House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was children.

Last in Parliament October 2000, as Reform MP for Calgary Centre (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 1997, with 40% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Supreme Court Of Canada May 14th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, whenever we challenge the government it seems to come out with an anti-American comment.

Review of the appointments to the country's top court is an international phenomena. Countries like the Netherlands, Germany, Italy and others all have such systems. Besides this, provincial justice ministers, a retired supreme court justice and legal experts from across the country all believe the current system should be changed.

Why is the Prime Minister so afraid of parliament? What is it?

Criminal Records Act May 14th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, I want to express my sincere thanks to the hon. member for Brossard—La Prairie for his excellent speech. He has covered many of the key points on the bill. I do not think it would serve the House for me to repeat them at any great length. He has articulated the purpose of the bill very well.

I will just touch on a couple of the points that have brought us to the decision the House will make today on Bill C-69. These points have to do with the human interest part of the bill. It speaks well to the process we have and that it can still work.

The hon. member articulated the purpose of the bill. It is to allow access to pardons. If a person, who has committed sexual offences, particularly against children, applies for a position of caring for children, there would be an opportunity for organizations to get access to the pardon records.

Bill C-69 is a bill for which, not surprisingly, there is broad support in the House. It relates very specifically to a bill that I brought forward to the House, Bill C-284, which effectively did the same thing and which passed second reading in the House.

We have the information in the CPIC system today of those who have been pardoned for sexual offences, as the hon. member mentioned. The bill will now allow those pardon records to be flagged so that those who want access to that information in order to assess someone who is applying for a job of caring for children can now have access even past the pardon.

It is a good bill. It is very consistent with Bill C-284, which I brought forward.

My bill, Bill C-284, passed second reading in the House. At about the time that we were in the justice committee looking at Bill C-284 the government brought Bill C-69 forward. Bill C-69 effectively did the same thing as my bill. It was broader in some areas and included more types of sex offences, which was good. However, it was not as strong in our estimation in some other areas.

Collectively, we worked together to bring both bills to that committee at the same time so that committee members could examine the different aspects of both bills and come up with a stronger option at the end of the day.

There are some things I would like to see in Bill C-69 that are not there, but the majority of issues I was concerned about have been addressed.

How did we get here? I think there is a human interest story the House should be aware of. Six years ago a lady in Vancouver named Gertie Pool started a petition to allow for greater access to information to protect children from sexual predators which quickly received 25,000 names and was brought forward to the House.

The Reform Party member for Fraser Valley put forward a private member's bill in the 35th parliament that was basically on the same theme as Bill C-69 and Bill C-284. That bill was never drawn or deemed votable but it was in the House.

In the 36th parliament, I took the member's bill, modified it slightly and put it back into the mix. Interestingly enough, my private member's bill was drawn. I appeared before the committee to see if it would be deemed votable and we had some witness testimony that helped the decision. In the wisdom of the committee, they said, “Yes, let us bring this before the House and make it votable”.

We debated the bill in the House. Even though there were a number of members on the government side who thought maybe we did not need Bill C-284, it passed second reading and that got it to committee.

From a concerned citizen's petition we have a private member's bill that has passed second reading. The government was also somewhat concerned about the issue. It had been doing some studies in Correctional Service Canada and was working on Bill C-69.

This all came together in the justice committee. Once we were in committee we put forward some amendments to make it a more automatic disclosure so that there would be less discretion on whether or not the information would be disclosed to the hiring institution.

I give thanks to the many witnesses that came before the committee such as the police association and the chiefs of police association. Julian Fantino also came forward, as well as many victims groups. These witnesses brought home the tragedy of a sexual offence, particularly against children, being a life sentence to the victims, something they never fully get over.

Many groups from the YMCA, boys groups, boy scouts and all kinds of children's organizations signed on. They told us they were behind us in this regard and wanted us to get it through the House of Commons. Many of them sacrificed time and effort to support the bill. They are one of the reasons we are able to support an amended version of Bill C-69 which combines the strength of both bills.

