Evidence of meeting #54 for Access to Information, Privacy and Ethics in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was threshold.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Bélanger  Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

The Chair Conservative John Brassard

I call the meeting to order.

Welcome to meeting number 54 of the House of Commons Standing Committee on Access to Information, Privacy and Ethics.

Pursuant to the order of reference of Thursday, February 12, 2026, section 14.1 of the Lobbying Act and the motion adopted by the committee on Wednesday, September 17, 2025, the committee is resuming a statutory review of the Lobbying Act.

I'd like to welcome our witness with us today to complete the study, Nancy Bélanger, the Commissioner of Lobbying.

I know, Ms. Bélanger, for the sake of members of the committee, you've asked for a little more time to address the committee, given the scope of the study we've done. I'm going to give you that time.

I'd like to remind members of the committee that in the second hour of Ms. Bélanger's being here, we're going to reset the clock, and we'll have a six-minute rounds of questions for members of the committee.

Ms. Bélanger, go ahead. Please address the committee.

Nancy Bélanger Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Thank you very much.

Good morning, Mr. Chair and committee members.

Thank you for inviting me today as you conclude your study of the Lobbying Act.

You have heard different perspectives from witnesses and received a variety of written submissions. I appreciate the time that you have taken in conducting this study and the participation of these stakeholders.

In these remarks, I will address my recommendations that received the most attention. I have also shared an additional written submission to address other representations and to provide details for each recommendation.

All my recommendations are informed by my experience of close to 20 years in the areas of ethics and transparency working for agents of Parliament and as Commissioner of Lobbying. They are also informed by the Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying's experience administering the Lobbying Act, the experience of my colleagues across the country and the standards set by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, OECD.

As you have heard, Canada is recognized as a world leader in regulating lobbying. But the OECD testified that, while the “foundational elements” of Canada's lobbying regime are strong, “there remains scope for improvement in more detailed and technical aspects of the regime”.

The act has many unnecessary complexities and gaps that limit transparency and result in uneven application. Eighteen years have passed since the last substantive changes. Meanwhile, other jurisdictions both in Canada and abroad are adopting modern frameworks that address weaknesses observed in our federal law.

First, let me underscore that registration is not required when citizens seek your help or that of other officials, when they raise a personal issue or when they seek information. The act requires registration when a paid consultant lobbyist on behalf of a client—or an employee on behalf of their employer—communicates about specific matters identified in the act with public office holders, a category that includes not just MPs and their staff, but also senators, ministers, parliamentary secretaries and their respective staff, as well as public servants. My submission includes a graphic showing the types of communications that are covered by the act.

Let me now turn to some of my recommendations.

My first recommendation is to remove the registration threshold for employers and replace it with registration by default, subject to limited exemptions.

Currently, employers are required to file registrations if the volume of the lobbying activities engaged in by their employees, individually or collectively, amounts to a significant part of the duties of one employee. This threshold is not defined, and commissioners have had to issue interpretation bulletins to give it meaning. Even with the benefit of this guidance, in practice this registration threshold remains difficult to apply for both those who must register and my office when ensuring compliance.

As the OECD stated, “thresholds are always a matter of interpretation, and most importantly, they can be used to circumvent registration.” The RCMP testified that proceeding with its work “could be very challenging and complex” given the existing threshold.

I am alarmed that some witnesses called for legislating a registration threshold for employers of 32 hours of lobbying in a month. This would allow for more than 380 hours of lobbying activities in a calendar year to go unreported. Such an approach is inconsistent with the transparency objectives of the act and is not an acceptable baseline in an open and democratic society like ours.

We also recognize that in 2026, lobbying professionals have access to powerful artificial intelligence tools that significantly reduce the time and effort required to develop and carry out lobbying activities. The reality that AI will be used increasingly in lobbying is reason enough to eliminate an hour-based threshold.

To be clear, and despite what some have suggested, I have not recommended universal registration by default. My recommendation is to adopt registration by default with limited exemptions based on objective criteria. Smaller entities would be exempt from having to file registrations unless one of their main purposes is to engage in advocacy. This change would guarantee clarity and fairness in application.

Laws currently being developed in other countries do not contemplate registration thresholds. In Canada, the B.C. legislation provides registration by default with exemptions for small entities. The B.C. registrar of lobbyists testified that the strength of their model is its simplicity. New Brunswick, which recently adopted new legislation, has also replaced its former threshold with registration by default, subject to exemptions to be defined by regulation.

