Evidence of meeting #46 for Canadian Heritage in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was athletes.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Brown  Associate Deputy Minister, Department of Canadian Heritage

12:20 p.m.

Associate Deputy Minister, Department of Canadian Heritage

Andrew Brown

I'll say two things.

First, Cycling Canada itself is an independent organization in terms of the sorts of decisions that it makes with respect to members of a national team and the participation of our men's and women's national teams in international competitions—in this case, a qualifier for the LA 2028 Olympics.

As well, as I mentioned, the SDRCC is an independent organization hearing about complaints and rendering decisions, so I think it's important that we at Sport Canada acknowledge and recognize the independence of both Cycling Canada and the SDRCC.

12:25 p.m.

Conservative

Ned Kuruc Conservative Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, ON

That's fair enough.

I would urge Sport Canada to have a meeting with the women's track pursuit team. Is that possible? How would that work?

12:25 p.m.

Associate Deputy Minister, Department of Canadian Heritage

Andrew Brown

Certainly, we do speak with national sport organizations such as Cycling Canada on a regular basis. It would probably be less common that we would reach out directly to specific athletes or a team.

12:25 p.m.

Conservative

Ned Kuruc Conservative Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, ON

I appreciate your answer. The only reason I ask is that it has been escalated to the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario, which is a very serious issue. I would advocate that your office meet with them, if possible, because there have not been too many instances where we have seen Canadian athletes, and specifically women athletes, have their cases escalated to the human rights tribunal. I would advocate that, if that's possible.

12:25 p.m.

Associate Deputy Minister, Department of Canadian Heritage

Andrew Brown

I'll certainly take that recommendation away.

At this time, where that team has brought forward a case before the Ontario human rights tribunal, we also need to recognize and respect its own process. I'll note that we wouldn't want to be seen as interfering in that particular process.

12:25 p.m.

Conservative

Ned Kuruc Conservative Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, ON

That's fair enough.

My second question is about Bowl Canada, which has reached out to me. It is a not-for-profit organization.

People may or may not know that five-pin bowling is a Canadian invention. It was invented in 1909 by Canadian Thomas F. Ryan, and it was voted the third-greatest Canadian invention of all time. It's quite fantastic.

Now, this isn't necessarily—

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

We don't have time for an answer to that question, but that was a very good intro.

12:25 p.m.

Conservative

Ned Kuruc Conservative Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, ON

Their funding was stripped, so can you please look into that? It's part of Canadian Heritage.

Thank you very much.

Thank you, Chair, for allowing me to say that.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

That's fair enough. I'm happy to give you that time.

Mr. Myles, you have five minutes.

David Myles Liberal Fredericton—Oromocto, NB

Thank you very much.

Thanks to Mr. Kuruc for bringing new information to the table. I like this committee, because I learn something every single time. I had no idea five-pin bowling was a Canadian invention.

We spoke about this a bit on Tuesday, when Dr. Pipe was here. There's been a philosophical change from Own the Podium to “playground to podium”. There is a difference between those two philosophies. One is based on participation and accessibility, but the idea of making it to the podium still stands. The idea is that we will still produce very competitive athletes.

Mr. Brown, can you or one of your colleagues speak about the shortcomings of the Own the Podium philosophy and why there was a change at this point to a more inclusive, accessible approach?

Thanks.

12:25 p.m.

Associate Deputy Minister, Department of Canadian Heritage

Andrew Brown

I can begin.

This is a really important part of the change. We heard the secretary of state speak already about the pillars: Build, participate, perform, protect and host. Those are the key elements of his vision for the sport system moving forward. Notably, in particular, I'm going to focus on “participate”, “protect” and “perform”.

What we saw was that with some of the changes brought about to the sport system with the creation of Own the Podium before the Vancouver 2010 Olympics, a lot of the efforts of our sport system and our national sport organizations were driven towards performing and getting to the podium. Unfortunately, there were also some negative impacts of that drive towards performance that may have contributed to some of the challenges we've seen in terms of safe sport and thinking about the grassroots and participation. Those are the reasons for the emphasis now on participation and ensuring safe sport, or the “protect” pillar, in particular within the sport system.

