Lawful Access Act, 2026

An Act respecting lawful access

Sponsor

Status

In committee (Senate), as of Oct. 22, 2026

Subscribe to a feed (what's a feed?) of speeches and votes in the House related to Bill C-22.

Summary

This is from the published bill. The Library of Parliament has also written a full legislative summary of the bill.

Part 1 amends various Acts to modernize certain provisions respecting the timely gathering and production of data and information during an investigation. It, among other things,
(a) amends the Criminal Code to, among other things,
(i) facilitate access to basic information that will assist in the investigation of federal offences through confirmation of service demands given to telecommunications service providers or judicial production orders for the production of subscriber information,
(ii) expedite the response to production orders by shortening the review process and clarify the ability of peace officers and public officers to receive and act on certain information that is voluntarily provided to them and to obtain and act on information that is publicly available,
(iii) specify certain circumstances in which peace officers and public officers may obtain evidence, including subscriber information, in exigent circumstances,
(iv) allow a justice or judge to authorize, in a warrant, a peace officer or public officer to obtain tracking data or transmission data that relates to any thing that is similar to a thing in relation to which data is authorized to be obtained under the warrant and that is unknown at the time the warrant is issued,
(v) provide and clarify authorities by which computer data may be examined, and
(vi) allow a justice or judge to authorize a peace officer or public officer to make a request to a foreign entity that provides telecommunications services — or that provides services by a means of telecommunication — to the public to produce transmission data or subscriber information that is in its possession or control;
(b) makes a consequential amendment to the Foreign Publishers Advertising Services Act ;
(c) amends the Mutual Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters Act to allow the Minister of Justice to authorize a competent authority to make arrangements for the enforcement of a decision made by an authority of a state or entity that is empowered to compel the production of transmission data or subscriber information that is in the possession or control of a person in Canada;
(d) amends the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act to, among other things,
(i) facilitate access to basic information that will assist the Canadian Security Intelligence Service in the performance of its duties and functions under section 12 or 16 of that Act through confirmation of service demands given to telecommunications service providers and judicial orders against those providers, and
(ii) clarify the response time for production orders; and
(e) amends the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act and the Cannabis Act to provide and clarify authorities by which computer data may be examined.
Part 2 enacts the Supporting Authorized Access to Information Act . That Act establishes a framework for ensuring that electronic service providers can facilitate the exercise, by authorized persons, of authorities to access information conferred under the Criminal Code or the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act . It also makes related and consequential amendments to the Intelligence Commissioner Act .
Part 3 provides for the parliamentary review of Parts 1 and 2.

Elsewhere

All sorts of information on this bill is available at LEGISinfo, an excellent resource from Parliament. You can also read the full text of the bill.

Bill numbers are reused for different bills each new session. Perhaps you were looking for one of these other C-22s:

C-22 (2022) Law Canada Disability Benefit Act
C-22 (2021) An Act to amend the Criminal Code and the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act
C-22 (2016) Law An Act to establish the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians and to make consequential amendments to certain Acts
C-22 (2014) Law Energy Safety and Security Act

Debate Summary

line drawing of robot

This is a computer-generated summary of the speeches below. Usually it’s accurate, but every now and then it’ll contain inaccuracies or total fabrications.

Bill C-22 seeks to modernize "lawful access" rules, equipping law enforcement with tools to investigate digital crimes. While proponents argue it closes crucial investigative gaps, the bill faces criticism regarding potential overreach, the threshold for accessing private data, and the scope of metadata retention requirements.

Liberal

  • Modernizing law for digital investigations: The Liberal Party aims to modernize Canada’s legal framework to match current technological realities, ensuring law enforcement can investigate digital crimes like extortion and child exploitation as effectively as they did in the analog era.
  • Proportional judicial oversight and privacy: This bill establishes a staged investigative process where the level of oversight remains proportional to the intrusion, requiring judicial authorization for identifying subscriber information while protecting the internal content of private communications.
  • Mandatory technical capabilities for providers: This legislation requires electronic service providers to maintain the technical capability to respond to lawful warrants, preventing investigations from stalling due to a provider’s inability to retrieve metadata or confirm service locations.
  • Aligning with international security partners: By establishing a modernized lawful access regime, Canada aligns its public safety tools with G7 and Five Eyes partners, facilitating better international cooperation against transnational organized crime and global security threats.