I commend my colleague from Brossard—La Prairie. He has been instrumental in working with the committee, with the solicitor general and with me. He has been true to his word throughout the process. He has been a key factor in bringing it all together and implementing a very important bill, which I believe is one of the first bills of the new solicitor general.

This very important bill allows children's organizations and those concerned about the care of children to do a thorough check of the information. The information is in the CPIC system. The flagging which he detailed in his speech is all that is needed. We can now use the information we already have to do a more thorough check to protect our children.

I am glad we have been able to demonstrate in the House through the bill and through the process that we can bypass partisan issues. We are not entirely agreed on how exactly to do it, but substantively, for the most part, there is agreement. It is better that we get 80% rather than nothing. Both sides of the House saw that. At the end of the day we have proven that the process can work, that we can serve the needs of Canadians and that we can better protect children.

In addition to the good work the bill will do, for me and for many members of the committee one of the most rewarding aspects of the whole process is that with persistence, perseverance and an honest concern on the part of citizens, witnesses and members of the House we can put forward legislation that serves the people and better protects our children, the most vulnerable members of society.

We can actually implement laws which will enable us to do that. A very encouraging note for me as a two year member of the House is that there is a way for all of us to impact on the process if we really care about putting Canadians first and putting some of our partisan positions aside.

I thank the House and the member for the earnest and diligent effort that all have applied in this regard. I encourage the House to send the bill on today to the Senate and hopefully soon for royal assent so people have access to this new tool to better protect Canadian children.

Supreme Court Of Canada May 13th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, it is interesting that even retired supreme court justices are calling for a more open process. Why is this government so averse to public scrutiny and accountability?

The current closed door process clearly does not have the backing of Canadians, especially in this era of increased judicial activism. What is it about a parliamentary review of potential appointments to one of the most powerful institutions in our country that the Prime Minister is concerned about? What is it about consulting parliament that offends the Prime Minister so much?

Supreme Court Of Canada May 13th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister has an opportunity to restore public confidence in the judiciary. Supreme Court Justice Cory is retiring. Canadians, legal scholars and even provincial ministers of justice want a more open process. “Judges should be known to the public as much as possible ahead of time”, stated retired supreme court Justice La Forest.

It is time to open up this pre-charter process. Will the Prime Minister take action and bring nominees to a parliamentary review before appointing them to the highest court in the land?

Public Sector Pension Investment Board Act May 11th, 1999

Madam Speaker, I appreciate the thoroughness with which you have gone through the motions for us today on this section of the bill and the Group No. 2 amendments. This is an important group of amendments and I would like to take a minute to detail why they are important and to point out some of the grievous shortcomings in this section of the bill.

The amendments I put forward and ones other members have put forward, but particularly mine, are designed to return the act to where it was prior to this current piece of legislation. There is a very good reason to bring it back to where it was.

This government bill before us affects the pension plans of public service employees. Bill C-78 makes a significant change in the determination of who will be eligible for survivor benefits.

The bill changes the test. Prior to this bill the test was fairly clear. With this bill if the contributor is married and the contributor dies, the surviving spouse, a party to the marriage, is eligible for the benefits. There are a few other minor tests such as living together at the time of death and that kind of thing. Basically a person who is married to a contributor who has died is eligible for the benefits.

There is another group that is eligible. The sole test for this other group for the benefits from the contributor is cohabitation for a year and having a relationship of a conjugal nature. This terminology is new to law. We have had the phrase “having a conjugal relationship” but in this bill it is “having a relationship of a conjugal nature”. It may seem like a small point but it is not. Let me explain why.

The word conjugal usually applies to some sort of physical intimacy or sexual activity within the confines of a marriage type of relationship. Bill C-78 is basically saying that the private intimacies between two people will be the determining factor as to whether or not one is going to receive a benefit.

Think about that for a minute. The private intimacies between two people will determine whether or not they receive benefits. How will anybody know about these private intimacies? And whose business is it anyway? That is where this bill is taking us. Prior to this bill, in the legislation that is being amended, that was not a required test for the extension of benefits, nor should it be.

