House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Petitions February 5th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate that you recognize I am most in need of exercise, so you have me stand up and sit down most often. Thank you.

I am proud to represent directly the constituents of Elk Island in their petition. They are deeply concerned about the fact that the CRTC promotes violence, sexual exploitation, the degradation of women and children and also men through pornographic channels which are approved but refuses to allow Christian broadcasters to get a licence, even though apparently our constitutional rights give us freedom of religion, conscience and expression.

The petitioners plead that Parliament review the mandate of the CRTC and change its policy so that this type of religious broadcasting is permitted and the other one shut down.

I am proud to present this petition on their behalf.

Point Of Order February 4th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I would like to support my colleague's point of order by addressing specifically the liability of the crown.

I would argue that the liability issue that my colleague has referred to regarding ships in section IX of the Canada Shipping Act is applicable to the federal crown despite the fact that this is not expressly stipulated in the act. The presumption of crown immunity from statute, in both its common law form and as enacted in section 17 of the Interpretation Act, only applies to statues which are prejudicial to the crown.

Liabilities for crown owned docks, canals or harbours are not imposed by the Canada Shipping Act, but arise from section 3(b) of the Crown Liability and Proceedings Act, which states: “The Crown is liable in tort for the damages for which, if it were a private person of full age and capacity, it would be liable in respect of a breach of duty attaching to the ownership, occupation, possession or control of property ”.

In the Alphonse Desjardins case, 1994, the Quebec Court of Appeal ruled that other provisions of the Canada Shipping Act did not apply to the crown, but that the provisions in part IX did apply to the crown. In that case a boat owned by the crown was charged with discharging pollutants into the St. Lawrence River, contrary to section 664 of the Canada Shipping Act. The application of an offence provision, such as section 664 in part XV, would prejudice the rights and interests of the crown.

Another more obvious reason why section 664 would not apply to a crown owned vessel is section 641 of the act, which declares that “this Act does not, except where specially provided, apply to ships belonging to Her Majesty”. There is no similar provision for government owned docks, canals or harbours.

Bill S-4 unmistakably constitutes an indirect demand for supply because it would leave the crown bound to make a demand for supply.

The government House leader keeps reminding this House that my party supported a Senate bill in the last Parliament. I would like to point out that the official opposition plans on supporting the principle of Bill S-4, Bill S-3 and Bill S-5. The principle in these bills is not what is at issue here.

What is at issue here is the principle of democracy. It is obvious from the minister's comments that he does not recognize that the people of Canada are represented in this House and not the unelected Senate.

Mr. Speaker, I conclude by saying that I ask that you consider this argument which we have put forward today carefully and remove Bill S-4 from our order paper as soon as possible.

Income Tax Amendments Act, 1997 February 3rd, 1998

Madam Speaker, on a point of order, I regret to do this but I would like to plead the rule of relevancy. We are talking about the federal government and federal taxes. This member has spoken about nothing but provincial systems to this point. I would like to ask you to have him brought back on topic.

Income Tax Amendments Act, 1997 February 3rd, 1998

Madam Speaker, it is really tough to follow that stand up comedy act by the member for Winnipeg South but I will try to do my best.

It is absolutely incredible. The Liberals have it down to an art how to communicate that they are wonderful when in fact they are doing exactly the opposite. They say “We are the defenders of health care”, and at the same time they cut and burn and slash the transfers to provinces.

It is a simple strategy. I have to congratulate them. If we were fighting a war, they would be on my team because they know how to win a war by making everybody else take the hits. Their own soldiers stand up and don't get touched at all because they are somehow able to communicate that misinformation by saying “We are not responsible, it was not us. We cut $7 billion out of health care and transfers to the provinces for education and welfare. We cut that but no, it was not us”.

The provincial governments landed up taking the heat for it. Then the Liberals have the gall to stand up in this House and criticize governments like the Harris government in Ontario because of the cuts to health care and education that government has found it necessary to make as a result of the fact that the funds from the federal government have been drastically cut. Now gingerly a little bit is being put back in.