Conservative

  • Modernizing digital investigative tools: The Conservatives support modernizing lawful access laws to provide police with updated tools for digital investigations, noting that Canada remains the only Five Eyes nation without a modern framework for accessing communications in criminal cases.
  • Charter and privacy protection: The party emphasizes that any revisions to the law must be Charter-compliant and respect the privacy rights of Canadians, specifically criticizing the lowering of legal thresholds from "reasonable belief" to "reasonable suspicion" for accessing data.
  • Cybersecurity and system vulnerabilities: Members warn that mandating service providers to build surveillance capabilities into their systems creates technical vulnerabilities or "back doors" that could be exploited by hackers or hostile foreign states, compromising overall network security.
  • Oversight of secret ministerial orders: The party critiques the use of secret ministerial orders and the broad definition of "electronic service providers," arguing that allowing the government to implement surveillance requirements behind closed doors without judicial oversight threatens civil liberties.

NDP

  • Balancing investigative tools and privacy: The NDP recognizes the need to modernize investigative powers to combat serious crimes like human trafficking, but emphasizes that these tools must be balanced against strong protections for civil liberties and privacy.
  • Opposing bulk metadata retention: The party criticizes the bill's provisions for mandatory metadata retention, arguing that collecting data on all users for up to a year constitutes an invasion of privacy and replaces targeted suspicion with generalized surveillance.
  • Strengthening independent judicial oversight: New Democrats express concern over the Minister of Public Safety’s power to issue secret system modification orders without judicial authorization, asserting that administrative processes are insufficient replacements for independent judicial review.
  • Addressing systemic cybersecurity risks: The party warns that mandating large-scale data retention and building surveillance capabilities into systems creates significant cybersecurity vulnerabilities, potentially exposing sensitive data to breaches and exploitation by malicious actors.

Bloc

  • Improvement over Bill C-2: The Bloc Québécois acknowledges that Bill C-22 is more comprehensive and better crafted than its predecessor, though the party remains undecided on its final vote until further consultations and committee studies are completed.
  • Low evidentiary thresholds: Members express concern over lowering the legal standard of proof to "reasonable grounds to suspect," arguing this threshold is too low and could permit intrusive surveillance or "fishing expeditions" into personal information.
  • Strengthening oversight mechanisms: The party criticizes the reactive nature of the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency. They advocate for stronger oversight, proactive consultation with independent agencies, and more timely monitoring of government access to data.
  • Metadata and hacking risks: The Bloc warns that requiring providers to retain a year of geolocation metadata creates a "treasure trove" for hackers, potentially endangering the privacy and security of millions of citizens who are not suspected of crimes.

Green

  • Conditional support pending amendments: While acknowledging improvements over previous iterations, the Green Party cannot support Bill C-22 as currently drafted and urges the government to adopt a more collaborative process to achieve consensus.
  • Objection to novel legal terminology: The party opposes the "reasonable grounds to suspect" threshold for warrants, arguing it is an unprecedented, lower standard that lacks jurisprudence and will create legal confusion for law enforcement.
  • Risks of permanent surveillance capacity: Elizabeth May warns that requiring Internet providers to install surveillance capacity could allow foreign governments to access Canadians' personal data, creating permanent spyware risks that must be addressed.
Was this summary helpful and accurate?

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:35 a.m.

Conservative

Scott Anderson Conservative Vernon—Lake Country—Monashee, BC

Mr. Speaker, Liberal catch-and-release policies have actually caused this crime. Before Trudeau came along 10 years ago, we did not have a crime wave; now we do. We also did not have Bill C-22. The difference here is actually the catch-and-release problems, the catch-and-release policies we are suffering under.

Would it not make more sense to stop shooting down Conservative bills, anti-crime bills, and leave the privacy of Canadians alone?

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:35 a.m.

