Mr. Speaker, today in answer to a question the Minister of Justice referred to a letter which he received from CAVEAT, from Priscilla de Villiers. Pursuant to citation 495 of Beauchesne, we request that the letter be tabled.
House of Commons photoWon his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.
Points Of Order April 10th, 1997
Mr. Speaker, today in answer to a question the Minister of Justice referred to a letter which he received from CAVEAT, from Priscilla de Villiers. Pursuant to citation 495 of Beauchesne, we request that the letter be tabled.
Criminal Code April 9th, 1997
Mr. Speaker, I would like to add a few words of what I hope will be considered common sense to the debate. The bill which my hon. colleague has put forward has a lot of common sense at a very elementary level.
The bill simply deals with refusing to allow a person re-entry who has been already illegally evicted from a premise. Let us stop to think about it from a very practical point of view. There is not a merchant in the country who will kick his customers out if the customers are good for business. It also makes a lot of sense to consider if he or she is encountering interference by people on the premises who are preventing other people from coming in or even making them uncomfortable because of their antics. If there is adequate reason to remove that person lawfully, which is the first part of the bill, why should there not also be a simple provision that says the person may not come back? Perhaps 24 hours is not enough.
That is what the motion is stating. A person can be kicked out of a place, walk right back in, do the same thing, be kicked back out, come back in, do the same thing and on it goes. There is no remedy to that situation. It can be repeated over and over.
My hon. colleague is simply saying that we should give that individual a chance to stop and think about it and give the involved security people or the police staff the opportunity to say to the person: "You are out of here for 24 hours. Stop to think about what you are doing. Maybe you will correct yourself".
At the time of the initial eviction, especially with young people, very often there is a little element of peer pressure. They just want to prove a point and maybe have a bit of fun. That would break this up and solve the problem. We in the Reform Party are very interested in preserving the rights of law-abiding citizens.
In this instance we are taking people who are pushing to the limit the rights and the privileges of others. We are saying that for a short time their right to enter the premise will be suspended. It is just a very gentle way of correcting them instead of digging them into a big hole.
There is always the debate on whether this is a provincial matter. We have heard that a lot this week in the debates on justice issues. I suppose one could argue that almost everything is provincial in the sense that almost everything is given in the Criminal Code to the provinces to administer. There is a national Criminal Code, the Criminal Code of Canada. Within that code are these articles of trespass and other provisions. Why not strengthen it so that it could be made to work more smoothly?
One of the last things I would like to see happen is our security people or those working on police forces wasting their time frivolously putting people out and allowing them back in because they have to under the present provisions without there being a remedy.
Now it is suggested that every municipality could have a regulation in this regard. Why should we ask the thousands of municipalities to deal with the issue and to include it in their own provisions? That would result in a lack of uniformity and an inefficiency in terms of the use of legislators' time when we could have a national law in the form of a change to our national provisions which would solve the problem?
In conclusion, it is unfortunate the way this place works. The member from the Bloc who spoke said: "I and the members of my party will not be supporting this provision". In other words he is the justice critic. He comes in here. He looks at it and says: "That is the end of it. Our guys will not be supporting it".
The parliamentary secretary already made the decision on behalf of the Liberal Party. This is a private member's bill. Of course we have free votes. Instead of a carte blanche that says we will not support it and thereby have everybody jump into line, perhaps it would be better if the leaders in their respective caucuses would challenge their people to think about the matter and to make their decision individually.
They should talk to the people in their ridings as my hon. colleague has done. His motion is a direct result of representations to him by people involved in these kinds of things. He has talked to the police who actually have a suboffice in the shopping mall. They have a problem where their time is being wasted by having to repeatedly put people out. They have no legal provision to tell them not to come back.
That is all that is being asked here. It makes a great deal of common sense. As I said in the beginning, it is perhaps a little too elementary for members opposite to realize, but I plead with them to consider the matter carefully. Let us allow the legislative process and the Liberal red book commitment to more free votes to apply. Let us deal with the issue rather than simply have one person say: "We will not support it because it is a Reform motion" or for whatever other reason.
