That is a profoundly hard question. One of the deep challenges is that....
Sustainably harvested biomass can produce energy. When you burn a fuel, you produce CO2, just as if you had burned a fossil fuel, but that CO2 is recaptured when the biomass regrows. Biomass combined with carbon capture and storage captures that CO2 and puts it underground. There's a net transfer from the active biosphere, from fresh CO2 in the atmosphere, to the deep underground.
The challenge is the environmental footprint of biomass extraction, because the climate is just one environmental problem that people face. Another problem is the human appropriation of photosynthesis on the land surface.
Forgive the professor in me, but historically, the environmental impacts from excessive use of biomass have been huge. In the United Kingdom, where the Industrial Revolution started, it transitioned from being dominantly biomass-powered to fossil fuel-powered around the end of the 1700s. That was because they'd essentially cut down a significant fraction of all the standing biomass they had access to.
A real challenge is that while biomass absolutely can work, it inevitably involves trade-offs with other environmental things we might care about. There are other environmental reasons we might like to leave natural systems as undisturbed as possible.
I think we should, most of all, be focusing on energy systems that have a small land footprint. Solar power and nuclear power, for example, have a relatively small land footprint compared to biomass per unit of energy. I'm not saying we should ignore biomass—Canada has a big biomass potential—but we have to think hard about the trade-off between the benefits of reducing net carbon emissions, which is what this committee cares about and what matters for the climate, and other environmental concerns, for which increased biomass use will have other negative environmental impacts.
