House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Canadian Human Rights Act May 8th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, a point of order. My apologies but we could not hear the vote. The microphone system was not working.

Canadian Human Rights Act May 7th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, I feel honoured that I was able to make the list to speak on this bill.

We are at a crossroads in our country because of the process on which we have embarked and the results which will undoubtedly follow from this bill.

I am very concerned about the procedure that has been followed. It seems that respect for the law and respect for government are a direct result of members of Parliament representing their constituents, of being careful to listen to what the people of Canada are saying.

There is a growing disrespect for certain governments that, without the consent of the people, have imposed different rules, regulations and laws on Canadian citizens without their consent. The best example of that is the GST which has seized our attention in Parliament and across the country. During the election campaign of 1993 I heard over and over again the complaint that my predecessor did not represent his constituents on that issue.

When we embark upon a change in law, an important bill such as this one, it is important that individual members of Parliament be given time to return to their constituencies to debate the precise wording of the bill and discuss its implications with the people.

That process has been and is being denied to us. It is almost as if we had a question of privilege in terms of how we are hampered in effectiveness in doing our work.

I feel frustrated that the government, through a motivation which I think is straight political expediency, introduced the bill at this time. It was not in the long term plans. It was not mentioned in the throne speech. Suddenly at the end of January it was very important to prorogue Parliament to get a new start. Then there was a new throne speech with a list of all items the government considered to be priorities. The bill was not mentioned in the throne speech. The minister expressed approximately a month ago that it was not his intention or plan to introduce the legislation at this time.

Why was it introduced? I confess to a growing amount of cynicism in the political process. I believe it was introduced as a simple tactic to divert the attention of the press and other media away from the extreme attacks the Liberal government was receiving on accountability, keeping promises made during the election campaign, the GST and other issues. It was brought forward as a strategy to divert criticism.

That is unconscionable. I do not think the lives and well-being of Canadians and their families should somehow be put on the list of items which are disposable for political reasons.

My second complaint is even greater, that is the necessity to invoke closure. It does not make any sense. When we want to rebuild trust in government, in the House of Commons and in Parliament why would we ram through a bill because we suspect if the people ever got to debate it there would be opposition and a great political fallout from it? It is unconscionable.

Closure should be used for matters of dire emergency. It should be used when our country or our security is a stake and we need to bring an item to conclusion because there would be great consequences if it were not done right away.

It is unconscionable of the government to close off debate in the House and in committee. Many Canadians sincerely want to have input. How much time were they given to prepare? I suppose they got a weekend and should not complain. Should they drop everything to make sure they get to Ottawa to appear before the committee to present their briefs? People were asked to respond in a very short period of time.

The vote will be finished before a lot of people even know it is taking place, simply because it takes time to communicate to people. What would be wrong with giving us an opportunity to put the question fairly and squarely to the people we represent?

If the argument in favour of the legislation is strong surely it will have the support of the people. If it does not have the support of the people, let us be honest and admit that we are giving but a token acknowledgement to democracy. We are clearly abandoning the principle that the majority rules in a democracy. We are abandon-

ing the principle that the voters even count. I do not know why we should bother with this process if there is such a limitation.

I should like to make a few comments about the bill. A lot of people who support the legislation have tried over and over again to assure us that this is the end of it and that all we are talking about is discrimination.

I will speak loudly and clearly in favour of principles that do not discriminate against individuals because of personal characteristics. However there are two real flaws in the Canadian Human Rights Act when it starts making lists. One flaw is the difficulty of not including all possible groups and individuals. The second flaw is just as important, that is somehow implying that anyone not on the list is fair game for discrimination.

I reject that hypothesis. One of my main reasons for opposing the bill is that I am not on the list, which means it is correct and acceptable to discriminate against me.

Members must be wondering what I am talking about. I am one of those people who some describe as being robust. Sometimes the word rotund is used and I am discriminated against because of my weight. It goes beyond being squeezed into economy seats in aeroplanes. It goes much beyond that. I was discriminated against in the House because of my weight.

This is what happened. I used to work at the Northern Alberta Institute of Technology. As a staff member I was permitted to participate in its insurance plan. When I came here I thought I could replace it. I was refused participation in the House of Commons life insurance plan because of my weight. They did not take into account the fact that my dad is 85 and just as heavy as I am. They did not take any of these things into account. I am not on the list.

