Bill C-32 (40th Parliament, 3rd Session) committee  At minimum, ISPs should be required to implement a policy that would deal with repeat infringers.

Bill C-32 (40th Parliament, 3rd Session) committee  In the interest of speed, Mr. Chair, I was going to make some general introductory remarks, but I think there are people here who are more important to be heard from. I'll let us start right off with Maïa. You all have our biographies, so we'll skip those. They're in French and

Canadian Heritage committee  [Inaudible--Editor]...misrepresentation, the classic straw man.

Canadian Heritage committee  That's not true.

Canadian Heritage committee  Straw man.

Canadian Heritage committee  Straw man.

Canadian Heritage committee  If you like the straw man.

Canadian Heritage committee  If you like the straw man.

Canadian Heritage committee  If you'd like a complete misrepresentation of our business, you're welcome to read it.

Canadian Heritage committee  At this point, it's everything.

Canadian Heritage committee  Oh, I see; it's cannibalizing. No, I don't believe the legal digital marketplace is cannibalizing CD sales. We're at a frontier, right? We're at a tipping point. This has happened before in our industry, from vinyl to cassette, cassette to CD, CD to digital. So we're seeing tha

Canadian Heritage committee  If that should be around 5% of somebody's livelihood, can you see why I might be interested in getting the 95% back?

Canadian Heritage committee  That's the focus, the 95%.

Canadian Heritage committee  I don't disagree. I thought I'd answered that. I thought I'd made it very clear that--

Canadian Heritage committee  I think we're at a stage in our copyright evolution that contemplating something like a graduated response.... I think “three strikes”, by the way, is one of those terms that has been applied to it. It's like a pejorative term, to make it sound worse than it is. A graduated respo