House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was debate.

Last in Parliament October 2010, as Conservative MP for Prince George—Peace River (B.C.)

Won his last election, in 2008, with 64% of the vote.

Statements in the House

The Budget March 13th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, the transparency of that answer does not impress the auditor general. It does not impress the Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants and it sure does not impress overtaxed Canadians.

Bob Rutherford, vice-president of standards for the CICA, says that accounting rules which the government claims to be using simply do not exist. Apparently the finance minister has made them up.

The point is this. If Canadians tried to hide their money from the tax collector by setting up dummy accounts, they would go to jail. Why can the finance minister use accounting tricks that would get the rest of us thrown in jail?

The Budget March 13th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, the auditor general, Canada's top financial watchdog, says he does not trust the Prime Minister's budget because of false entries and dummy accounts.

Now the Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants, the very people who write the rules of accounting, say that the Prime Minister is cooking the books also.

By falsifying the books the government has hidden $2.5 billion this year alone, money that should have gone to tax and debt relief.

Why does the Prime Minister believe that he knows more about accounting than accountants do?

Canada Labour Code February 24th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, it is absolutely amazing, astounding actually, how Liberal members opposite can distort the facts and what is in the legislation.

If the hon. member had been in the House during my very brief speech on Friday, I referred to the fact that there are some people out there who are lobbying all members of this House to pass this legislation. Why is that? Because they say it is better than nothing. I said in my opening remarks that the official opposition wants to see legislation which is much better than just better than nothing.

We have serious concerns about this legislation. The reality is that this bill does nothing to help move grain from the farm gate to the port. History will show that is where the disruption takes place. The Liberals brought forward Bill C-19 which narrowly defines how to settle a dispute problem at the port. They are holding it up as the be all and end all. It is absolutely ridiculous and she knows it.

Canada Labour Code February 24th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I thank the hon. member for his comments and his question. Unlike the comment which came from across the way, he certainly brought forward some valid points. Unlike the Liberals who rise in debate on this very important legislation, obviously the member has given some thought to it.

He refers to the fact that he does not see anything specific in the bill which deals with anti-scab workers. I hate that term. It is very derogatory.

My understanding is that the bill gives the real power to the Canada Industrial Relations Board, the CIRB, to decide on the question of replacement workers. We have some concerns about that because the board will be under incredible pressure from the unions. The unions will say that replacement workers in a strike situation should not be allowed, even if it puts the corporation in an untenable position, in a position where the corporation might actually have to close its doors.

I speak not on behalf of corporations when I say that, but on behalf of the workers themselves. We only have to look at the situation which developed in Edmonton where the meat packing plant had to shut down. Ultimately who was hurt? It was the workers themselves who were out of work and who lost their jobs.

When I speak to this issue it is not only out of concern for the shareholders and the company, but for the workers themselves.

Canada Labour Code February 24th, 1998

It would not destroy it. It is shameful what this Liberal government will do with labour relations and what it is attempting to do with this bill.

The hon. member wondered if I would like to comment. Yet I get up to comment and now he is saying he has heard enough because he does not like what he hears. Let me finish. This is my time. It is questions and comments.

Canada Labour Code February 24th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am very pleased to add my comments.

The audacity of the member opposite knows no bounds. It is just incredible. This is the government whose answer to labour disputes is to legislate people back to work. In the autocratic, top down way in which this Liberal government operates all we have to do is hearken back to pre-Christmas. It is not that long ago. Certainly the hon. member's memory should go back that far to the Canada Post dispute where the Liberals sat on their duffs and did absolutely nothing when they knew that dispute was going to flare up. Everyone in the country knew it was coming but they did nothing. They knew in the end they would simply legislate them back to work.

This is the hon. member's answer on how to respect democracy and how to respect worker rights.

Final offer selection arbitration, despite the opinion of the member opposite, would augment the collective bargaining process.

Canada Labour Code February 24th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I am being heckled by members across the way which is a standard operating procedure in the House.

Farmers are very cognizant of these serious ramifications and Canadians are very aware that when these stoppages occur our international reputation is greatly damaged. We all want to protect against this.

There have been several occasions where back to work legislation appeared to be the only alternative to end a dispute and provide relief to those losing thousands, even millions, of dollars due to work stoppage. It is not the only alternative available.

It is not Reform's policy to simply criticize a policy but to proactively come up with concrete alternatives and legislation that will provide substantive change. In the case of labour disputes, we are confident that final offer selection arbitration is the best hope for getting a settlement. It requires both sides to act in good faith and lessens some of the bitter aftermath of a strike or a lockout.