Somehow the Liberals have the ability to spin it in such a way that the Canadian people do not look to the real depth of the message. They buy into it and say “Let us send those Liberals back to Ottawa. They really know how to manage the economy”.

Let us look at the facts. This government claims to be so wonderful and talks about having brought the deficit under control. That is only one part. I will put it this way, it is one leg of a four-legged stool. The stool is tottering but they finally got that one leg and I will gingerly applaud them for that.

I am glad the Liberals are borrowing less than the Conservatives were borrowing. Had we still been borrowing at $42 billion per year, our fiscal picture would be much more bleak than it is now. Yes, they have slowed down the rate of borrowing to the pace where they are now borrowing only about $9 billion a year instead of $40 billion a year. While these Liberals have been in power since 1993 our debt has gone up.

I started this political thing. I was one of those people who was not involved in politics at all. I never belonged to a political party until I joined Reform. But I got so cotton-picking upset about the mismanagement of the Government of Canada since Trudeau took power way back, spending more money than we were taking in, adding to the debt and transferring the taxpayers' hard earned dollars not into programs that were needed by Canadians but to lending institutions because of the debt and the interest payments on them.

I got involved. I remember when I first started. It was in the fall of 1991. When I was first thinking of running as a candidate I gave a speech and said that it was deplorable that our debt was $420 billion. The Conservatives took it from the $320 billion which the previous Liberals had left them to $420 billion. In nine years they added $100 billion to the debt.

The fact is that this government since 1993, in four and a half years, has added almost $100 billion to the debt. The Liberals are twice as good as the Conservatives. While they stand up and say that they are wonderful, that they are not borrowing so much, the fact of the matter is that still, because of the accumulated debt and the large interest payments, the Government of Canada, on behalf of the hard working taxpayer of this country, has driven us into debt $100 billion in round figures more than when the Liberals took office in 1993. And like I said, they have the gall to stand up in front of Canadians and say “Vote for us again because we are wonderful, we are really solving this problem”. I find that unconscionable.

I am going to say something else about this whole system. We are talking today about a tax bill. What are taxes? In the olden days as we used to say, it was a king or a lord who had power over the subjects in his little kingdom. He could say “For me to have my castle, my gold and to run my armies and so on, you will each pay a certain portion of what you earned, a certain part of your crops, or whatever”. They gave it as a law.

It was a bit of a symbiotic relationship. Those subjects benefited from the protection of the king or the lord. The armies were really there to protect the king's or the lord's investment in those people since they were the source of his wealth.

In a democracy taxes are really a contribution made by hard working, risk-taking workers and entrepreneurs. They are saying that they will pay into a public purse the amount required to run their governments. The taxes in this country are killing families and poor people. It is incredible. The Liberal government says over and over that it is wonderful and cares for the poor people. There are people who make $18,000 or $20,000 a year, some of whom are single moms, and they still have a tax bill to pay.

During the last Parliament there was a big controversy over who should pay the taxes on the child support paid by a supporting spouse to a custodial parent. This government had the gall again to increase the taxes when it said that the person paying the money will pay the taxes instead of transferring the taxes to the spouse.

The government could have had the person pay a deduction in advance which the lower paying taxpayer could get back in the case of an overpayment. Instead the government said no, that it would just do it. The government ended up taking millions of dollars away from the poorest in our society. Yet they stand up and say “We are the Liberals who look after the needs of the needy in this country”. Pardon me for being sarcastic but the truth and what the message is are on opposite sides of the spectrum.

I will be so bold as to suggest that taxation in this country has become a form of legalized theft. If someone came into my house and took half of everything I had in my house, including the left speaker of my stereo system which is worth $20 and my old black and white television, I would phone the RCMP and ask them to get there tout de suite to arrest the guy who was taking half of my stuff. Yet I allow the federal, provincial and municipal governments to take from me by the coercion of taxation, which I call a form of theft, 50% of my earnings every year. If I do not co-operate with the system I am told by government bigwigs that I am not a good citizen. Why should I?

