Evidence of meeting #53 for Environment and Sustainable Development in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.)

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Keith  Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual
Zitner  General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada
Jarvis  Vice-President, External Affairs, pHathom Technologies Inc.
Lawton  Emeritus Professor, Carbon Management Canada
Kravtsov  Chief Executive Officer, CarbonCure Technologies Inc.
Philip  Vice-President, Community and Government Relations, Planetary Technologies

4:10 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

I don't have a magic answer. I'll give you one example from work I'm doing now.

As many of you may know, I founded a Canadian company called Carbon Engineering. While I had that hat on, I don't think we told any lies, but of course I would try to put the best case forward for CE's version of technology. Now, at UChicago, I have a lot of resources to work on, for example, open ocean alkalinity, on which we are in co-operation with Frontier, a big entity that has about $1 billion to spend on purchase commitments for this. We're actually funding a Canadian company, Sacré-Davey, to do an engineering analysis of the costs of large-scale lime production for open ocean alkalinity, just to give you that example. That's the kind of work that I think individual companies don't do, because the kind of work we're doing in this joint thing with UChicago and Sacré-Davey will be all public information, dealing with trying to assess the cost of very large-scale open ocean alkalinity in the long run. It's also something that regular academia doesn't do, because regular academia can't work with industrial contractors very well.

Maybe that's overselling our own work here, but I think there's a need in Canada for institutions like this.

David Bexte Conservative Bow River, AB

I'm almost out of time, Professor Keith, and I have one more question.

The environment I'm looking at.... I'm a farmer in southern Alberta. I grow biomass like crazy every year, yet I don't get credit for incorporating biochar into the soil. There are so many different industries that have intersections, potentially, and our way of evaluating is just inadequate.

Thank you very much.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you, Mr. Bexte. We're out of time on that one.

We'll go to you, Mr. Fanjoy, for five minutes, please.

Bruce Fanjoy Liberal Carleton, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Dr. Keith, I'd like to begin with you. You began to discuss a particular use case of cement, and I want to give you some time to finish that thought.

4:15 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

I was going to say that in terms of.... This is a response to ask, essentially, why we should do CCS if renewables are cheaper. The answer is that it's complicated. Renewables are not always cheaper by any means.

Cement is a particular case in which CCS does something that you essentially can't do any other way. The emissions from cement come from process emissions, and we need cement. The only plausible way, in my view, to reduce that is to do CCS on cement plants.

Bruce Fanjoy Liberal Carleton, ON

Okay. Thank you.

A couple of witnesses mentioned the importance of cutting emissions and that this is where our first focus needs to be. To the extent that industry is focusing on carbon capture and storage, do you think that this will have a neutral impact on cutting emissions? Will it delay the cutting of emissions or advance them?

Maybe I'll turn to you, Ms. Zitner.

4:15 p.m.

General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada

Miriam Zitner

Our understanding is that there needs to be about 1,000 gigatonnes of removals to meet climate standards. We've already exceeded 1.5°C, and I think nobody here is disagreeing that cuts are required. I think the reality is that cuts alone won't get us where we need to get to, so IPCC and others are saying that we must do removals. It's not now a question of either-or; it's a question of “and”.

As per David Keith's testimony at the beginning, now is the time to test and try small-scale deployment technologies to see which ones will advance, which ones work, which ones might not work, which ones can scale and under what conditions they can scale. We need to do that R and D now.

Bruce Fanjoy Liberal Carleton, ON

Thank you.

Ms. Zitner, what are the ecological risks of storing vast quantities of carbon in marine environments?

4:15 p.m.

General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada

Miriam Zitner

I think you're asking two questions. One is about scale—you used the word “vast”—and the other is about risk.

In the Bedford Basin in Nova Scotia, there have been small-scale deployments, and Planetary will speak with you about this later this afternoon. The deployments have been verified by Isometric, which David also suggests there should be some conversation around. We have information based on that scale of deployment, and Carbon to Sea is looking at creating a global research network to try to determine what the impacts are in different regions and in different seasonalities, temperatures and salinities. The research is still early, and it needs to be scrutinized globally if it is going to scale and be a viable climate solution.

