House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was debate.

Last in Parliament October 2010, as Conservative MP for Prince George—Peace River (B.C.)

Won his last election, in 2008, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Supply June 6th, 2002

Mr. Speaker, it is a pleasure to join in the debate on the opposition motion, the last opposition motion before we break for the summer recess.

If the government decides to demand the $3.3 billion in capital gains refund overpayments from the four provinces including the $121 million from British Columbia it will be a massive blow to those provinces, particularly British Columbia. I will focus my remarks on the devastating economic and moral impact repaying the overpayments would have on the province of B.C.

Clawing back $121 million could not come at a worse time for British Columbia. The provincial finance minister announced earlier this year that for the first time in recent history B.C. has become a have not province. Finance minister Collins also announced that British Columbia's budget deficit for the coming year would be a record $4.4 billion.

If that is not bad enough, the Conference Board of Canada predicts real GDP growth in B.C. this year will be a paltry 1.8%, the weakest performance of all provincial economies. The board also said the softwood lumber dispute with the United States is keeping the outlook for forestry gloomy and that rising interest rates would suppress housing starts next year. Furthermore, the value of B.C. exports declined 24% in the first quarter of this year mainly because of the major reduction in demand for energy products.

To battle the bleak economic forecast the B.C. government has had to make tough cuts and spending halts. The government will cut all ministries except health care and education by 25% over the next three years. The provincial government is currently restructuring education and health care. Given this depressing economic climate the federal government's demand for $121 million for its own mistake will have a negative effect on the lives of all British Columbians.

Time and time again the federal government has demonstrated a callous neglect for B.C. It is turning its back on British Columbia on almost all major industrial fronts. Farming is under threat due to the recent U.S. farm bill and the dramatic increase in subsidies to U.S. farmers. What is the federal government's response? It has done nothing.

Offshore drilling for oil and gas is another issue. B.C. is dependent on the co-operation of Ottawa to start exploring for oil and gas. This is an opportunity, given the success in Newfoundland, for the federal government and the B.C. government to work co-operatively and be proactive on this front for the betterment not only of British Columbians but all Canadians.

I have raised the issue of the mountain pine beetle time and again in the House. The mountain pine beetle is eating up massive amounts of forest in the B.C. interior. Yet the request for $60 million of federal assistance over five years to help solve the problem has been ignored. Where is the federal government's help? It is nonexistent.

There is also the potential impact of softwood lumber tariffs on B.C.'s economy. The forestry sector directly accounts for about 9% of the province's total economic output. Approximately 20,000 forest sector jobs province wide, or one in five, are expected to be lost as a result of restructuring in the industry between 2001 and 2003. Up to 50,000 jobs could be adversely affected by the tariffs. What has been the government's response? It has directed less than $100 million toward the softwood lumber crisis. If the situation was not so serious it would be laughable.

How can the government justify giving $158 million to three marketing companies in Quebec for advertising and sponsorships, companies which could not possibly employ more than a few hundred people, while giving only $100 million to a situation affecting 50,000 potential jobs in B.C.?

Now more than ever the province of British Columbia needs co-operation and a little understanding from the federal government. It does not need an economic blow that would require it to take $121 million out of its budget to repay a mistake made by the federal government.

This brings me to another point: The new finance minister justified his decision to ask for the overpayment to be repaid by saying it is common practice and that the government is maintaining its fiscal policy of reducing the national debt. Why does the minister find it acceptable to hide behind the Liberal policy of reducing the debt while overseeing a ministry that has been diverting funds to foundations to avoid paying the surplus toward the debt? I am speaking of the roughly $7 billion that has been hidden away in foundations which are largely unaccountable and which, by the auditor general's own accounting, she cannot get at to see where the money is going or where it is to be spent.

These types of justifications and hypocritical actions, like the government's dishing out of hundreds of millions of dollars to Liberal friends and contractors while in the same breath it demands an economically strapped province to pay for a mistake it did not make, only add to the growing perception that the federal government does not care about British Columbia. The government's arrogant and dictatorial style of governing is fueling the increasing sense of cynicism and hopelessness Canadians from coast to coast have toward our federal political system.

