Yes. You're talking about 2019, but I'd like to go back to 2009, because that's when the Government of Canada committed to eliminating inefficient fossil fuel subsidies. In all that time, the government has yet to come up with a real definition.
In our sessions on this topic, we had witnesses who had a very simple definition: any benefit to the oil and gas industry is a fossil fuel subsidy.
I won't hide that I strongly disagree with your broad analysis of inefficient subsidies. The ultimate goal is not to reduce oil's carbon intensity, but to begin the transition. We have no choice but to make that transition.
In addition, witnesses told us that Canada's financial support for the oil and gas industry is 14.5 times higher than its financial support for the renewable energy sector. This is basically a disincentive to innovate in renewable energy. Are you restoring the balance between funding to the oil and gas sector, which is currently far too high, and the renewable energy sector, which is far too low?