Thank you.
Mr. Chair, we've heard in a previous answer by a witness today that a private industry is not able to regulate itself. You'll recall that in previous testimony, the RCMP disagreed with the findings of the Privacy Commissioner about violations that were present, so I want to ask the Office of the Privacy Commissioner about this.
The OPC found that the RCMP's use of Clearview AI contravened the Privacy Act and PIPEDA. The RCMP testified that they disagreed with the findings of the investigation. Through you, Mr. Chair, why does the OPC believe that the RCMP violated the Privacy Act and PIPEDA?