House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was tax.

Last in Parliament September 2008, as Liberal MP for LaSalle—Émard (Québec)

Won his last election, in 2006, with 48% of the vote.

Statements in the House

The Economy September 19th, 1994

Mr. Speaker, before answering I should like to congratulate my colleague on having been named one of the two co-critics. If it takes two I am a critic on ten. In all sincerity I should like to congratulate him on his appointment.

Certainly I congratulate him on the fact that he has moved to the front benches. I must say I find it amazing, knowing this particular member, that he has moved a little closer to the centre of the political spectrum.

The answer to the question is that the assumption upon which it is based is simply not well founded. The accumulation of past deficits and the fact of compound interest, as the member knows full well, have led to the tremendous increase in debt. Indeed had the party opposite, heaven forbid, been in office we would have had this compound interest effecting this tremendous increase in the debt. I hope the member understands that.

In any event the member asked what the government was going to do. Let me simply cite the Prime Minister yesterday. We are going to hit our targets.

Goods And Services Tax June 22nd, 1994

Mr. Speaker, if anybody wants an example of double talk, it is the minority report of the Reform Party on the GST.

They said: "We don't have to bring in an alternative because we are going to eliminate the deficit within three years", and then given time after time in this House, including a prebudget debate, they have refused as we have asked for them to lay their plans on the table. The time has come for them to put up.

Goods And Services Tax June 22nd, 1994

Mr. Speaker, what we committed to do was to bring in a tax that was less cumbersome administratively, was fairer to Canadians and was much more simple in terms of small and medium size businesses. That is exactly what we are going to do.

The Economy June 22nd, 1994

Mr. Speaker, you can certainly judge somebody by their friends.

What we intend to do is precisely what the Prime Minister has said repeatedly. In fact, if there is something Canadians are very confident that we will provide, it is good government. We will and we do. And this will be made obvious in our statement in September. This is as clear as the fact that the real reason our debt is so high is because of irresponsible statements on the part of certain people that have caused interest rates to soar.

It is not only from Jacques Parizeau or the Bloc Quebecois that we hear responsible statements. As a Canadian, I take some exception to the leader of the Reform Party last week calling for a mini crisis as a way of solving our problems.

The Economy June 22nd, 1994

Mr. Speaker, what I will do in September is exactly what the secretary of state said earlier.

What I said in the budget speech is this. "The government will release a comprehensive statement that will clearly lay out changes in the economic and fiscal outlook since the last budget. Economic scenarios for the future will be put forward and the government's economic and fiscal goals and broad proposals and how they might be achieved in the next budget will be made public".

That was a commitment made in the budget and I intend to carry it out. I would like to congratulate the new member on one of his first questions in the House.

Report Of Finance Committee June 22nd, 1994

Mr. Speaker, as I said yesterday, it must be said that the Chamber of Commerce of Metropolitan Montreal wants the two taxes to be harmonized, as do the Quebec Chamber of Commerce, the Quebec manufacturers' association and the PQ candidate, but not the member.

I must tell you that it is clear for the Conseil du patronat that most of the interested groups and individuals in Quebec want harmonization; most of them do not agree with the Bloc Quebecois on that and on everything else as well.

Report Of Finance Committee June 22nd, 1994

Mr. Speaker, I know I speak on behalf of Mr. Rae. I know that in my case and in his case either one of us would rather share a bedroom with a gorilla than each other.

Mr. Speaker, it is very clear. The finance committee's report- I must congratulate the members of all parties who were on that committee. I think that they heard 500 witnesses, they read at least 500 briefs; in any case, they received a lot of people. I think that they did an outstanding job and we will certainly accept it as a basis for discussions with the provinces.

I believe that the main recommendation, namely harmonization with the provinces, is something that everyone-that is, the business community and consumers-wants.

Report Of Finance Committee June 22nd, 1994

Mr. Speaker, unfortunately, the Leader of the Opposition is wrong. I have in front of me quotes from Newfoundland's finance minister, Winston Baker, who says that he is in favour of beginning discussions; so is Allan Maher, New Brunswick's finance minister.

I must tell you that the Leader of the Opposition quoted Mr. Rae. I have Mr. Rae's exact words, which I will quote in English since he spoke English.

Mr. Rae said he was willing to work with Ottawa to replace the tax, we have a tax that is like sharing a bedroom with a gorilla, so if we can have any suggestions as to how to move the gorilla out of the bedroom I would be happy to discuss that.

I have not had a lot of experience with gorillas in bedrooms-I would interpret that it may well be difficult-but I believe the premier of Ontario was saying he is prepared to co-operate.

Goods And Services Tax June 21st, 1994

Mr. Speaker, I would just like to quote what was said by a Quebecer who testified when the hon. member was sitting on the committee: "The GST should be harmonized with provincial sales tax. The Association manufacturière du Québec is ready to work with the finance committee to identify the potential measures which could lead to greater harmonization. Once those measures are identified, we will be willing to make the necessary representations to the Government of Quebec". This was said by Richard Le Hir, ex-president of the association and now PQ MNA for Iberville.

Goods And Services Tax June 21st, 1994

Mr. Speaker, from what we have heard publicly from the vast majority of Quebecers, including consumers and the business community, it is clear that they want a harmonized tax. For instance, the Metropolitan Montreal Chamber of Commerce and also the Quebec Chamber of Commerce have already come out in favour of the harmonized tax, as has the Conseil du patronat. My question is this: Why is the Bloc

Quebecois so hostile to the interests of Quebecers and the business community?