In some cases, it may not be necessary.
Personally, I'd still like to start with mandatory training. Then, if someone registers late again, we could impose an administrative penalty. I agree the penalty itself may not be the deterrent; rather, it's the fact that it's made public. It becomes a way for the person to remember that, next time, they'll respect the deadline.
I would say that these regimes exist elsewhere and they should be part of our tool kit. We can assess whether it's actually the most effective approach for the situation.
Mr. Thurlow is entitled to his opinion. Personally, I'd prefer administrative penalties to having to refer everything to the RCMP.