What I can tell you is that in the Bedford Basin, independent academic researchers' data suggests that there is no harm at the volume of the dosing that has occurred now.

I want to add that I do think that we invite the engagement, scrutiny and objectivity that you all wish for as well, and you would have heard me invite your attention on this. If you have questions, it would behoove you to develop the systems to objectively find those answers and to develop independent MRV protocols that meet your standards.

Bruce Fanjoy Liberal Carleton, ON

I grew up next to the Bedford Basin, so I'm glad to hear that it's doing fine.

Mr. Jarvis, would you like to comment on ecological risks?

4:20 p.m.

Vice-President, External Affairs, pHathom Technologies Inc.

Alastair Jarvis

Yes, thank you.

Earlier, I was going to share that we work with the Huntsman Marine Science Centre in New Brunswick. At the moment, under the Fisheries Act, the onus is on us, as a company, to build the evidence that regulators require in the compliance regime. We've run toxicity testing across a range of species, including algae, zooplankton, urchins, lobster larvae and mussels. We do that testing against different concentrations of total alkalinity in order to set a safe design threshold and then identify the margin below it that we can design to. Again, the stressor we tested is the increase in total alkalinity above the ambient level. We'll publish those results soon.

To your question on emissions versus carbon removal, it isn't either-or. What's been made clear to us by the IPCC scenarios is that we have to eliminate the emissions where we can and remove carbon where we can't. It is going to take some time, as has been identified, to identify the portfolio of technologies that will be required to achieve our carbon removal goals, because—as we also heard—none of these individual technologies alone can achieve the scale we need within the planetary boundaries that constrain each of these pathways.

We're—

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you, Mr. Jarvis. I'm sorry, but we're out of time.

We need to double our time for these technical conversations.

Mr. Bonin, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Patrick Bonin Bloc Repentigny, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Mr. Keith, you talked about biomass and the potential ecological impact of extracting it.

Can you tell us more about that?

I'd like you talk about, among other things, carbon emissions related to soil disturbance and the resulting emissions, as well as emissions related to the part of the biomass that would not be recovered and sequestered, for example.

What kind of footprint does that leave? I'd like you to talk about biodiversity.

4:20 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

The basic impact of extracting biomass is this: You cut down and use the standing biomass, which means you've interfered with the natural processes. That's the most general statement. Beyond that, it depends on the specifics. Extracting peat, as has been done in some cultures for a very long time, is very different from cutting fast-growing softwood, which is different from cutting wood in the boreal forest. There are very different impacts in different places.

The general thing to say is that there are competing demands for land. We need agriculture. We need recreation. We want to leave some land for nature. Using land for biomass energy is another land use. The economists teach us that there's no free lunch, and those competitions always have trade-offs. There are consequences to the large-scale use of biomass energy.

I wonder if I can say one thing that builds on prior discussion and give you a sense of the scale of effort on CCS versus cutting emissions or on carbon removal versus emissions.

Right now, globally, the world is spending about $2 trillion, or almost 2% of the global economy, on clean energy, which is a fantastic, amazing victory. It's the reason emissions will probably peak in the next couple of years. It's an enormous win. However, the total amount of money on all work, globally, on long-term carbon removal efforts is only a few billion dollars a year. As I said at the beginning, I absolutely agree that we shouldn't think we're going to distract ourselves from emissions cuts by carbon removal, but if we think carbon removal is important in the long term, it makes sense to spend 1% now. That would be over $10 billion a year globally—I'm not saying in Canada, since it's proportional—on capital for emissions cuts and testing out how different carbon removal methods work. That way, we can understand what happens and give our kids the chance to make decisions a few decades later.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you, Mr. Keith, for your answer.

We'll now go to Mr. Rowe for five minutes.

4:20 p.m.