I am certainly willing to help those in need, absolutely. I do it voluntarily. On a number of occasions I have come across people with needs. Whenever I am able to with my after tax dollars I love to help people. But for me to send it to Ottawa, have this government twirl it around in its centrifuge, have 70% of the money I have contributed spill over in government waste and inefficiency, have some of it doled out to its political friends, and if there is some left over it may go to the poor, I am not content with that. That is theft and it is wrong.

This is what I would like to see in a taxation system. We should fix the tax system so Canadians get to keep some of their hard earned money and use it the way they see fit, which includes helping their neighbours and others who need help.

It is absolutely absurd the way this and other governments impose tax upon tax upon tax. We get taxed with income tax and we pay our municipal taxes with the money left over. My municipal tax bill is around $2,500 a year and I have to earn $4,000 to pay it because the federal and provincial governments first take 35% or 40%. With the money I have left I write a cheque to my municipality and my $4,000 is gone. It goes on and on and on.

This government can tinker with taxes, like it is doing with this bill, for decades. We will never rest until it starts lowering taxes, making the tax system fair and making it less onerous.

Income Tax Amendments Act, 1997 February 3rd, 1998

You have got to be kidding.

Euthanasia February 2nd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I realize this motion is of considerable importance and great consequence.

What is this motion really about? We need to recognize it is part of a political process. Instead of a motion that asks specifically to permit euthanasia, it is legislation by degrees. It first proposes that the committee study this issue in the hopes that everybody will say yes.

Slowly we will be dragged along to accept something we recognize deep inside ourselves is wrong. I believe most Canadians deeply inside themselves know that it is wrong. I am speaking against this motion simply because I am opposed strongly to the outcome of what this motion proposes.

I want to make it very clear that the whole issue of euthanasia and the lack of it in this country has nothing to do with forcing people to undergo continued suffering and artificially prolonging life using extraordinary means. Within the legal values in our country it is already a permissible act to ask that treatment be discontinued. Any patient has the right to deny further treatment.

I also want to emphasize that in our present technological age there have been great advances made in palliative care and in pain control.

The greatest danger in walking down this road is that it is the beginning of a long road which will inevitably have serious ramifications. There is no doubt in my mind as has been experienced in The Netherlands that once we start, the pressure will increase. Elderly people will feel if not direct pressure then subtle pressure to try to save their family members from their grief.

They speak of dying with dignity. I cannot help but think of the passing away of my wife's father several years ago. He had terminal cancer. He suffered with it, yes. There was pain, yes. When I think of the term dying with dignity I think strongly of my father-in-law Mr. Dan Klassen who to the very end kept a strong faith, a strong love for his family. He told me “It is tough to say goodbye. I would like so much to be with mom and the children but I am ready to go. That account with God was settled long ago”. He died with real dignity. That is the dignity of which I speak.

In the past 30 years we have undergone a dramatic change in our thinking. We have shifted 180° from the concept of the sanctity of all human life to the bizarre notion that somehow death is benign. That is a contradictory statement. I wish we would look again at our values and our true roots. Why do we think that death is an option? Is it because we despair of any other solution to our problems?

I was deeply moved by the speech this morning of the hon. member for Lac-Saint-Louis. His situation is very similar to that of my family. I have spoken in the House before of my sister Marian, who next week will turn 53. She lives in an extended care centre. She was born with cerebral palsy. She cannot speak. She never has. She cannot look after herself. She cannot dress herself. She needs help with eating. She can sometimes eat on her own, but it gets rather messy. However, there are loving people in the facility who will help her clean up.

Somehow many people have come to the conclusion that it would be better for people like her to die. That is a false assumption.

The facility in which she lives is a residential cottage in which disabled people like my sister are looked after. The cottages are brightly coloured. They are named after birds. My sister is in the Swallow cottage along with 20 or 30 others.

I am going to paint a picture of the future if we continue this way of thinking. What would we say if next Tuesday on my sister's birthday a bus were to roll up to the Swallow cottage and take the 20 or 30 residents to the hospital in downtown Moose Jaw and all of those severely handicapped people would undergo one last assessment after which they would be given a lethal injection?

