For many of the technologies now, we really don't have a meaningful answer to the question of where we are, because they're for very small projects.
There are two parts to this. I'd say for direct air capture, the answer is that the cost is many hundreds of dollars per tonne for projects that would be executed now. I think it's plausible that costs could come down quite a lot. Part of that depends on access to very cheap energy, which is likely solar power in sunny places. I think that's a realistic prospect, but it's moving a few steps further away in time.
For open ocean alkalinity, we've been thinking a lot about the cost assessment recently. There are good reasons to believe it's possible that without any fundamental technological advance in the process we have in place today, the cost could be on the order of $100 a tonne, but we simply haven't done much of the engineering. Really, very little has been done on the engineering of the large-scale dispersal of materials in the open ocean, and it's possible that there's actually no cost-effective way to do it. People just have not done the engineering for real.
In terms of the cost that we need to get to, I keep coming back to $100 a tonne as a nice benchmark. If we wanted to remediate some of the environmental damage we did by putting carbon dioxide in, in a world after 2050, when emissions are coming down, we would need to think as humanity about removing something like 1,000 gigatonnes—a teratonne—of CO2 over a long time, maybe a century, so that would be 10 gigatonnes a year. If you got to $100 a tonne, you'd be spending about 1% of the global economy on that.
It's not crazy to imagine that people would spend 1% of the global economy on this kind of long-term environmental cleanup. That's comparable to some other environmental costs, and it's comparable to what some developed societies have spent on different kinds of foreign aid or national parks protection that didn't have an immediate economic utility. You can hope that people would pay that.