I am thankful for the opportunity to participate. I hope I have added value to the debate this evening.
Points Of Order April 9th, 1997
Mr. Speaker, my point of order is with respect to an answer given by the Minister of Finance to a question.
I draw your attention to citations 348 to 352 of Beauchesne which has to do with statements by ministers. What he gave was primarily a statement by a minister and should have been so directed.
Second, I draw to your attention citation 408 of Beauchesne in which it states explicitly that questions should not require a lengthy and detailed answer. Answers to questions should be as brief as possible. Citation 410 states: "Time is scarce" and "Brevity both in questions and answers is of great importance".
It is quite obvious that the member asking the question and the minister had communicated beforehand. This could have been done in another venue and I object strongly to this.
Keith Brimacombe March 21st, 1997
Mr. Speaker, Dr. Keith Brimacombe, director of the Centre for Metallurgical Process Engineering at the University of British Columbia, is the 1997 winner of the Canada gold medal for science and engineering.
We all acknowledge that our participation in the world economy and our very high standard of living are directly proportional to success in scientific research. Without the contribution of people like Dr. Brimacombe, we would not have the high quality, safe materials that we have to produce our vehicles, airplanes, bridges and buildings.
We would like to add our congratulations to Dr. Brimacombe. His gold medal is well deserved. We would like to thank him for his efforts over the years. His leadership in research and training is of immense value and is appreciated by all Canadians.
Canadian Census March 19th, 1997
Madam Speaker, it is a delight to stand in the House today to lend my support to the motion proposed by the member for Beaver River.
Sometimes I am asked what it means to be a Canadian. I have a number of different pictures in my mind of what it means to be a Canadian that are very strong, very emphatic.
I am privileged by the fact that my grandparents were literally chased out of their home country in 1923. They suffered great persecution there. A number of my relatives were unjustly murdered. My grandparents knew it was not a safe place for our family and wondered where to go. Through various circumstances which I do not have time to relate tonight they were able to find their way to this wonderful country, Canada.
I have recollections as a child growing up in a little farmhouse in Saskatchewan where I was born and raised. I remember overhearing my parents, grandparents, uncles, aunts and some of their friends talking about the life they had experienced in what they called the old country.
They talked about some of the hardships and difficulties they had gone through and some of the ways in which their freedoms had been totally taken away: their freedom to make a living the way they wanted to make a living and their freedom to worship the way they wanted to worship. Those freedoms were wrenched away from them and they came to this country. I remember them talking about how grateful and how blessed we were as a family because we could be Canadian.
I remember being at the home of my grandparents many times. Whether it was to celebrate a birthday, Easter or Christmas we would get together as a family and my grandparents would lead us
in family prayers. My grandmother was more expressive than my grandfather. In her prayers she would say over and over: "Thank you for the privilege of living in this wonderful free country". They came here with 10 children. As an aside, until last year all of them were still living. The youngest was 75. I come from hardy stock. We live long.
My grandparents, my uncles and aunts on both sides of my family came to this country as immigrants, worked hard and helped to open up the west. They helped to till the land to produce food to feed themselves and others. They were as proud as we are to be part of this country. My parents were 12 years old when they came to Canada so I am a first generation Canadian. I was actually born in Saskatchewan. I called that home until I married and moved to Alberta. I have very strong attachments.
There is especial attachment to the country when one grows up in a farm family and tills the soil. There is an attachment to the land when one actually works the soil and grows food for sustenance, because we all know that without food we would not survive.
I have other recollections about being in this country. One of the most valuable ones was that of my son who has served in different places in the world where people were experiencing the same kinds of hardships my grandparents experienced. Because of our family heritage, partially at least, he felt it was a useful to spend part of his life helping others who were in difficult circumstances. He worked with various relief agencies around the world, carrying and wearing a Canadian flag. He went there not only in the name of the organization he was with but also in the name of our country.