In closing, the list is not complete until every Canadian is on it. That is the situation. Discrimination is not acceptable. All we are doing is adding to the list, which means by implication that everyone who has not yet made the list is fair game. I reject that hypothesis and I urge Liberal members, who have it in their power to do something about it, to vote against the bill because it is so wrong.

Liberal Party May 7th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, the Liberals declared in their red face book that they would give a greater role to members of Parliament, more free votes and a greater amount of influence in committees. They promised to listen more carefully to citizens and to rebuild trust in our parliamentary process. That is turning out to be quite a sham.

In the last week we have seen the government introduce bills which it is intent on driving through all stages without adequate debate by either the public or members of Parliament. It is invoking closure as soon as debate begins. And the Liberals call that democracy?

When the Liberals were in opposition they howled in protest when the Mulroney Conservatives did it. Now they meekly at the pull of their strings stand up and vote in favour of closure at every stage, even in committee.

The people are not being given an opportunity to express their wishes and their representatives are muzzled. Shame. I call on Liberal members to assert their responsibilities to their constituents, to end the charade and do what is right.

Budget Implementation Act, 1996 April 26th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to be able to stand in Canada's Parliament and talk about the one issue which is probably more important to Canadians than almost anything else.

Canadians are concerned about the justice system and its failures. They are concerned about the fact that these days they are not represented in Parliament by their MPs because the rules of the party do not permit that to happen. Undoubtedly what hits people the most across the country is the problem of jobs, of balancing their budgets and paying their bills. With that comes that greatest of all expenses for most Canadians, the largest single expense that they incur, their monthly tax bill. That is the biggest item in family budgets.

We are in this House today debating on behalf of the Canadian people whether or not their money should be spent wisely or foolishly and how it should be allocated. I am somewhat appalled that there is little accountability here.

I do not know exactly how to put this. I need to stay within the rules of debate. I will studiously attempt to do that. It is totally unconscionable for individuals, for citizens of this country, to go around during an election campaign laying out their plans so that the voters can presumably make a decision on who to send to Ottawa to represent them while during that campaign, the words they use cannot be trusted. We have heard so much rhetoric these

past days about what we meant, about we said and about what we wrote. Frankly, those three should coincide.

We should write what we intend to do. We should communicate what we intend to do and we should intend to do what we say and write we intend to do. How can the voters during an election make an informed decision if they cannot trust the words that are being used?

That is really the crux of the matter. There are 295 members of Parliament. I am very honoured to be one of those. We have that awesome responsibility of being, in essence, the board of directors of this giant corporation called Canada.

Some people say that government cannot be run as a business. I am afraid in some areas there is no choice but to run it as a business. That is when it comes to budget.

We can certainly debate what we want to spend our money on. That is a legitimate debate. How much should we spend on welfare? How much should we spend on health care? How much should we spend on education?

I am appalled that the governments of the past 30 years have arranged our affairs so that right now Canadians from coast to coast to coast are being cut down at the knees. There is no longer sufficient money to support education. There is no longer sufficient money to support a proper level of health care. There are cutbacks all over the place.

Every week I get letters and phone calls from people who say that my son cannot get a job, therefore he will not be able to continue his education. I get others who say that mom is in the hospital and if we were not there to care for her, she would have no care at all because all of the nurses have been let go. That is not acceptable.

Our predecessors in this place over the last 30 years have not been honest with Canadian taxpayers. They kept telling them election after election: "We will do this. We will do that. Elect me and you will have this in your community especially if I become a cabinet minister. There will be all sorts of grants and special privileges available. If I am already a cabinet minister, be sure to re-elect me. Those goodies will continue if you do".

Meanwhile the government is spending $1,000 each second more than is taken in. That is unconscionable. To add the greatest insult of all to Canadian taxpayers, at election time, when their candidates say that they are going to do this and this with taxation, that they will eliminate the GST or whatever the issue of the day is, the word, eliminate does not mean eliminate.

