Refine by MP, party, committee, province, or result type.
Official Languages committee But if the survival and vitality of these communities are, as set out in the act, a concern of this government and, as Mr. Fraser said, there has been no consultation, hence they have not complied with the act. It seems self-evident to us that the program needs to be restored. I
June 14th, 2007Committee meeting
David Birnbaum
Official Languages committee The situation for both sides is extremely specific and important. If we talk about the evolution of minority linguistic rights with regard to education, first in response to the suggestion, which even the Commissioner has denied, that what has been done has already been done, the
June 14th, 2007Committee meeting
David Birnbaum
Canadian Heritage committee We would greatly welcome it, with the proviso that like any law adopted by a government it would be subject to the full scrutiny of the courts and complete access to those courts. Otherwise we would have difficulties understanding the full value of that law, no matter how well it
December 13th, 2006Committee meeting
David Birnbaum
Canadian Heritage committee I would like us to get over the idea that we are advocating for programs which only matter to minorities. A few years ago, in Quebec, a poll asked the following question: Should the anglophone linguistic minority have access to essential health services in its languages? A vast
December 13th, 2006Committee meeting
David Birnbaum
Canadian Heritage committee First of all, the basic suggestion that a government will not adopt unconstitutional legislation is an absurdity. Is that to question that the judiciary is no longer a legitimate and vital branch of democracy? That leaves us rather speechless. Secondly, if you look at the import
December 13th, 2006Committee meeting
David Birnbaum