Industry committee  I don't think completely scrapping it will be efficient. I think the legislation does have good bones. I think it's the guts that need to be focused on. I think that can be done by targeting on the definitions, looking at the parts that are really restrictive, comparing it to the

Industry committee  Not that I'm aware of.

Industry committee  That, of course, would happen today. I find that interesting. I'm definitely going to take a look at that and read it for myself, just based on what you brought to us today. I still stand by my position. I do disagree with that. I do think that the points we brought up today, es

Industry committee  We should approach the private right of action the way Mr. Elder was saying in answer to the previous question. If we are able to target the most malicious forms of spam, which is what CASL was intended to do, then the private right of action can come in the way it is. I don't th

Industry committee  Fair enough. I think constitutional arguments are being put forward to the CRTC. I'm happy to provide more information on that after today's meeting, if that's something the committee wishes to look at further. My point today is really to focus on—yes, I know it was not the prio

Industry committee  Yes, that's correct.

Industry committee  For that, I think I was getting at the fact that there are definitions that are very broad, like that of CEMs. Although people understand what the act is saying, they don't necessarily see the effects that it's having. I think there's a difference between what's written on paper

Industry committee  I think it came to that because I looked at what the definition actually laid out. I think that's what a lot of people, businesses, and individuals are having a difficult time with, looking at the law and seeing what it's actually laying out. It's being specific in the sense tha

Industry committee  Correct, I serve as an adviser with the Lighten CASL committee, but I believe that Andrew's submissions today—

Industry committee  Thank you, Mr. Chair, and committee members for giving me the opportunity to speak to you today. By way of a brief introduction, my name is Stephanie Provato and I'm an associate lawyer at Buchli Goldstein in Toronto. My involvement with CASL to date has been evaluating the leg