The basic impact of extracting biomass is this: You cut down and use the standing biomass, which means you've interfered with the natural processes. That's the most general statement. Beyond that, it depends on the specifics. Extracting peat, as has been done in some cultures for a very long time, is very different from cutting fast-growing softwood, which is different from cutting wood in the boreal forest. There are very different impacts in different places.
The general thing to say is that there are competing demands for land. We need agriculture. We need recreation. We want to leave some land for nature. Using land for biomass energy is another land use. The economists teach us that there's no free lunch, and those competitions always have trade-offs. There are consequences to the large-scale use of biomass energy.
I wonder if I can say one thing that builds on prior discussion and give you a sense of the scale of effort on CCS versus cutting emissions or on carbon removal versus emissions.
Right now, globally, the world is spending about $2 trillion, or almost 2% of the global economy, on clean energy, which is a fantastic, amazing victory. It's the reason emissions will probably peak in the next couple of years. It's an enormous win. However, the total amount of money on all work, globally, on long-term carbon removal efforts is only a few billion dollars a year. As I said at the beginning, I absolutely agree that we shouldn't think we're going to distract ourselves from emissions cuts by carbon removal, but if we think carbon removal is important in the long term, it makes sense to spend 1% now. That would be over $10 billion a year globally—I'm not saying in Canada, since it's proportional—on capital for emissions cuts and testing out how different carbon removal methods work. That way, we can understand what happens and give our kids the chance to make decisions a few decades later.