Usually in the English language, we have come to a consensus. I am sure it is the same in French. There is a consensus on the usual meaning of words. In the fall 1993 election campaign not once did I hear the Liberal candidate for Elk Island tell the people in our constituency that if elected the Liberals would harmonize the tax. I do not recall hearing that word once, yet the Liberals are now saying that eliminate means harmonize. A new synonym. A change to the dictionary.

The poor taxpayers do not have any input which is not right. It has happened year after year. The taxpayers are given a choice, but once elected the people sent to this place do whatever they want. There is no accountability. I do not want to hang my head in shame because I have done everything I could to resist this. I will have to exclude myself, members of my party and frankly, some members of the other parties in the House.

I have spoken to some government members in private conversations. I will not divulge names but they have said: "Keep hammering the budget. You guys are right on". Liberal members have said that to me, yet they are not permitted to rise in the House of Commons to speak against the budget or to move amendments.

How can taxpayers, through their elected representatives, ever get control of the spending of their hard earned money if we are not going to permit members of the House to speak and to vote according to their own conscience and according to the wishes of their constituents? If that does not happen, I do not hold out much hope for Canadians. It has to happen.

I am very proud to be a member of the Reform Party of Canada which, since its inception, has endorsed this as part of its principles. In fact it is one of the things which drew me to the party. I will stand here and try to communicate as forcefully as I can for as long as I can that what this country needs is a system whereby, like in the Reform Party, members not only have the right to represent their constituents when they debate and when they vote, but they also have the obligation to do so.

I would be out of step with my party if I went against the wishes of my constituents. I do not know whether my party would kick me out of the caucus; we have not discussed that. I really doubt it. Although it might because I would be breaking a very fundamental principle of what Reform stands for and also what is right for the country.

I will say one more thing about the budget and the fact that the government is overspending so greatly. The government proclaims how wonderful it is because it has brought the amount of overspending from $40 billion to $35 billion, from $35 billion to $30 billion, and down it goes. The present number it is projecting is somewhere in the area of $17 billion. Some Canadians, because of the way the words are spun and because some people do not bother to explain the difference between the debt and the deficit, really think that the debt is being eliminated.

I do not wish to embarrass him, but it just so happens that last week I hauled out the campaign literature from my riding and I looked at the Liberal literature to see what that candidate said. Believe it or not, in the brochure which he distributed to the voters of Elk Island, his statement was that a Liberal government would bring down the debt to 3 per cent of gross domestic product. The debt. Of course, the official platform of the Liberal Party was to bring the deficit, the amount of overspending per year, to 3 per cent

of the gross domestic product. I will forgive him. I think it was a legitimate error. He did not know any better. However, I think it is unconscionable.

When there are deficit budgets it means the debt is still growing. I want every member of the House and every Canadian to understand that the debt is not decreasing under this government. The debt is still increasing. Admittedly it is increasing at a slower rate than it did before. If I can give any commendation to the government I will give a reluctant one on that issue. At least it is not putting us into the hole as fast as it could.

When the government continues to add to the debt, right now at $17 billion per year, that is premised on a very important assumption. Those who have lent Canada the money it is borrowing, whether they are foreign investors or domestic investors, all expect their money back. That is based on the assumption that sometime in the future we will have a surplus of over $50 billion a year for 25 years in a row before we can pay off that debt.

Mr. Speaker, you do not know how much I regret that my time is up because I am just starting, but thank you.

Canada Post April 26th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, the Reform Party, courier businesses, advertising businesses and others have long held that the government dominated tax advantaged crown corporation, Canada Post, should be privatized.

Now the government's own bureau of competition policy is recommending that Canada Post should be stripped of its monopoly.

My question is for the Minister of Public Works and Government Services. Will the government begin planning to take this old and long overdue step?

Volunteers April 26th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, I want to salute and thank all of the volunteers across the country, particularly those in my Elk Island constituency.

Special mention must go to Henry Unrau, Jeanne Frame and the other community leaders who are managing the Information and Volunteer Centre for Strathcona County. These special volunteers in my community have spearheaded a new national initiative helping to recognize the important contribution volunteers make.

Volunteer Spirit Day exemplifies the motivation and satisfaction of the millions of people across Canada who give freely of their time and bountifully of their resources to help others. This is truly the spirit that makes Canada the outstanding compassionate society it is.

