Evidence of meeting #53 for Environment and Sustainable Development in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.)

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Keith  Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual
Zitner  General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada
Jarvis  Vice-President, External Affairs, pHathom Technologies Inc.
Lawton  Emeritus Professor, Carbon Management Canada
Kravtsov  Chief Executive Officer, CarbonCure Technologies Inc.
Philip  Vice-President, Community and Government Relations, Planetary Technologies

October 29th, 2026 / 4:25 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

For large-scale open ocean alkalinity, when we're turning limestone or dolomite into a hydroxide that goes into the ocean, there's very strong evidence from oceanographers that it could have very low environmental impacts and create permanent storage, which is why I see it as one of the more important kinds of storage. In this case, you're looking at a bit more than two kilowatt hours net per tonne reduced, assuming you've captured the CO2, if I did the math in my head correctly.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you, Mr. Keith. Thank you, Mr. Rowe.

Mr. St‑Pierre, you have the floor for five minutes.

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Dr. Keith, as someone I've known before and who lives in Canmore, I consider you to be Canadian. I wanted to get that on the record.

4:30 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

I want to thank you for the great work. I was recently listening to the Canadian podcast that you're involved in, Energy vs Climate. Thank you for your contribution to Canadian climate policy.

Can you comment on the cost of carbon removal? Specifically, can you comment on the current cost of certain CDR technologies or processes? What cost do we need to get to in order to make it more marketable? Where is it right now, and where should we get it to?

4:30 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

For many of the technologies now, we really don't have a meaningful answer to the question of where we are, because they're for very small projects.

There are two parts to this. I'd say for direct air capture, the answer is that the cost is many hundreds of dollars per tonne for projects that would be executed now. I think it's plausible that costs could come down quite a lot. Part of that depends on access to very cheap energy, which is likely solar power in sunny places. I think that's a realistic prospect, but it's moving a few steps further away in time.

For open ocean alkalinity, we've been thinking a lot about the cost assessment recently. There are good reasons to believe it's possible that without any fundamental technological advance in the process we have in place today, the cost could be on the order of $100 a tonne, but we simply haven't done much of the engineering. Really, very little has been done on the engineering of the large-scale dispersal of materials in the open ocean, and it's possible that there's actually no cost-effective way to do it. People just have not done the engineering for real.

In terms of the cost that we need to get to, I keep coming back to $100 a tonne as a nice benchmark. If we wanted to remediate some of the environmental damage we did by putting carbon dioxide in, in a world after 2050, when emissions are coming down, we would need to think as humanity about removing something like 1,000 gigatonnes—a teratonne—of CO2 over a long time, maybe a century, so that would be 10 gigatonnes a year. If you got to $100 a tonne, you'd be spending about 1% of the global economy on that.

It's not crazy to imagine that people would spend 1% of the global economy on this kind of long-term environmental cleanup. That's comparable to some other environmental costs, and it's comparable to what some developed societies have spent on different kinds of foreign aid or national parks protection that didn't have an immediate economic utility. You can hope that people would pay that.

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

Okay.

Very quickly, maybe in a minute, I'm curious about this: If we got it down to $100 a tonne, do you think government policy should play a role, or should we be leaving it to voluntary corporate initiatives?

I think of what a company like Stripe does, with multi-year advance purchase agreements for early-stage start-ups.

What role should governments play, and the federal government especially?

4:30 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

The government's role is fundamental. This is a classic externality problem in economics. Stripe and Frontier do the same thing, and I work closely with those people. I don't think there's any prospect that the voluntary market will play a significant long-term role. It just can't. According to corporate law, companies are meant to be maximizing profit, and they can't be spending a huge amount on voluntary emissions reductions. That's just not the way we deal with environmental problems. This will be government policy, and we'll have a big fight to make it so.

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

Thank you.

Ms. Zitner, I'm really curious about seaweed or kelp. My colleagues may laugh at me for talking about seaweed, but kelp is one of those nature-based solutions that grows very quickly and absorbs a significant amount of ocean CO2.