I recommend a model where employers of less than a specified number of employees are excluded, but only where advocacy is not one of their primary purposes. As you heard from witnesses generally, the requirements of the act must be clear so that employers know precisely when registration is required. Adopting this model would serve this objective.

You also heard concerns from stakeholders about requiring registration in relation to communications about the awarding of grants and contributions, particularly when these are the only communications they have with federal public office holders. These concerns have been addressed through recommendations three and four, where public and transparent processes already exist.

I would also like to address claims that registration creates an undue burden or excessive red tape, as well as the contention that the requirement to register might put a chill on communications with federal officials. To suggest that transparency must come at the cost of Canadians' ability to engage with you or any other federal official is at best speculative and at worst self-interested, particularly if clear exemptions are set out in the act.

Currently, what is burdensome is the effort needed to determine if the existing registration and reporting requirements are met. This can lead registrants to hire lawyers or to engage in extensive communication with my office to understand the intricacies of the law. This is where the burden lies. It's not in taking five minutes to open an account in the registry and another 25 minutes to add required information. Registration does require some effort, but it's a minimal effort that is necessary and clearly outweighed by the increased transparency and the related public confidence to be gained. Adopting this recommendation will effectively eliminate the effort required to determine whether an employer is required to register. It will also support and recognize Canadians' right to know who is lobbying which federal institutions and about what subjects.

Many of the witnesses stated that the accessibility and usability of the registry is one of its strengths. I would encourage you to listen to a recent podcast by CharityVillage, which is an organization that supports the not-for-profit sector, where they interviewed CEOs about their experiences with the lobbying regime. In my written submission, I've highlighted a few quotes in which these CEOs affirm that requiring more people to register is a good thing, as it reinforces the role and credibility of charities in Canada, and that registering is neither a barrier nor a burden.

To demonstrate the minimal effort required to register, I would be happy to arrange a demonstration for any or all members of this committee.

Let me turn to recommendations 12 and 13, which focus on the reporting requirements when designated public office holders are lobbied and which garnered much attention.

I am more convinced than ever that all communications with designated public office holders that amount, in substance, to lobbying should be disclosed, regardless of whether they are oral or written or arranged in advance and regardless of who initiated them. In my view, there is no compelling rationale for limiting disclosure based on these criteria. My recommended approach is consistent with what already exists in British Columbia and with the law recently passed in New Brunswick. The OECD testified that this is standard practice in OECD member countries.

I have also not been convinced by those who argued against eliminating the current “arranged-in-advance” criterion. It concerns me when I hear that requiring impromptu communications to be reported would “flood” the system. Such claims should raise serious concerns for you and all Canadians, as they suggest not only that a significant amount of nontransparent lobbying is taking place, but also that such unplanned lobbying may be of significant value. This recommendation is not, as some have suggested, about requiring lobbyists to report the pleasantries they exchange with designated public office holders in line at a coffee shop or at the airport. The reporting obligations should be exclusively with respect to lobbying communications.

I also want to address concerns that requiring the disclosure of impromptu meetings is problematic because communication reports do not convey the context or circumstances in which lobbying takes place, including that a given designated public office holder may not have agreed to be lobbied in the first place. In my view, the appropriate response to these concerns is not to allow for such instances of lobbying to go unreported, but rather to allow for important contextual aspects of lobbying communications to be disclosed. The requirements for filing monthly reports could be adjusted for contextual and simple information to be reported—such as whether the communication is written or oral, whether it was arranged in advance or occurred by happenstance, as well as who initiated it.

Currently, communication reports only require the names of all designated public office holders who were lobbied to be disclosed. These reports should also identify all those who participated in the lobbying. There is no reason that the identities of the clients and the employees, as well as any other public office holders who participated in a lobbying communication should not be disclosed.

Lastly, I will mention the additional compliance measures in recommendation 17. The act currently lacks basic administrative enforcement tools available in other federal and provincial legislation. The OECD testified that a graduated system of penalties promotes compliance. Amending the act to provide a range of measures would allow for greater flexibility and proportionality in achieving compliance. It would also enhance transparency in enforcement. Of course, as is the case in any other jurisdictions, the process for implementing any of these compliance measures would be subject to the rules of procedural fairness and judicial review by the Federal Court.

In closing, adopting the recommendations I have made would not only enhance transparency and clarity but also simplify the requirements of the act and make it easier for lobbyists to comply. It would also allow for my office's resources to be optimized to improve the registry, further educate and assist stakeholders, and monitor compliance.

