Thank you very much.
I'm David Keith. I'm a Canadian based in Canmore, Alberta, but I'm speaking to you today from the University of Chicago, where I lead the climate systems engineering initiative, which is perhaps the most ambitious effort at a big research university to build climate engineering as a field. That includes open-system carbon removal.
I've worked in climate more or less full time since 1990. In the early 2000s, I was one of the first people to realize that combining biomass energy with carbon capture and storage would produce something radically new—a power plant that could remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and move the carbon to long-term storage. I and others helped to push these ideas and other methods into the climate policy system through the IPCC, and they were adopted into models of energy decarbonization.
In 2009, still as a professor at University of Calgary, I founded Carbon Engineering, which became one of the major companies working on direct air capture. The plant using that technology would capture half a million tonnes a year from the air and is now commissioning in west Texas. That company was sold, and I'm no longer involved in it.
About a decade ago, climate modelers tasked with assessing how the world might meet the newly signed Paris commitment to a goal of 1.5°C relied on models that had the biomass energy with CCS. This is technology that I and others had worked on. Because those models showed a huge reliance on these, this catapulted carbon removal into the mainstream, and it became a hot topic among businessmen and politicians concerned with climate change.
An academic idea, if you like, had gone from obscurity to, I think, some overhype within about a decade. The overhype brought sensible criticism that carbon removal served industry and the status quo by holding out the promise that climate commitments could be met by substituting vague promises of future removals for emissions cuts today.
Now, as the carbon removal bubble is somewhat deflating, it's easy to dismiss the technology. My view is that this dismissal would be a mistake, because carbon removal is a unique tool in the climate solutions tool box. It's the only way that we can move the atmosphere back towards its pre-industrial state, making the atmosphere more like that in which humans and every species now alive evolved. I see it, then, as an essential part of the climate tool box if we wish to help to restore the natural world back from these impacts.
What should Canada do to advance carbon removal? I just got invited to do this on the last day. My understanding is that the topic here is carbon removal, but it sounds like maybe it's more about carbon capture and storage, which I have also worked on, but it is not what I'm addressing most now.
My view is that large-scale deployment of carbon removal makes little sense until the latter half of this century, when emissions have been substantially reduced. In the near term, our focus should overwhelmingly be on cutting emissions, and the goal for the next few decades for carbon removal should be not to deploy the technology at scale but to figure out which carbon removal technologies could be scaled up to this gigatonne-a-year scale with acceptably low cost and low environmental impacts while we maintain the focus on cutting emissions.
Much of the current policy framework supporting carbon removal aims to help various small companies grow gradually into larger markets, and this is complemented with funding for academic research. I'm somewhat skeptical of this framework. The niches, which make sense for small companies to develop under these current voluntary and other carbon markets—however well intentioned, however hard people work at them—may not do that much to advance the learning needed to enable large-scale, environmentally sound CDR later in the century. Academic research is often far too dominated by theory and is insufficiently grounded in practical engineering.
I suggest that Canadian policy-makers who want to advance these technologies rethink this strategy and think hard about how to develop publicly funded efforts towards technology development within environmental constraints. That might look quite different from the current policy environment.
I look forward to answering questions. Thank you.