Are there realistic ways of scaling kelp? I'm looking at my colleague from Halifax, who might get excited about this. What federal policy levers are at our disposal for ocean-based solutions?

4:30 p.m.

General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada

Miriam Zitner

I've spent the last four years working with the private sector, academic institutions, philanthropy organizations and buyers on ocean alkalinity enhancement that uses alkalizing minerals and doses those into seawater. I have to admit that I don't have expertise on the question that you've asked. I can certainly ask others and get back to you via email.

Eric St-Pierre Liberal Honoré-Mercier, QC

Thank you.

I think I'm out of time. I have many other questions. Thank you for being here, witnesses.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you, Monsieur St-Pierre.

As chair, I'm going to use my prerogative to ask one quick question, as I have witnesses here from Halifax and Nova Scotia. I'm really excited to have you both here. We've worked together for some time.

I'm excited by the potential for supporting innovation leaders and trailblazers in this question of carbon capture, which the IPCC is saying that we need to do.

What is the most urgent and impactful thing, in your view, that the federal government needs to do to ensure that we can keep allowing folks like yourselves, these innovators and trailblazers, to continue the exploratory work that you're doing?

Ms. Zitner can go first, followed by Mr. Jarvis, please.

4:35 p.m.

General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada

Miriam Zitner

You would have heard in one of my three recommendations that I'm urging the Canadian government to think about existing frameworks. I'm urging the Canadian government to think about the defence industrial strategy and the evolution of the ITB paradigm, especially with the increase in defence needs and, consequently, defence spending.

There are billions of dollars of private sector money that are now governed by the key industrial capabilities frameworks. Within those 17 KICs, at last check, there are notions around funding sensor vehicles and uncrewed ocean vehicles and providing guidance around funding for removing and reducing carbon pollution. There are pots of money that exist in the private sector. There are existing frameworks currently being evolved that could fund the R and D this committee is asking for to be able to explore the viability of some of the carbon removal technologies being assessed.

If there was one thing, I'd suggest that we all take a look at those paradigms that already exist and the funding that's already there, and that we think about how we can integrate with existing paradigms versus asking for new money and building new things. The money is there. The interest is 80% there. It just needs some fine tuning, some direction and, essentially, a sponsor to move that forward and focus it.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you, Ms. Zitner.

Go ahead, Mr. Jarvis.

4:35 p.m.

Vice-President, External Affairs, pHathom Technologies Inc.

Alastair Jarvis

There are three things for me.

First, add marine storage as a third eligible use in the CCUS tax credit; second, establish a permitting pathway with the provinces; and third, make sure federal protocols, the national inventory and Canada's IPCC engagement don't foreclose on non-geologic storage.

A fourth, if there were room, would be resources for ECCC and DFO to work with the provinces on this.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

I asked for one and you gave me four.

Thank you so much to our three witnesses for your time and expertise. We really appreciate it. We're going to suspend briefly to switch over to our next set of witnesses.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

We will resume our meeting with our second set of witnesses.

Thank you so much for being here.

In person, we have Donald Lawton, professor emeritus, from Carbon Management Canada, and Diana Philip, vice-president of community and government relations, from Planetary Technologies. Online, we have Yuliya Kravtsov, the CEO of CarbonCure Technologies Incorporated.

Welcome. You'll all have up to five minutes to provide some opening remarks. Then we'll move to questions from the committee.

We'll begin with you, Mr. Lawton, for up to five minutes, please.

Donald Lawton Emeritus Professor, Carbon Management Canada

Good afternoon, Madam Chair and committee members. Thank you for the invitation to provide testimony at this important meeting.

My name is Don Lawton. I am an emeritus professor of geophysics at the University of Calgary and currently an adviser to a small not-for-profit, Carbon Management Canada, that has been working with industry, researchers and technology developers for the past 15 years on technologies for emissions reductions.