It is my sincere hope that this study will lead to improvements to the Lobbying Act. Transparent and ethical lobbying is a cornerstone of a healthy democracy that supports citizen trust in public institutions. Amendments that enhance transparency will foster increased accountability, integrity and public confidence. They would also serve to ensure Canada remains a global leader in the regulation of transparent and ethical lobbying.

Mr. Chair and committee members, I will always remain available during the drafting of your report should you require additional information.

Thank you and I welcome your questions.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative John Brassard

Thank you, Commissioner. There was a lot of value in that opening statement. I can tell that you and your staff have been watching the deliberations—clearly.

We're going to start our opening questions with a six-minute round. We're going to go to Mr. Gunn first.

Go ahead, Mr. Gunn.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Aaron Gunn Conservative North Island—Powell River, BC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you, Commissioner, for coming and presenting here today.

To start off, in your position, are you able to give us an update on how many files have currently been referred to the RCMP, or what has changed since the last time you presented to this committee?

11:15 a.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

I think that, since...I actually sent a file to the RCMP last week. There currently are three files with the RCMP, plus one in which charges have been laid and they're awaiting a trial, so they have four.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Aaron Gunn Conservative North Island—Powell River, BC

Thank you.

In terms of what you previously mentioned, do you believe there's an argument that it would be easier if you had the ability to impose monetary penalties or policies when you believe a contravention of the act has taken place, as opposed to always having to refer to the RCMP?

11:15 a.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

Of the 20 files I've now referred to the RCMP, most, if not all, could have been dealt with a lot quicker through administrative monetary penalties, through training and possibly through a prohibition on lobbying. There are no tools in my tool box. If I investigate and I have reason to believe, I have to refer to the RCMP. I do believe that right now it's very costly and time-consuming to have full-blown investigations for every single allegation.

I think it would be a lot more efficient. It would also ensure compliance. Most of my decisions would also be made public, so there would be a lot more transparency in relation to the work we do. One of my frustrations is that I can't talk about any of the investigations I do.

It's your frustration too, I know.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Aaron Gunn Conservative North Island—Powell River, BC

Right. I understand.

Speaking to those investigations, my Bloc colleague and I wrote to you back in August, I guess, requesting that you look into the federal government's so-called condo bailout program, where they're buying up a bunch of unused condos in British Columbia. Our questions were always surrounding who stands to benefit, who may have asked for the policy, who wrote or shaped the policy and whether unregistered lobbying took place.

Are you able to guide the committee on what you're able to look into, what you're not able to look into and what you would hypothetically be looking into for something like that?

11:15 a.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

Obviously, I will not comment on this particular file, but I can tell you that most times, when any one of you write to me, I'm already aware of what's going on. Most often, I open files to look into everything. I open them through preliminary assessments. If I think I need to investigate further, after I review what's available in the public domain, I open an investigation and I proceed.

I have a very active team. We do look at and watch what's going on outside. We use the media. Very often, we'll be communicating with you to find out whether you were lobbied, and if so, about what. Then we'll continue our investigation.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Aaron Gunn Conservative North Island—Powell River, BC

I'll give you an example. I'm sure you can't comment on this specifically. There's this one individual, Duncan Wlodarczak, who's the chief of staff at Onni Group, which is a big development firm. He's also chair of the Liberal Party in British Columbia.

Does the act run into issues or deficiencies when it comes to people being able to wear two different hats, taking one hat off and putting on another one when conducting a form of lobbying?

11:15 a.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

Obviously, any former designated public office holder can't lobby. If anyone leaves office, they can't lobby for five years. I need to evaluate whether lobbying has occurred and whether there's a breach of that particular section. I can tell you that of the 20 files I have sent to the RCMP, five of them were in relation to former DPOHs who lobbied in the past.

When somebody is a lobbyist and comes into office, then I ensure that their former colleagues won't be lobbying them. If the firm is a lobbying firm, then they can't lobby them. We have rules in place to ensure that there are cooling-off periods in the revolving door.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Aaron Gunn Conservative North Island—Powell River, BC

Okay.

11:20 a.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

I may not be answering your question. I'm not sure.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Aaron Gunn Conservative North Island—Powell River, BC

If somebody is appointed by the government into some kind of volunteer role and is obviously communicating with the government on a particular policy, do they have to register and disclose their lobbying activities, or is it just assumed by their appointment?

11:20 a.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

No. If they're appointed in a government role, they themselves possibly become public office holders, so anyone else lobbying them may have to register. It depends on what they're appointed to do. Anyone appointed as an officer or agent of the Crown by a minister or by GIC becomes a public office holder themselves.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Aaron Gunn Conservative North Island—Powell River, BC

I'm talking about someone who is given some kind of advisory title.

