Thank you, Chair.
The motion that my colleague has moved here today has to do with public concern that has grown in this country around the increase in censorship that is happening at the hands of the current government and the encroachment on freedom of expression within Canada. In particular, he is drawing special attention to religious freedom and the conversation around that.
Here's why it's so important. When speech is restricted, when Canadians are not able to hold a variety of viewpoints and express those viewpoints freely, it then actually restricts the flow of ideas, and it puts instead a dangerous amount of power in the hands of government. It puts a concentration of power in the hands of government.
I'll give you an example.
Bill C-11 was put in place by the Liberals. It requires that certain online content be given preference over other content. This government would argue that, even though certain preference is given, it's not taking the speech away altogether. For example, certain content will have to be bumped up in a person's search, and it will be given preference on the very first page of your search. However, other content will fall to page 53. Now, we all know that we don't read to page 53 when we do a quick Google search. As a result, this actually is censoring speech because it's giving preference to some over others.
It's akin to saying that, in a library, all books can exist. We believe in a myriad of viewpoints. They can be here. However, there are certain books that will be allowed on the first floor, and certain that will be allowed on the second, and certain allowed on the third. Then there will be this other category of books that will be tucked away in a storage room somewhere in a back corner. If you dare search for it, you'll find it. Then we claim that all books are treated with equal value, that all people who would use this library would be given equal access to these different ideas.
In fact, is that the protection of free speech? Is that protection of all ideas and viewpoints? I would argue no. I believe most Canadians would agree with that.
It's like saying to someone that they have free speech, the ability to share an idea with the general population. However, the only place from which they can speak is in some basement room with a locked door. Do they have the ability to speak? Absolutely, they have the ability to speak. This government would contend that free speech is protected.
There's another side to be considered, however. Within our charter, we not only have the right to express an idea; we have the right to be heard. By locking that person in a basement room with a locked door, yes, they had the ability to speak, but they did not have the ability to be heard. Bill C-11 does exactly that within the online space. It's a direct infringement on our rights and freedoms as Canadians.
Now, we are looking at other bills that potentially do the same. We'll have an opportunity to talk about those more at this committee. Our concern on this side of the table is this. When legislation is put in place that slowly but surely erodes the rights and freedoms of Canadians and their ability to hold a true belief and express that belief publicly, we enter into a very dangerous space.
The public square should be an area where we are able to join as a community, as a country, etc. and exchange ideas. Maybe we disagree, and that's great. Let's have the debate. To shut down that debate is altogether wrong. In fact, it can actually cause the problem to fester even more. The search for truth should be done in the public square. It should be done in that robust place rather than pushing people to the fringes where potentially harm and violence can fester and come forward.
Further to that, when infringement on free speech takes place, or when government overreaches, it causes people to censor their own voice. It causes them to go small. It causes them to go quiet. In many cases, it causes certain religious groups or certain faith groups to shrink back. Bill C-9 is a great example of this. It was put forward by this government in the name of wanting to protect faith groups, but in fact it actually causes many faith groups to shrink back, because the provisions within that bill allow for the potential prosecution of holding certain beliefs and of those beliefs reaching public airwaves.
This is a problem in our country. If we cannot agree to protect one another's right to believe certain things, to engage in certain faiths, of our choice as the Canadian people, if we do not respect that freedom, then we enter into a very dangerous place as a nation. It very quickly takes us towards countries like North Korea, Iran, Turkey and China. We do not want to go there.
The motion that my colleague Mr. Lawton has moved here today with regard to a study on this issue is very important. We must make sure that we are in fact protecting Canadians and their ability to believe what they want to believe, to speak what they want to speak, to exist within the rights and freedoms that are granted to them in the charter. Let's take the time. Let's look at that and make sure that our country is doing well.
