House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was money.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Conservative MP for Edmonton—Sherwood Park (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Employment Insurance Act December 11th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I am delighted to enter into the debate on the bill today and on the motion before us.

I will begin by talking briefly about the problems we will have if we send the bill to committee prior to second reading. It is a problem for me because I was a member of the committee when Bill C-43, the Lobbyists Registration Act, was first tried in Parliament. At first I eagerly accepted it. I said it would be a really good thing because then we as ordinary members, backbenchers, would have input into the bill at the very beginning. Hopefully we would be able to craft the bill so it would include from the beginning the necessary changes that would produce widespread approval among all the parties.

However, I was greatly disappointed. During the time of the committee everything went really well. We had a good chairperson and it was a time when we built good collegiality among ourselves. There were many times when we discussed these things. We came to a consensus but I was very disappointed when finally we came to the end of the process. Even though we thought we had agreement on a number of issues we raised on behalf of Canadians we represent, the members of the committee on the day of the voting of the clause by clause came in with their little check sheets and voted according to a pre-plan, which greatly disappointed me.

I was really distressed. A number of the things they voted against were things that I thought we had reached consensus on. In the end, it simply did not materialize that the individual members were able to express their convictions.

I would like to be on record as being opposed to this process. I know it was supposed to be new and innovative but my experience is that not only does it not work at that level, but it cuts off the next level of amendment possibilities and further debate which is very important in the House; to go through the regular procedure of having first reading, second reading, committee and then third reading.

I am against that part and urge all fellow members to preserve the functioning of Parliament by rejecting this motion to send it to committee at this time. It ought to go through second reading in a normal sense first.

I would like to now speak about the whole question of unemployment. Unemployment is a very severe problem. In the downturn of an economy many businesses respond of necessity by laying off some employees. Those employees now have lost their jobs and because generally the downturn in the economy produces fewer opportunities in other businesses, as more and more people get laid off the probability and the availability of getting other jobs is reduced.

Obviously something has to be done. The present plan and the plan by the Minister of Human Resources Development are not long term solutions to this problem.

The types of policies the government is embarking on further erode the employability of Canadians. The real task before us is to provide a climate in which there are jobs available, in which there are employment opportunities and in which it is possible for people of all skills levels to find their niche and to contribute to society economically and in other ways. Tinkering with the bill will not do anything to achieve that fuller goal.

With respect to meeting the needs of those temporarily unemployed, Canadians should begin to recognize they are getting a very short shrift from government, from the unemployment insurance commission and from the whole system which is designed to tide them over through a difficult period. Many people would much rather have a job than rely on the limited benefits of unemployment insurance.

I will go even further. I reiterate what I have said many times at public meetings and in private. A number of employers have spoken to me since the time I became involved in the political process. They find it very difficult to obtain and keep workers because they are competing with unemployment insurance. They are competing with a situation in which an individual says: "I get this much if I do not work. Why should I work for you?"

I was at one time the recipient of this policy. I owned a small business with a partner. We hired someone who worked for us for a short time and then abruptly quit. When I asked him about it he listed the salary and benefits he received from us and said: "It costs me only about $200 less per month to not do anything, so I am out of here". Unfortunately the business we were in required us to have accessibility to our employees at very odd hours. It was not a very pleasant working situation. We did not have the financial flexibility to pay huge bucks to persuade people to stay. We went through a continuing line of people who worked for us basically long enough to qualify for unemployment insurance and then they were gone.

One thing which really annoyed me was that those employees, all of whom were male, as it was heavy industrial work, when they filed their income tax returns, in every case they were able to receive a refund on their overpayment to UI. They were unemployed and under the limit, so they overpaid. However, we as employers struggling to keep the business going ended up paying the maximum to the UIC and to the Canada pension plan and we were ineligible for rebates comparable to the overpayments the employees were making. That was a great unfairness.

Unemployment insurance is exactly what its name implies. It ensures we will have unemployment. The name is now being changed. It is a cosmetic change. All the principles remain essentially the same. There are a few cosmetic changes being proposed, none of which will produce any profound changes in how the system operates and the disincentives built in to take part time work.