On Wednesday the bus would go to the Swan cottage. On Thursday the Robins would go. On Friday the residents of Owl cottage would go, and so on. There would be 20 to 30 people each day. There are 430 residents living there so it would take a whole month. How many days would pass before there would be a sufficient public outcry to stop this? Is this acceptable? I say no, no, no, a thousand times no. That is not acceptable and it is not a correct way of thinking.

Most of us, I believe, recognize that what I have proposed would be terribly wrong. The simple question I ask is, if it is wrong for all of them, how can it be right for any one of them? How badly we have slipped when we are ready to accede to the notion that the elderly, the handicapped or the suffering are not worthy of being protected.

Recent events in my home province of Saskatchewan show that there is a surprising level of support for ending the life of one who cannot speak for herself. Where are we going? In my view, if we go forward with what is proposed under the term doctor assisted suicide, we are dangerously close to the scene that I have described.

It is not possible to logically argue against it once we have accepted that basic premise. How can we persuade our young people who are contemplating suicide that death is not the answer to their problem?

I cannot say it strongly enough. This whole notion of death to end suffering, to remove a person whose quality of life is judged to be less than acceptable is based on a wrong notion of false premise. I regret that in our society today so many of us are ready and willing to set aside those strong pillars of our society that have protected us and have kept us safe for all these years. In my view, we are indeed on a very dangerous slope and slide to oblivion if we continue with this way of thinking.

There will be some who will argue why not have a committee study it. The Senate committee has engaged in a prolonged study on this. I do not believe that having a committee studying it serves any purpose at all because we are fundamentally opposed to it.

I will close by re-emphasizing my question which I want to burn into the hearts of all of the members here. If it is wrong for all of them, how can it possibly be right for any one of them?

Committees Of The House December 11th, 1997

Madam Speaker, I have a comment, and the member may want to respond to it.

She used the same phrase the Liberals use over and over and over. It is not a correct way of stating the situation. She talked of paying down the deficit. That is physically impossible because a deficit is an amount of money that was borrowed. It is true that the Liberal government is now borrowing less, so it has reduced the deficit. It is borrowing less but that has nothing to do with paying the deficit.

Would the member acknowledge and tell Canadians that the government has in fact increased the debt but at a slower rate by reducing the rate of borrowing?

Coinage December 11th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, I want to know why the government is using taxpayers' money to compete with private enterprise.

The government has authorized the building of a $30 million coin plating plant in Winnipeg in direct competition to Westaim Corporation, a firm in my riding with a 30 year record of high quality products.

Why is the government risking $30 million of taxpayers' money to build a plant that will compete directly with a successful private firm?

Westaim December 11th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, Westaim is a successful corporation with a major plant in my riding. For 30 years it has been supplying Canada and many other countries around the world with high quality materials from which coins are stamped.

The company has had an exceptionally good working relationship with the Canadian Mint providing blanks for most of Canada's coins, including the $1 and $2 coins. But the Canadian Mint has now been authorized to spend $30 million to build a plant in Winnipeg to compete with Westaim.

The government's claims of savings are greatly exaggerated. Furthermore, when we were told that this will create 100 to 130 jobs in Winnipeg, no mention was made of potential job losses in my riding.

It is a mystery. Why would the government risk $30 million to get into a business which is in a worldwide state of oversupply and which could result in the loss of up to 100 jobs in my riding?

Amendment To The Constitution Of Canada (Newfoundland) December 8th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, I would like to address the question of my colleague about the financial penalty, the people who do not have the financial ability. We made some sacrifices in our family which meant almost no vacations. It meant driving old cars. In fact, I still have my 1959 Meteor. I do not drive it anymore. But it meant keeping a car four times as long. I am still driving my 1982 Chevy Suburban. We made those sacrifices because the money had to go to tuition.

I was on the board of the school I attended and we made the decision that in order to make it easier for children to attend our school, we would try to reduce the financial barriers. We set up a tuition plan so that for a family with more children the tuition rates were steeply reduced. As a matter of fact, if there happened to be a family with more than four children, after the fourth child's tuition was paid the rest were free. They were allowed into the so-called family plan.

Certainly that should not be necessary. It is a great hardship for these private schools to endure the costs when there is a very uneven playing field. That was our solution.