I myself have worked mostly on technical aspects of CCUS for the past 25 years and have been involved in public education about this technology. Just as a point of interest, I presented the basics of CCUS to parliamentarians here in Ottawa in 2021 through the so-called Bacon and Eggheads program that is put on by the Partnership Group for Science and Engineering.

Today, greenhouse gas emissions reductions face challenges from concerns about energy security, energy poverty, the economy and general affordability. In Canada, our annual GHGE equivalents are around 700 megatonnes per year. We're 13th on the world's scale, but we're among the highest in terms of individual emissions per capita.

On the question of longevity of oil and gas, in the previous discussion Dr. Keith mentioned the peak for oil production, but many agencies, including the IEA, talk about the continued use of oil and gas through to at least 2050. Thus, we cannot shy away from being proactive about emissions reductions, and we must focus on technologies that are most cost-effective and scalable in the short to medium term.

In my opinion, what I call “conventional CCS” can really lead the way. By this, I mean CO2 capture from large point source emitters and storage in deep underground saline aquifers or depleted oil and gas fields. These options are not available across all of Canada. Certainly in the west, the western Canadian sedimentary basin has gigatonnes of storage capacity, but deep aquifer storage does exist elsewhere, such as in southwestern Ontario, the St. Lawrence valley in Quebec and the Maritimes, but these capacities are still being investigated.

As you heard in the meetings last week, storage through mineralization of mine tailings and in basaltic and ultramafic rocks is also being investigated, but these technologies have yet to be proven at scale. There are valid questions about storage capacity, injectivity and the efficacy of monitoring and verification technologies for these, as well as their full life-cycle analysis.

For conventional CCS, about 80% of the project costs are in the capture side and the remaining 20% in transportation and storage. Canada is actually a world leader in new capture technologies being developed by companies, and this will be reducing costs. That's really the key: How do we reduce costs for all of these carbon renewable projects or carbon capture projects?

We also have carbon dioxide removal through, for example, direct air capture, which you heard about in the previous meeting. This is still expensive, because of the necessity to move very large volumes of air across the capture contactors. Ultimately, we need these carbon removal technologies to get scope 3 emissions, which are ubiquitous, but the technologies are generally not yet ready for upscaling and, for some of these technologies, performance in cold climates is still being evaluated.

The current state of the conventional CCS industry is that projects at the scale of about one megatonne per year are quite well established, such as by Quest and in Enhance in Alberta, but even at this scale, not enough projects are reaching FID to make a difference. I think this is primarily because of regulatory uncertainty and carbon pricing, which were discussed at the meetings last week. We must not only accelerate these projects but also upscale storage cumulatively to the 100-megatonne storage range. The Pathways project is an example of this next step to be able demonstrate the scalability of the technology.

However, upscaling geological carbon storage has challenges that need to be researched, including, for example, pressure interference—I'm getting to the technical stuff—between adjacent projects, induced seismicity, monitoring and verification strategies for regulatory compliance and addressing public assurance.

On this last point, Carbon Management Canada, in collaboration with the University of Calgary, has established a CCS field research station in southern Alberta that has been working with national and international partners to advance new cost-effective MMV strategies necessary for upscaling CCS to large-scale projects.

In conclusion, CCUS is not some singular silver bullet for emissions reduction. A broad range of technologies—including CO2 utilization, conversion and removal—must all be pursued. Arguably, CCUS has the highest potential to be upscaled rapidly to contribute significantly to Canada's emissions reduction climate plan. We must get on with it.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much, Mr. Lawton.

We will now turn to Ms. Kravtsov for five minutes.

Yuliya Kravtsov Chief Executive Officer, CarbonCure Technologies Inc.

Madam Chair, vice-chairs and members of the committee, thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today.

My name is Yuliya Kravtsov. I'm the CEO of CarbonCure Technologies. [Technical difficulty—Editor] Canadian carbon utilization company had marked six months since I joined the company. I have spent the last 15 years in the building materials industry, working on decarbonization strategies and solutions for large multinational producers of cement, concrete and other construction materials.

