Refine by MP, party, committee, province, or result type.
Justice committee As I informed the committee, I have to leave at 12:45 for another matter downtown. I wonder if perhaps I could try to answer your question for me first, before he does, if you want, or else I'll just have to say goodbye now.
November 23rd, 2006Committee meeting
Prof. Peter Rosenthal
Justice committee Actually, I would like to comment on what you asked him, if that's okay with you.
November 23rd, 2006Committee meeting
Prof. Peter Rosenthal
Justice committee Yes, thank you. First off, when you look at Pennsylvania and things like that, it's ups and downs. Because it happened coincidentally that they passed a minimum law and then it was down the next year doesn't prove that was the reason. Just as it was pointed out, in Canada we hav
November 23rd, 2006Committee meeting
Prof. Peter Rosenthal
Justice committee Thank you very much, sir.
November 23rd, 2006Committee meeting
Prof. Peter Rosenthal
Justice committee Yes, the question of incapacitation is raised, as it was a while ago here, that if someone is in custody, he's not going to be committing crimes, at least outside the prison. He might do it in prison, but he won't be committing crimes outside. Well, how much effect is this bill g
November 23rd, 2006Committee meeting
Prof. Peter Rosenthal
Justice committee Absolutely. I want to agree with you on that aspect, too, but I wanted to make the other point about incapacitation. Even per se is a very, very minuscule matter and shouldn't really be considered. Certainly, the evidence is that the longer you spend in prison, the more you learn
November 23rd, 2006Committee meeting
Prof. Peter Rosenthal
Justice committee Absolutely. I completely agree with you and would urge that you look at those kinds of questions as to how you can really rehabilitate people.
November 23rd, 2006Committee meeting
Prof. Peter Rosenthal
Justice committee Thank you. I should like to take up something that Mr. Ménard has indicated. He pointed out that in Toronto and Vancouver there were increases in gun crimes and in the other areas there were decreases. That alone should prove that the mandatory minimums had nothing to do with i
November 23rd, 2006Committee meeting
Prof. Peter Rosenthal
Justice committee I don't believe that was the reason I was invited.
November 23rd, 2006Committee meeting
Prof. Peter Rosenthal
Justice committee I promise you, I won't give you a mathematics lecture.
November 23rd, 2006Committee meeting
Prof. Peter Rosenthal
Justice committee Thank you very much. Thank you. I'm not sure who decided to invite me here, but I know it was not because of anything I did in mathematics. I am also a practising lawyer with Roach, Schwartz and Associates in Toronto, and I'm also an adjunct professor of law at the University of
November 23rd, 2006Committee meeting
Prof. Peter Rosenthal