11:20 a.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

If they become an adviser without an official title, without an appointment, then they would have to be careful to make sure that in whatever lobbying they do, if it's going to benefit their employer, they would need to register.

Sometimes, these people who are appointed on the advisory are already registered lobbyists. That happens as well.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

Aaron Gunn Conservative North Island—Powell River, BC

Thank you.

11:20 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative John Brassard

Thank you, Mr. Gunn.

Mr. Al Soud, I have you next. Go ahead for six minutes.

Fares Al Soud Liberal Mississauga Centre, ON

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, Commissioner, for taking the time to join us today.

I want to start with this. First and foremost, I will take you up on that offer for a demonstration on how to register. I think that's an invaluable experience, and I would advise my colleagues to do the very same.

Because you've been following along so clearly in the course of what we've heard here in testimony, you will have heard that Jacques Shore and Suzanne Sabourin of Gowling WLG raised concerns about your recommendation 20. In their brief, they wrote that:

Granting the Commissioner of Lobbying independent regulation-making authority would constitute a significant institutional overreach, blurring the line between enforcement and law-making in a manner that is seriously inconsistent with foundational principles of Canadian administrative law.

Ms. Sabourin also told the committee that “those who enforce the law should not also make it.”

In your opening remarks, you made mention of this notion of a baseline democratic society like ours and the values that it carries. How would you respond to those concerns that were highlighted?

11:20 a.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

I'm not convinced I completely agree with their analysis, and I'll tell you why. I did not ask for unilateral regulation-making power. I've asked for the possibility to recommend regulations that would be subject to the same usual process—Governor in Council approval. That's what I recommended. They extrapolated, dramatized, I'm not sure. They did not read the portion where I said “appropriate” process.

It's not true to say that regulatory bodies do not have that authority. The CRTC does. The Canadian Transportation Agency does. The Competition Tribunal does. Most of these regulatory bodies have the power to recommend or suggest, and then GIC approves it and we would simply apply.

My recommendations are really in relation to what should be on the registry and how we could offer some recommendations. For example, the regulations have not been looked at since 2010. I've had to use the category “other” to add climate, budget and economic development as items of subjects. It's really to be able to offer, as an independent agent of Parliament, some recommendations of what should be on the registry. I just don't agree with their position.

Fares Al Soud Liberal Mississauga Centre, ON

I think, at its core, we all share a similar commitment to that notion of transparency. Maybe there are distinctions as to how we believe we should go about it, but I think in large part that's why conversations like this are so valuable.

As we review the Lobbying Act, as we head to the closure of this, there are fundamental considerations that should be granted to ensuring that stakeholders clearly understand their obligations and that the framework remains predictable and accessible.

Are there areas where you believe that we as Parliament could provide clearer statutory direction in the act itself to reduce reliance on guidance documents or administrative interpretations?

11:20 a.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

Absolutely. The first one is the threshold for employers. I think that one right now is “significant part of the duties”. What's interesting is this committee back in 2012 recommended that the threshold should be eliminated, and nothing has happened. I think that threshold needs to go. There needs to be a clear statutory obligation to register. This committee needs to decide what it wants excluded. What should be the exemptions? It can be the size. That's clear. It's objective. What is the size? It's over. There's no debate.

The other two recommendations I've made that would help are to decide what types of communications you don't think should be subject to the Lobbying Act. Those who apply for simple grants through a portal should be excluded, but right now they're included. Those are recommendations three and four. Those are all recommendations that would help to simplify what we really mean by lobbying and then exclude those that are particularly small, that don't do this as a business, really.

Fares Al Soud Liberal Mississauga Centre, ON

Do you have immediate thoughts on what guiding principles might help determine the way that we should address certain responses—that is, legislation, regulation, administrative guidance?

As a general rule of thumb—we spoke about transparency earlier—are there other pieces that you can imagine tying into this puzzle?

11:25 a.m.

Commissioner of Lobbying, Office of the Commissioner of Lobbying

Nancy Bélanger

Simplify. For anything that's clear, do not add exemptions to exemptions. The answer to every question we get in the office right now is always “it depends.” Let's remove the “it depends”. Honestly, most of my recommendations aim to do that. Simplify, focus, make clear and enhance accountability. Right now, corporations don't have to list all of their employees who lobby, but organizations do. Why is that? Why is there a distinction? It should be the same for everybody. Keep it simple.