A most recent recollection I had of the value of being a Canadian was a very moving experience for me. I participated for the first time ever in the ceremony of welcoming new Canadians at a citizenship court. It happened last year on July 1. We were in the historic court house in Fort Saskatchewan. As I recall the court house was built before Saskatchewan became a province and joined Confederation. It was an historical court house. There we were up on the second floor with a number of different people who were making Canada their home.
One lady in particular struck me. As she reached out to take from the presiding judge her citizenship papers there were tears literally streaming down her cheeks. It touched me because I had the recollection of my grandmother who had that same emotional reaction, that tie, that love of this country.
When I talked to her afterwards she said essentially the same thing that my grandmother had said: "I came from a country of great strife and I am so proud, so happy and so blessed to be a Canadian".
I do not believe that I can express more strongly or with more emotion my support for the bill before the House today. It is a bill which says let us call ourselves Canadians. This is the most valued
part of planet Earth. It is the most enviable place to live. There are people around the world who would literally give anything they have to live here, but for some reason we are hesitant to say that we are Canadians.
I thank the House for the opportunity to speak to this motion. I urge all members on all sides of the House to support the motion not because of any partisan consideration but simply because it is the right thing to do.
Copyright Act March 17th, 1997
Madam Speaker, in order to have clarity and no big problems about this later, you indicated this was on Motions Nos. 8 and 11. I believe the intent is 8, 9, 10 and 11. I would like that clarified, please.
Copyright Act March 13th, 1997
Mr. Speaker, it is with pleasure that I rise to voice my strongest objections to this part of the bill.
I really would like to urge the minister, who is listening carefully, and all the other members who in the red book promised to have free votes, to exercise that free vote, to vote against this bill unless this part is amended right out of there.
I remember when I was a young man in high school, there was one time our biology teacher had to leave the classroom. I was busily working quietly. We had a rule in my generation that whether the teacher was there or not, there was a lot of silence in the classroom. It was strictly enforced.
Some of my classmates started talking. Bless his heart,Mr. Harold J. Newlove, my famous biology teacher, came into the classroom to find the place in general pandemonium. He declared a penalty. Everyone would stay after school.
I tell you the truth, Mr. Speaker, I was not involved in that. I went to Mr. Harold J. Newlove and I said to him: "Sir, I have to catch a bus because I am one of these rural students. I have to get home to help my family with farm chores. I have to get away from here. Otherwise I need to walk four miles to get home. Can I please be exempted on the assurance that I was not involved? I am not guilty". Mr. Newlove said: "If I make an exception for you, where will it end? You will stay". You do not know how injured I was because I was innocent.
This is the fundamental premise in this part of this bill which is false. It assumes that if I go into a store to buy a tape that is blank I am going to commit a crime with it. What backward thinking that is. Why would even the Liberals, as they believe in the common goodness of all people, now suddenly come to the conclusion that there would be even one person in the country who would break the copyright laws?
I recognize the harsh reality is that some people do this, but to pass a law that causes every other person to pay the penalty for the person who actually did break the law I think is a violation of our fundamental sense of justice. We should all be outraged, as I was when I was in high school. That is the first point. We ought not to be punishing people for crimes they did not commit.
Second, and this I think is just as important, I believe that it is wrong to, by supposing that someone is going to break the law, make them pay the penalty in advance.
I read a statistic not too long ago that in the city of Ottawa the average person drives about 20 kilometres an hour over the speed limit. Judging by the cabs I have ridden in it is about 100 per cent over. Instead of going through that costly exercise of having police persons with radar and all of these other things, why do we not put a boundary around the city and everyone who comes in we will charge them all $100, a payment in advance of their speeding fine which we know that they will commit?
If we did that we could say to them go ahead and speed. Would we say that? What is the purpose of that speeding law? Is it not to protect, in the case of vehicles, the lives and the property of all of us?
