House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • Her favourite word was let.

Last in Parliament May 2004, as Canadian Alliance MP for Edmonton North (Alberta)

Won her last election, in 2000, with 51% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Somalia Inquiry September 19th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, not on evidence but by inference he was saying that Jean Boyle is a great guy. On national television the minister stood up and said: "He is a fine man, we support him and he is doing a great job". I do not know how much more clear I could get that he is trying to influence and interfere with the commission and its findings.

The only reason the Prime Minister will not fire these guys is because he is worried about potential political damage. Let me tell him from Canada: There is far more damage in keeping them than in letting them go.

I ask the minister, the Prime Minister or whoever is going to juggle and get themselves up on this one, why does the Prime Minister not just admit he was wrong, cut his losses and let these guys go?

Somalia Inquiry September 19th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, this very minister, by appearing on TV and pronouncing Jean Boyle innocent even before the thing was finished, has castrated that commission and that is all there is to it. It is as simple as that.

The Somalia inquiry is having such a hard time doing its job because the department does not have any real leadership. We then see a minister step in and think that he can make announcements about it before it is even over.

The minister and Jean Boyle himself do not know up from sideways. There is precious little respect in the military across the country for this minister and for Jean Boyle. That is why the department is in such a mess and why the Somalia inquiry has taken so long.

I will ask one more time. If the Prime Minister is really serious about mopping up the mess in the military, why will he not start at the top with the minister and Jean Boyle?

Somalia Inquiry September 19th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, the government cannot have it both ways on the Somalia inquiry. The Prime Minister has complained that it is too slow, too expensive and too hard on witnesses. The reason the inquiry has been delayed again and again is that the department was not producing the relevant documentation. If this government wants someone to blame in this whole affair, it should simply look in the mirror.

Why will the Prime Minister not simply admit that if the Minister of National Defence and Jean Boyle were really capable of doing their jobs, the commission would have had all the documents and the Somalia inquiry would be on track today?

Liberal Party September 19th, 1996

Well, Mr. Speaker, the summer is over The Liberals thought they were really in clover Three months back home to talk to the folks Would give them the chance to garner some votes

What do you know, the people were mad A brand new government they thought they had But when listening closely it was the same old tune Liberal, Tory, just two sides of the same old loon

We want jobs, real jobs, not an infrastructure scheme We want leaders to really say what they mean We want violent criminals to do their time But the government says, hey, everything's fine

The military is crumbling from the top down The general blames the troops on the ground The minister says I'm proud of that man He should be let go, not given a hand

Let's get on with how to fix this land Let's get people to work-let's give them a hand Let's show the world if you commit a crime The consequence is you do the time

Let's prove to the world that our country is one And quitthis fighting the separatists have begun Canada is good butlet's make it great Times running out and the people can'twait.

Petitions September 18th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, pursuant to Standing Order 36, I too would like to table a petition with several hundred names on it, most of them from the constituency of Beaver River but some from Edmonton and perhaps Edmonton Southeast and other cities.

Resulting from a murder this spring in the town of Bonnyville, these people are very concerned that there be stricter penalties for young offenders who commit crimes causing bodily harm or death. These individuals should be held in custody pending their court hearing. Young offenders 16 years and older who take the law into their own hands and cause death should be charged and treated as adults and tried in adult court without the consent of judges.

Therefore these petitioners pray and request that Parliament please make amendments and stiffer penalties to the Young Offenders Act.

Criminal Code September 17th, 1996

Madam Speaker, I think we really need to look at some of the details of this bill. As my colleague said, maybe we are just tinkering with it.

One frustrating thing that the Canadian public feels is that there needs to be some large changes made, not just tinkering with any piece of legislation, whether it is financial, economic or criminal justice.

I want to respond to a Liberal member who just called across asking: "Why did you not support the gun control bill"? If I though that the gun bill would eliminate or reduce crime and violent offences in great measure, I would be willing to support the gun bill. I think Canadians across the country probably would.

What they see is a situation where the government is perhaps out of touch. The same member also is calling out right now. I do not know whether I could call this an assault, but I certainly do hear a lot of noise coming from that direction. The member says: "Don't you think we listen to the people?" Of course I do. I would not be arrogant enough to say that nobody in this House but Reformers listens to the people because that simply is not true.