These are exactly the sorts of things that the government is doing right now with the additional money that was received through the spring economic update. Additional money going out to our national sport organizations in this fiscal year is providing them additional funds to work on building participation and ensuring safe environments for all participants.

We are not neglecting but are continuing to work towards “perform” as well. That continues to be important, but we need to make sure that these areas that may have been neglected in the past are adequately supported with resources.

It's fair to say that national sport organizations that have already been receiving money are all going to be receiving more money. Those decisions are still being finalized, but that's going to help out all organizations, including Bowl Canada, that have been receiving funding from Sport Canada.

David Myles Liberal Fredericton—Oromocto, NB

It's notable that the podium is still part of that equation, and that it and the idea of high participation are not mutually exclusive.

We've talked about this a little, but to get more into it, how do we work with the provinces and territories effectively to make sure that the participation rates are high? That involves schools and education facilities. What are the roles that the federal government can play in that collaboration?

12:30 p.m.

Associate Deputy Minister, Department of Canadian Heritage

Andrew Brown

That's a wonderful question. There are a number of opportunities for collaboration with provinces and territories, as well as other partners, frankly.

You touched on the infrastructure. That is one of the key pieces itself. As the secretary of state mentioned, about $250 million was set aside, specifically to support sport infrastructure. That's thinking about some of the large projects that have been identified by national sport organizations but also through the build communities strong fund.

There's also funding available at the community level. In fact, the minister spoke with his provincial and territorial counterparts, and we brought our Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada colleagues to that last meeting to talk about what some of the opportunities are, so that should help in terms of the infrastructure.

The next part, though, is how we can actually get more participants in sport. That's something where, again, we're looking at partnerships. This is pushing the national sport organizations to partner with organizations at the local and community levels to get children in particular involved in sport, exactly like the sort of HopOn or Embarquez projects that the secretary of state was talking about. Those are opportunities to introduce people to a range of sports across the country and get them excited.

I could probably turn to my colleagues to see if they'd like to add more on that.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

We don't have time. I'm sorry.

I'm going to turn the floor over to Mr. Lawton for five minutes.

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

Thank you very much, Madam Chair.

Pursuant to the motion on notice, I move:

That, given the prevalence of vandalization, destruction and removal of public statues, monuments and historical landmarks across Canada in recent years, the committee undertake a study, pursuant to Standing Order 108(2), on these incidences and the important role these public symbols play in shaping Canadian heritage and identity; and that the committee dedicate at least four meetings to this study and prepare a comprehensive report with its findings and recommendations.

I'd like to speak to that motion as well, when permitted.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

I will say that the motion is in order. You have given the committee proper notice. I have a speaking list already begun with Mr. Myles, Mrs. Thomas and then Mr. Lawton.

Oh, are you going to start, Mr. Lawton? Okay, go ahead.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

Thank you very much, Madam Chair.

We have seen in the last five years quite a significant wave of vandalism, destruction and removal of public statues and monuments. In some cases, this has been the result of vandals and thugs who are trying to denigrate things that are very dear to communities across this country and to the country itself. Those should be condemned. Criminality should be prosecuted.

The most egregious decisions, however, have been the ones made by lawmakers when city councils, legislatures and governments have capitulated to the mob and, rather than defend this country, have opted to give in and cover up or remove some of these statues. In some cases, we've seen this be undone. We have seen in other cases.... Notably in Kingston, for the last five years, the future of the Sir John A. Macdonald statue is basically unknown. It's been noteworthy that the Liberal whip and member of Parliament for Kingston Mark Gerretsen has not wanted to confront this, has not wanted to speak up for this bit of Canadian heritage, despite being the member for Kingston, which is a city of tremendous value to the story of Canada and the story of John A. Macdonald.