Conservative

Jonathan Rowe Conservative The Eastern Peninsulas, NL

Thank you.

My first question is for Ms. Zitner.

It's great to see you taking advantage of, or using, our ocean. Newfoundland was founded on its ocean. Coming from a coastal riding, I think this is the answer to our future as well.

I see that there are other techniques. You guys are basically inserting stuff in the ocean to increase carbon capture in the ocean. We see some theories out there saying that plankton growth can also contribute to carbon storage. You insert certain minerals in the water, and then plankton can grow. Then they die and fall to the bottom of the ocean. It can be stored for centuries.

Are you guys looking into that kind of storage as well, or are you very much on alkaline chemical storage?

4:25 p.m.

General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada

Miriam Zitner

We are very much focused on ocean alkalinity enhancement.

4:25 p.m.

Conservative

Jonathan Rowe Conservative The Eastern Peninsulas, NL

Do you think those can work together?

4:25 p.m.

General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada

Miriam Zitner

There are some interesting questions about marine spatial planning—who is doing what, and where, and what is the state of R and D for each of the possible carbon removal technologies that require a system-wide assessment? When you hear me talking about engagement and inviting the Canadian government to get engaged, it is to come together to answer these kinds of questions, because, as it stands....

I used to work with technology companies. We'd talk about point systems. One technology is doing this, and other one is doing that. We're putting it together. It would be great to see consolidation and government-led initiates to assess, evaluate and develop.

4:25 p.m.

Conservative

Jonathan Rowe Conservative The Eastern Peninsulas, NL

For that type of carbon capture, one of the leading inputs for plankton growth is actually mammal manure. When whales release their manure, it increases plankton growth. Now, in Newfoundland and Labrador, we have the federal government trying to reduce mammal manure going into our oceans, which I think would actually decrease plankton growth and decrease the amount of carbon that would go through to our oceans. I was hoping you could speak to that, but I'll pivot to something more in your arena.

Do you use crushed rocks or crushed minerals, perhaps from old existing mines, to do what you are doing?

4:25 p.m.

General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada

Miriam Zitner

Yes, we do, exactly.

There is research under way to take a look at exactly that to figure out which feedstocks are the best to use, like alkalizing minerals. We have been using magnesium hydroxide, and we're moving to calcium-based ones. A lot of the companies that are working in this space are looking at waste feedstock.

We tend to look at proximity to the dispersal site. You want to make sure you're quite clear about the LCA and, for lack of a more scientific word, the cleaning process. When you're using waste materials, you really need to take a look at trace metals. You might have differences in composition between batches from one waste source to another. It requires the kind of R and D that philanthropy is funding, the R and D that we are thinking about and that I urge all of us here to consider.

In the end, if it can be demonstrated that OAE is a viable climate solution, we are going to have to figure out a multiplicity of things, including the scale, the best feedstock to use, the best partnerships and whether to create independent MRV. These things need to be figured out.

4:25 p.m.

Conservative

Jonathan Rowe Conservative The Eastern Peninsulas, NL

I think there's an opportunity there for our mining industry to be much more profitable if we can put our waste into the ocean immediately and then help carbon storage. I understand what you're saying about needing a process. I'd be curious about the economics of that, if you want to submit that later.

However, I want to give my last minute to my colleague Branden Leslie.

4:25 p.m.

Conservative

Branden Leslie Conservative Portage—Lisgar, MB

Thank you.

Madam Chair, if you seek it, I believe you will find unanimous consent, based on previous discussions, for the following motion:

That the Chair report to the House requesting that the committee be formally designated to undertake the statutory review required by section 27.1 of the Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act.

I will give my remaining time back to my colleague.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

You have 30 seconds.

4:25 p.m.

Conservative

Jonathan Rowe Conservative The Eastern Peninsulas, NL

Mr. Keith, I'm curious about the tonnes of carbon storage versus the kilowatts produced. What is that looking like right now at today's best capacity, and what are you hoping for in the near future?