This bill is being proposed by a government that once had a prime minister who said the government has no place in the bedrooms of the nation. Now it is putting forward legislation which says that someone who has physical intimacies with a person will receive survivor benefits. It seems unworkable to me. How will anyone know? What are we going to set it up? Will we have some sort of inquisition of people's personal intimacies? That is a scary thought but it seems that is where this bill is taking us.

Beyond that, the bill does not in any way define what a relationship of a conjugal nature is. What is that doing? It is leaving it to the courts. People will be in the courts arguing whether or not they had a relationship of a conjugal nature. This is after the contributor has died. Who knows what was going on and again, what business is it of the government anyway to make that the key factor for determining benefits? It does not make sense. Where could this take us?

The bill does not say a relationship of a conjugal nature with one person. What about three people living together? Does that mean that both of those people have a relationship of a conjugal nature with the contributor? Are they both eligible? Nowhere in this legislation is it defined or addressed. It is wide open. This is a significant cause for concern. It makes the legislation unworkable.

On the other side of the coin, why is this test of a conjugal nature the key? If we want to extend benefits under Bill C-78 to people who had some sort of relationship, does that mean we are going to exclude certain people? If two people have a close relationship, share expenses, have lived together for years, are more than just average friends but they do not have any intimate physical relations, are they out or are they in? Who is going to decide that? The courts again? Certainly not this legislation because it gives absolutely no direction in that area. It is a recipe for confusion and litigation. It is very poorly drafted and very poorly thought out.

We had an opportunity in committee to ask the minister about this very issue. I thought surely the minister would have thought this out and would have an answer for me. Here is the answer I got and I am paraphrasing but it can be seen in the committee Hansard . He basically told me that the lawyers made them do it. I could not believe it.

The courts had made some decisions and I think he was referring to the Rosenberg case where the courts ruled a redefinition of the term “spouse”. The justice minister said she was going to appeal that decision and defend the current Canadian law and never did. Now the courts have redefined a section in one act in government legislation.

The President of the Treasury Board said that the courts made them do this and the lawyers told them to write it this way. Is this how the Liberal government governs? The courts made them do it. The lawyers told them to do it. What are they doing? They are setting this up for a test of physical intimacy for the determination of benefits. It just does not make sense. It is a poor approach to the serving of the people.

What kind of a bureaucracy are we going to have to establish to assess who qualifies and who does not? I hesitate to use the term as I do not want to offend anyone, but we can envision some sort of sex police or something like that who would determine the regulations on this, who is included and who is excluded.

I am attempting to point out to the House and to those who are listening today that if we are going to go down this road, surely we have to keep it independent from the government invading in the physical intimacies between two people. I concur with the statement of the Liberal prime minister of some years back. Mr. Trudeau said the government has no business in the bedrooms of the nation, yet this very piece of legislation is driving it right in there. For that reason we proposed the amendments.

I am hoping my talk today and talks I have given on this before will cause us to rethink this. I believe the hon. member from Scarborough has some points to make on this as well. I hope that we can look at these amendments to bring the act back to where it was before, where the government was not intruding in the private affairs of people. If the government wants to go down this road, rethink it and come up with something that works a lot better than this.

Of course we are told that this change is not going to impact on costs at all. It is going to be a very minor cost. How can we know that when we do not know who qualifies and who does not qualify? I do not buy the argument that this change is going to be very minor cost because we do not know who is in or out. That just does not wash.

Finally, the amendments I have proposed today were only some of the amendments that were needed. There are 249 times in the 200 pages of this bill where any mention of wife or spouse or widow or any of those kinds of terms has been replaced with one word, the word survivor. Of course, survivor is subject to the conjugality test.

We went to the legislative counsel for assistance in bringing this act back to where it was before. Because of the rush and the way the government has pushed Bill C-78 through the House without a good airing of all the issues, the government has made it impossible for the legislative counsel to make the appropriate amendments to all sections of the bill. Many sections of the bill need amending to bring it back to where it was before. I have not had an opportunity to bring them to the House because of time constraints.

Having said all that, I think I have shed some light on this. There is a very serious concern to which we all need to pay attention. I hope that when the vote comes we see some reason and accept these amendments and have another look at the bill and come forward with more appropriate legislation.