I am sorry the rules of the House do not permit props because I have a volunteer T-shirt to present to the Prime Minister from this group in Elk Island.

Congratulations and thanks to volunteers everywhere.

Liberal Party Of Canada April 24th, 1996

Mr. Speaker, voters need accurate information to make wise decisions at election time. With one vote they are asked to choose their member of Parliament, select the government for the term, indirectly choose the Prime Minister and give their approval to a complete all or nothing list of agenda items.

During an election campaign it is not acceptable to say that the GST will be axed with pledges to resign if it is not, to write in small print that it will be harmonized, but to keep it and hide it once the election has been won. It is not acceptable to promise more free votes if all this means is that the status quo of free votes on private members' bills will be maintained. It is not acceptable to say that MPs will be given more authority to represent their constituents if it means nothing and that MPs will still be whipped into submission by threats and actions of expulsion.

I cannot understand why the Liberal Party, running on words of rebuilding the trust of Canadians, would so blatantly ignore its campaign commitments now that it has gained power.

The Budget April 16th, 1996

I tell you, there hasn't been very much on that side, Tom.

The Budget April 16th, 1996

Madam Speaker, this reminds me of a number of occasions in my professional career when I was asked to help explain math and finance to lawyers. It would not be the first time in my life that I have done that.

We are talking about three different things here. There is the rate of reduction in expenditures per year. For the Reform Party budget we were talking of a total reduction in costs or in government overspending, in other words a reduction of government expenditures over a three year period. Just as the Liberals projected, so did we project a-and I hesitate to use the word-conservative growth rate in the economy.

Our plan did in fact work over a three year period. It does not work if we compare the three year number with the one year number which we are talking about when we deal with the budget every year here. The member and I will have to get together afterward to look at the actual numbers.

The fact is when we did that budget originally when we did our planning during the campaign, the assumptions then were that the deficit was around $35 billion. It only came in over $40 billion after the accounting was in from the previous government. Obviously in our budget plan last year we took the new figure which I think was around $37 billion. If we take that number away, add the amount of economic growth, in fact in three years we did have a plan for a balanced budget. There is just no other way of saying it. I do not know how to explain it without the use of an overhead projector which I am accustomed to using.

The Budget April 16th, 1996

Madam Speaker, I have a considerable challenge to change the minds of hon. members in the House who have the real power in this place.

I am very annoyed on behalf of my constituents and on behalf of all Canadians that we do not in this boardroom on behalf of the country have the mechanism to defeat a budget which is bad. This is even before I am talking about this particular budget.

Let us say a party brought in a really bad budget. We will not say the Liberals did that this time, that is self-evident. Let us say it was some hypothetical party some time in the future. The thing that is wrong with this place is there is no mechanism which permits the members of Parliament as representatives of their constituents back home to actually defeat that budget.

I believe that is deplorable. It is deplorable that the member for Saskatoon-Dundurn cannot stand up here and vote against this budget if he felt he should without the fear of being disciplined and without the fear of losing that treasured privilege of being able to run a second term in order to get his high priced pension plan.

A lot of people are aware of this MP pension plan. They are also aware that the Liberals have only tinkered with it. They did nothing tangible really. Changing the age to 55 is commendable. For most Canadians there is no pension until they are 65. Furthermore, they do this at a time when they are talking about reducing the number of years ordinary Canadians can pay into their RRSPs. They are talking about it at the same time they are talking about increasing the age when Canadians will become eligible for the Canada pension plan. Yet for themselves they bring it down to age 55.

We have this new member from the Bloc here who is now 22 years old. Theoretically before this little change he could have picked up his pension at age 28 for the rest of his life. The wonderful Liberals said: "You cannot have that. You now have to wait until you are 55", while other Canadians have to wait until they are 65.

Canadians ought to know one important fact. There is a much greater price to pay for that MP pension plan than what is evident. As members probably know, I am a mathematician of sorts, although not a very high powered one. I taught high school math for four years and I taught at a technical institute for 27 years teaching mathematics and computing.

I know a little math of finance. I did some calculations. If I wanted to provide for myself the same pension I would be eligible for if I were in the MP pension plan, and I am proud to say I opted out, the cost to me at my age would be around $4,000 per month.