A number of years ago I worked at the Northern Alberta Institute of Technology and once again our UI premiums increased. It was at the time when they crossed the $100 per month threshold. I talked to my fellow instructors. We did some calculating. There were approximately 750 instructors at the institute. We were paying $100 per month each, which means a monthly contribution of $75,000. Our employer, paying 40 per cent more, contributed an additional $105,000 per month, making a total of $180,000 per month, sent to Ottawa for the UIC from our little group of instructors. That makes a total of $2.16 million per year.

Instead of being involved in that coercive system, we would have been able to keep the money and invest it or use it. We would have been able to provide the equivalent of 54 jobs based on a salary of $40,000 per year. Meanwhile, our fellow instructors were being laid off because of pressure of taxation and other things. We were forced to pay people to leave work when we would much rather have shared the workload with them. Fifty-four of those people were being subsidized.

Recognition Of Quebec As A Distinct Society December 6th, 1995

How about inequality?

Recognition Of Quebec As A Distinct Society December 6th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I am both angry and grieved this evening. I am angry because something which I value so highly, the wonderful country in which we live, is being treated with such indifference by the government. I am grieved because the principles of equality are being violated in the proposed legislation.

I joined the Reform Party and became a member of Parliament because of my commitment to the equality of Canadians. I cannot understand how a government can look back without seeing that the policies of the last 30 years have driven a deep wedge into this country. How can those members then conclude that wriggling around that wedge some more is now going to produce unity? That does not make sense to me.

I am very gravely angered by that. I am grieved by the fact that we are here in a Parliament where we cannot properly and openly discuss this. Whenever we bring forward ideas we get into name calling instead of honestly and openly debating the issues and the principles that are involved.

We have a parliamentary system here that does not respond. There is no mechanism in this Parliament to change what is now being proposed and what is clearly wrong. The reason is that all the members on the government side do not have the freedom to speak and to vote what they truly believe.

I cannot believe that among the 176 members on the other side, not one of them has any serious questions about this legislation. There are four members in the government from Alberta. Every one of us in the Reform Party who is from Alberta has heard from numerous constituents that there are large problems with further bifurcating this country with this kind of legislation. Surely those other four Liberal members in Alberta have heard those same messages. If they have chosen not to listen and not to represent them here because of that nasty party discipline that is exercised in the House, which makes this place ineffective, that makes me very angry. We have here a system of governance that cannot respond to a major crisis in this country because of its archaic systems.

I plead with those members opposite to use their own intelligence, their own analysis, their own convictions, their own beliefs, and stand in the face of this government. Because of their majority, they alone can do it. They are the only ones who can save this country.

If we keep on following the plan that is proposed, it is inevitable that the divisions among us will increase. In this very weak attempt to try to appease one province that has legitimate beefs and instead of listening to the legitimate beefs to offer this little appeasement carrot, they are putting at risk the unity of the whole country. They are doing that with impunity and as if they do not care.

It is a total shame. It distresses me. I really eagerly wish the Liberal members in the House would exercise principle and forget about this policy they have had of voting the way they are told. That will destroy this country.

Department Of Public Works And Government Services Act November 27th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I realized there were some hazards when I got into the political business, but I did not realize I would be interrupted for 349 days, almost a year, on an

important statement that I was making. Because I have so little time left I want to get right to the statement.

Bill C-52 would put into action a decision made by the previous government to establish the department and we are dealing with some amendments to the bill. I go on record as reviewing what I said almost a year ago and emphasizing as strongly as I can that I think we would make a gross error in approving some of the items in the bill unless we accept the amendment proposed by the Bloc to delete clause 16.

We run the risk of actually losing the very foundation of the economic system of the country, namely free enterprise or the private initiative to go out and get it. The government has taken it upon itself to tax everyone to death and use that money to subsidize activities that should properly take place in the private sector and, most important, to compete unfairly with it.

It is unjustifiable to force businesses to pay taxes and then use that money to provide the services the companies are in the business of providing. It is a contradiction that will destroy the economic basis of the country if we proceed. I emphasize as strongly as possible that we should not do what the bill proposes, which is to give the Minister of Public Works and Government Services carte blanche to do anything for anyone as the bill proposes, just anything that he decides, using government departments to provide engineering services, printing services, advertising services, all the services which many businesses depend on in order to provide for their employees for their very survival.

