Thank you, Chair and committee members.
My name is Luke Mari. I’m a professional planner and land economist, and the managing principal of Aryze Developments in Victoria. We are a real estate developer and builder of market-rate and affordable housing, and about 50% of our projects are non-profit or first nation collaborations.
To be clear, I am not an energy engineer. My perspective is from the point where good policy has to intersect with the economics of financing, building and operating housing. Done well, retrofits are not simply climate policy. They're housing policy, affordability policy, resiliency policy and economic development policy at the same time.
I think it's helpful to begin with a simple principle: Technology either helps us use less energy or helps us produce more energy. We should be clear about which problem we're trying to solve and choose a solution accordingly.
For existing buildings, the first opportunity is often to reduce the amount of energy the building needs. Better windows, improved envelopes, heat pumps and ventilation can all lower energy use and emissions, but they also improve the everyday quality of life for residents, including indoor temperatures, air quality, moisture and mould, and resiliency during extreme heat and cold events. The challenge is that there is a large gap between a retrofit that makes technical sense and one that will actually happen, and that barrier is often capital.
Financing has to match the housing. That is especially true for non-profits and co-operative housing. Many organizations own aging buildings occupied by people paying deeply affordable rents. Those rents simply do not generate enough cash flow to support the debt required for major capital improvements. A loan alone does not solve that problem. Programs that combine low-cost financing with meaningful forgivable contributions can. We have seen federal programs provide forgivable funding of up to $85,000 per unit for deep retrofits, and that funding has been fully subscribed. To me, that's an argument for continuing and expanding the model, not walking away from it.
Private rental housing has a different version of the same problem. The landlord pays for windows, insulation or mechanical systems, while the tenant often receives the benefit through lower utility costs and a better home. In a regulated rental market, the owner may have limited ability to recover that investment. This is what we typically refer to as a split incentive problem.
Financing programs should reward measurable energy improvements, but they also need to be stable. Owners cannot plan five- and 10-year capital programs in the future around incentives that constantly change names, rules or eligibility.
There's another issue we need to talk about, and that's embodied carbon.
We built one of Victoria, B.C.'s first passive homes, and one of the products we used was called XPS insulation. After the project was built, we came to understand that the greenhouse gas emissions associated with manufacturing that product were so high that the home's operational carbon savings were estimated to take roughly 300 years to offset that product alone.
We're good builders, but that building will not last 300 years. That illustrates an important blind spot. If we measure only the energy a product saves after installation but ignore the carbon emitted to manufacture it, we can make decisions that look green on an energy model but are not green on a whole-life carbon basis.
That also creates a great opportunity for Canada. We are one of the world's great forested nations. We produce an enormous amount of quality wood fibre and sawmill residue, much of which goes to relatively low-value uses, or we just burn it. Canada could move that material up the value chain by becoming a leader in high-performance wood-fibre insulation and other low-carbon building products. These products are common in Europe but very expensive and emissions-intensive to import to Canada.
Wood-fibre insulation can reduce operating energy while storing biogenic carbon in buildings for decades. That is climate policy and industrial policy at the same time: Canadian forestry, Canadian manufacturing, Canadian jobs and lower-carbon buildings.
We also need to remove surprisingly mundane regulatory barriers. Adding exterior insulation to an existing building makes an existing wall thicker. In some municipalities, that thickness can trigger a setback variance or reduce the allowable floor area in a building, triggering expensive planning processes. It should not take months or years of approvals simply to make an existing building more energy-efficient.
Finally, while the study is focused on retrofits, we cannot lose sight of new construction. Retrofits are important, but a new building is one of the longest environmental commitments that we can make. Every new building is tomorrow's existing building. The envelope, mechanical systems and materials we choose today may remain in service for 60, 80 or 100 years. While we improve the buildings we already have, we should put equal effort into making sure the buildings we add today are designed to perform for the long term. The cheapest retrofit is the one we never have to undertake because we built it properly in the first place.
My recommendations are simple. Make retrofit programs stable. Use grants where financing tools alone cannot work. Measure whole-life carbon. Remove unnecessary regulatory barriers. Use federal policy to help Canada become a manufacturing leader in the low-carbon building materials market, which we need here and around the world.
I have lots more to say, but I'll reserve it for Q and A.
Thank you.
