Evidence of meeting #54 for Access to Information, Privacy and Ethics in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was threshold.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Bélanger  Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Fares Al Soud Liberal Mississauga Centre, ON

Thank you, Commissioner.

This speaks to something else that I found quite interesting today: this notion of good faith. Our system seems to rely on good faith to a tremendous extent, rather than on enforceable rules or safeguards. What I'm effectively asking here is how we might best balance the presumption of good faith with the need for independent verification, transparency and meaningful consequences for misconduct. I don't think any of us disagree with the idea that, yes, we should be operating within a transparent system, that individuals should be reporting those activities and that Canadians should have a good line of sight on what's happening around them.

At the same time, our system does rely on good faith. That this tends to work well is what we heard from you earlier, if I recall correctly.

12:45 p.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

I believe there's good faith. It is somewhat voluntarily that people choose to register. I have a team of 32 employees. We're trying to regulate and ensure compliance as best we can, but those who lobby as a profession need to know they should be on time doing this, in particular without tardiness. To me, transparency delayed is transparency denied almost.

I think it's important. That's why we should continue to rely on good faith, but we should also have tools to ensure compliance at the point where people are simply not respecting the rules.

Fares Al Soud Liberal Mississauga Centre, ON

Where I wholeheartedly agree with you, above all else, is that there is—there's no way of avoiding it—a need to ensure that our rules are being followed and that people are being as transparent as humanly possible.

Where I have a slight challenge, in the context of the outcome of this, is here: Do we then, potentially, in the course of these recommendations you've brought forward, risk creating a system that is primarily geared towards the few who are not operating in good faith, rather than continuing to incentivize the system we currently have, which does operate on good faith, by and large?

That's not to say that everything is perfect, by any stretch of the imagination, but if things are, to an extent, going relatively well as they pertain to transparency requirements, are we currently risking this with certain recommendations being brought forward?

12:45 p.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

If we go through each of my recommendations, I think for the most part it's to simplify, to focus and to make accountable, which are all these priorities that we've been hearing. It's actually an opportunity right now. The last time this act was looked at was in 2008.

Let's make it better. I do think there's a way to simplify it. Some of the way the act is right now—we can't explain why it's like that. If we can't explain it, that's a problem. You don't need to accept all my recommendations, but certainly there's a number of them that really should be, just to make it easier and to make it easier for people to follow. Right now we spend a lot of time answering questions. To every question we get, the answer is, “It depends.” We need to figure it out together.

12:45 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative John Brassard

Thank you.

We'll go back to Mr. Hardy.

If I understand correctly, you're going to share your time with Mr. Jivani.

12:45 p.m.

Conservative

Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC

Yes, thank you.

I have two quick questions that haven't been asked so far, and I'd like to ask them.

Do you think you have the necessary funding to take actions that meet these evolving needs? As mentioned earlier, it's been a few years since the Lobbying Act was last amended, but the needs themselves have evolved. Do you have the necessary team? Do you feel that you're able to do your job to the standard that's expected of you?

12:45 p.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

We're doing a great job. We have 35 employees, and I currently have 32. I'd say I have a dream team. It's a fantastic team that works very hard to fulfill our mandate.

Could we do more? Absolutely. I could do more outreach. If I had more funding, I could reduce my 21 compliance cases and keep that number down to just five.

In addition, I think there should be independent funding, but that's another matter.

12:50 p.m.

Conservative

Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC

Yes. You're an oversight body. Your job shouldn't depend on the people you're overseeing.

I also like your point about prevention. We shouldn't always wait for a problem to arise; we need to be able to act proactively.

What do you think are the two or three things that urgently need to be done or changed? We have several proposed amendments, but what do you think needs to happen quickly, within the next year?

12:50 p.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

My 21 recommendations are good. I want them all.

However, I think that registration by default, combined with recommendations 3 and 4, to really restrict and clarify who must register, is one of the most important elements.

I also believe that recommendation 17 would be very helpful to me, as it would give us a tool kit that would allow us to move more quickly on compliance and make that information public.

Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC

Thank you very much.

12:50 p.m.

Conservative

Jamil Jivani Conservative Bowmanville—Oshawa North, ON

Thank you.

I have another one of those ideas for you that I'm curious to get your feedback on. One thing that I find very fascinating about how the intersection between big business and the government works is that it's possible for large companies like Rogers and Bell to own TV and radio stations and for them to have political influence through the ownership of those media channels, yet there's very little transparency involved in where there's a connection between what would go out on the airways and what might be good for their core business, which is overcharging Canadians for their cellphones.

Do you have any concerns about how businesses might grow so big that it becomes a little bit obfuscated as to what their area of influence is, where it begins, where it ends and how media might be manipulated to serve the interests of a big company?

12:50 p.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

I don't think I will comment on that. To me, again, my job is to make sure that if there are communications that must be transparent, they are transparent, irrespective of the size of the organization—unless it's an exemption, of course.