Instead, we have this move by the government to give the minister unbridled ability to do whatever he or she wants in terms of competing with private enterprise. That is a wrong principle.

Let us ask for some careful thought on the part of the government. Let us not wait until the other place has to be the Chamber of sober second thought. Let us do some sober thinking in this Chamber and defeat this bill unless we can get the amendments for which we asked.

Canada Labour Code November 10th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, it is a delight to enter into the debate on Bill C-317, a bill that would cause certain amendments to be made to the Canada Labour Code.

I will preface my statements by saying that the hon. member who has proposed this bill and its amendments to the code has a very good motivation in standing up to try to defend the workers. This country is very dependent upon its labour force in order to continue to enjoy our high standard of living. The bill is certainly in the best interests not only of the workers but also of the companies involved, the organizations, the rest of Canadians and customers both in Canada and around the world. They benefit from Canadian products if the workforce is very well organized and works efficiently and smoothly.

What is being addressed here is the problem of a dispute. What happens when the firm that employs the labourers and the labourers cannot reach an agreement? Sometimes these disputes are over wages. Members will agree that there have been occasions where employers have been unfair to workers with respect to wages. Even more important, there have been a number of occasions where the workers' safety is at risk and the employer is unwilling to spend the money or to take the necessary measures to protect the safety of the workers.

Bill C-317 proposes that if any of these disputes regardless of their origin result in a strike, then as that strike is a hard won right of the workers, it should not be reduced or eliminated by the hiring of replacement workers. To me, that is indeed one of the solutions. If we are going to provide that workers cannot be replaced, that indeed considerably strengthens the bargaining position of the workers in areas of dispute.

However, we need to ask whether this is the best way of solving the problem. I propose that it is not. While we are saying the worker is having his hamburger taken away from him, what this bill proposes is to simply give him ketchup on the hamburger. What I would like to propose is that we offer that worker a good Alberta steak instead.

What am I talking about? I am talking about ways of dispute resolution. Having worked in this area for a number of years as a representative of people who were employees in a professional association, which to a degree is a euphemism for a union, because we did collective bargaining, I believe very strongly that the very worst way of dispute resolution is that of the strike, because no one wins in a strike. When there is a strike and business is shut down, or in my case the educational institution is shut down, the students, the employees, the instructors, and all of the other employees in the work suffer because of a loss of wages during the time of the strike.

In the case of industry across this country, not only our own domestic customers suffer but our customers around the world suffer when our businesses are put on strike or when our transportation systems fail because of strike or our communications systems are brought down to their knees because the employees refuse to work and no one else is ready and permitted to work in this area.

What then is the solution? If it is not a strike, what can be done? There are many, many other areas of disputes in which we do not resort to strike. For example, if there is a dispute between one of us and our neighbour as to where the boundary should be, we do not proceed to put something in front of their driveway so they cannot get out of the house in the morning. That would not be an acceptable way of solving that problem. Instead, we go to the authorities. We may get surveyors in to make sure the boundaries

are clearly marked. When that is done and if your neighbour still does not agree to it, then we may go to a court of law.

I propose, and I have experience in this and it works very well, that what we need to do in the case of a dispute between employees and employers is to have an orderly mechanism that works to solve this problem, so that the workers, the employers, all of the customers, all of the citizens, and indeed our reputation around the world for timely delivery of goods and services can be maintained. It would help us in the long run because of the reliability that would be automatically assumed when people around the world place customer orders with Canadian firms.

I am proposing that we should be using a dispute mechanism that involves some sort of a hearing, a court, an arbitrator, something that is final and binding.

I would like to tell you that I have had first-hand experience with this. I had the honour of being chosen by my fellow instructors, way back in 1982, to be the founding president of our staff association. I had considerable input. It was not a one-man show by any means, but I had considerable input into the formulation of our first collective agreement, which then became the pattern for all subsequent agreements at the Northern Alberta Institute of Technology, where I worked. Indeed, many of the items in that contract persist to this day. And one of the things I pressed for very strongly was that we would immediately bargain away our right to strike.