Public Sector Pension Investment Board Act May 11th, 1999

moved:

Motion No. 30

That Bill C-78, in Clause 81, be amended a ) by replacing line 26 on page 57 with the following:

“nor the contributor's surviving spouse or children” b ) by replacing line 41 on page 57 with the following:

“sion Act, all surviving spouses within the meaning of”

Public Sector Pension Investment Board Act May 11th, 1999

moved:

Motion No. 28

That Bill C-78, in Clause 76, be amended a ) by replacing lines 24 to 32 on page 53 with the following:

“surviving spouse of a contributor is not entitled to an annual allowance in respect of the contributor under this Part if that contributor married the surviving spouse or was deemed under subsection 25(4) to have become married to the surviving spouse after having become entitled under this Part to an annuity or annual allowance, unless, after the marriage, or after having been so deemed to have become married, the contributor became or” b ) by replacing line 39 on page 53 with the following:

“the surviving spouse of the contributor or the children” c ) by replacing line 5 on page 54 with the following:

“Part by virtue of being the surviving spouse of a female” d ) by replacing line 16 on page 54 with the following:

“Part by virtue of being the surviving spouse of a female”

Public Sector Pension Investment Board Act May 11th, 1999

moved:

Motion No. 26

That Bill C-78, in Clause 75, be amended a ) by replacing lines 1 and 2 on page 52 with the following:

“(5) A surviving spouse is not entitled to receive an annual allowance if the surviving spouse makes an” b ) by replacing line 4 on page 52 with the following:

“(6) A surviving spouse may make an irrevocable” c ) by replacing line 10 on page 52 with the following:

“three months after the surviving spouse is notified of” d ) by replacing line 14 on page 52 with the following:

“(8) A surviving spouse is not entitled to receive any” e ) by replacing, in the English version, line 17 on page 52 with the following:

“surviving spouse is found criminally responsible for” f ) by replacing line 19 on page 52 with the following:

“(9) A surviving spouse is not entitled to receive an” g ) by replacing, in the English version, line 22 on page 52 with the following:

“Minister that the surviving spouse cannot be found.” h ) by replacing line 25 on page 52 with the following:

“and there are two surviving spouses of the contributor,” i ) by replacing lines 28 and 29 on page 52 with the following: a ) the surviving spouse referred to in paragraph ( a ) of the definition “surviving spouse” in subsection” j ) by replacing lines 34 to 39 on page 52 with the following:

“contributor or since having been deemed under subsection (4.1) to have become married to the contributor bears to the total number of years that the contributor so cohabited with the surviving spouses; and ( b ) the surviving spouse referred to in paragraph ( b )” k ) by replacing lines 2 and 3 on page 53 with the following:

“with the contributor since having been deemed under subsection (4) to have become married to the contributor bears to the total number of” l ) by replacing lines 5 and 6 on page 53 with the following:

“surviving spouses, either while married or while having been deemed to have been married.” m ) by replacing line 12 on page 53 with the following:

“(12) When one of the surviving spouses referred to” n ) by replacing lines 17 and 18 on page 53 with the following:

“surviving spouse who died or is not entitled shall be paid to the remaining surviving spouse in addition to”

Public Sector Pension Investment Board Act May 11th, 1999

moved:

Motion No. 15

That Bill C-78, in Clause 53, be amended by replacing line 9 on page 29 with the following:

““surviving spouse” in relation to a contributor, means”

Motion No. 17

That Bill C-78, in Clause 61, be amended by replacing line 19 on page 38 with the following:

“under this Part to the surviving spouse and children of”

Motion No. 18

That Bill C-78, in Clause 62, be amended a ) by replacing line 12 on page 40 with the following:

“payable under this Part to a surviving spouse or child,” b ) by replacing line 24 on page 40 with the following:

“surviving spouse has become entitled under this Part to” c ) by replacing lines 33 and 34 on page 41 with the following: b ) a benefit to which a contributor, surviving spouse or child is entitled under this Part or Part”

Motion No. 19

That Bill C-78, in Clause 64, be amended a ) by replacing line 38 on page 42 with the following:

