved using that bill was a crime in North Vancouver. The police had been waiting for the power to use the DNA results. Why it had been delayed for so long heaven only knows. All it took was the willingness of the government to sit down and do something sensible that the people of Canada wanted. When we look at the DNA bill and the amendments proposed by the opposition members, anyone reading the bill can see that they are sensible amendments and really should be made.
As my colleague for Wild Rose alluded to, we have had 30 years of the Liberal wishy-washy bleeding heart approach to crime. Where has that got us? Absolutely nowhere. The situation today is that the police are frustrated. They can arrest people for crimes and they cannot get convictions.
I know I cannot use props but the tiepin I am wearing today was lent to me by a policeman friend. The policemen I know are friends and they should be friends of law-abiding people. These days the police are forced to act as facilitators because if they actually arrest anybody, they have a terrible job getting anyone convicted. The tiepin is a pair of gold handcuffs that the police wear to represent the difficult time they have in actually getting criminals convicted. I wish we could do something in the House to assist the police to do their work.
One of the frustrations alluded to by two of my colleagues is what we call the tyranny of the judges. The supreme court overrules the intent of parliament, turning us into an even worse type of wishy-washy Liberal approach to crime. I wonder, but perhaps I do not have to wonder too much what that has to do with the fact that the government actually appoints the judges and we end up with the same philosophy in making judgments on what comes down in the way of the law.
A few weeks ago the Supreme Court of Canada made a judgment on the Delgamuukw case, the Indian land claims case that came out of B.C. The case goes back probably about a decade. Many years were spent hearing the testimony in the case in B.C. It took more than a year for the judge to come out with his judgment. The judgment that there was no Indian claim to title was upheld by the B.C. supreme court after lengthy hearings. Then it went to the Supreme Court of Canada. In a lightning fast hearing a central Canadian court overturned everything that had been determined in the British Columbia courts and created nothing but chaos for the land claims process in the province.
This is another example of the type of tyranny that goes on that should be dealt with with the notwithstanding clause as mentioned by the member for New Westminster—Coquitlam—Burnaby. These sorts of decisions undermine the parliamentary process. They make it very difficult for parliament to do its work.
Over the Easter break I was in Australia. I was looking at a similar problem Australia ran into. About five or six years ago a court made a similar ruling to the one that has just been made by the Supreme Court of Canada. The court ruled that the aboriginals of Australia basically owned everything. They had title to everything. That created such chaos in Australia over the next three to four years that every time the government tried to do something, to develop a new park, to build a school, whatever it was trying to do, aboriginals would lodge claims in the court that they owned the land and nothing could be done with it.
We already see that happening in B.C. Three or four weeks ago the B.C. government announced it was building a new school in the heart of the city. What happened? Immediately some natives claimed that they own the land and the school cannot be built until they have settled their land claim. We can see this whole process running away into uncontrolled judicial decisions.
In Australia, after putting up with that for four years, they finally passed the native land titles act to put an end to the tyranny that was shown by the judges and to extinguish that aboriginal title.
All of these things stem from the refusal of government to treat crime in a meaningful manner and to treat criminals for what they are, criminals.
We know what causes crime. Criminals cause crime. We need to take a much harder line with criminals than we have been taking.
While the opposition is pleased to see this type of DNA legislation coming through, we would certainly like to see amendments made to reinforce the provisions of the bill.
Canada Labour Code May 7th, 1998
Mr. Speaker, I am calling quorum because there is not a single government member present.
And the count having been taken:
Prostate Cancer May 7th, 1998
Mr. Speaker, on March 10, during the prostate cancer information session held here on the Hill, almost 80 men took PSA blood tests for prostate cancer.
I am pleased to announce that most of those men had levels below four. Unfortunately, three of our colleagues had levels above four, with the highest being in the range of 13, a level of significant concern.
Because of other commitments, some MPs who should have did not take the PSA test. However, prime ministers, party leaders, ministers and deputy ministers do not have immunity from prostate cancer.
In light of the results I have just given, I hope those who did not take the PSA test and who are above the age of 50 will now call their doctors and make an appointment to take the test, if not for themselves then for their families, their loved ones and their colleagues.
Canada Labour Code May 7th, 1998
Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to rise on the Group No. 2 motions before us at report stage of Bill C-19.
I am pleased to see you back in the chair, Mr. Speaker. I knew you would be pleased that I was speaking whilst on your watch.
I would like to follow up a little more on the points raised by the Reform member who spoke. It would be nice if we could call the members here by their names. I realize it is tradition that we have to call them by their riding names.