We built into our contract and the constitution of our association a mechanism that provided for a dispute resolution with time lines. So many days prior to the expiration of the contract we had to give notice of our desire to enter into negotiations, and if we did not the employer might. If neither of us did, that was a tacit understanding that we would carry on with the current agreement. After so many days of that happening we had to have negotiators in place. After so many days we had to lay our opening positions on the table. After so many days if an agreement had not been reached we had to name an arbitrator. And so it went. It was all set up in such a way that prior to the expiry of a contract the new contract would be in place by one means or another.

A very important problem developed. With that contract we had an excellent mechanism and did not have any strikes or work stoppages. Unfortunately the Government of Alberta played its hand. I need to say this because there are dangers in this type of a system. When we went to the arbitration system the government passed a law that stated that in the case of an arbitration the arbitrator must take into account the policy of the government. Unfortunately the government was our employer. We were in the situation of being in the boxing ring and our opponent happened to also be the referee, which made it very difficult to get fair settlements from then on.

If the mechanism is truly independent of any pressure from either party so that there can be a really justified way of reducing the problem and dispute to a resolution, that is by far the best way.

In conclusion, if we are not going to go for things like final position bargaining or arbitration as the method of solving labour disputes, we will continue with these very wasteful and hurtful strikes. Instead of supporting this bill, which would only strengthen the dispute mechanism of striking and fighting with each other, I would like to propose the opposite: that we move toward a more rational system of dispute resolution, which would benefit us all.

Auditor General For The Family Act November 8th, 1995

Madam Speaker, I take the few remaining moments in this private member's debate to say that I am very proud to be part of a political party, an organization which stands unashamedly for the family.

As the hon. member opposite just said, family is very important. There is no doubt in anyone's mind in the event a father is taken away by death or even by divorce that there are many additional hardships on the mother who is left to raise the family as a single parent. I cannot help but say that we are not in any way desirous of adding any more hardships to the person who already has so many.

I presume I will have more time when this debate resumes.

Protection Of Personal Information Obtained By Certain Corporations Act October 26th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, it is a great honour to stand in defence of the private members' bill offered by my colleague.

All of us have characteristics and facts about us which are of interest to many people. I cannot begin talking about all the information private firms would like to have about us without also thinking of that vast array of information the government has about us. We know of some of the abuses of that information, its lack of accuracy and its inaccessibility to the individual in order to check its accuracy.

There was a very interesting case about which I will not divulge all the details. As a member of Parliament, I was approached by an individual who was caught in a cross web of government databases. Before he knew what was going on, he was having some very serious problems with the government. The government thought there was money owing on a student loan account but there was not. It took a lot of work to get that straightened out. The information was wrong. He had a lot of trouble finding out what information the government had on him. Information was missing. The government said that because it did not have that information, what he was alleging was not true. It went on and on.

The same thing is true with data which is gathered by private firms in order to know more about us. To a degree, I agree with this. There is a value for organizations like financial institutions to maintain databases. It protects us. That is if the databases are properly managed and there is accountability built into the system.

For example, I do not think credit ratings are all wrong. I like the ability of applying for a loan and receiving speedy service. That is only possible because businesses can very quickly check whether I paid my last loan. If they could not do that quickly and reliably then of course it would take them longer to check it out.

Also, as a consumer I could end up paying for more people who take loans and then disappear without paying for them. With the modern database systems it is possible to find out a person's history and consequently deny that person a loan because of his unreliability in repaying. As a person who pays interest to financial institutions I could then be spared the cost of picking up the tab for both the principal and the interest which was lost.

There is some merit to this but certainly as in many other areas, whether it is government or corporations, there needs to be accountability. We ought to look very seriously at the proposed bill in terms of the accountability and accessibility it would provide to a person who wants to find out what is known about him.

The government likes to have all kinds of data on us, income tax information, where we earned our money, how much, how much we gave to charity and all the details of our personal financial lives. This data needs to be accurate. Like government, organizations like to keep census. They like to know everything about us, our religion, how many children we have. They want to know whether we own or rent our residence. They want to know whether other people live with us. On and on it goes. There definitely needs to be a limitation on business and government on how much data can be gathered.

In order to make this efficient there should be a procedure where individuals give consent at the time of giving the information or where they may refuse it. Although the private member's bill says the firm which proposes to sell a list needs to check with the individual on the list to gain permission, it would be much better if each database were flagged. If I indicate at the time I give information that my name is not to be passed on to another buyer of the list, it could simply be another field in the database. Then that information would not be given and it would not incur the cost the hon. member opposite was complaining about.