I hope the government members in the House take the time to listen while I elaborate on this process. It is an excellent alternative to back to work legislation that they will find attractive.

Back to work legislation undermines the collective bargaining process. Final offer selection arbitration kicks in only after a union and an employer cannot come to an agreement. Together they must agree on and recommend an arbitrator or arbitration panel. The union and the employer must give the arbitrator a list of the issues they cannot agree on and a list of the issues they have agreed on. For the disputed issues the arbitrator receives from each party a final offer for settlement. The arbitrator will then select one of the final offers. His offer is binding on both parties.

What this means is that both sides will be forced to make reasonable offers. Each will want the arbitrator to pick their offer or they will be forced to live with the offer made by the other party. Therefore to provide a better chance that the arbitrator accepts their offer, I believe that both the union and the employer will make a good attempt at being more than reasonable.

This concept is simple and it avoids prolonged work stoppages or back to work legislation. The entire nature of the collective bargaining process can be improved in the long term. Unions and employers will become more aware of the reality of final offer selection arbitration and will be more inclined to habitually negotiate in good faith. As a result unions and employers will become more focused on negotiations instead of the political ploys and media stunts that are seen frequently in current labour disputes where back to work legislation looms on the horizon.

I would like to digress at this point and explain to viewers back home in a simpler way and use an analogy. In business there is a common practice for partners who are in business together. I am sure you are well aware of this, Mr. Speaker. You have been in business for a number of years in different enterprises over your working life in the real world. I am certain you can appreciate what I am going to talk about.

The reality is that when people enter into a partnership sometimes they are concerned about what may happen in the future. They enter into what is commonly referred to as a shotgun agreement. How does a shotgun agreement work? If you come to an impasse where one of the partners wants to leave the partnership and wants to sell his side to the other partner or see the business sold, the agreement protects the partner who is still in the enterprise.

You have to make a reasonable offer. Under the terms of that agreement, if you put too high a value on your half of the company, let us say you have a 50:50 share in a corporation, the shotgun agreement allows the other partner to say “that is too high, you pay me that amount and instead of me buying you out at x dollars, you buy me out”. This is similar in a way to final offer selection arbitration. It forces both sides in a potential dispute to be reasonable. It forces them to come up with a reasonable offer, because there is a certain amount of fear that if they do not have the most reasonable offer the other side's offer will be accepted.

I use that because a lot of farmers I am pleased to represent are well aware of shotgun agreements and how they work. It might better help them to understand what we are talking about when we talk about final offer selection arbitration and how that could force both sides to be more reasonable and force them to the middle ground.

The federal government has jurisdiction over approximately 10% of the labour force. Federal legislation and the Canadian Labour Code affect 700,000 employees. The federal government has an opportunity and an obligation, I suggest, to set an example in labour relations. The advantages and benefits that would arise from the use of final offer selection arbitration by the federal government have the potential to resonate through the entire Canadian labour force.

As I have said, there are a number of flaws contained in Bill C-19. I am primarily concerned with the substance it lacks in order that farmers can avoid the dire consequences of work stoppages. There are several aspects of this bill that are nothing short of alarming.

Section 109.1 gives the Canada Industrial Relations Board authority to order an employer to release names and addresses of off site workers to union recruiters. I can hardly believe this government would consider this kind of legislation in today's society where we are supposed to be knowledgeable about the risks to personal privacy and safety.

Under no circumstances should individual rights be compromised, particularly to initiate unsolicited contact from any organization or individual.

One of Reform's amendments to Bill C-19 put forward by my hon. colleague would have at least given employees the freedom to choose whether their names and addresses were released. This is a fundamental right and I am astonished that I am even debating this issue in this House. How can this government justify violating an individual's right to privacy? We should think about it.

There are many other options available to ensure that off site workers have access to union information and activities without going to this extreme. This is certainly not the way to go about it. There is no evidence of fairness and balance in a bill which jeopardizes personal rights, privacy and safety.

I want to get to one other issue also contained in the bill that I am very concerned about. Under this section the minister will not guarantee Canadian workers under federal jurisdiction the right to participate in secret ballot representation votes to determine whether a union will represent them. There is a section in this bill that will allow that. We should just think about this for a moment. They will not get a secret vote. This bill is actually an attack on democracy and I feel very strongly about this. It kind of reminds me of another bill.

As I said at the outset, Mr. Speaker, regarding your concern about relevance, I do not want to digress too much but it is very similar to a bill that was recently rammed through this House with the use of closure, Bill C-4, the amendments to the Canadian Wheat Board Act, which I referred to briefly in my remarks earlier this morning. Why does it remind me of that bill? Democracy delayed is democracy denied, and freedom delayed is freedom denied. That is what happened with Bill C-4.

