Thank you, Madam Chair.
This is a very important motion that fits squarely within the mandate of the heritage committee, and I will say that the reason I'm moving this now is because earlier in this meeting I attempted to move another motion that dealt specifically with some of the attacks facing faith communities. I had started to mention attacks on churches, mosques and synagogues in the ridings of the members around the table here, representing a range of faiths. When that was ruled out of order, it actually raised what I am concerned is a very dangerous precedent, which is that we do not recognize the integral role that faith and faith communities play in the cultural fabric of this country.
I would note that this committee has in the past entertained motions, debates and discussions on hate crimes, on matters to do with the Criminal Code. I have a list of motions that I found just in the last 30 minutes that have been accepted, debated and sometimes adopted, from members on both sides, dealing with the Criminal Code. Oftentimes, when assaults on identity and heritage take place, these are illegal, but we have to underpin that with an acknowledgement of the role that these organizations play.
I remember when one of your colleagues, Marc Miller at the justice committee—about a year ago to the day, actually—said that people should face criminal prosecution for quoting certain verses of the Torah and the Bible. A lot of faith communities were understandably mortified by that comment from someone who's now the minister responsible for Canadian heritage and identity because it showed a lack of recognition of the positive role that faith communities and people of faith play in this country.
A few weeks ago, the St. Thomas Islamic Centre, a Muslim mosque, hosted an interfaith gathering that I was very honoured to attend. We had representatives of Christian groups, Sikh groups and Hindu groups sitting in a mosque talking about the way that faith communities can work together to support the betterment of society. We also have, of course, opportunities all the time as members to go to various celebrations. We need to understand that, but we also need to understand the attacks that take place against faith communities.
I mentioned the Afzaal family's murder in London. I mentioned the attack at the Quebec Islamic centre. I also mentioned the 133 churches that have been burned and vandalized, including, as I was starting to say earlier, in Madame Auguste's riding.
I believe that in Hamilton we've seen Hindu temples subjected to break-ins and thefts. The Beth Jacob Synagogue was defaced with hate graffiti. The Hamilton Downtown Mosque...and arson as well at the First Unitarian Church. As well, at St. John the Baptist Catholic Church, there was a break-in. Altars were burned. There was about $75,000 in damage.
All of us on this committee have examples of this in our ridings. I've noted that there seems to be an imbalance in when political leaders speak out about these. I think we need to stand up for hate against all faith communities. I would have argued to have a study on this. Now, that was not the prerogative for the chair, but we do need to, at a minimum, recognize the role that faith communities play.
This is incredibly timely now because we have seen the finance committee in the last Parliament recommend that faith organizations not be allowed to have charitable status.
Fortunately, with the prorogation and dissolution of Parliament, that recommendation died. I will note, however, that the finance committee's pre-budget consultation in this Parliament did have a provision that organizations that have a particular view on matters of life should be denied charitable status. If we start making the determination that charitable status should be dependent on the views of an organization in matters of conscience, we are de-legitimizing the role that faith and religion play in Canadian society.
This does not mean that everyone needs to adhere to a faith or a religion, not at all, but we need to recognize the tremendous work that faith-based organizations do, whether it's Indwell on housing, The Salvation Army or the individual mosques, synagogues and temples that are running food programs to deal with the food affordability crisis that has been allowed, sadly, to blossom on the Liberal government's watch.
All of this is why I think that, at a minimum, this committee needs to recognize the role that faith institutions play in our country, and that is a positive role.