CarbonCure was founded in 2012 on a simple promise but an ambitious idea: Carbon-captured CO2 can become both an ingredient and part of the solution in one of the world's most essential and difficult-to-decarbonize industries, concrete. Carbon utilization is often viewed as a niche solution. However, our solution at CarbonCure is far beyond the pilot stage.

Carbon-mineralized concrete, produced using CarbonCure technology, has built thousands of homes, hospitals, schools, skyscrapers, roadways, airports and much more. CarbonCure's technology has been adapted by hundreds of concrete plants across North America and many continents, producing over 12 million truckloads and delivering close to 100 million cubic yards of carbon-mineralized concrete to lower carbon on construction projects around the world. That is enough to build approximately 1,900 CN Towers in Toronto. To date, we've reduced and mineralized more than 840,000 tonnes of CO2 that would have gone into the atmosphere.

Our technology is very simple. It injects captured CO2 into concrete during production, where it can chemically react with nanoparticles to become nano-limestone and calcium carbonate. It embeds inside the concrete, permanently sequestering the CO2. Mineralization improves the concrete's microstructure, enabling producers to use less carbon-intensive cement while maintaining the concrete's strength. The result is low-carbon concrete that works with existing plans, supply chains and construction practices. This matters because cement accounts for approximately 7% to 8% of global CO2 emissions and because concrete demand is expected to remain very strong for decades. Decarbonizing this industry is essential.

Canada's opportunity is to scale practical solutions like CarbonCure's, which is already in operation and commercially proven, rather than waiting for the entirely new solution of CCUS to address this infrastructure. For CarbonCure, adoption depends on economies and sustainability. Reducing cement construction can lower costs, while lower-carbon products can help producers compete for construction projects. Climate technologies scale fastest when they create business value.

Government can accelerate this progress in two different ways.

First, buy clean procurement could consider embodied carbon alongside traditional purchasing criteria, creating demand for low-carbon materials and rewarding Canadian manufacturers that invest in innovation. Federal green procurement standards and embodied carbon requirements have already sent important market signals, but we need to continue to build on this product.

Second, we need an inclusive carbon market. As Canada explores a framework for internationally transferred mitigation outcomes, verified industrial emissions reductions should have a place alongside carbon-removing technologies in nature-based solutions. At CarbonCure, we share our carbon credit revenue with our concrete-producing partners. That revenue encourages technology adoption and greater use, generating further verified emissions reductions.

In closing, Canada could not only lead in developing climate technologies like CarbonCure but could also create the policy and market conditions that allow for the faster adoption of those technologies locally.

Our message is simple: Recognize proven technologies for carbon utilization solutions used in public purchasing to drive the demand for technologies and ensure that credible carbon markets can support industrial decarbonization. Today, those measures can reduce emissions while strengthening Canada's innovation in manufacturing.

Thank you again for the opportunity to appear today. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much, Ms. Kravtsov.

We'll now turn to you, Ms. Philip, for five minutes, please.

Diana Philip Vice-President, Community and Government Relations, Planetary Technologies

Good evening, Madam Chair and members of the committee.

My name is Diana Philip. I'm the vice-president of community and government relations at Planetary Technologies.

Planetary is a Canadian climate tech start-up headquartered in Nova Scotia and developing an approach to carbon dioxide removal called coastal ocean alkalinity enhancement, or OAE. Using existing coastal infrastructure, such as power generating stations, we introduce carefully measured amounts of alkaline minerals into seawater. This supports the ocean's natural ability to absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere while potentially helping to counteract local ocean acidification. Scientific research and environmental monitoring are central to our work.

To reach net zero, Canada and the world need both emissions reductions and carbon dioxide removal. Our work focuses on removing CO2 already in the atmosphere. Canada is already demonstrating leadership in this emerging field. In Halifax, Planetary works with Dalhousie University and Nova Scotia Power, and we became the first company in the world to deliver independently verified coastal OAE carbon removal credits, with over 8,000 tonnes delivered to date.