I am already over 55. I would be eligible right now if I had six years of service here. That is incredible, approximately $4,000 to provide me with a lifetime pension if I live to be the same age as my grandfather did. He had the same shape I do and he lived to be almost 90. Obviously I am taking that into account.

That is incredible. It means the members here who say how terrible of our member from Calgary who said we should increase the salary of the MPs are the same Liberal members who are taking the money. They are taking that money but they want to keep it a secret from the Canadian people. That is-I cannot use bad words. I do not want to get into any unparliamentary language, therefore I will stop there.

There is a lot of resistance on the governing side to actually fix the budget and to reduce government spending. It does not have to be done in social programs only. Certainly there are areas in our social spending that should be done more efficiently. There are many areas of government spending where we waste an incredible amount of money. We use around $5 billion a year to subsidize business. That is obscene when there are hundreds of people struggling to make ends meet and to pay their annual tax bills.

The government is eager to get re-elected. It is doing that by making sure the people of Canada do not have the bare facts on what it is actually doing.

I will give members opposite a little insight into what it means when one allows the debt to grow. I preface this by saying I would like to commend the Liberals. They will take this out of context. They will say the member for Elk Island said he wanted to commend the Liberals. Please listen to the end of the sentence. I want to commend them for borrowing less than probably the Conservatives would have done if we would have left them in. It is really incredible since the people chose Reform and put a lot of influence through Reform, through their own members to cut spending somewhat.

This has been done. Canadians ought to know that in the last three years of the government there has been a reduction of government spending on operations. In 1993 when we came here it cost around $120 billion a year to operate the government. That was reduced the next year to about $119 billion and the next year to about $116 billion.

We have a reduction. With the projected budget in 1996-97 there is a reduction in government spending of around $8.8 billion. If we are spending $8.8 billion less, we would expect that either we are paying down our debt because we are spending less or there should be a tax cut.

Has there been a tax cut? No. We hear a lot about no changes in tax rates. That is not entirely true. We experienced last year the increase in gas prices. There have been other changes as well.

While government operations have decreased by about 7 per cent, interest payments have gone up in that same period by almost 30 per cent. That is something Canadians ought to know. Members on the government side ought to know that.

When they see that, there should be a greater sense of urgency on balancing the budget and getting the deficit not to 3 per cent or 2 per cent of gross domestic product, not continuously adding to the debt, but getting the deficit to zero, getting the Government of Canada to spend no more in total than it is taking in. The reason is that interest is eating this up because in the same time interval total government revenues have increased by approximately 17 per cent. That means the government has taken that money out of the economy and spent 7 per cent less, but interest has increased by approximately 30 per cent.

Those are the facts. I have taken them right out of the budget book which the minister presented in the House. I have done a bit of work with my calculator on those numbers.

That should cause these members to ask whether they are really representing their constituents, their children, their grandchildren and future generations by loading on to them an additional debt.

As I approach the end of my time I would like to talk a bit about amortization. Again I have made a few computations based on paying off a mortgage.

Canada has a huge mortgage. In 1993 when the Liberals took over the mortgage was around $508 billion. If at that time we had had a balanced budget what kind of a surplus would we have needed to pay off the debt in 25 years? We would have needed an annual surplus of some $48 billion if we ever hoped to pay off the debt.

Some people say it does not matter if we pay it off. I am sorry, but every individual who has bought Canada savings bonds, government T-bills or any of the other items wants to get their money back. That debt has to be paid, whether it is to foreign lenders or to Canadians. We have to pay it back. Every year we delay the price goes up.

After we reach $603 billion, which will happen after this budget year, the annual budget surplus required to pay off the debt in 25 years will have grown to $56.5 billion annually, an increase of some $8.8 billion per year for 25 years. All we have done is waited for three years.

I am with these members. I look at the people of Canada who have needs. We are a country rich in resources. We are friendly and compassionate. No one in Canada will starve to death, not if I can help it. However, I am not sure the way to arrange our affairs is to sink our children into an enormous debt. Anyone who knows anything about the magic of compound interest will realize we are getting into an increasingly difficult debt hole.

I am not content to be in a Parliament which, in this term of office, has increased the debt of Canadians by approximately $8 billion annually. That is not acceptable; $100 billion dollars more debt.