I know there are members in this House, and you probably yourself, Madam Speaker, spent the summer at home and listened to what people had to say. The concerns are the same across the country. Let us face it, nobody on either side of the House wants Clifford Olson to be free and wandering around in the Canadian public any more.

What has happened is that the executive branch of the government says that it knows best. I know there are Liberal backbenchers here who are equally frustrated as we are. They have been home, and we have been home, for the summer and listened to what has gone on. People are hearing in their own constituencies that they want people to be accountable. They want government to be accountable. It is their cash that we are spending here. They want to make sure that murderers are accountable for their crimes as well. They feel a sense of frustration that Bill C-45 which is not completely repealing section 745 of the Criminal Code is going to do that job.

The private member's bill brought in by our colleague from York South-Weston was going to do exactly that. It was repealing section 745 so that we would not have this automatic kickback in place so that after 15 years a murderer could automatically apply for early parole.

We talk about justice and say that justice must be done. We could all debate in this House about how important it is for justice to be done and to be served. Let us remember that justice means justice. In a lot of our academic discussions we have probably forgotten what the word justice actually means.

Those people who think that they know the meaning of it, the academics, the lawyers, the judges, the media and so on, perhaps have lost the true meaning of what justice is. Ordinary Canadians have not and whether they live in Reform ridings or Liberals ridings is immaterial. Ordinary Canadians regardless of whom they are represented by in the House of Commons realize that the meaning of justice has been lost or certainly watered down.

I could give a definition of justice to mean acting in accordance with what is morally right or fair. We are afraid to walk the line to even talk about morals. Somewhere there is ultimate justice coming and those people who have taken a life, first degree murderers, who are applying for early parole now must realize that their victims are dead forever. When we hear on the news or see on television that someone has been brutally murdered by one of these violent offenders we feel that pain. We try to understand the grief that family is going through.

Yet a couple of years later, for instance in the Mahaffy and French cases, although I feel that pain, it is certainly not the way the family feels it. That is with them forever. The person who committed murders may feel somewhat repentant. I do not know how they feel in their hearts. I know that they are alive and they are doing whatever they can do. Clifford Olson is working on his appeal right now. He is not feeling the grief that the families are feeling. Many people who have had loved ones murdered are feeling that pain. Dead is dead forever.

When we think that justice means acting in accordance with what is morally right or fair, there are wrongs, there are rights, there are absolutes that it is wrong to take another life. We could just discuss it away in these hallowed halls all the time and say we think that this person needs special treatment or we think that this person deserves to get out of jail. There are people who genuinely do get rehabilitated but the frustrating part is that we just use all of them in a blanket statement.

The words bleeding heart were used here earlier by various people. We need to be sensitive, to make sure that people who are forever going through the pain of losing loved ones are not going

to be hoodwinked or going to be held to ransom by a body of legislators who think that they know best for everybody and that is by giving the criminals more attention than the victims.

Something we have to get to in our society, when we are talking about morals or what is absolutely right or wrong, is that when the rights of a victim and the rights of a criminal conflict we must always come down on the side of the victim. Yes, criminals need attention, rehabilitation, love and caring, but the victim was someone who was totally innocent and paid the price. As I mentioned earlier, those who have lost somebody have lost them forever.

I would just like to mention Clifford Olson for a couple of minutes because his name has come up over and over again. He has been the flashpoint of this section 745. Clifford Olson wreaked havoc on many people's lives and those lives are suffering just as much now, 15 or 16 years later, as they were when the act was committed.

I think Clifford Olson was arrested in August 1981. I was on a camping trip on the coast. I was camping in a tent on the sand at Long Beach on the west coast of Vancouver Island. I got up the next day and packed up my tent to drive across Vancouver Island to go over to Vancouver. I heard on the news that Clifford Olson had just been arrested around Ecluelet on the west coast of Vancouver Island which was about two miles from where I was camped. A young woman, sleeping in a tent on the beach, I thought I was perfectly safe. I had no thought in the world that anything wrong or dangerous would happen to me.

Ironically, I found out he had just been arrested a couple of miles up the road. He had picked up a couple of girls and had not done anything to them yet. Fortunately they did not have to pay the price with their lives. However, he was out and about and free. Who knows, many other people could have been his victims.

He was arrested then and is now applying, 15 years later, for early parole. The sad and ironic twist about this thing, which was brought in by a Liberal government in 1978 by the member for Notre-Dame-de-GrĂ¢ce, I understand is that the time goes from the time of arrest which is 15 years ago. As one of my colleagues said, the moment one is arrested the time is added and therefore the 15 years are up.

