House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was justice.

Last in Parliament May 2004, as Liberal MP for Etobicoke Centre (Ontario)

Won his last election, in 2000, with 56% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Ethics May 15th, 2003

Mr. Speaker, it was on November 21, 2000, that the ethics counsellor concluded his examination of this very question. In a letter addressed to the leader of the Progressive Conservative Party, the ethics counsellor, after his examination, said that “the Prime Minister, in calling the President of the BDC, did not violate any rule...established by the...Government in terms of Ministers dealing on behalf of constituents with government agencies”.

Auberge Grand-Mère May 14th, 2003

Mr. Speaker, I reject the allegations of the member. They are absolutely without foundation.

If the man in question has done something wrong, he will have to answer for that before the courts. In the meantime, the member should not make unfounded allegations about motivation or conduct on this side of the House.

Auberge Grand-Mère May 14th, 2003

Mr. Speaker, again members of that party seek to raise facts long in the public record, make accusations that have been answered in the past, and once again try to demonstrate their irrelevance to Canadian public life.

Are they dealing with the issues of the day? Are they dealing with social and economic issues? Of course not. They are dwelling on the irrelevant, demonstrating once again they have nothing to offer the Canadian people.

Auberge Grand-Mère May 14th, 2003

Mr. Speaker, I fail to understand this member's fixation on this case where the relevant facts have long since been disclosed and discussed, and the view of the ethics counsellor has been solicited and delivered in writing. All the concerns that this member wants to raise again have been examined and put to rest. I urge the member to accept the reality of the situation and move on.

Auberge Grand-Mère May 13th, 2003

Mr. Speaker, it was in a letter addressed to that member that the ethics counsellor expressed his opinion on all of these matters, including the facts referred to just now in the question. The ethics counsellor said clearly that there was no violation of any principle involved.

Auberge Grand-Mère May 13th, 2003

Mr. Speaker, the ethics counsellor has examined this issue. The relevant facts have been looked at time and again. The ethics counsellor's decision was made, in writing, available to all members of the House of Commons.

All these matters have been considered and gone into time and again. What we are seeing here is a desperate party with nothing to offer of any relevance to Canadians, no position of value of the true issues facing this country, looking backwards yet again.

Auberge Grand-Mère May 13th, 2003

Mr. Speaker, the matter has been investigated and every relevant fact has been examined and has been laid on the table. These members will do themselves no good by poking through the embers of a dead affair trying to advance their political interests by attacking the reputation of a man who in 40 years has achieved more for this country than that party ever will.

Auberge Grand-Mère May 13th, 2003

Mr. Speaker, all the relevant facts are on the table. They have been examined time and again. The record is quite clear.

One thing I can observe, is the people of Perth district or Stratford, Ontario, that whole region, have been watching very carefully the behaviour of the Alliance Party and yesterday they expressed their view of the performance of the Alliance and its leader. We agree with their judgment.

Auberge Grand-Mère May 13th, 2003

Mr. Speaker, the court documents speak for themselves, and as the member well knows, the RCMP makes its own judgments in such matters. However I can tell the member that all the relevant facts of this affair have long since been known, have long since been on the record, have long since been examined, and the hon. member would do better to spend his time and attention focusing on issues that are of relevance to the Canadian people rather than chasing shadows in matters that have long since been put to rest.

Auberge Grand-Mère May 12th, 2003

Mr. Speaker, the member continues to fish.

The member will recall that in a letter addressed to him in November 2000 the ethics counsellor dealt with the Prime Minister's intervention and made it clear that the Prime Minister's conduct did not violate any rule that pertained. The member is raising issues that have been looked into long since. Facts and questions have been examined in the past. I urge him to consult the record for the answers he seeks.