Liberal

Ali Ehsassi Liberal Willowdale, ON

Mr. Speaker, as the member opposite is likely aware, today we are here to debate Bill C-22, which is a very significant piece of legislation. As I have indicated, this government has always benefited greatly from the views and the perspectives of individuals throughout this chamber. We are always willing to welcome any input that anyone has. This bill, as I indicated, has also benefited from that. I have no doubt that, once it is adopted, our law enforcement agencies and individuals who are working around the clock in this country will benefit greatly from the adoption of this bill.

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:35 a.m.

Bloc

Claude DeBellefeuille Bloc Vallée-du-Haut-Saint-Laurent, QC

Mr. Speaker, I appreciated my colleague's speech. We serve on the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security together. I listened to him carefully, but I want to ask him a brief question to ensure I have understood correctly.

According to the bill, the definition of essential service providers, which may be subject to injunctions when it comes to lawful access to information, is to be determined by regulation. I wonder whether it is appropriate for this to be determined by the executive branch. Why should such an important definition in this bill be established by regulation rather than by legislation?

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:35 a.m.

Liberal

Ali Ehsassi Liberal Willowdale, ON

Mr. Speaker, the member opposite and I have had the great benefit of working closely together on the public safety committee. The point she raises is certainly a valid one, but as we know, this particular bill will be referred to committee, and that would be an exceptional opportunity for us all to weigh in and make sure this is as robust and as good a piece of legislation as possible. I have no doubt that the member will be a very big part of that exercise.

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:40 a.m.

Liberal

Mark Gerretsen Liberal Kingston and the Islands, ON

Mr. Speaker, the legislation is extremely important, because it is giving law enforcement the necessary tools that they need in order to protect Canadians. I understand that Canada is the only one of the Five Eyes counties that does not have lawful access legislation in place in order to give law enforcement those tools. I am wondering if the member can expand on why it is important, given the context of the Five Eyes and Canada's position there.

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:40 a.m.

Liberal

Ali Ehsassi Liberal Willowdale, ON

Mr. Speaker, as the hon. member has rightly indicated, there was a big gap in terms of making sure that our law enforcement agencies have all the necessary tools to do a thorough job when they are investigating a wide variety of crimes. We certainly live in an era when the speed and the pace at which such crimes are taking place are very different from what they were previously.

It was certainly high time for us to listen to those law enforcement agencies and to look at the experience that the other Five Eyes and indeed the other G7 countries had on this. We looked at that to make sure we would come up with a robust system that was balanced and that would have legal safeguards, and that is why I think the product of this entire exercise is a very good piece of legislation.

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:40 a.m.

Conservative

Tamara Kronis Conservative Nanaimo—Ladysmith, BC

Mr. Speaker, there is an old story about a traveller in the desert. Night had fallen and the air had turned bitterly cold. The traveller had just enough space and warmth in the tent to get through the night, but then a camel approached and asked if it could put its nose inside just to stay warm. The traveller agreed. It seemed harmless. However, then the camel asked to bring in its head and then its shoulders, and before long, the entire camel was inside the tent, leaving the traveller out in the cold.

It is a simple story, but it carries an important lesson: When we allow something small without thinking through where it could lead, we can often end up somewhere very different from where we intended. That is the caution we should keep in mind as we debate Bill C-22, because this bill is about expanding the powers of the state into the digital lives of Canadians. While each individual step may seem reasonable on its own, we have to ask ourselves where the path we are taking leads.

There is no disagreement in this House about the goal. We all want law enforcement to have the tools they need to go after child predators, organized crime, human traffickers and terrorists. We all recognize that criminals are using modern technology to hide their activities and that the law must keep pace. Conservatives are always open to modernizing the law. The question before us today is not whether to modernize. The question is whether Bill C-22 gets the balance right. Modernization should not come and need not come at the cost of accountability, and it cannot come at the cost of the freedoms that Canadians expect us to protect.