This brings me to the morally negative impact the federal government's actions are having on the province of British Columbia, an impact it will further by demanding repayment of the $120 million.

By and large the people of British Columbia read the same news stories as people in Ottawa. Do members think British Columbians are uplifted when they read that B.C. must pay Ottawa $120 million and then turn the page and read that the Prime Minister paid $101 million for two new Challenger jets he did not need? Are they uplifted when they read that over $158 million was awarded to three Quebec marketing agencies that coincidentally happened to have donated $246,000 to the federal Liberal Party since 1997? Are they uplifted when they read that the former defence minister paid his ex-girlfriend $36,000 to produce a 14 page report on post traumatic stress disorder when his own department was also studying the issue? Are they uplifted when they read that $1.6 million was given to Groupaction Marketing for three contracts? As if that were not enough, the public then finds out two of the reports were identical. One cost $575,000. The other, which the government never received, cost $550,000.

Why would the government demand the money back just to give out billions of dollars in federal programs that have been proven to be deeply flawed like the HRDC billion dollar boondoggle, Shawinigate or the sponsorship program? Does the government think its demand for $121 million from B.C. will restore hope and trust in the political system among British Columbians?

The new finance minister should follow in the footsteps of his predecessor who advocated forgiving past revenue overpayments to the provinces. Political gains and leadership infighting should not be allowed to adversely affect millions of people's lives, jobs, hopes, education and health care.

Given the callous disregard the government displays on a daily basis for the tax dollars with which it is entrusted, is it any wonder Canadians have given up on democracy? They do not bother to vote anymore. Before he became Prime Minister the current Prime Minister promised Canadians in the red book of 1992-93 that he would restore trust and integrity to government. Yet time and again he has done everything possible to destroy that trust. Is it any wonder Canadians throw their hands up in despair and say the system is so wrong they might as well vote Liberal and have it all?

It is frightening to see this happening in a supposed democracy. Why would the federal government want to rub salt in the wounds of British Columbia as it struggles with the damaging softwood lumber tariffs? British Columbians would not mind repaying the money if they felt Ottawa would manage it wisely and contribute tax dollars fairly to all the provinces. However with the federal government's track record why would B.C. want to give the government its hard earned money and be forced to cut social programs so the money could be burned up in smoke by some Liberal government spending boondoggle?

In conclusion I will quote from Mark Twain's autobiography because it is pertinent to my point about Canadians giving up on the system and the actions of the federal government affecting the morality of Canadian society. Mark Twain said:

To lodge all power in one party and keep it there is to insure bad government and the sure and gradual deterioration of the public morals.

Divorce Act May 31st, 2002

moved for leave to introduce Bill C-469, an act to amend the Divorce Act (shared parenting).

Madam Speaker, I would like to thank my hon. colleague from Fraser Valley for seconding this important bill.

The purpose of the bill is to amend the Divorce Act so that in the event of separation or divorce the court will grant child custody to both parents, except in cases of proof of abuse, neglect, mistreatment or if it is not in the best interests of the child.

All too often children are used as pawns during emotional divorce proceedings. The bill would stop that by putting both parents on an equal footing. Automatic joint custody would increase the probability of support payment compliance, reduce court appearances by one parent trying to gain access to their child and reduce the likelihood of one parent denying the right of the other to see their children.

Four years ago a special joint committee on child custody and access recommended that shared parenting be included in new legislation. It is yet to be introduced. Children are still waiting for this government to act.

(Motions deemed adopted, bill read the first time and printed)

Public Safety Act, 2002 May 29th, 2002

Madam Speaker, I must say at the outset that I did not intend to get up and participate in the debate today but I guess one of the great advantages of all members from all parties is that when we sit here--

Canada-U.S. Relations May 28th, 2002

Check the record, Mr. Speaker. This is not the first time I have asked the Prime Minister to begin building a better relationship with the president of the United States. Instead, he has been globe-trotting, focusing on his African initiative rather than concentrating on our deteriorating trade relations with our southern neighbour and biggest trading partner.

