House of Commons photo

Crucial Fact

  • His favourite word was conservatives.

Last in Parliament August 2018, as NDP MP for Outremont (Québec)

Won his last election, in 2015, with 44% of the vote.

Statements in the House

Public Safety February 18th, 2015

Of course, Mr. Speaker, when the Prime Minister uses the word “extreme” to define the opposition, and then he denies that this is about political opportunism, everybody can see right through it.

CSIS already has a mandate to investigate security threats and potential attacks of any kind against Canada.

The Prime Minister's bill would expand its mandate, but to what? What activities? He is not able to give Canadians a single example.

Public Safety February 18th, 2015

Mr. Speaker, terrorism is a real threat and everyone agrees that public safety is the primary responsibility of any government, but Canadians do not have to choose between security and their rights.

Interfering with infrastructure, interfering with economic stability, why is the Prime Minister lumping in legitimate dissent with terrorist activity?

Public Safety February 18th, 2015

Mr. Speaker, right now CSIS investigates security threats, but the Prime Minister's proposed bill would redefine security threats to include all activities that “interfere” with infrastructure and economic stability, to give only two examples.

CSIS is already charged with investigating things like terrorist threats against our economic infrastructure. It is already there

So what new kind of economic interference would CSIS now be charged with investigating? Can the Prime Minister give Canadians a single example?

Public Safety February 18th, 2015

Mr. Speaker, inciting a terrorist act is already illegal. Is the Prime Minister the only one who does not understand that?

Right now, CSIS already has the mandate to investigate any threat to Canada's security. Under the Prime Minister's bill, the definition of a threat to security would include anything that could interfere with economic stability. What does that mean?

Can the Prime Minister tell Canadians exactly what his bill means when it refers to interfering with economic stability?

Public Safety February 18th, 2015

Mr. Speaker, inciting a terrorist act is already a crime in Canada.

The Prime Minister wants to change the law so that promoting terrorism in general will now be a crime. The problems is that this definition does not add anything meaningful. The Minister of Public Safety claims that he does not want to get caught up in definitions.

Can the Prime Minister give Canadians an example of a situation that is not covered by the existing legislation?

CBC/Radio-Canada February 17th, 2015

Mr. Speaker, I am sure the Prime Minister will show us where the word “imminent” appears in that law.

The problem is that the Prime Minister sees enemies everywhere. Right now, he has CBC employees in his sights.

Yesterday, the Prime Minister said that CBC reporters “detest” Conservative values, and that the majority of CBC reporters, no less, want to get rid of his government.

Is it possible that the Prime Minister is mistaken and what he actually meant to say is that he has finally realized that the vast majority of Canadians want to get rid of his government?

Public Safety February 17th, 2015

Mr. Speaker, let us look at what else will be considered a crime in Canada.

Bill C-51 would expand CSIS's mandate to spying on “interference with...infrastructure” and “interference with...economic or financial stability”. The language is so broad that it would allow CSIS to investigate anyone who challenges the government's social, economic, or environmental policies. What is to stop this bill from being used to spy on the government's political enemy?

Public Safety February 17th, 2015

Mr. Speaker, yesterday, the minister of public peril said that he was not going to get caught up in definitions. That is not reassuring for anyone, especially since the Conservatives are unable to explain how peaceful dissent would still be protected under Bill C-51.

The Minister of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness refused to give any examples of activities that CSIS might now undertake to “disrupt threats”.

Can the Prime Minister tell us how far CSIS will be able to go under Bill C-51?

National Defence February 17th, 2015

Mr. Speaker, the problem is that the Prime Minister keeps changing his story.

He did not tell the truth about sending our troops into the line of fire. He did not tell the truth about the cost of the war in Iraq. Once again, he is not telling the truth. However, today, the Parliamentary Budget Officer is telling us the truth.

If the Prime Minister is so convinced that his war in Iraq is a good idea, why on earth is he refusing to tell Canadians the truth about the cost of his war?

National Defence February 17th, 2015

Mr. Speaker, from the outset, the Prime Minister has been refusing to tell Canadians the truth about our role in Iraq. Our troops were not supposed to be on the front line and they were not supposed to be involved in combat, but of course we now know that they are. Now the Parliamentary Budget Officer says that the Conservatives “appear to breach [National Defence]'s legal obligations under the Parliament of Canada Act”.

In clear terms, they have broken the law, and it is because the Conservatives are refusing to tell the truth about the cost of the war in Iraq. Why does the Prime Minister keep hiding from Canadians the truth about his war in Iraq?