“annuity or an annual allowance, the surviving spouse” b ) by replacing line 4 on page 43 with the following: a ) in the case of the surviving spouse, an immediate” c ) by replacing lines 10 and 11 on page 43 with the following:

“without leaving a surviving spouse, the surviving spouse is dead or the surviving spouse is not entitled to receive” d ) by replacing lines 17 and 18 on page 43 with the following:

“died without leaving a surviving spouse, the surviving spouse is dead or the surviving spouse is not entitled to receive” e ) by replacing line 26 on page 43 with the following:

“(2)( a ) or ( b ), the surviving spouse and children of the” f ) by replacing line 42 on page 43 with the following:

“1967 of less than five years, the surviving spouse and” g ) by replacing lines 15 to 17 on page 44 with the following:

“service, the surviving spouse and children of the contributor, in any case where the contributor died leaving a surviving spouse or a child less than”

Motion No. 20

That Bill C-78, in Clause 65, be amended a ) by replacing line 29 on page 46 with the following:

“the surviving spouse and children of the contributor” b ) by replacing lines 37 and 38 on page 46 with the following:

“more years of pensionable service, the surviving spouse and children of the contributor are entitled”

Motion No. 21

That Bill C-78, in Clause 75, be amended a ) by replacing line 4 on page 50 with the following:

“the surviving spouse and children of a contributor are” b ) by replacing line 7 on page 50 with the following:

“surviving spouse except that” c ) by replacing line 11 on page 50 with the following:

“payment is to be made the surviving spouse is dead” d ) by replacing lines 17 and 18 on page 50 with the following:

“for died without leaving a surviving spouse or at the time payment is to be made the surviving spouse” e ) by replacing lines 27 to 29 on page 50 with the following:

“surviving spouse at the time payment is to be made, the total amount shall be paid to the surviving spouse and the children so living apart in” f ) by replacing line 32 on page 50 with the following:

“stances, or to the surviving spouse or any of the” g ) by replacing line 37 on page 50 with the following:

“to be made the surviving spouse is dead or cannot be” h ) by replacing line 39 on page 50 with the following:

“leaving a surviving spouse and at the time the”

Motion No. 22

That Bill C-78, in Clause 75, be amended a ) by replacing lines 8 to 14 on page 51 with the following:

“(2) If there are two surviving spouses of a contributor, the share of the total amount to be paid to surviving spouse referred to in paragraph ( a ) of the definition “surviving spouse” in subsection 3(1) and the share to be paid to the surviving spouse referred to in paragraph ( b ) of that definition shall be paid as the Minister may direct.” b ) by replacing line 17 on page 51 with the following:

“the share of one or other of the surviving spouses under”

Motion No. 23

That Bill C-78, in Clause 75, be amended by replacing lines 27 to 42 on page 51 with the following:

“(4) For the purposes of this Part, where a contributor dies and the contributor had been, for a period of not less than one year immediately before the contributor's death, residing with a person of the opposite sex to whom the contributor was not married, the Treasury Board may deem that person to be the surviving spouse of the contributor if, during that period, that person had been publicly represented by the contributor to be the spouse of the contributor, and may deem that person to have become married to the contributor on the day established by that person to the satisfaction of the Treasury Board as being the day on which the representation began.

(4.1) For the purposes of this Part, where a contributor dies and, at the time of death, the contributor was married to a person with whom the contributor had been residing for a period immediately before the marriage and who, during that period, had been publicly represented by the contributor to be the spouse of the contributor, the Treasury Board may deem that person to have become married to the contributor on the day established by that person to the satisfaction of the Treasury Board as being the day on which the representation began.”

Supreme Court Of Canada May 11th, 1999

Mr. Speaker, the minister talks about consultation. I want to ask her, did Canadians have an opportunity to be consulted on child pornography, on aboriginal land claims, on redefining the family? The list goes on and on and the answer is no.

These issues are too important to shut out Canadians. We should be able to see, learn and evaluate the supreme court candidates, before his or her appointment is a fait accompli. It is a closed shop today.

Will the minister open the door to public scrutiny and allow parliament to assess the nominees? Yes or no?