We are now more than ever at a time when people are rallying around the flag and embracing Canadian identity, but we don't get to pick and choose which parts of Canada we get to love and support when we want to be patriotic. We have to acknowledge the founding of our country, the story of our country and people like Sir John A. Macdonald, whose vision really created the country we know today and without whom there would not be a Canada, who worked so hard to keep a very fractious coalition together in Confederation. That coalition has endured, thanks to the work that was done around then by Sir John A. Macdonald.

When we look at examples over the last few years of this, we see the statue of Sir John A. Macdonald in Montreal that was pulled down and spray-painted. Premier Legault at the time was very swift in saying that it should be fixed, repaired and protected. I was very grateful for that, because not a lot of other political leaders were doing that.

In Winnipeg, statues of Queen Victoria and Queen Elizabeth II were pulled down. The late Queen Victoria statue's head was thrown into the Assiniboine River, and that statue was declared beyond repair. Again, there was a lack of political will to put forward the defence that was necessary for that.

In Hamilton, the council voted to keep a statue of Sir John A. Macdonald in Gore Park, but then it was taken down, spray-painted and hammered. Effectively, the mob overruled a decision that was a democratic one. This has happened in Victoria, Vancouver and Toronto.

It has even happened with war memorials. In Surrey, a World War I soldier statue was pushed off the Cloverdale Cenotaph. In Regina, the Victoria Park cenotaph was spray-painted two days in a row. In Chatham, they had a cenotaph that was defaced with swastikas, and this has been a problem that veterans there have acknowledged.

This has also touched some of the communities of the members of Parliament present here. In Mr. Myles' town of Fredericton, I know the Fredericton police were trying to find the people responsible for damage to a legion a couple of years ago. The Legion's Field of Honour memorial was vandalized twice. I believe that was in 2023. In Ms. Royer's riding, in Port Moody, I believe it was—or Coquitlam, I can't remember which.... Actually, it was in Port Coquitlam, so in a neighbouring riding. I apologize. In Port Coquitlam, there is a Terry Fox statue—again, a Canadian icon I think we'd all support—that was vandalized.

Statues and monuments are an important way for us to acknowledge and pay tribute to Canadian heroes, Canadian identity and Canadian heritage. I think it's very important for us, as the heritage committee, to have a study on the scope of this and actually put some leadership forward on how we protect and preserve these pieces of public art.

Thank you, Madam Chair.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you, sir.

Given the amount of time we have left in this committee and given our speaking order list, I will say to the department's sport officials that if they would like to leave, I think we are done with questions for them.

I don't want to force you to stay and listen to this debate that is not related to your roles in Parliament. I thank you for your time today.

We'll move on to the speaking list.

Mr. Hardy, you now have the floor.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

[Technical difficulty—Editor] in Montmorency—Charlevoix. This is the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage, and what has more to do with heritage than Quebec? What has more history than Quebec? As we know, here in Canada, everything began in Quebec. Everything began in my riding, Montmorency—Charlevoix. According to official documents, the first francophone mass was celebrated in Isle‑aux‑Coudres in 1535, when Jacques‑Cartier arrived. The first meeting between the first nations and Champlain took place in Baie‑Sainte‑Catherine in 1603. We have so many historic sites in Montmorency—Charlevoix.

I was very sorry to learn something in recent months. This is an issue I have often raised here: the cross of L'Isle‑aux‑Coudres. It's a cross that was erected almost 100 years ago. We will be celebrating nearly 500 years of history in Isle‑aux‑Coudres in 2035. That cross was dismantled this summer, on the pretext that it was too worn, too dangerous. The amazing thing is that it's a cross made of granite. In theory, stone monuments are supposed to last a very long time when they're properly maintained. That can be seen all over the world. In theory, stone monuments are not supposed to fall apart. However, what has happened in recent years is that there have been cuts, which means that the minimum amount of maintenance was carried out until it became too dangerous to keep the cross in place. Under the pretext that it was dangerous, it was dismantled, but what's surprising is that it was said that the cross would not be rebuilt, because of budget cuts. We're talking about $75 million in cuts that have to be made year after year.