We have been here before in this parliamentary session. The government tried to legislate for lawful access earlier in this session when Bill C-2 was introduced as a sweeping solution. It was broad, it was rushed and it raised serious concerns across the board. The fact that we are now debating Bill C-22 is, in itself, an acknowledgement that the first attempt missed the mark. This bill is an improvement in many respects. It narrows certain provisions. It introduces some safeguards. However, improvements do not mean that we have it right. There are still real concerns that we need to work through in committee as this bill wends its way through Parliament.

To start, I want to talk about accountability. The National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians found that our agencies do not systematically track the challenges they face with lawful access. Let us think about that. We are being asked to expand powers in an area where we do not even have consistent data on what is not working today. Where in this bill, then, is the requirement to track those challenges and report them clearly to Parliament? If we do not measure the problem, how can we claim to solve it?

We also need to engage with the trust that Canadians have put in us. They are not legal experts. Most Canadians are not reading every clause of this bill, but they still want to feel safe. They want to know who can access their information, under what conditions and with what limits. Right now, those answers are not as clear as they should be.

This bill would lower the threshold in key areas from “reasonable grounds to believe” to “reasonable grounds to suspect”. That may sound like a small change in the legalese, but it is not. It is a real shift that would make it easier for the state to access personal information earlier in an investigation and it needs to be studied carefully to ensure that it is absolutely necessary and minimally impairing of rights. When we combine lower thresholds with broader powers, we have to be very careful and ask whether we are gradually moving that camel further and further into the tent.

I want to move to data retention. This is something a number of speakers have touched on and it is something I have received a lot of correspondence about from members of my community. In serious investigations, especially those involving children or violent crime, data can disappear quickly. In some cases, it is gone within 30 days. That makes it harder to hold offenders accountable. Yes, Parliament absolutely needs to address that, but the solution cannot be to collect and retain large amounts of data on everyone, regardless of suspicion, indefinitely.

This bill would allow for the retention of metadata, including information that can reveal locations and patterns of life in some cases when combined with other information but nonetheless in a way that has a lot of people worried. We need to be asking basic but critical questions about this: Who is holding that data, where is it stored, how long is it kept and why do we need to apply this broadly instead of targeting serious offences? If we are going to impact privacy rights, then we must do it in a targeted, proportionate and justified way that we can explain to the public. Otherwise, we risk casting a wider net than intended, creating all kinds of concerns and worries in our society.

I want to move on to system vulnerability. This bill would require service providers to build and maintain systems that allow for lawful access. The intention is understandable, but we have to be realistic about the risks. Creating access mechanisms can create vulnerabilities. We have seen cases in other jurisdictions where systems built for lawful access were later exploited by hackers. Canadians have a simple expectation. They do not want back doors into their private communications. Even if this bill does not explicitly create one, we need to be absolutely certain that it does not create independent pathways that could be abused.

Again, secrecy and oversight are an issue. This bill would rely somewhat on secret ministerial orders and delayed notice. In some cases, individuals may not know their data was accessed for years, if at all. Oversight that happens after the fact is simply not enough. If we are expanding powers, the safeguards must be strong, independent and timely. Canadians need to know that there are real checks in place, not just internal reviews behind closed doors.

Finally, we need to be honest about the broader picture. This bill addresses some challenges in digital investigations, but it does not address many of the issues Canadians are most concerned about when it comes to crime and public safety. It does not address repeat violent offenders. It does not address gaps in bail or sentencing. It does not solve the broader crisis we are seeing in communities across the country. Therefore, we need to be careful not to overstate what this bill would achieve.

Our discussion and our debate today should not be about choosing between safety and freedom. Canadians deserve both. They deserve laws that allow the police to do their job effectively and they deserve to know their rights are protected at the same time. That is the balance we are trying to strike. The current iteration of Bill C-22 is a step in that direction, but is not there yet. We need clearer accountability. We need stronger safeguards. We need to ensure that in trying to solve the problem we are not quietly creating others, because once these powers are granted they are very difficult to take back. That is why we have to get this right, not just for today but for the future, so Canadians can feel both safe and free, not one at the expense of the other.