With Bill C-4, this government and the Minister responsible for the Canadian Wheat Board had the opportunity to act and to grant farmers some freedom. What did we see? We saw them completely flout democracy and it has been denied.

I asked the minister if he intends to sit idly by and watch farmers be thrown in jail for protesting what they view as a fundamental issue of democracy and freedom, the right to sell their own product. Obviously with the passage of Bill C-4 he does.

Similarly, Bill C-19 gives the Canada Industrial Relations Board jurisdiction to certify a trade union that does not have a majority support “where, but for the unfair labour practice, the union could reasonably have been expected to have had the support of the majority of the employees in a unit”.

Imagine that. What we see here is an attack on democracy. No secret vote, and it will be left to this Canada Industrial Relations Board to make this arbitrary decision to certify a union despite the fact that it will not have any clear signal whether the majority of the workers in that workplace wish to be represented by that union. Think about this.

Neither the Canada Industrial Relations Board nor any other body has the capacity to rationally discharge a task which involves nothing more than wild speculation. If an employer has committed an unfair labour practice the board should sanction the employer, not deprive workers of their fundamental democratic right to vote on the wisdom of union representation. Certainly I am in agreement with that.

Mr. Speaker, I see you are indicating, unfortunately. It is amazing how quickly time goes when a person is concerned about this legislation and the attack on democracy built into Bill C-19.

Canada Labour Code February 24th, 1998

Mr. Speaker, I will be using the 20 minutes or whatever portion of time you deem I have remaining.

At the outset I wish to indicate that I will endeavour to stay as relevant as possible during my remarks today. I know how important it is to the Speaker that we remain on topic when we address bills and that is my intention.

When I was unfortunately cut off from further debate on Friday, I was at that part in my presentation where I was talking about Bill C-19 as it relates to farmers and as it relates to the transport of farm products and commodities throughout the land. At the end of my remarks I said that despite government claims to the contrary, Bill C-19 will not guarantee that grain will be transported to its destination. I will pick up where I left off.

It was just a couple of years ago in 1995 when western farmers saw rail traffic come to a grinding halt. Now these farmers are haunted by the very real possibility of another rail strike or a lockout this spring because the agreement that brought an end to the 1995 strike expired in December. Bill C-19 will do absolutely nothing to stop that from happening.

As I discovered during debate on Bill C-4, an act to amend the Canadian Wheat Board Act, which was rammed through the House under closure, this government gives farmers little priority. Farmers are not getting the attention and substantive legislation they deserve from this Liberal government.

On many occasions we have seen work stoppages in the national transportation and grain handling sectors. In 1987 there was a five day dispute between the railways and their union. Late that same year there was a 42 day work stoppage between Prince Rupert Grain Ltd. and the Grain Workers Union which resulted in some very heavy financial losses. In 1991 there was a 16 day dispute between the Department of Transport and the public service union. As I mentioned earlier there was a 20 day work stoppage in 1995 during a dispute between the railways and their unions.

In all of those cases the federal government followed through with back to work legislation. This is a patchwork method of ensuring the continuation of essential services. Both management and unions have little incentive to negotiate in good faith. Both parties come to rely on back to work legislation as a way to eventually end the work dispute but it is divisive and simply means that labour disputes will flare up again all too soon. This will certainly be the case this spring if the rail workers and management cannot come to an agreement. Grain farmers will be saying “Here we go again”.

These stoppages in our transportation system have very serious ramifications for our reputation on the international stage as a reliable shipper of farm commodities. As agriculture critic for the official opposition I can say that—

Canada Labour Code February 24th, 1998

I thought it was more Mr. Speaker, but I will bow to your wisdom. I am sure you have checked Hansard .

Disaster Assistance February 23rd, 1998

Mr. Speaker, last Tuesday the minister of agriculture announced an ad hoc relief program for part time farmers who are not eligible under the regular rules of the federal disaster financial assistance arrangements.

Part time farmers in Ontario and Quebec who suffered ice storm damage will be getting some much needed help. However, the government has forgotten full time potato farmers and grain producers in B.C. whose crops were destroyed by record rain storms and flooded fields. The government has also forgotten maritime farmers devastated by a long draught.

It seems like Liberal disaster assistance is allocated according to the level of media coverage and mud on Peter Mansbridge's boots.

It does not matter if a dozen farm families are affected or 1,000, the pain is exactly the same. When will the government learn it cannot continue to treat eastern and western Canadians like second class citizens. If it is to change the rules for central Canadians then it should change them for all Canadians.