House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Supply October 21st, 1997

Mr. Speaker, I cannot let this go by.

I would like to ask the hon. member exactly what he means by going back to deficit spending since we have not left it since the Liberals first came to power in the 1970s. We have had deficit spending every year, including every year since this government was elected in 1993 and even now.

Admittedly the deficit is now smaller. We are going away from the target of no debt at a slower rate, but the debt is still increasing. That cannot be denied.

The Minister of Finance said that the deficit has been brought down to $8.9 billion, which deserves mild applause. However, we are still borrowing. The debt is bigger now than it was when the government took office. It is growing this year. Interest payments are still going up. Thank goodness for low interest rates, otherwise we would be in deep trouble.

How can the member talk about going back when we never left deficit spending?

Supply October 21st, 1997

Is that why they are going around in circles?

Supply October 21st, 1997

Mr. Speaker, what frightens me when we hear the Liberals talking is that they speak with such passion they are quite convincing. They believe that what they say is true. It frightens me because they are able to deceive Canadians by being so totally deceived themselves about the facts.

I want to draw an analogy. In my youth I worked as a truck driver on the big rigs. We did not have phones in the rigs in those days but let us take it to modern days. Here I am, my job is to haul some combines from Regina to Winnipeg, which conveniently is about 600 kilometres, about 100 kilometres for every billion dollar of debt we have. I take the truck and phoned my boss and say I am doing fine. I tell him I am at Indian Head, a few kilometres away, and I am doing great. He says, “Good, what time do you think you will get to Regina?” I say, “Well, I may not because Regina is behind me. I'm on the road. I'm going about 20 to 30 kilometres an hour but it is behind me.” I keep on driving all day and the boss phones again. He says “How are you doing now?” I say, “Well I've just crossed the border into Manitoba”. He says, “Hey, you are supposed to go to Regina”. I tell him I will go a little faster.

We had the Trudeau Liberals for awhile and then we had Mulroney Conservatives and they goosed the thing up to 40 kilometres an hour, $40 billion a year. Now we have these Liberals and just as they are approaching Winnipeg, $600 billion, they are bragging because they have slowed the truck down to 17 kilometres an hour. I am sorry, now it is only going nine kilometres per hour, but Winnipeg is just about there and Regina the destination is way back behind in the rearview mirror. And these guys think they have—

Division No. 11 October 20th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, it is with mixed feelings that I stand at this time of the day to debate this bill because we need to have an opportunity not only to debate it in this House, not only to have experts who look at the many ramifications of the hundred pages of legislative change, but we should also have an opportunity to take it to the people back home whom we have been elected to represent.

It is devastating for me to find that my role as a parliamentarian is being limited by a government that again thinks it knows everything and that it cannot make a mistake. That is what is presumed here. If it puts forward a motion and says that it wants it all finished today I would hope that what it is saying is that there is no error in this legislation, that there is nothing that can be made better for the people of Canada, that it is a perfect piece of legislation, so let us just get it on the way.

I would have to concede that there would come occasions where there is a small technical change to be made where that may be the truth, but we do not know that. As my colleague from Calgary indicated, that was the assumption made a couple of years ago when the legislation was passed that we are now trying to undo.

How can the government carry on with this premise? I am insulted by it and I am hurt by it. Our respect for the parliamentary process and for this institution is being reduced. We have an obligation to maintain the integrity of it.

I feel so strongly that not only myself but also the members on the other side—we call them affectionately the Liberal or the government backbenchers, those who do not have a say in government—all have an obligation to provide scrutiny to these bills. These things have a tremendous impact on our society, on the citizens of this country, on the taxpayers of this country. For the backbenchers to go along with this charade and to say “No, we are willing to abdicate our responsibility and not provide that scrutiny” I think puts them also in dereliction of duty.

It is incredible to think that the ministers who sit in the front rows really do know everything. If that is really true then perhaps we ought to save the taxpayers a lot of money and just have a 20 seat Parliament and let them run it. We can just call it a cabinet and let them run the show. Let us call it what it is, an elected dictatorship between elections. That is what it boils down to.

I would like to see those backbenchers on the other side—what term do I use now. It was going to be a four letter word that starts with g and ends with ts but I cannot use that. I wish they had the internal fortitude to actually stand up and say “I'm sent here to represent the people who elected me” and to stand up against the front bench of their party when they pull these kinds of shenanigans. This is really despicable.

One of the greatest concerns we have in our ridings, at least I am hearing in my riding, is the concern of seniors with respect to their personal financial security. It is being eroded big time. They plan for their future and for their retirement given certain parameters. Now those parameters are being changed rapidly and they do not have an opportunity to make adjustments to their earnings, to their savings plans. Certainly they cannot anticipate all of the different and additional taxation rules that the government is giving to them.

It behoves us as members to show some genuine concern for the seniors in our society, those who are most affected by changes in these rules, those whose very continued livelihood depends on their financial security.

We ought to show a great amount of scrutiny and care when we propose to change bills. This is an affront to us. I am ashamed members opposite are going along with this kind of a charade and still claiming they won the election and can do whatever they want. That is not good enough.

The people of Canada will rise up and revolt against this kind of a government. They will say “Enough of this. We want a true representational government. We want a government where MPs are sent to Ottawa to represent the people”. They should take their voting orders from the people who elected them and not from their party bosses who think they know everything and will not even contemplate that perhaps one of their bills or motions should be subject to amendment, improvement or perhaps even defeat.

It is time that happens. I invite Canadians everywhere to wake up to what is happening in this place. It is a sham and it is a shame.

Income Tax Conventions Implementation Act, 1997 October 20th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, it is my understanding that prior to this bill being passed, that is under the rules that are now in place, 50% of the security income was taxed and now 85% of that income is going to be taxed. If we are going to tax a greater proportion of the income, it seems to me that will result in a tax increase. I would like the member to explain if that is not so, how that would come about.

My second question is with respect to the retroactivity. The government claims that its bill is going to be retroactive. I would like to know what specific procedures are going to be followed to make sure under the retroactive rules that those who have paid taxes will no longer be accountable for how they will get their refunds or rebates and how they will be looked after.

These are two very serious questions and I would appreciate a response.

Income Tax Conventions Implementation Act, 1997 October 20th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, mine is an academic question. I would ask the member to declare publicly that people who have a low income will not be taxed by this provision. Is that true or is that not true?

We are talking about inclusion rates. Is he saying that people who have low incomes will not be taxed?

Income Tax Conventions Implementation Act, 1997 October 20th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, I would like to ask the member a very simple question. He is so interested in fairness. With the changes coming to CPP, with benefits decreasing relative to the premiums and seniors generally being really pushed, does he also believe in the fairness that will cause him to say no to his MP pension plan?

Canada Marine Act October 10th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, I apologize but I was not informed by my leadership. Will the whip give me assurance that consent has been reached?

Supply October 9th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, this is more for my information than anything. If the member has only 15 minutes remaining, do we not then get 5 minutes for questions and comments?

Supply October 9th, 1997

Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of order. Would you ask the member to be intellectually honest in the connections he makes?

It is a deprecation of the quality of debate in the House to hear him talk like that. It is wrong.