I don't regulate. People often ask me that: You have to stop big corporations. We need more time for the little ones. I don't regulate your calendars or who you meet with or who you should meet with. What's important to me is that if you do, Canadians can look at the registry and say, “Okay, these groups are having more time than these groups are.” That's the purpose of transparency.

12:50 p.m.

Conservative

Jamil Jivani Conservative Bowmanville—Oshawa North, ON

That's a fair point. Let me give you another example, though.

Let's say, hypothetically speaking, some lobbyist shows up on television for the evening news, and is.... What's a professional way to say this? They're glazing—just being very positive toward the Prime Minister in an absurd manner. Isn't it a weird thing that a lobbyist can go on TV, essentially openly and publicly lobby, and benefit from being given that platform, knowing that many other lobbyists don't have the same opportunity and the corporation, Bell or Rogers, gets to make the choice of which lobbyists get those platforms and which ones don't? Isn't that an area of concern?

12:50 p.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

To me, if that platform is open.... There's freedom of expression here, so we have to be careful what I regulate.

12:50 p.m.

Conservative

Jamil Jivani Conservative Bowmanville—Oshawa North, ON

I would agree.

12:50 p.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

If, after that, there is an actual lobbying communication between these people and whomever they commented favourably about, then I need to look at whether there is a close relationship. There is a code of conduct that you shouldn't be lobbying with people who would have a sense of obligation towards you. Maybe there's a relationship there. I don't get to regulate that, no, but I understand what you're saying.

12:50 p.m.

Conservative

Jamil Jivani Conservative Bowmanville—Oshawa North, ON

You can see where people would be concerned.

12:50 p.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

12:50 p.m.

Conservative

Jamil Jivani Conservative Bowmanville—Oshawa North, ON

I would go so far as to say, appreciating the freedom of speech concerns, that it's about transparency. If Bell and Rogers are able to use their control over television and radio stations to promote their business interests and bring lobbyists onto their platforms to say good things about Mark Carney, there seems to be an obvious potential conflict of interest there that the public should be informed on. That would be my point.

12:50 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative John Brassard

Thank you.

Ms. Tesser Derksen, you have five minutes. Please go ahead.

I understand that you're splitting your time with Mr. Al Soud.

Kristina Tesser Derksen Liberal Milton East—Halton Hills South, ON

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

Yes, I'm going to share my time.

12:50 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative John Brassard

Afterwards, Mr. Thériault, if you want the floor for two and a half minutes to end the meeting, I'll give it to you.

Go ahead, Ms. Tesser Derksen.

Kristina Tesser Derksen Liberal Milton East—Halton Hills South, ON

This is more of a comment, but I might have a question too. I want to follow up with respect to this “Ottawa bubble” that Ms. Chagger mentioned.

It is true that it's a simple process—I understand that—but sometimes just the fact that there's another bureaucratic step or another government requirement creates an obstacle for a small business or not-for-profit, which frankly are already quite resource-stretched. It does create an obstacle, whether it's a mental obstacle or it's finding someone else to learn how to do it, ask the questions and look into it. There could be a lot more time and resources that go into someone just finding out that they have to do this.

My concern is that the message the public or these folks will be getting is that “there's now one more obstacle that I have to go through to reach my elected representative”. I fear that it will have a chilling effect, and I fear that it will also result, because oftentimes the public doesn't differentiate between the bureaucracy and the elected people, in people saying, “It's another screen that I have to get through and it's their way of locking me out.” That's a concern as well.

All that being said, I want to give you a chance to take us through the process. If I were a small business or a very small non-profit and learned about this requirement that I don't know a lot about, how would I go about finding the information I need? What would the process look like for me to determine that I had to register? What would I go through to actually register?

12:55 p.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

Assuming right now that you meet the threshold, we have lots of information online. People can communicate with us. We also proactively offer information sessions answering that question: Do I need to register? This is all on our website. We are on LinkedIn. We have all the different ways. We've done 93 sessions so far, just since April 1. I do sessions. I meet 80 people at a time, in which we sort of hold their hand and explain what the regime is.

Once you've determined that the type of communication you are having is actually a lobbying communication.... It's not just to say, “I need help.” It's not just to say, “Here's my problem and my issue” or a personal.... It's actually a request. It's a lobbying communication, which is particularly defined. Then we do one-on-one sessions to help them register.

The burden, to me, is that, yes, it's an effort, but it's amazing that once people do it, they realize that it was no big deal. The transparency that comes out of it, for them as well.... People call them up after that and say, “Hey, you have this interest. I also have this interest. Let's align our conversations.” If that's what they do for an employer or for a client.... I mean, it's not about their personal issues.

12:55 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative John Brassard

You have two minutes and 10 seconds, Mr. Al Soud.