Industry committee  Sorry, Mr. Knopf, just before I go to you, I want to follow up on some of that, quickly. The YouTube exception, for example, it came out of the last review because YouTube was a new thing, if you will. Who knows what five years from now will bring, so in terms of not reviewing

Industry committee  Sorry, Mr. Knopf, go ahead.

Industry committee  Nice. All right, It's good to be back, Mr. Chair.

Industry committee  Thank you, witnesses. It's good to see a thorough study of copyright continues, as back in my previous time here. Mr. Chair, do I have five minutes?

Industry committee  Thank you. I do want to come back to your comments, Mr. de Beer. I'm still struggling to understand why, regardless of whether it's five years or it's 10 years in terms of the mandatory review.... I believe that what we're trying to accomplish as a committee is to look at the lo

Industry committee  Through the chair....