Good afternoon, Madam Chair and committee members. Thank you for the invitation to provide testimony at this important meeting.
My name is Don Lawton. I am an emeritus professor of geophysics at the University of Calgary and currently an adviser to a small not-for-profit, Carbon Management Canada, that has been working with industry, researchers and technology developers for the past 15 years on technologies for emissions reductions.
I myself have worked mostly on technical aspects of CCUS for the past 25 years and have been involved in public education about this technology. Just as a point of interest, I presented the basics of CCUS to parliamentarians here in Ottawa in 2021 through the so-called Bacon and Eggheads program that is put on by the Partnership Group for Science and Engineering.
Today, greenhouse gas emissions reductions face challenges from concerns about energy security, energy poverty, the economy and general affordability. In Canada, our annual GHGE equivalents are around 700 megatonnes per year. We're 13th on the world's scale, but we're among the highest in terms of individual emissions per capita.
On the question of longevity of oil and gas, in the previous discussion Dr. Keith mentioned the peak for oil production, but many agencies, including the IEA, talk about the continued use of oil and gas through to at least 2050. Thus, we cannot shy away from being proactive about emissions reductions, and we must focus on technologies that are most cost-effective and scalable in the short to medium term.
In my opinion, what I call “conventional CCS” can really lead the way. By this, I mean CO2 capture from large point source emitters and storage in deep underground saline aquifers or depleted oil and gas fields. These options are not available across all of Canada. Certainly in the west, the western Canadian sedimentary basin has gigatonnes of storage capacity, but deep aquifer storage does exist elsewhere, such as in southwestern Ontario, the St. Lawrence valley in Quebec and the Maritimes, but these capacities are still being investigated.
As you heard in the meetings last week, storage through mineralization of mine tailings and in basaltic and ultramafic rocks is also being investigated, but these technologies have yet to be proven at scale. There are valid questions about storage capacity, injectivity and the efficacy of monitoring and verification technologies for these, as well as their full life-cycle analysis.
For conventional CCS, about 80% of the project costs are in the capture side and the remaining 20% in transportation and storage. Canada is actually a world leader in new capture technologies being developed by companies, and this will be reducing costs. That's really the key: How do we reduce costs for all of these carbon renewable projects or carbon capture projects?
We also have carbon dioxide removal through, for example, direct air capture, which you heard about in the previous meeting. This is still expensive, because of the necessity to move very large volumes of air across the capture contactors. Ultimately, we need these carbon removal technologies to get scope 3 emissions, which are ubiquitous, but the technologies are generally not yet ready for upscaling and, for some of these technologies, performance in cold climates is still being evaluated.
The current state of the conventional CCS industry is that projects at the scale of about one megatonne per year are quite well established, such as by Quest and in Enhance in Alberta, but even at this scale, not enough projects are reaching FID to make a difference. I think this is primarily because of regulatory uncertainty and carbon pricing, which were discussed at the meetings last week. We must not only accelerate these projects but also upscale storage cumulatively to the 100-megatonne storage range. The Pathways project is an example of this next step to be able demonstrate the scalability of the technology.
However, upscaling geological carbon storage has challenges that need to be researched, including, for example, pressure interference—I'm getting to the technical stuff—between adjacent projects, induced seismicity, monitoring and verification strategies for regulatory compliance and addressing public assurance.
On this last point, Carbon Management Canada, in collaboration with the University of Calgary, has established a CCS field research station in southern Alberta that has been working with national and international partners to advance new cost-effective MMV strategies necessary for upscaling CCS to large-scale projects.
In conclusion, CCUS is not some singular silver bullet for emissions reduction. A broad range of technologies—including CO2 utilization, conversion and removal—must all be pursued. Arguably, CCUS has the highest potential to be upscaled rapidly to contribute significantly to Canada's emissions reduction climate plan. We must get on with it.
Thank you.