I would like to ask how anyone of us would feel if we were one of the victims' families and heard that Clifford Olson was going to get his day in court. Can anyone imagine having to open that wound again and watch him get that opportunity in court? I cannot think of anything worse, more damaging, more dangerous, more frightening and more harmful than to give this guy another day in court so that he can go and bring up all this stuff again. I do not think the families of those victims need to see that again. I do not think he needs his day in court.

I do not know if you were one of the ones, Madam Speaker, whom he wrote a letter to recently in this Parliament, but the fact is Clifford Olson sent mail to many of the people in this Chamber and there was a condom stuck in that letter. I would like people to reflect on that for just a minute by asking if this is what we are allowing to happen. Do we want to give this guy his day in court? I think not. I do not think that anyone of us needs to be subjected to getting a condom from this character, I really do not.

However, we see a government which says: "Yes, we are going to bring this in because we need to be compassionate".

Let me finish by saying yes, we do need to be compassionate. By repealing section 745 all together does not mean that we are not being compassionate. What it means is that we will still allow a trigger to be in place because some murderers and violent offenders are curable. They are not all incorrigible. Some of them will be rehabilitated. Some will care and will have a genuine conversion experience in prison. They will want to make their lives better and pay back to society some of the terrible things they did by doing good work. Some of them will be allowed to be released. By eliminating section 745 all together does not mean we are just going to lock these guys up and throw away the key. However, there is such a thing as a pardon. I think that trigger could still be in place.

I wish the Minister of Justice and his colleagues would say: "We want to make sure that even though we do repeal section 745 there is still room for a pardon so that somebody can be released on that but it would be the exception rather than the rule". I think that is a far healthier way of going about it than the way the government is moving with not repealing section 745 and going ahead with Bill C-45 right now. I think it is wrong and I do not think it will solve the problems that we face in the country.

Petitions September 17th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, pursuant to Standing Order 36, I would like to present a petition from several people in Alberta as well as B.C. and several places across the country. It talks about the wartime merchant marine navy.

It states that it was the fourth arm of the armed services; that veterans of the wartime merchant navy are under the civilian war related benefits act; that one in ten Canadian merchant seamen lost their lives, the highest proportional rate of all services; that merchant navy prisoners of war spent 50 months on average in imprisonment but only 30 months are recognized; and that these people were excluded from the War Veterans Allowance Act from pensionable benefits, from veterans' post-World War II free university education, housing and land grant benefits, small business financial aid and veterans' health care benefits.

They call on Parliament to consider the advisability of extending benefits or compensation to veterans of the wartime merchant navy equal to that enjoyed by veterans of Canada's World War II armed services. I am sure they would all say that fair is fair and let us get on with it.

Petitions September 17th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, pursuant to Standing Order 36, I would like to present a couple of petitions.

The first petition is signed by several people in the constituency of Beaver River from Thorhild and some from Edmonton. Who knows, Mr. Speaker, they may even be your constituents.

The petitioners ask Parliament to be aware of the fact that societal approval, including the extension of societal privileges, would be given to same sex relationships if any amendments to the Canadian Human Rights Act were to include the undefined phrase sexual orientation. They find that frustrating and discriminatory.

They call on Parliament not to amend the Canadian Human Rights Act or the charter of rights and freedoms in any way which would tend to indicate societal approval of same sex relationships.

National Defence September 16th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, the minister says I am not willing to accept change.

The fact is that I am demanding change. There are millions of Canadians who are doing exactly the same thing by making sure that he leaves. That is demanding change.

He also talks about money and downsizing changes in the military. We are not talking about money here. We are talking about morals.

I want to ask the Prime Minister one more time today and give him one last chance to think this through fairly and squarely. Will he demand the resignation right now, today, of this minister and General Jean Boyle who have been an embarrassment to the people who serve in our armed forces.

National Defence September 16th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, General Boyle says he enjoys the confidence of his political masters and the Canadian forces personnel.

Major Addy opposes him. So do Major-General Vernon, Major-General Lewis MacKenzie and many others. They think he should go and pack. The only people who think he should stay are the Prime Minister and the minister of defence.

When will the Prime Minister show some leadership and dump Boyle and the minister? They are the Laurel and Hardy of the Canadian military.