When the camel first asked, it did not ask to take over the whole tent. It did not demand. It asked politely. It asked for something small, something temporary, just enough to take the edge off the cold. That is what makes the lesson here so powerful. The traveller did not make a bad decision out of carelessness, but out of compassion and reasonableness. He thought he was in control of the situation, but step by step, decision by decision, the situation changed until he no longer was. If we are not careful, if we do not take the time to examine all the possible angles and unintended consequences of this bill, we risk finding that the balance has shifted against us, not all at once but gradually, in ways that were easy to justify at every stage along the way, but which nonetheless unduly upset the delicate balance between privacy and speedy enforcement.

I look forward to continuing the debate and discussion on this important topic.

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:50 a.m.

Bloc

Marilène Gill Bloc Côte-Nord—Kawawachikamach—Nitassinan, QC

Mr. Speaker, the Bloc Québécois finds it unacceptable that the government is granting greater powers to the police and intelligence services while slashing the budget of the body responsible for overseeing them, namely the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency, or NSIRA. Its budget has been cut by 15% as a result of the Liberal government's penny-pinching.

I would like to know what my colleague thinks.

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:50 a.m.

Conservative

Tamara Kronis Conservative Nanaimo—Ladysmith, BC

Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague for her question.

The hon. member has pointed out one of the really difficult issues that we are grappling with, with this government, which is that the Liberals talk, saying things that people want to hear. They talk about making changes that need to be made, but somewhere behind the scenes resources are not following the matter and Canadians are not, in fact, getting what they need.

That is one of the main reasons that we really need to think about this. We need to work hard to get this right.

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:50 a.m.

Conservative

Roman Baber Conservative North York, ON

Mr. Speaker, we recognize the necessity of protecting children online, especially from predators who access unlawful and criminal material.

I am wondering if my friend could tell me why she believes the Liberals refused to adopt the Conservative suggestion and, in response to the Senneville decision that struck down mandatory minimum sentencing for access and possession to materials that violate children, the Liberals decided they will have none of it.

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:50 a.m.

Conservative

Tamara Kronis Conservative Nanaimo—Ladysmith, BC

Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague for giving me the opportunity yesterday in the justice committee to ask questions about this very topic.

It is a good example of how the Liberals give with one hand and take away with the other. It is incredibly important to protect children against predation, online and off-line. I hope that the government will see reason and restore the mandatory minimums for child sexual exploitation.

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:50 a.m.

Green

Elizabeth May Green Saanich—Gulf Islands, BC

Mr. Speaker, I know this may offend people. There are people who think there are too many lawyers in politics, but I do not think there are enough of us. I want to thank the hon. member for Nanaimo—Ladysmith, whose legal background showed through in the way she put together that critique of Bill C-22.

I am also very concerned about changing “reasonable grounds to believe” to “reasonable grounds to suspect”. I would like the member to expand on whether she found any previous example of that kind of threshold being used. I cannot find a previous example of “reasonable grounds to suspect”.

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:55 a.m.

Conservative

Tamara Kronis Conservative Nanaimo—Ladysmith, BC

Mr. Speaker, I really want to thank my colleague for the generosity in her comments. It means a lot to me when one of my colleagues from Vancouver Island recognizes the value that other members bring to this House.

Like the hon. member, I have also looked for examples. The reality is, at the end of the day, suspecting and believing are two different things. The government is creating yet another change that dilutes rights in a way that is unclear, that the courts will have to grapple with, that will add to litigation, that will add to backlogs and that will add to the incredible weighty amount of legal mumbo-jumbo that exists.

I hope the government will think very hard about what we are trying to do here.

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:55 a.m.

Conservative

Scott Anderson Conservative Vernon—Lake Country—Monashee, BC

Mr. Speaker, we have heard much from the Liberals about how we are obstructing their bills and whatnot, even though they are filibustering their own bills in committee. Usually that means that they are trying to create a narrative that we are obstructing.

Do you feel that we are obstructing or debating this bill?

Lawful Access Act, 2026Government Orders

April 17th, 2026 / 10:55 a.m.

The Deputy Speaker Tom Kmiec

Before I let the member respond, I would like to remind members to speak through the Chair and not directly to members.