Are you familiar with section 8 of that agreement? It stipulates that the agreement may only be amended or terminated by the unanimous consent of Ottawa and the provinces. As things stand, there is no consent. We'd be voting on a bill that would have no effect because Quebec will not consent to interference in its areas of jurisdiction. Advertising, gambling and health all fall under the jurisdiction of Quebec and the provinces. I raise these concerns because, even though the bill targets advertising, the underlying objective is clearly to encroach on provincial areas of jurisdiction. Your bill has implications for health care. That's why I have serious reservations and why we don't support this proposal at all.
I know it's well intentioned and you're doing this because you care, and that's commendable. Earlier, my colleague, Mr. Coteau, talked about some things he observed when he was at the Ontario Legislative Assembly. However, good intentions alone don't make something relevant. I haven't found any grounds on which to support this proposal, and I can assure you that I've tried, Senator Deacon. Everything in it falls under the jurisdiction of Quebec and the provinces.
Earlier, you said something I found very interesting. You said that the world has changed, that the reality of communications, particularly with the Internet, has changed and that the provinces' rules around advertising no longer apply because there are no borders. That's simply not the case. The scope of states' and nations' jurisdiction is readily defined by territory. Quebec can enact regulations and laws governing advertising that apply within its borders and do not apply to Ontario, which has its own rules.
One example of that is the ban on advertising to children, which has been in effect for decades. It's in effect in Quebec—and pretty much everywhere else—and if ads aimed at children appear on online platforms, they're quickly reported and removed. Existing laws and regulations are as effective as they can be in today's digital environment.
Even on that point, where I had hoped to find grounds for supporting Bill S‑211, I came away empty-handed. I don't see any way in which this bill respects the jurisdiction of Quebec and the provinces in these areas.
I would even argue that reopening this issue is risky, given that the 1985 agreement was the result of a lengthy dispute. From 1973 to 1985, there was disagreement on this issue. The parties had to negotiate and, ultimately, they decided that responsibility for regulating gambling, lotteries and the like would belong to the provinces. Each province approaches these matters according to its societal values, priorities and circumstances, which aren't the same in Nova Scotia or British Columbia as they are in Quebec or Alberta, and that's entirely appropriate.
When I hear that the gambling industry itself, as well as representatives from several provinces, have raised concerns and aren't in favour of the idea, that's a warning sign. With all due respect, I applaud your idea and your dedication to this issue. I know your intentions are sincere and your objective is worthy, but, unfortunately, this bill encroaches on the jurisdictions of Quebec and the provinces, so I can't support it.
Thank you.