Something interesting happened to the New Zealand parliament when it switched to the MMP system of representation. Half of the members do not actually having ridings. They are selected on the basis of party lists. The house was faced with the problem of how to identify members when they cannot be called by a riding name. They dispensed completely with calling people by the ridings and now they call each other by their names. It raises the question why it was even necessary to have this tradition in the past anyway. But I digress as I tend to do, and I will get back to the point we were talking about.
A little earlier my colleague from the Kootenay area riding was talking about the 35% threshold for certifying a union. It really puzzles me how the NDP, which claims to be the New Democratic Party, can argue against democracy in this way.
I reinforce the argument of my colleague. How could you possibly take 35% to be representative of the majority? As my colleague mentioned, if the Bloc Quebecois had that rule for their Quebec referendum, especially if they could argue coercion, that people on the way to the polling booth to vote had to walk through an armada of no signs, they would automatically get certified for separation. It is totally ludicrous. If you have democracy you have democracy and that means a majority.
Perhaps the NDP support for such a concept is based on the fact that the workers have to compulsorily contribute to the NDP through their union dues. There are plenty of workers out there who do not want to do that.
The Wal-Mart affair in Ontario is certainly a good example of that. The Canada Industrial Relations Board in its wisdom certified the union when 151 of the Wal-Mart employees at the Windsor store voted against a union and 43 voted for it. How could a union possibly be certified under those circumstances? There were 151 against and 43 for a union and it was certified. Why? Because the CIRB made a random decision that the employer was unfair.
Now the workers are organizing to decertify. I would say that almost certainly indicates that their will has been absolutely defied by the Canada Industrial Relations Board. It is absolutely appalling that those people on the CIRB would use their political bent, their ideology to force a decision upon unwilling workers.
We will certainly be watching the ongoing happenings with that particular decertification drive. I think it will show conclusively that workers want control of their own destiny. They do not want these sorts of undemocratic laws forced upon them.
Reform's Motion No. 30 would fix this problem of 35%. The bill as it stands allows the Canada Industrial Relations Board to certify a union even if there is no evidence of majority support if the board believes there would have been support had it not been for the employer's unfair labour practices. That is a really subjective judgment.
The determination of what constitutes an unfair labour practice is left entirely up to the Canada Industrial Relations Board. The Wal-Mart case as I said illustrates that. What we would like to see is that a union not be certified unless there is a secret ballot held and a majority of the workers have to support that idea of a union.
Motion No. 7 also proposed by the Reform Party deals with the Canada Labour Code which states that the board may, and I underline may, hold a representational vote on union certification to satisfy itself that the workers want the union. The word is “may” and we would like to see that as “must”.
Again, how can we possibly guarantee a democratic process if we do not allow people to vote? The same members in this House who want to certify unions with 35% with all sorts of arbitrary procedures would never ever agree to such procedures in their own ridings.
You can laugh, Mr. Speaker. Can you imagine the situation in your own riding if that were to happen. You probably would not be sitting there today. All sorts of strange things could happen and you could be on the patronage bandwagon today, Mr. Speaker, looking for a position on the immigration and refugee board, or maybe on this Canada Industrial Relations Board. You would certainly deserve it, Mr. Speaker. You have been here long enough to prove that you are part of club Chrétien. I think you have earned enough membership points. You might even get to the Senate, I do not know.
In any event, in this group there are two Reform motions which obviously we support. There are two Bloc motions which we oppose. Members before me have indicated briefly why we would do that.
First the Bloc wants to delete the clause in the bill which allows the CIRB to make decisions without oral hearings in fairly straightforward cases. We think it clogs the system if there is too much process. Therefore we are not supporting that particular motion.
The other one proposed by the Bloc has to do with the common practice where a group of employers will join forces to have just one agent represent them in negotiations. The amendment from the Bloc removes the requirement that the board must satisfy itself that the employer representative is no longer qualified to act in that capacity before revoking the appointment. The Bloc amendment provides for the automatic removal of the employer representative upon receipt of an application from one or more of the employers in the group and the appointment of a new representative.
We believe that there should be a vote of the majority of the members in this employer's group before such an action is taken. We really feel that the Bloc motion would weaken the employer's association position if they could just have one employer come along and the same sort of lack of process that we are talking about on the union side would suddenly be appearing on the employer side as well.
That deals with my comments on the Group No. 2 motions. I realize you probably need to take a break soon, Mr. Speaker, but I hope you are back in time for my speech on the Group No. 3 motions.