Certainly to mail consent forms to thousands of people on a list would be very costly. This could be done in advance and would protect individuals from having their data circulated all over.

I was able to find a few examples of people who use databases incorrectly. Many of us are now involved with the Internet. I remember when I first signed on with the firm I am using, at the top I was asked: "Do you give permission for your name and your Internet address to be in the database that is searched by other members?" I gave permission because I want people to be able to find me. If they look for my name in the city where I live, my name and my Internet address will come up.

There have been some serious examples of breaches of this principle. An example to which I take great offence is from New Zealand. A chocolate factory there obtained a client's list from a weight reduction clinic and used that client list to produce some personalized advertising for their chocolates. That is an unfair intrusion into a part of the population that might have a weakness in that regard. That type of thing also needs to be prohibited. Of course there have been many cases of people who have used databases for illegal purposes.

It is most important that consent be given either in advance or at some future time before the data is passed on to another firm or another business.

I had a very interesting example of my name coming up. I received a brochure that was mailed to me personally. It had my name and my correct address. When I opened it I was amazed to find out it was totally in French. Unfortunately I do not speak French, I wish I did. I could not understand it but I could figure out that it had to do with a contest. There was a picture of a new car. I thought: "This has to be my lucky day. They have written me a personal letter to tell me that I have won this car".

I wrote a letter back and apologized for not knowing the language. I also told them that clearly from what information I could gather I had won this new vehicle and I would be very willing at their convenience to show up at the specified place to collect it. I thanked them greatly for that.

That is a very dramatic way to emphasize it but I knew that I had to do something that was really spectacular in order to get their attention because of other situations where I have received information and could not get off the mailing list. I tried and I could not. I wrote a letter and the mail kept coming. It seems these data lists go from one owner to another and even though the last purchaser may purge the list of my name, the next week the parent corporation sends an update of the list and my name appears again. It is virtually impossible to find out from where the name originates because these lists are passed from one firm to another to another.

I commend my colleague for this bill. It certainly points out a need. I am not sure that in all details it totally answers the question.

I would like to see that little amendment to give a disclaimer or a refusal to pass on the information at the time of giving information. In general the principle of the bill is sound and I am glad to support it.

Quebec Referendum October 26th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, two years ago yesterday over two million Canadians voted overwhelmingly for change by electing 52 Reformers. We have a vision for a new, revitalized country based on more effective democratic accountability, fiscal sanity, a justice system that works, and a decentralized federation that responds more effectively to regional and personal needs.

Today many Quebecers are considering giving up on Canada. I urge them not to. I urge them to vote no on Monday, to stay together as a country and join with Reformers in all provinces to build a new confederation and a new Canada.

We believe in a strong country, a strong federation of equal people and equal provinces and less interference in our lives by a heavy-handed, intrusive federal government. We believe that power should be closer to the people. We believe profoundly that we need to build on our strengths, the highest of which is a deep commitment to understand and care for each other. Things do not need to stay the same.

Points Of Order October 18th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order to assist in the maintenance of proper decorum in the House. I refer to a review on September 18 in which the Acting Speaker referring back to a ruling in June said: "We would hope and call upon members of both sides of the House to be mindful of the ruling of the Speaker in June regarding exhibits, lapel pins, et cetera".

Mr. Speaker, I draw this to your attention and ask you to remind members to refrain from wearing pins today. Perhaps we could all agree to do this. The members for Winnipeg South, Kent, Algoma, Verchères, St. John's West, and Kingston and the Islands are wearing exhibits.

Health Care October 18th, 1995

Mr. Speaker, I would like to come back once again to the question of waiting lists.

It was a cold Friday in January 1980 when my wife was diagnosed with breast cancer. I am very grateful that her life was spared because of the speedy surgery which a very competent surgeon recommended and performed three days after the diagnosis.

My wife now counsels and consoles women in the same situation. They are waiting in line while the government is funding boxes in domes with its infrastructure program. What is the government going to do about that? What should my wife tell these women who are waiting in line while their lives are being threatened?