The ongoing trade war, which now includes softwood lumber, farm subsidies and northern natural gas, is more than news clippings in my riding. It is our livelihood. My riding of Prince George--Peace River in the northern half of British Columbia is primarily dependent upon natural gas, farming and forestry. I agree with the government's action to take these disputes to the WTO but it may be too late when a decision arrives. Immediate action is required.

For the sake of my constituents and for all the other Canadians who rely on the billion dollar a day trade with the United States, will the Prime Minister go to Washington and not leave until President Bush commits to finding a solution to these trade issues?

Supply May 28th, 2002

Mr. Speaker, I listened, as did all my colleagues in the House, with rapt attention to the comments of my hon. colleague. I will follow up on the issue of the effort or lack thereof that the government has put into the trade dispute with our biggest trading partner and neighbour. Since last fall I have been urging the Prime Minister to engage personally in the file whether on the issue of farm subsidies, the steel problem, subsidies for the transportation of natural gas from Alaska, or softwood lumber.

Could my hon. colleague comment on what appears to be a complete lack of attention on the part of the Prime Minister in engaging President Bush on the file?

Public Safety Act, 2002 May 3rd, 2002

That is not nonsense it is the truth. If the hon. member had been here this morning he would have seen that happen. I seem to have touched a raw nerve. We can hardly hear ourselves think in this place all of sudden. Even though they are few in numbers they seem to be making a lot of noise.

The hon. member for Chicoutimi--Le Fjord who just spoke said opposition members should not exaggerate when they are talking about this legislation. He said they should not exaggerate the extent of the bill. He went on to say quite correctly that it amends 20 other pieces of legislation. Therefore it is an all-encompassing omnibus bill. We all agree on that.

This is a huge bill. It amends many statutes. The amendment to Bill C-55 put forward by my hon. colleague from Port Moody--Coquitlam--Port Coquitlam that we are debating states that the House should decline to give second reading to Bill C-55 since the bill reflects several principles unrelated to transport and government operations rendering it impractical for the Standing Committee on Transportation and Government Operations to properly consider it. I believe that is a well thought out amendment.

By their own admission government members who have addressed the bill, including several ministers, have pointed out how all-encompassing the bill is and yet they somehow expect the standing committee on transport to deal with this. That is totally unreasonable.

Are opposition members exaggerating when they voice concerns about the bill? Here are some concerns that were expressed yesterday in Hansard . We will see if they are an exaggeration. The first statement is:

First, while the bill seeks to circumscribe the power initially conferred upon the Minister of National Defence in the predecessor Bill C-42 to designate any part of Canada a military security zone, the scope of both the exercise and application of this power remain problematic.

I wonder if the hon. member from Chicoutimi would say that is an exaggeration. This particular member went on to say:

However, the definition of a “controlled access military zone” has a certain indeterminate feature to it, which could, however inadvertently, be stretched to result in the very thing that this revised version was designed to prevent, for example, the application of this power to something like the G-8 meeting in Kananaskis, simply because the presence of Canadian military equipment or personnel or foreign diplomatic personnel with their related equipment may result in a military zone being nonetheless designated.

Further on the member voiced another concern:

Second, and more important, even if the scope of this exercise of ministerial power is appropriately delineated and clarified, the absence of any cabinet or parliamentary accountability is disturbing. In effect, there is no requirement for cabinet authorization of this ministerial decree.

I wonder if the member, who is still sitting in the Chamber, would say that is an exaggeration to be concerned about that. At the end of this particular member's speech he went on to say:

However, there are also disconcerting features, as I have also described, that taint the bill and which need to be addressed and redressed so we can promote human security without unnecessarily intruding on civil liberties.