If we have a copyright law, the copyright law has the purpose of protecting the property of the creator of the property. I know of which I speak. I happen to be a mathematician, a low level one but I casually sometimes admit to it, and I have some experience with computing. For a while I used to write computer programs and I used to then sell them. I used to first give them away because people liked some of the things I did and I was a generous guy and I said go ahead and have a copy of that program. Then someone said why not sell them.
When desktop computers came along, we had these little diskettes and I could put my programs on to those diskettes. I realized very quickly that there were some people who were making illegal copies, even of my stuff. I found out about it surreptitiously. I accidentally found out about it.
I put a notice in all of my programs that said: "If you have made a copy of this program and you did not pay for it to Epp Software, here is the address where you can send your royalties". I received some money in the mail because there were some people who said they liked that program and wanted to know where they could get it. Everybody who had a copy of the program said "copy it and send Ken Epp 10 bucks and he's happy".
I got a bit of money, not very much, I will admit that, but I got a bit of income from that because I asked people to be honest. For the others, I cannot do that. I do believe in the ownership of property but I do not believe that I would want to charge a person a penalty for stealing my property before he does it in the anticipation that he will. This raises a very very fundamental question of justice.
Picture me walking into a store and buying a case of C-60s, the little cassette tapes. Included in the price is an amount which will come to about a dollar by the time we are all finished, as my colleague mentioned, because we will pay GST and HST and BST and mark-ups and all of this stuff on that original 30 cents to50 cents, which I predict will soon grow to $1 or $2. Once the
government gets its fingers on a source of income it loves to make it greater. I will have paid on my little case of C-60s maybe $10.
My teenage son will now say to me "dad can I take one of your tapes because I want to make a copy of this CD I have to give to my friend?" When my kids even suggested they would do that I gave them a blanket "no, that is not legal and we do not do that".
Is it now legal? Can my son now argue with me and say we have already paid for the copyright on that thing by paying this special levy on the tapes we bought? Is it now legitimate that this Liberal government would say it will put a tax on the tape to allow people to break a law? That is absurd.
That is why I emphatically ask the minister to reconsider, to use some commons sense and think this through. I urge the members of that huge majority governing party to think about what they are doing and to read their red book again. Remember the one that said more free votes? Here is one. Here is a point.
My point is that they have it in their power to force the minister, to cajole the minister, to persuade the minister or whatever method they use, to get this very offensive part out of this bill. One way of doing that is to simply vote in favour of our member's amendment. It is the motion that says let us rescind this part that pretaxes breaking the law or that causes me to pay the penalty for other people breaking the law. Let us rescind that. If all members vote in favour of that it will pass and we will have accomplished something. We in this House will have done the right thing on this issue. I strongly urge them to do that.
I will be watching because if they do not, then when I go back to my people during the next election campaign I will have a moral obligation to tell them that they have had, courtesy of this Liberal government, this very strange law passed. I think they would even be ashamed at that. I am sure they will all support it and I appreciate the opportunity to speak on this.
Member For Beaver River March 13th, 1997
Mr. Speaker, today is a most significant anniversary for it was on this date in 1989 that the hon. member for Beaver River was first elected to the House.
She has led the way in proclaiming that MPs are elected to represent their constituents, taking their voting orders from them and not from the party hierarchy in Ottawa. She has led the way in showing that there can be politicians who serve the people and not themselves by denouncing and opting out of a self-enriching, lavish MP pension plan. She has led the way in showing that women can compete with men for nominations and can win on merit and ability instead of bearing the insult of unelected appointment.
She suffered the loneliness of being the sole Reformer here for nearly five years, supported briefly by Canada's only elected senator, Reformer Stan Waters.
We salute the member for Beaver River today. She truly is a leader among leaders, a friend among friends and a mentor who leads by example. May she continue to inspire us all. We wish her continued success and happiness.
Appropriation Act No. 1, 1997-98 March 12th, 1997
Madam Speaker, I would like to ask, when the maximum volume for nos exceeded that of the yeas, you assumed those motions were all passed.