Our work has attracted international buyers. Through Frontier, a coalition of major companies, including Shopify, Google, Stripe and McKinsey, has committed to buying over 100,000 tonnes of carbon removal from Planetary between 2026 and 2030. We have also conducted pilots in the United States and the United Kingdom, demonstrating how Canadian innovation can attract international interest and investment.

Developing a new ocean-based technology requires more than scientific progress. It also requires the involvement and trust of coastal and indigenous communities. Our “Community Engagement Report” documents our extensive work with indigenous nations, local communities, fishers and environmental organizations. This engagement has directly informed our projects, including adaptations to environmental monitoring. In Nova Scotia, we established the world's first two-eyed seeing committee in the carbon dioxide removal sector, bringing indigenous knowledge systems and western science together to inform our approach.

This emerging sector also presents a significant economic opportunity for Canada. A 2025 report commissioned by Canada’s Ocean Supercluster estimates that by 2050, the sector could contribute $16 billion to Canada's GDP and attract more than $30 billion in investments. It also projects potential annual carbon removal capacity exceeding 100 million tonnes. Realizing this potential will require continued research, investment and responsible development.

Planetary's experience illustrates how public and private investment can work together. We have attracted venture capital, received support through Canadian innovation and research programs and secured long-term carbon removal purchase commitments from private buyers. This has helped to advance research, technology development and scientific verification, and it has demonstrated market demand.

Canada now needs a clearer national framework to build on this progress. Nova Scotia has demonstrated how coordinated regulatory oversight, including through its large industrial file team, or LIFT, can support emerging technologies while maintaining environmental safeguards. However, greater clarity is needed federally. The Senate's report, entitled “Carbon Removal, From Air to Sea”, called for regulatory clarity and recognition of land-based coastal OAE, but these recommendations remain unimplemented. Canada's 2023 carbon management strategy acknowledges ocean-based carbon removal but does not integrate it into the national framework. Coastal OAE is also not accommodated under the CCUS ITCs, while eligibility for federal carbon removal procurement remains absolutely uncertain.

This matters for Canada's international competitiveness. Europe's horizon Europe and innovation fund programs support technologies from early research through first-of-a-kind commercial demonstration. Without comparable pathways, Canada risks losing investment, projects and skilled jobs.

I therefore leave the committee with three recommendations.

First, clarify the federal regulatory framework for land-based coastal OAE, building on the Senate's findings.

Second, update Canada's carbon management strategy to recognize coastal OAE.

Third, review federal investment incentives and carbon dioxide removal procurement policies so that independently verified technologies like ours can qualify, based on scientific evidence and rigorous environmental standards.

With the right framework, Canada can strengthen its competitiveness, protect our marine environment and create long-term opportunities for Canadian innovation, investments and jobs.

Thank you. I look forward to your questions.

5 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much, Ms. Philip.

We will now go to questions from members, and we'll begin with Mr. Leslie for six minutes.

5 p.m.

Conservative

Branden Leslie Conservative Portage—Lisgar, MB

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I'll start with you, Mr. Lawton.

The Liberals have reversed their original position and now want enhanced oil recovery to qualify for carbon capture investment tax credits. It's a move that's drawn some strong criticism from many environmental groups.

From your perspective, should enhanced oil recovery qualify for those credits?

5 p.m.

Emeritus Professor, Carbon Management Canada

Donald Lawton

I think it should. Currently, it gets half the credit compared to CCS. Whether we should be subsidizing enhanced oil recovery is a good question. I think we should. At the level it's being done, I think it is appropriate.

When we look at the total captured emissions in 2024, we see that nearly half of them were actually from Petrobras' EOR. The question is that if we're doing carbon storage with enhanced oil recovery, we're adding more oil. The counter-argument is that if we don't do it, that oil will be produced elsewhere. If we do it with EOR, we're actually reducing the emissions on the production side.

I think it's reasonable to include those.