I agree with this particular member. It was a Liberal member, the hon. member for Mount Royal, who gave a great speech in this place about the bill. He voiced some thoughtful concerns about it.

However, I did not hear any of the Liberals. They are applauding now but if one of the opposition members were to raise those same concerns they would say we were exaggerating and not presenting them truthfully. However when it is a Liberal member who voices the same concerns everyone over there applauds. They nod their heads and say that is great.

It is a little ridiculous that we can never have a debate in this place without the government trying to play these partisan tricks on the public. However I think the public sees through this for what it is.

This piece of legislation has been ill thought through. The powers that are being bestowed upon the ministers are completely unnecessary. By their own admission, when we were confronted by the emergency of September 11, the Minister of Transport, the Prime Minister and other ministers had the authority and the power to act appropriately. They do not need this legislation.

Public Safety Act, 2002 May 3rd, 2002

Madam Speaker, obviously that does not sit well with the government. There is a responsibility of all members to be in the Chamber to listen and participate in debate. We all agree to that. However the responsibility primarily is on the government.

I have news for the government over there. It is the responsibility of the government to be here when it brings its legislation forward. It is not the legislation of the Canadian Alliance. I have an urgent breaking press release for those characters over there. It is government legislation that it is telling us is important and it cannot get 20 people to show up on a Friday to debate it.

Public Safety Act, 2002 May 3rd, 2002

Madam Speaker, thank you for trying to restore a shred of decorum to the Chamber on this Friday afternoon.

I found it quite astounding to listen to the dissertation by the hon. member for Chicoutimi--Le Fjord. I noticed he did not refer very much to the bill. It seemed to be an attack against the Bloc Quebecois.

I have always felt that it is unfortunate when debate reaches the stage where we have just 10 minutes of debate with no questions and comments. It does not allow for the back and forth parry and thrust of a good debate. However that is where we are at and so we will continue along. Hopefully if the members still want to discuss it between the two of them they could do it outside.

I have noticed one thing about government members when they address Bill C-55. They seem to indicate that this is something the government and country needs because of the events of September 11. All of us agree those were tragic and unprecedented events in the annals of history, certainly modern aeronautical history. Somehow that means we need to bring forward legislation like Bill C-55.

We have heard them say that we need to fast track the legislation and get it in place just in case. God forbid something like that would threaten us in the future. Hopefully the government would have the power and authority to act quickly to prevent something like that.

I want to refer to the Standing Orders of the House of Commons. Standing Order 29 states that should a quorum appear not to exist at the time the House meets, a count of the House will be taken, that if fewer than 20 members are present the Speaker will adjourn the House until the next sitting day and that the Speaker may take such an initiative only before the House has been called to order.

The interesting thing about this is the government's claims that there is a need to get the legislation before the House, get it debated, get it to committee, and get it into law. The government has 170 or so members. This morning the House waited for 23 minutes before the government could muster 20 bodies into this place to get quorum in order to debate the legislation.

Public Safety Act, 2002 May 3rd, 2002

Madam Speaker, if hon. members from the government and from the Bloc Quebecois could step outside they might settle this dispute they seem to be having. While it is always entertaining to listen to the ongoing banter and discourse between the government and the Bloc it is not adding a lot to the debate of Bill C-55.

Income Tax Act May 3rd, 2002

moved for leave to introduce Bill C-461, an act to amend the Income Tax Act (child adoption expenses).

Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague from South Surrey--White Rock--Langley for seconding my bill today.

I rise today to introduce a bill to amend the Income Tax Act, specifically to make the act more equitable for parents, in this case, those who have adopted a child. The bill if passed, will allow adoptive parents to deduct the expenses related to the adoption of a child up to a maximum of $7,000. The expenses must have been incurred in that taxation year or in the previous two years.

Canada is faced with the challenges of an aging population and a low birth rate. We as legislators should be doing everything possible to encourage childless couples to start a family. This bill if supported, would be a great first step.

(Motions deemed adopted, bill read the first time and printed)