My name is Ciara McCormack. I'm a professional soccer player, a whistle-blower and a board member of PFA Canada, the first pro soccer player union in Canada.
As an athlete, I was forced to leave Canada to escape abuse. Today, 16 years later, I live abroad, not feeling safe to stay in Canada, professionally or personally, because of the truth that I have shared.
Online, as I have watched these government hearings and seen countless athletes bravely retraumatize themselves, telling their horrific stories, I can't help but ask myself this: How many more stories will it take for those of you in government to demand a national inquiry and implement real change?
In 2007, I left Canada after reporting abuse by my former Whitecaps and Canadian national team coach, Bob Birarda.
A year later, in 2008, he was fired for sexual misconduct against Canada under-20 national team players, yet inexplicably was allowed by Canada Soccer to continue coaching teenage girls. For 12 years, I and others reported this known predator repeatedly, to no avail.
In February 2019, seeing no other options to get him off the field, I published, in my blog, a story entitled “A Horrific Canadian Soccer Story—The Story No One Wants to Listen To, But Everyone Needs to Hear”. The blog went viral, and victims came forward.
Today Birarda sits in jail, convicted of sex crimes against four former teenage players, over a 20-year period. The last victim was from 2008, the year that the Vancouver Whitecaps and Canada Soccer covered up publicly his departure as a “mutual parting of ways”.
However, the worst of the ordeal was not Birarda's abuse. Rather, it was realizing that for the decade we tried to report Birarda, the silencing we faced wasn't born out of a dysfunctional system, but rather was done with a wilful precision, a system where to play sports in Canada meant and means doing so with a deliberate lack of protection from abuse, as well as the threat of retaliation for speaking out about it.
As I watched a few weeks ago while MPs in this room spoke glowingly to members of Canada's women's national team, I couldn't help but think of Charmaine Hooper. You probably have never heard of her. I bet you didn't know that she was the most decorated player in Canadian soccer in the late 1990s and early 2000s. I bet you also didn't know that in 2006, she and two other players, who together had represented Canada 243 times, didn't show up to a national team game in protest of an abusive national team environment and were thrown off the team. Despite using all of the “proper” resolution channels, including the SDRCC, none of the three ever played for Canada again.
I bet you believe the heroes in Canadian soccer from the last three decades were those scoring goals and winning medals, but I'm here to tell you that the players who deserve your admiration are the ones you've never heard of, the ones who took a brave stand against abusive coaches and administrators with no protection, and lost everything. Their voices and treatment matter equally, if not more than those of the players who stayed silent and played on, and their stories deserve to be told through a national inquiry.
These hearings have outlined rampant conflicts of interest, zero oversight over money, and a massive power imbalance between athletes and the gatekeepers of Canadian sport organizations, causing immense harm. Many of these groups and people have testified or been spoken about during the government hearings in the last few months.
Let me recap some of the learnings, starting with Canadian Soccer Business, a for-profit business that has made a preposterous and secretive 20-year deal with our non-profit NSO, Canada Soccer. The committee is now aware that there is no record in Canada Soccer meeting minutes that this ludicrous deal was ever ratified, and Canada Soccer board members have stated explicitly that they did not sign off on this deal.
We've heard from and about Victor Montagliani. He was found in these hearings to be involved with the above CSB deal. He was also identified in the July 2022 McLaren report to have been directly involved in covering up for a now-convicted sex offender, along with Peter Montopoli, someone who should also be called to answer for his despicable conduct in his time with Canada Soccer. Both continue untouched in their prominent roles at FIFA.
I can't help but wonder this: Will you force us to watch Montopoli and Montagliani take centre stage at the Canadian taxpayer-funded 2026 FIFA World Cup, despite the documented harm they have caused, or will this government step up and take a stand against their behaviour?
Outside soccer, we've heard about for-profit “safe sport” groups such as ITP and Sport Law, operating like wolves in sheep's clothing, that present themselves as a safe place for vulnerable, abused athletes, not revealing that in actuality they are paid by and to protect the interests of sport organizations that have caused these same athletes harm.
Then there's an academic receiving millions in government funding to research safe sport, who, according to a witness who stood before you, attempted to silence him when he came to her with an abuse claim in her role as welfare officer at Gymnastics Canada, an organization riddled with abuse.
There are law firms such as Ruben Thomlinson, displaying zero moral compass, that present their normalized lie to sport abuse victims, such as our group, as doing “independent investigation”, when in reality they're glorified PR jobs with an attorney-client privilege for abusive organizations. Neither fits the definition of either “independent” or an “investigation”. It's a team effort to operate the status quo of harm.
The list goes on and on, so I again ask all of you here today, what will it take for a national inquiry to finally commence, or will this silent complicity by the Canadian government continue?
Those whose egregious actions have been revealed in these committees are hoping that you will forget about their conduct and allow them to retain their money and power, and that in a few short weeks this will all go away. Instead, I'm pleading on behalf of Canadian athletes for you to loudly support a national inquiry, an inquiry that will shine a spotlight on how abuse has been allowed to happen, build a new sports system based on safety, accountability and transparency, and allow people like me to finally feel safe to come home.
Thank you.