Good afternoon.
Mr. Chair, members of the committee, allow me to deliver my remarks in French.
Thank you for the invitation to appear as part of your study on the impact of consumer debt in Canada.
I am a senior manager in recovery and insolvency at Raymond Chabot Inc., a subsidiary of Raymond Chabot Grant Thornton. I am a licensed insolvency trustee, or LIT, a profession regulated by the federal agency known as the office of the superintendent of bankruptcy, or OSB. Therefore, I act as a practitioner in the field of consumer and business insolvency and recovery on a daily basis. I should also note that I am the chair of the Conseil des syndics autorisés en insolvabilité du Québec. This organization represents nearly 225 LITs practising in Quebec.
From the outset, I consider the starting point of your study to be fully justified. My practical experience allows me to say that the problem goes beyond macroeconomic trends and recent statistics, which show the increase in the ratio of household debt and consumer insolvencies.
Moreover, the profile of Canadian debtors facing insolvency has changed in recent years. New consumer groups that were previously less represented in cases of insolvencies are now emerging, such as seniors, workers with fluctuating incomes and single-parent families. In addition, the rise in mental health problems and the ease of access to online gambling are all factors that influence insolvency situations on a daily basis.
For the middle class, it is seldom one bad choice alone that leads to insolvency. Rather, it is a succession of shocks and cost increases that gradually reduce their financial capacity. Many people are living paycheque to paycheque, with little room to manoeuvre, while the cost of living has risen sharply. In the end, it becomes difficult for consumers to balance their budgets, and a life event, such as an illness or job loss, can quickly tip the consumer into insolvency.
When liquidity runs out, non-mortgage credit becomes a tool for fiscal survival. This is also when many vulnerable households turn to high-interest credit or even payday loans to cover essential day-to-day expenses such as groceries.
Also of note is the case of owner households, which may appear to be financially steady because of the real estate equity accumulated in recent years. These households often lack liquidity, which complicates any refinancing. In the event of insolvency, the LIT takes into account the high value of the residence to propose repayment to creditors. However, these households generally cannot offer this value to creditors without selling their home, due to their already high debt-to-equity ratio. Selling makes it possible to pay off debts but forces them to move to a home that is often more expensive than the mortgage.
Another common problem is online fraud. Vulnerable people, especially the elderly and those living alone, are particularly affected. These individuals often contact us ashamed of having lost all their savings and going into debt because of malicious manipulators they met on the Internet.
Not to mention the fact that many debtors demonstrate a lack of financial literacy in that they struggle to differentiate between budget, income, assets and liabilities. They are often unaware of their debt structure or of their monthly income or expenses. The trustee then plays a key role in assessing the debtor's financial situation.
In closing, I cannot ignore the important role of LITs in the financial rehabilitation of consumers. We have little control over macroeconomic trends, but we remain the only professionals who can provide legal financial recovery measures to Canadian consumers. The regulatory framework, which is currently under review by the OSB to facilitate access to simplified insolvency proceedings and adapt trustee compensation, must evolve to ensure Canadians' access to LITs.
Thanks to your questions, I will have the opportunity to further clarify the picture of households in insolvency and the role and contribution of LITs. I would like to point out, however, that we can take action by limiting the damage and accelerating the return to balance in consumers' financial situations.
Thank you very much for listening.