Parks Canada is responsible for that. I have a document that indicates $24.6 million in 2026‑27, $45 million the following year and $75 million for subsequent years. Parks Canada's budgets are being cut, but the result is that, unfortunately, we're told that these monuments will have to be removed because they are too expensive to maintain. If there's one thing a nation must defend, I think it's their history, culture, language and monuments, which enable every generation that follows to know where they come from so that they can better understand where they're going.

I think it's very important for us to do this study, because I think we need to re-emphasize the reasons why our monuments are important. We should talk about how we should maintain them and why, over time, we should be proud to have our monuments and to bring in people, both for tourism and for the history and values that get passed on so that people know where they come from.

Another thing was mentioned in the news. It's the famous statue of Champlain, which has become a major issue across Quebec. It was removed under some pretexts or following discussions in Ontario. This didn't take place in Quebec. Once again, there's a certain desire not to live in the past as it is and to say that this past should be changed. Our monuments and statues are being removed.

I think this is an absolutely necessary and important study. I think we owe it to ourselves, as a committee, but also as Quebeckers and Canadians, to ensure that we pass on to future generations the history of where we come from. We should not hide it, and we should not be ashamed of it. On the contrary, we must maintain it, because I believe that, for us as a nation, it's truly a priority to leave a legacy for future generations and to ensure that we also honour those who, over time, have come before us, with their stories, their strengths and their flaws.

As for the famous Isle‑aux‑Coudres cross, I don't think we should erase crosses from the history of Quebec or Canada. They are part of our history and our values. They have to remain there, and that has to stop being seen as an expense. It has to be seen as an investment. With the Liberals, these are often investments. Well, that's what this is. Investing in keeping our monuments and statues in place is an investment that's more than profitable. If we forget where we come from, we have a serious problem for the future.

This affects me directly, and I think it's very important for this study to take place.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you, Mr. Hardy.

Mr. Myles, you're next on the list.

David Myles Liberal Fredericton—Oromocto, NB

Thank you very much.

Thanks to all the members, and thank you to Mr. Lawton and Monsieur Hardy for the thoughts.

I share the same concern. I think many of us do. I'm a member of the Legion in Oromocto, part of my riding. I'm a proud member of the Legion. I share the same concerns.

We've been really good in this committee in terms of good faith, with what motions are coming next, what studies are coming next. We've talked about this in committee business. We have been working towards other motions and are getting there. I think it's important for us to continue that work and our gentlemen's agreement, as we have we spoken about. Though this is an important study, and I think we all share the concerns, I would move to adjourn this debate so we can talk to the others.

I know you think that's funny, but the good-faith agreement that we've talked about in the gentlemen's agreement.... I think good faith goes both ways, without surprises, without these kinds of things—

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Mr. Myles, given that you've already moved to adjourn debate, you can't continue to debate.

David Myles Liberal Fredericton—Oromocto, NB

Thank you very much. Then we can talk about Bill S-211, and we can get ourselves sorted for what the program will say to that.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

It is a dilatory motion. We will go to a vote on whether to adjourn debate on this topic.

(Motion agreed to: yeas 6; nays 5)

The motion has carried.

Mr. Myles.

David Myles Liberal Fredericton—Oromocto, NB

I wonder if we might take a second to speak about the timing of Bill S-211. We spoke about it just briefly. I'll just lay out what we were thinking. I know there was a bit of confusion at the end of the last meeting, and I just want to address that. I apologize for the confusion, first and foremost.

What we are proposing is, as we said last week, two days of the study. What it would look like would be that the first hour would be the presenters of the bill. We would add witnesses for only one hour of the first meeting. The second meeting would be clause-by-clause—I was saying line by line before, I'm learning—and amendments, because we do have some amendments. I think there are some simple amendments from your side. None of them are too complicated.

I would suggest that if we get through clause-by-clause and amendments, we are prepared to go to a draft report, because we have draft reports to get through. If we don't, and if it takes the two hours, it takes the two hours. I think, either way, we're into that second meeting. That's what we're proposing, and I'm happy to hear your thoughts on it.