House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was federal.

Last in Parliament May 2004, as Canadian Alliance MP for Calgary Southwest (Alberta)

Won his last election, in 2000, with 65% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Canada Pension Plan February 18th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister once said he would kill the GST. He broke that promise. The Prime Minister claims there have been no tax increases under his administration. Now we have a 70 per cent hike in a particular payroll tax alone.

Soon the Prime Minister will be sending candidates across the country to seek re-election. As they go from meeting to meeting, they will be followed like some hound from hell by the Prime Minister's record of broken promises on jobs, broken promises on taxes and broken promises on integrity.

How does the Prime Minister hope to improve his reputation for honesty and integrity when he refuses to admit that CPP contributions are a payroll tax and a 70 per cent hike in premiums is a tax grab?

Canada Pension Plan February 18th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, therefore according to the Minister of Finance and the Prime Minister, the CPP premiums are contributions and not a tax.

I have on my desk a paper entitled "Growth in CPP/QPP Contributions". In it the author clearly describes contributions to the Canada pension plan and the Quebec plan as compulsory payroll taxes. He demonstrates that increases in the payroll taxes from 1986 to 1993 reduced employment by 26,000 jobs. The author of this paper, Joe Italiano, is with the economic analysis and forecasting division of the Department of Finance.

Who is right, the finance minister who says that CPP premiums are not a payroll tax and that raising them has no impact on jobs, or the analysis of his own department that says exactly the opposite?

Canada Pension Plan February 18th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, a 70 per cent increase in mandatory Canada pension plan premiums; up to $10 billion more per year in revenue for the

government; $690 more taken off Canadian paycheques. That sounds like a tax, smells like a tax and looks like a tax, but not so according to the Minister of Finance.

In the House yesterday he said: "This is not a tax grab. It is not a tax". I would like to ask the Prime Minister whether it is really the position of the Government of Canada that Canada pension plan payments are not a payroll tax.

Canada Pension Plan February 17th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, when it comes to pensions, the government has a complete double standard.

Under the Canada pension plan Canadians will pay premiums of 9.9 per cent for a maximum pension of $9,000 a year. Under the Liberals' MP pension plan the premiums are roughly the same, around 9 per cent, but the returns are much, much greater. For his 9 per cent the leader of the federal Tories will receive $53,000 a year and for her 9 per cent, the Deputy Prime Minister will pocket $49,000 a year. That is a far cry from $9,000.

My question is one we are going to ask in every riding in the country: How can this government ask Canadians to pay 70 per cent more for a paltry pension of $9,000 a year when Liberal members opposite continue to qualify for an obscenely wealthy MP pension?

Canada Pension Plan February 17th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, the hypocrisy of the minister's reply is not only an insult to every Reformer, but it is an insult to every senior citizen in the country.

Here is a well to do finance minister who himself qualifies for a fat MP pension and what does he do? He is clawing back old age security from thousands of seniors every month; he is gouging CPP contributors to the tune of a 70 per cent premium hike and he has his covetous eye on the RRSP savings as well. Then he has the nerve to stand in the House and pretend that he is taking care of seniors.

Will the minister not admit that the Canada pension plan is in trouble because of decades of Liberal and Tory mismanagement? If the minister had been the manager of a private pension plan and it had been mismanaged like the CPP has been, he and his colleagues would be making licence plates in some penitentiary instead of sitting in the House.

Canada Pension Plan February 17th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, on Friday the finance minister announced one of the biggest single tax grabs in Canadian history, a 70 per cent hike in CPP premiums, payroll taxes with no increase in benefits.

Under the old system Canadians paid 5.8 per cent of their paycheques for a $9,000 pension at the end of the day. Under the

new system they will now have to pay 9.9 per cent of their paycheques to receive the same $9,000.

Is this the government's primary response to the pension crisis: a $10 billion tax grab that will penalize young Canadians and kill jobs? No wonder we need a fresh start on pension reform.

Somalia Inquiry February 12th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, the net result of all that the minister has said is that he is choosing to ignore the charges made by the commissioners against the government: charges of political interference, charges of making misleading statements and charges of participating in a whitewash.

That being the case, how can the public possibly believe that the government will respond to the final report of the commission when it is already ignoring what the commission is saying about interference, deception and cover-up?

Somalia Inquiry February 12th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, in their responses today neither the Prime Minister nor the defence minister has acknowledged the seriousness of the charges made against the government by the Somalia inquiry commissioners, a commission that they themselves set up: charges of political interference with an independent tribunal, charges of making misleading and unfair statements on the work of the tribunal, and charges of contributing to a whitewash.

Has the government no response to these serious charges other than to ignore them?

Somalia Inquiry February 12th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, that answer is not good enough for Canadians. Justice Létourneau said this morning that the government's decision has precluded the possibility of effectively investigating any cover-up at the senior level. He said the government understood clearly that this would be the impact of its decision to terminate the inquiry because they had informed the privy council of this implication before the decision was taken.

What political reason did the government have for terminating this independent inquiry when it was specifically forewarned that the effect would be to prevent effective investigation of the cover-up at the top?

Somalia Inquiry February 12th, 1997

Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister says the government did not intervene. The head of the Somalia inquiry also said clearly this morning that the government had interfered with the conduct of an independent public inquiry. What he could not say was whether the government had interfered for political reasons.

I ask the Prime Minister directly did his government interfere with the Somalia inquiry for political reasons. Is there a political reason why the Prime Minister does not want the inquiry to get to the bottom of a high level cover-up in the Somalia affair?