Parliament Of Canada Act March 11th, 1997
Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the opportunity to enter into the debate. I came here as a Reformer with a very high interest in reforming Parliament. The people of Elk Island, particularly the people in the west where I grew up and where I have lived all my life, gave a very strong message that Parliament had to be made to work in favour of the people who elected us.
I take a great deal of pleasure standing in support of the private member's bill put forward by my colleague. It is another way of holding the government accountable. It is another way of returning power to the people instead of vesting in their government between elections.
This is part of a larger problem as I see it. I am distressed by the fact that over and over we see the exercise of power by a very few people in Parliament. It has already been alluded to but I was particularly distressed this evening during the vote.
Parliamentary rules prevent me from talking about a vote that has been held so I will not break that rule, but I will simply comment on the fact that over and over we see members of the government voting on command. I can scarcely believe that on each and every issue there is always 100 per cent agreement with what the government whip says. If that is the case I am very surprised.
I would like to see true freedom in Parliament and an end to the manipulation that takes place by the Prime Minister and by ministers of the crown as they operate and as they run through a vote.
I would like to come to the issue we are dealing with this evening, the proposition that people should actually be able to plan ahead the time of a federal election being held.
I am new to the political world. I worked as an instructor at the Northern Alberta Institute of Technology. From the time of my nomination in 1992 until the election was finally called for the fall of 1993 I lived in uncertainty for some 16 or 17 months. I did not know whether I should tell my employer and my students that they would have the continuity of the instruction I was offering until the end of the semester or until the end of the year. I was unable to plan financially and unable to plan in terms of scheduling my career and my life.
I was very supportive at that time of the plank in Reform Party policy that elections should be held periodically at predetermined dates. I do not like the words fixed elections because there is an implication that the outcome of the election is predetermined rather than the date of the election. We need to distinguish between those words.
Why can we not say to the people that the government will govern in a democratic way by going to the people for that accountability session? I have heard parliamentarians refer to it as the ultimate accountability session. We go to the electors and ask whether on the basis of our record they will elect us again That is the strength of democracy. There is no reason in the world we cannot do that at predetermined dates with some regularity. The only exception would be if there were a time of real national emergency.
I have a great deal of support for democratizing Parliament, the House of Commons, this place where Canadians expect their aspirations to be reflected. Canadians expect to have their desires fulfilled in terms of the rules that are developed which control our lives and the way our money is spent.
These parliamentary reforms are absolutely necessary. The faster we can get on with them, the better. It is a shame that we go on and on, I was going to say from century to century, but we are not quite that old as a country yet. We keep moving along and there is hardly ever a mind for change, a change for betterment, a change for a more true democracy.
It is a matter of considerable urgency, particularly because of the issues that face us. We need to ensure that the electors of this country are given the opportunity to elect a fair and an honest government, a government that will represent their aspirations and will neither run behind them nor ahead of them.
We have large issues in this country, the debt, the national unity question, the whole matter of our justice system and its inability to respond to the needs of Canadians, yet we find in this Parliament, over and over again, a mechanism which does not permit true change to take place. The mechanism is lacking to actually balance the budget. All of these things tie together when we think of the way Parliament works.
It is my delight to stand to urge parliamentarians to exercise their right, as provided under the Canada Elections Act and the Parliament of Canada Act, that no one should be able to control their vote. When it comes time to vote on this bill, I hope they will vote right, not just as they are told. They should think about it individually and represent their constituents. The constituents elected us. They should do what is best for them, not what is best for one party. They should not simply be trying to prolong their time in power. It is not acceptable any longer for governments to be in power, lording it over the people, ignoring their wishes, going on an on and then trying to manipulate the vote by so carefully choosing the time when the election is to be held.
When the time comes to vote I am going to be watching to ensure that members other than Reformers will be voting according to what is right, according to the actual item of debate.
Let us support this bill not because it was introduced by a member of the Reform Party but because it is long overdue. It is a bill which is needed in order to improve our democratic systems.